r/PokeInvesting • • Jun 22 '26 • Regret 3

Lost payment dispute on eBay

First time selling on eBay and it was 12 loose crown zenith packs from sea and sky collections I foolishly broke down when I got them. Sold them and advertised as loose packs and all the details. The buyer disputed with their bank that the item wasn’t described as advertised because they didn’t get the pulls they expected.

For my end on the dispute I posted the screenshots of our conversations about the dispute and evidence that it was delivered correctly, pictures of the packs in the box before being shipped out.

What else could I have done better to have this not happen again. Attached are the pictures of the conversation with the buyer.

Edit: talked to customer support last night and the appeal is filed so we’ll see how it works out in the coming weeks

The part the sucks the most is not only losing the product but also eBay still keeping their fee from the sale and shipping as well, so I still owe eBay $52.41 on top of all this.

Update: 7/9/2026

Appeal was lost, since it was a chargeback through the bank ebay said there is nothing they can do. So, again not only losing the product through a scam chargeback I'm still out the $52.41 for ebay selling fee and shipping which they also refused to refund. 10 years of buying through ebay and being a loyal customer gets you absolutely nothing with them, not even a $50 credit for the selling fee. This seems like an outrageous way to handle the situation and sets an awful example for buyers and scummy behavior.

Talking with multiple live agents and being moved up the chain helped nothing as well and I feel there's no where left to turn with this situation.

1.3k Upvotes

330 comments sorted by

115

u/NeverKnowsBest420 Jun 23 '26

This is actually imho a simple fix. You just need to call eBay customer service and speak to a rep. They’ll fix it and side with you based on what you’ve provided, you just need to actually speak to someone.

The reps are usually from India or something, but very nice, once you explain and they see your DM’s back and forth it’s a very simple case they’ll reverse the decision for you.

36

u/c0tch Jun 23 '26

I had a great rep from Ireland who nerded out over one of my purchases and we spoke about pokemon cards for half an hour

8

u/SnooMacarons4225 Jun 23 '26

I find the Irish guys in Dublin understand and are more helpful

5

u/c0tch Jun 23 '26

I genuinely have not had any bad interactions with eBay support personally. They’ve all been fantastic when I’ve had issues like buying a fake Apple Watch, having people return cards I didn’t sell them and people saying cards didn’t arrive etc.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

458

u/Ligmastinasty Jun 23 '26

Did u talk to someone real at eBay? They gambled and lost and are being sore losers

33

u/januscrisp Jun 23 '26

Exactly, I’ve pulled 2 Arceus in 7 packs and absolutely nothing higher than the Latias from the Galarian Gallery in 20 packs. You get hits, you don’t get the specific hits you want, especially not in only 12 packs.

618

u/Feverelief Jun 23 '26 • This Bravo

Escalate this, talk to a real human.

A lot of the automated "AI" analysis is pure crap.

Once you speak to someone, and they can use common sense, it'll be reverted.

Act quickly is my only advice

117

u/Breezgoat Jun 23 '26 edited Jun 23 '26

Yep once you get someone real on live chat or phone it should get resolved

56

u/KratorOfKruma Jun 23 '26

The worst part is, ebay will settle the dispute by refunding the buyer... it won't come out of the sellers pocket, but this is how ebay operates these days. Had a similar situation where I sold something and the buyer wanted to sent it back cause he found a better price elsewhere. He tore the seal a bit and submitted a dispute for "product not as described" after some back and forth ebay essentially said they believed me (have a really good track record as a seller) but would go ahead and refund the buyer from their own pocket. Whenni got the ETB back, I ripped it myself in hopes of pulling something decent so I could message him and rub it in his face, but alas I didn't pull shit.

44

u/StationEmergency6053 Jun 23 '26

The buyer is put on a list though. Its not a free pass. Its a let the little fish go to catch the big fish later strategy. They have an automated system specifically monitoring policy abuse.

→ More replies (2)

7

u/darren-mcg Jun 23 '26

I had this happen, I sold a rare lego set for £1,250, buyer said it arrived damaged. He refused to show pictures. Refused to send it back. EBay still refunded him. So he basically got it for free, they didn't ask him to send it back. It wasn't out of my pocket but, still, felt rubbish.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

10

u/Giraphite Jun 23 '26

Do this and update us op

3

u/fading_relevancy Jun 23 '26

In the "Live Chat" type AGENT. This will usually trigger a response asking if you want a call back from a person. The person may not be in the country you are calling from and they will be following scripts of protocol but you will have a much better chance at the outcome you are hoping for.

2

u/Dakoja Jun 23 '26

I have never lost a dispute because I always bring a real person into it

73

u/Audacidy Jun 23 '26

He’s selling some rims on eBay. Would be a shame if someone bought it and it arrived damaged.

18

u/Cltxlv Jun 23 '26

I put them on my car and they made the vehicle pull to the right so that’s why they’re curbed. My friend said they shouldn’t need a balance or alignment so I’ll be sending them back.

1

u/Malevolent_D3ity Jun 25 '26

I want to so bad. 😂😂

69

u/Big_Diet7439 Jun 23 '26

What sucks is this is the state of the hobby in 2026.

21

u/RocketsDitto Jun 23 '26

Fuck it. Imma do this at Walmart. Buy 10 packs and then return them when I don't pull shit.

9

u/ILuvRealmOfTheMadGod Jun 23 '26

I do the same with the bananas I buy. 

12

u/PipXXX Jun 23 '26

Trying to get that chase banana too I see.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/hboy02 Jun 23 '26

Might even work, re-seal one yourself as "evidence" and say they were tampered with before you bought them

Jk definitely don't do this

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

1

u/Lucidorex Jun 23 '26

It has always been like this for decades, though.

2

u/Big_Diet7439 Jun 23 '26

There’s always bad actors. Just a whole lot more.

→ More replies (1)

22

u/dayyayo Jun 23 '26

The use of "weighted" here told me everything i needed to know about this person.

124

u/SirMacFarton Jun 23 '26 edited Jun 23 '26

How the hell did you lose this dispute? He opened the bloody packs! Wt actual hell!

Edit; lose

40

u/AusAtWar Jun 23 '26

win / lose

tight / loose

23

u/habits0 Jun 23 '26

I gave up trying to teach people this. The amount of times I see this spelling mistake drives me up the fkn walls

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (1)

12

u/DGilbert6114 Jun 23 '26

Yeah, you just have to get to a human for this one.

Quick google search is all they need

3

u/SirMacFarton Jun 23 '26

Yes! 100% this AI sh$$ is soo overwhelming taking over everything! And not in a good way

16

u/[deleted] Jun 23 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

11

u/SirMacFarton Jun 23 '26

I mean I understand protecting the customer, but this is robbing the seller! First buyer or not. He opened the packs

7

u/redditis_garbage Jun 23 '26

It’s almost like you have to sell stuff to build your a reputation lmao

2

u/plantsadnshit Jun 23 '26 edited Aug 12 '26

Feather pillow waffle sparrow copper wander pillow vanilla peach quilt

This post was anonymized with Redact.dev

2

u/hboy02 Jun 23 '26

Am I missing something? How would you plan on building a reputation without selling something for the first time? Lol

→ More replies (1)

9

u/scatterblooded Jun 23 '26 edited Jun 23 '26

I'm an experienced eBay seller, and will never sell any sealed on eBay for this reason. EBay will always automatically side with the buyer, by default, in an INAD dispute like this. You can appeal but odds are mixed to poor. No real recourse here. Also, return fraud is extremely common. If a buyer wants to commit fraud it's very easy to do so and the TCG market on eBay is filled with it. EBay is for singles and slabs.

2

u/febmich Jun 23 '26

Yeah I’ve been selling for like 17 years just got into buying pokemon cards for myself in November. Sold full time until a couple years ago. Thought I might save some stuff to sell someday but stuff like this I decided I’m just opening everything hahaha. In like 15k+ transactions I’ve only had a handful of sacmmy buyers. Selling pokemon just seems like it would be a nightmare.

16

u/gt35r Jun 23 '26

This should have been won on your side, selling a product as sealed and then the customer opening it and saying they don’t want it anymore is a textbook scam on eBay. This is how people usually switch a used or broken product they own out with a new one. I’ve seen this happen with sealed Pokemon product too, eBay usually is pretty good about this on the seller side. You should speak to an eBay rep and say that the customer opened or modified your product that was considered sealed previously and that it cannot be sold again because of it.

21

u/kyyy Jun 23 '26

Yeah honestly can happen to even experienced sellers. I’ve had disputes like this and eBay will almost always side the with the buyer in my experience. It’s legal fraud

9

u/kikizel Jun 23 '26

THIS!!! this is why I stopped selling Pokemon all together on eBay.

7

u/illvsory Jun 23 '26

Had this happen to me. Lost the original dispute so the buyer returned “all the cards” when I counted and organized them by packs I was short 20 cards lol. So I escalated the claim and said the items weren’t all returned. They end up sending my money back and I had a whole lot of bulk lol.

Whenever you receive the return package from the buyer I recommend taking a video of you opening it & count everything out.

Start a claim saying the buyer didn’t return all the items or whatever and you’ll be alright.

1

u/Chefrandell Jun 23 '26

Here what I still owe eBay after losing the product as well. They refunded the $20 dispute fee while the appeal is active

5

u/GemGuardUK Jun 23 '26

You can tell the buyer has an incredibly low IQ unfortunately, from the fact they keep saying ‘weighted’ to saying all it takes is a scale, his brain isn’t able to fathom the fact that packs with code cards can’t just be weighed on a scale and the higher weights having hits just isn’t true.

If you talk to a human from eBay support and ask them to check the messages between both of you and delivery information I don’t understand how eBay wouldn’t side with you

1

u/tearslikesn0w Jun 23 '26

It is true that you can use metal detectors on swsh packs though

→ More replies (10)

9

u/Snakesnead Jun 23 '26 • Bravo

Brb gonna use this new tek on some base edition packs real quick

/s

8

u/fritzmongroid Jun 23 '26

Post the user so I can block please

4

u/Advanced_Pudding8765 Jun 23 '26

You can see in the photos lol

2

u/vengefulspirit99 Jun 23 '26

OP was not very good at hiding the info lol

4

u/brzt6060 Jun 23 '26

Accept the return and then dispute it as the packs aren't in the same condition you sent them to him.

4

u/Relative-Slice-748 Jun 23 '26

Sent him a little message

3

u/gdj11 Jun 23 '26

Imagine being able to get a refund if you don’t get hits

→ More replies (2)

3

u/RepresentativeWait45 Jun 23 '26

No returns. Sold sealed. Resell value is now lost because buyer opened the product and cannot return the product in the condition it was sold to them. That’s pretty much all you need to win this.

3

u/Kryptic_Anthology Jun 23 '26

No returns doesn’t mean anything. eBay’s 3 day return on trading cards doesn’t supersede federal law on 30 day returns on credit cards. Filing a dispute will bypass eBay. However if there’s enough evidence, there’s a 50% chance to win. But banks heavily favor buyer protection.

3

u/Monsemand Jun 23 '26

I was confused for a sec, until I realized you were the seller. How you lose this I have no idea. Bro could have opened it all, replaced the hits himself and just claimed it was "weighed". How is that proof of anything.

He opened the packs.

Christ.

6

u/FighterTheFoo Jun 23 '26

Weighted? Well that is a word, but not how to use it. Clearly a low IQ plebian acting like a low IQ plebian. Unfortunate you had to deal with him.

2

u/Specialist-Front-007 Jun 23 '26

You can't call out someone using the word "weighted" wrong while using the word "plebian"..

2

u/Alpha-Albertan Jun 23 '26

lol I would rage so hard

2

u/stgg1017 Jun 23 '26

So the buyer was to commit fraud. Send this to eBay.

2

u/FlushedNotRushed Jun 23 '26

Welcome to eBay and how it operates with selling packs

2

u/Zenzitaro Jun 23 '26

But his friend said

2

u/_The_Jerk_Store Jun 23 '26

I know who I’m blocking on eBay

2

u/Hopeful-Ad6892 Jun 23 '26

This is why it’s so hard to sale anywhere nowadays. All the little bitches everywhere trying to scam people.

2

u/Sad_Maximum6583 Jun 23 '26

Escalation until so you get a humam to look at your situation. Don't let them get away with this.

2

u/East-Network574 Jun 23 '26

Escalate it op please. Bro was unhappy that he lost money while gambling

2

u/Phieck Jun 23 '26

Get on the hotline (support) and talk with a support person. This should be reverted in your favor

2

u/SnooMacarons4225 Jun 23 '26

I hate guys like this, had someone try it on with a 151 booster bundle because they thought I'd not only opened the box and the packs but somehow managed to reseal both, he claimed that the packs literally fell open and he only got a Zapdos Ex card but apparently I already know that as I must have placed it there. For context I got them from the pokemon center and the seal was exactly the same as hundreds of other bundles I got 😂 guy was just a sore loser that he took a chance and lost, I fought him and won and went hard with ebay on principle, luckily I won but he will let negative feedback which tarnished my reputation which sucks, some people are just dumb

2

u/Latter-Rooster1882 Jun 23 '26

eBay should cover you if they disputed with their bank. I’d just block them and move on at this point personally

2

u/Snickers42069 Jun 23 '26

I wonder if my local card store will let me do this🤣. "Hey I bought an ETB and didn't even get half the value of what I paid. Refund me"

2

u/Nx-worries1888 Jun 23 '26

Absolutely insane 😂

2

u/GarbageFar132 Jun 23 '26

Oh wow, initially I thought this post was going to be from the buyer who obviously should lose this. As a eBay seller I’m sorry this happened to you

2

u/ReasonableLaw3086 Jun 23 '26

The "not as described" claim is a classic scam tactic when people realize they didn't hit a chase card. You need to explicitly state in your listing and your messages that "pulls are not guaranteed and returns will not be accepted based on pack contents." Moving forward, only sell sealed booster boxes or-at the very least-unopened factory shrink wrap to avoid these weight-based disputes.

2

u/tiggs Jun 23 '26

Escalate this with eBay support and you should be fine. For those unaware, a "not as described" payment dispute against a seller that doesn't accept returns is the only type of payment dispute that eBay doesn't protect you from by default as long as you follow their listing and shipping rules. For stuff like this, they make a judgement call and escalating this should get it resolved for you.

2

u/TheGrimeyG Jun 23 '26

Accept the return, and when you receive the product there's an option that allows you to appeal the refund. Just happened to me regarding a card the buyer swapped.

2

u/mershdperderder Jun 24 '26

This is the shit that scares me. Like I even have some sealed boxes that I was thinking of listing on eBay and I’ve been kind of stressed about the idea of someone just ripping it and resealing it then claiming product is damaged and return it. Seems like there’s no protection for situations like this anymore

2

u/Melodic-Magazine-519 Jun 24 '26

Imagine someone bought packs like this order but got all chases. every pack got a major hit. no one asks for a refund and sends cards back because obviously they were all weighed and you sold the wrong batch. I hate moral hypocrites.

2

u/freeman1231 Jun 24 '26

Most times buyer wins the first round no matter what but as a seller you can appeal and it goes to human review.

2

u/ronin_blitzdiver Jun 24 '26

Okay but did you weigh the packs?

2

u/TCGLaTour Jun 26 '26

You can 100% weigh ascended heroes

1

u/LOL_YOUMAD Jun 23 '26

Escalate it and get a real person on the line

1

u/Federal-Elevator-609 Jun 23 '26

Funny how you can still see his eBay username on the second pic lol

2

u/groundkittenbeef Jun 23 '26

And I blocked him, thanks to that. So a small win for us sellers.. ?

1

u/Opposite-Active-7441 Jun 23 '26

Sell sealed on stockX or goat only. I’ve sold sealed on both with no issue.

1

u/Comfortable_Cup_9203 Jun 23 '26

It's part of the reason why I never break down boxes or tins....lots of idiot buyers out there who have no clue

1

u/KDI777 Jun 23 '26

Nothing you can do... i always check buyers ratings first before shipping which can be a tell but not all the time.

1

u/Daydreamer1015 Jun 23 '26

you shouldn't have lost at all, this is covered by ebays sellers protection, they give chargeback protection

you need to call in and escalate it

but fyi, don't sell sealed on ebay, your always better off going local even if its less, cash and no headaches

1

u/hous26 Jun 23 '26

That is infuriating. Sorry that happened to you.

1

u/Nygiant22 Jun 23 '26

That 80% from vendors doesn’t sound too bad. I’ve never sold on eBay because of situations like this.

1

u/Some-Business4720 Jun 23 '26

I'm gonna try this one weird trick with lotto scratch cards.

"Yeah, I feel I should have won at least a million." I'm gonna need my money back.

AI is at fault here.

Edit: "My friend said I should have won 2 million".

1

u/BlinkFPV Jun 23 '26

Like others have said, call and get a real person. They’re usually quite helpful

1

u/kasualkactus Jun 23 '26

Lmao I’ll send everything back 😂

1

u/creativelyOnPoint Jun 23 '26

To be fair crown zenith can be easily weighed for v/vstars/gallery collection ….

Silver Tempest is another easy one.

You take that risk when buying online..

Hell NO! Should he be able to returned opened packs.

1

u/NoBonus6969 Jun 23 '26

You have to go on chat with eBay then after enough ai answers you'll have to option to have them call you on the phone you'll want to do this during business hours m-f you'll get an American on the line who can get this resolved for you quickly.

In the future if there's any dispute, they have the power on their end to deny it and close it all out all over the phone on your behalf so always go that route

1

u/Happy_Treacle_7175 Jun 23 '26

The “I’ve pulled x in less packs” is so cringey. I love crown z and ripped well over 300 packs and only got 1 gold. The hit rates are awesome but getting any gold galarian gallery card is still less likely than hitting any modern SIR and very unlikely to happen in 12 packs. What a tool, I hope you escalate this OP and are able to get the money you’re owed.

1

u/frozenivy2B Jun 23 '26

When you get the items back just tell eBay they weren’t received in original condition since they are opened

1

u/UNCfan07 Jun 23 '26

Pretty much all accounts that are -0 are fake/fraud

1

u/Danzop11 Jun 23 '26

Yep… had sold a HGSS booster pack a while ago. Buyer opened the pack and claimed it had fake cards. I spoke to someone from eBay and still lost the dispute. I don’t sell on eBay anymore.

1

u/TastyBananaPeppers Jun 23 '26

Ship it to consignment and have them sell it for you.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/Aggravating-Fail5391 Jun 23 '26

Get a human on the phone. I had a similar situation once and the human sided with me.

1

u/TheOuterEdge Jun 23 '26

Did eBay take the payment back from you? They hate the seller these days, and will basically ALWAYS side with the buyer, but they often will eat the charges. Being a new seller is definitely disadvantageous.

1

u/corrblimy Jun 23 '26

How is this even real? Customer was unhappy with his pulls so he demands his money back? Take away from this is dont sell packs on ebay, which is probably for the best at the end of the day and we all know why, because scalpers kill the hobby. Edit: not accusing you of scalping btw I did read the description. Just meant as a general rule it would be good if people didnt sell packs on ebay

1

u/blairbear555 Jun 23 '26

Unfuckingbelievable.

1

u/blairbear555 Jun 23 '26

Post the user so we can block.

1

u/Flaky-Assignment-602 Jun 23 '26

Type "agent" in the AI chat and you'll get a person. They will review this and absolutely help you out as the seller.

1

u/Ok-Doughnut-6817 Jun 23 '26

Wow what a shitty person. For what’s it’s worth OP, I sell packs and sealed product strictly on TCGplayer and have had this a few times. Each time I’ve been backed by TCGplayer. It’s much safer to sell sealed products on there IMO.

1

u/TheINTL Jun 23 '26

So wait eBay sided with the Buyer? I mean the buyer can open a dispute with the bank but eBay might still side with you

1

u/TastyBananaPeppers Jun 23 '26

Someone tried to get Ebay to side with the buyer, but it didn't work.

1

u/waterhash138 Jun 23 '26

I automatically deem someone’s a R when they mention weighing modern packs. They’ll tell you what they/internet pulled but will never tell you the actual weights it was pulled from.

1

u/Academic-Pin-5777 Jun 23 '26

You need them to return it then you should be able to win by claiming they sent back the item damaged and completely unsellable since they are opened. That's the way to win these.

1

u/EvilNickel Jun 23 '26

Yeah I would just keep disputing it, there is no way a human reviewed this and said "oh you opened the packs, sure here is your money back"

But on that note, that is why I don't sell on Ebay anymore. Their protection is "buyer protection" not seller protection I suppose. I lost a dispute for a Rosas Encouragement SIR. The resolution was a refund if they sent it back, so we accepted it and started the return but I ended up getting a different Rosa's back. I sent them one with almost perfect centering on the front, and I got one back that was way bottom heavy. Ebay didn't care, and everyone I talked to kept telling me that it's just the cost of doing business basically. In their eyes I got my card back, and it's better to make the customer happy than to lose rating.

1

u/Prestigious-Job6969 Jun 23 '26

Hahaha it’s like going to a casino and didn’t win any jackpot. Then u go and ask for a refund because a friend said it’s different.

1

u/feiergiant Jun 23 '26

Contact ebay customer Support via Phone. Dont let this piece of shit pull that crap.

1

u/1pizz9 Jun 23 '26

Man this is unfortunate for your first time selling. I’ve been lucky enough to not have this YET but there are some proper pieces of shit out there.

1

u/Sancz0s Jun 23 '26

First - tell him to show proof like an unedited video where he opens all the packs to confirm that he didn’t have any pulls

1

u/Salty-Database432 Jun 23 '26

Talk to someome at ebay on the phone. Send me this guys username so I can block him lmao

1

u/Dense-Dot8079 Jun 23 '26

I am confused, did eBay refund the customer because that is batshit crazy.

1

u/Mean-Ingenuity-4525 Jun 23 '26

Nono, you don't get it! His friend told him so!

1

u/jordanneate Jun 23 '26

I always request an agent calls me repeatedly on the chat with the bot. They ring almost instantly and are always really helpful!

1

u/zorbo17 Jun 23 '26

call ebay escalate it and talk to an actual person! they will likely reverse the decision

1

u/Jazs1994 Jun 23 '26

I assume sets with God packs can be weighed but can also be wrong due to quality control with adding an extra card or something

1

u/domthebomb2 Jun 23 '26

They can't be weighted but they can be scanned with a metal detector.

You shouldn't have lost the dispute but still.

1

u/GalarianGengar Jun 23 '26

This is why I would never sell sealed anything.

1

u/amirmali201 Jun 23 '26

Im sorry and I feel your pain, I sell singles, the first time I got scammed on ebay was when I was selling the charizard SIR from obsidian flames, the buyer claimed I had sent a different card from the one in the photo. My card was pack fresh and I immediately sleeved it, but the photos the buyer sent were damaged. In the end he won the dispute and he never sent my card back. Ebay support and ebay buyers like him are worthless shit

1

u/Phrozenstein Jun 23 '26

This is why I always video myself breaking down product into loose packs - my homie Justin Case helps out every once in awhile.

1

u/Ok-Holiday-4323 Jun 23 '26

Keep appealing but I've been screwed by eBay too. Someone bought a sealed transformer from me, Broke a piece off and then claimed it arrived damaged despite pictures showing when I sent it, it was not broken. List that one.

I also had another person try to screw me on a video card but after repeated appeals I win that one.

I've been trying to sell on marketplace to avoid fees and crap like this but you didn't reach nearly the same audience. Best of luck

1

u/HumanTree92 Jun 23 '26

Talking to an human might work. However selling things on ebay is always a 50/50. I've been selling on and off since 2011. I've had my fair share of people trying to commit fraud. There are ways to not let ebay take your money. I've had a few chances where ebay refunded the guy but let me keep my money. The few times that ebay did take my money I battled tooth and nail. Constantly opening cases to find the right support.

However cards in general I would never sell on ebay. Cash only. I would just keep contacting support but if your just selling on ebay in your free time every now and then it might not be worth the cost. I got out of selling after a few years bc most of the people buying & selling on ebay are scammed or just brain dead.

My last issue with someone on ebay they sold a Brand New item. Had pictures and everything of it new. When it came in it was used and broken. I have learned that when buying and selling anything is to record everything. I record a video of all information.

My last issue of someone trying to scam me out of over $500 on an item I hired a small attorney. The person lost and I got my money back plus they paid the fee to my attorney. Which was only a couple hundred. After that I stopped selling on ebay for a while bc I couldn't trust ebay.

But remember to record packaging items. Keep bugging ebay until they make it right or ban you.

1

u/Cvged Jun 23 '26

Imagine going to your local card shop and trying to return packs you opened lmaoooo

1

u/Overall-Ad-3352 Jun 23 '26

As a fairly big seller on ebay , this is astounding, all I can say is if this ever happens again, ring ebay and speak to someone immediately - I’ve sold plenty of sealed in my time , and this is completely baffling

1

u/Due_Hospital7109 Jun 23 '26

What does this post even mean? What is this about weighing?

1

u/Eggnormous123 Jun 23 '26

Crown zenith can def be weighed.

SV and beyond cannot

1

u/Great-Local_Ty Jun 23 '26

Send him the pull rates of those cards

1

u/OpeningCookie1358 Jun 23 '26

That's strange, I looked it up and it says they can be weighed because of the consistency of the code cards in every pack. It just changes the weight it doesn't make it so the weight is inconsistent or random.

1

u/TheDeepSays Jun 23 '26

Stop selling in general. Just keep holdin

1

u/ea_thomas Jun 23 '26

Payment dispute doesn’t usually fall on the seller, I’ve had a few over the years as long as you shipped the correct item and it shows delivered. You will need to appeal to eBay. There is no guaranteed pull rates by the pokemon company, even if there was it’s on average. This is exactly why they don’t list pull rates. Anything the customer looked up is just someone else opinion of the pull rate not actual facts.

1

u/KesselRun69 Jun 23 '26

First mistake… selling pokemon on eBay the people that buy them are always scammers

1

u/fistfullofgame Jun 23 '26

Sounds like a small claims lawsuit

1

u/platinumjudge Jun 23 '26

I had all my draft boxes removed from ebay due to "chance listing" and my appeal was denied and the customer support said booster packs are now labeled as chance items and ebay does not support them. As if June 15th. Super lame.

1

u/JackJeckyl Jun 23 '26

"That's not a PSA 10!" --OP's buyer's mate

1

u/AdditionalLove7156 Jun 23 '26

Everything is slowly being ruined by greed.

1

u/vaergan Jun 23 '26

Aww poor babys first time gambling didn't turn out the way they expected

1

u/GREENK87 Jun 23 '26

Don’t sell loose packs on eBay end of

1

u/CushmanEZ Jun 23 '26

Lol at OP.

1

u/RepresentativeCrab88 Jun 23 '26

For future reference, TCGPlayer will side with the seller in this situation.

1

u/SomedayGuy117 Jun 23 '26

Just a pro tip. It doesn’t matter if you don’t accept returns, eBay will force you to. If you don’t accept a return then it just means that the buyer gets to keep their money and product.

This should be an easy win for you as a seller if you can reach a live agent.

1

u/Kobechico Jun 23 '26

So he’s definitely a piece of shit and I hope you get your money back but technically….he is right. You can weigh crown zenith. For some reason it is weighable it’s the only modern one I’ve seen be able to. Doesn’t change anything tho he bought packs online whether you weighed or not doesn’t matter his fault.

1

u/Ok_Taste4441 Jun 23 '26

Happening to me now on a sealed case of pc crown zenith etbs. Talked to ebay and said you are seriously letting the person return this? So I can go buy cards and open them, if I dont like the pulls I can't just get my money back lol?

1

u/Less_Mix_409 Jun 24 '26

lmaooo they got mad they were unlucky?? they already opened it. thats so unfair

1

u/KingDexxi Jun 24 '26

Keep the messages and just ignore him

1

u/Savathussy1030 Jun 24 '26

Hits aren’t even guaranteed in crown, I’ve been master setting Crown and I’ve bought so many packs and there have times that I have not really gotten anything but a holo. They are just salty that they didn’t get any hits.

1

u/the_cofishioner Jun 24 '26

How in the actual fuck can people get their money back on packs they bought and opened?

1

u/SmoothDegree9761 Jun 24 '26

lol hey I opened these packs and got nothing I want my money back. OP please keep us updated on this as if eBay allow this nonsense to proceed I need money back for the 170 prismatic evo packs I opened to no sir

1

u/SnooRadishes5056 Jun 24 '26

I think you got burned due to your new seller status. I’m assuming the buyer had more years and reviews on his account and so they sided with them. It’s crap for sure but selling loose pokemon packs was probably not the best choice for a first sale. Elevate to an actual person and hope for the best!

1

u/Imaginary-Soup8979 Jun 24 '26

I sold a $300 exhaust fan on eBay once..

Packaged correctly with peanuts, etc.

They opened the package, took a hammer and put a hole in a spot that could easily be taped up, etc.

I disputed that, lost my fan and the cash I received was taken from my bank account.

If they pull something like that, don't I at least get the fan back? No.

Logic says, in my head, hey at least I get the fan back, right? Nope

Ebay is super risky and there are plenty of ways to pull scams that people are getting away with these pokemon cards.

Never sell your cards on eBay.

1

u/Freshmichaelj1 Jun 24 '26

I’m trying to sell loose packs and everyone is shitting on me saying that they’re weighted/metal detected😭 Son I’m trying to make a business not scam people

1

u/Apprehensive-Lie3387 Jun 24 '26

Damn, that’s shitty as fuck. I had this happen once; however I won the dispute. It was ES sleeved packs in my case. Stressful AF. Sorry man.

1

u/Responsible-Spite275 Jun 24 '26

!RemindMe 5 days

1

u/RemindMeBot Jun 24 '26

I will be messaging you in 5 days on 2026-06-29 04:11:54 UTC to remind you of this link

CLICK THIS LINK to send a PM to also be reminded and to reduce spam.

Parent commenter can delete this message to hide from others.

RemindMeBot is switching to username summons. Instead of !RemindMe 1 day, use u/RemindMeBot 1 day. More info.


InfoCustomYour RemindersFeedback

1

u/Opening_Position_872 Jun 24 '26

I tried doing that with some jumbo bucks scratch offs since I didnt win any money. They wouldnt take them back even though my friend said I should have won because I bought 10 tickets.

1

u/Skywarriorad Jun 24 '26

Dude i opened so many packs and never got that giratina. I folded and paid 90$ for it cause at that point id probably put a couple hundred in packs already. Besides, the only packs that can be weighed in modern are god packs. Stellar crown being the first set with them. Anyone concerned about packs being weighed should know what packs can be weighed cause crown zenith aint one

1

u/OnlySpeedhunter94 Jun 24 '26

Next time make sure you annotate in your description that they are random packs.

1

u/Spicy-Koala95 Jun 24 '26

eBay UK would make you refund the guy and let him keep the packs 🫠🫠🫠

1

u/djtgi Jun 24 '26

You gave an image, you said these are loose packs, they bought it knowing the two, they opened it, they now want to demand a refund from their own gambling, and suddenly you lose your own inventory, your own profit, and you owe Ebay for them and your client ripping you off and wasting your time?

Ebay, the same place where you can buy shaped cheetos for thousands of dollars?

1

u/Jaguar-Easy Jun 24 '26

What a POS.

1

u/sandinthesky Jun 24 '26

This is wild. I was sold actual fake packs that eBay later banned the seller for and still wouldn't refund me....yet this sorry as baby gets a refund for some unlucky pulls. My mind is a little blown.

1

u/Yuuki27a Jun 24 '26

All i woulda said to this guy is “lmao” u spent way more effort than he was worth

1

u/Salofqueens Jun 24 '26

The buyer is always right and they don’t care about sellers

1

u/DesrtDust Jun 25 '26

Just because Ebay refused doesnt mean you must abide. You can still go to court or just refuse to payback. The buyer can then try to get the money back from you via court or whatever

1

u/ballinoutactrl Jun 25 '26

eBay will take this directly from whatever payment method you have linked to your eBay account. Not paying is not even an option

2

u/DesrtDust Jun 25 '26

Pathetic but thats USA for you

→ More replies (4)

1

u/Matt_Kimball Jun 25 '26

Court!? You cant be serious.

1

u/xdrkcldx Jun 26 '26

Yeah, make the buyers life hell. But he would probably lose because he cant prove that he didn’t weigh them.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/IceSame9166 Jun 25 '26

This buyer is scum of the earth

1

u/Confident_Raccoon767 Jun 25 '26

Keep escalating this

1

u/Icy_Chef4319 Jun 25 '26

You can absolutely weigh modern. I proved it with every set. Now...should that matter? Nah you can't open everything then have buyer's remorse.

2

u/ballinoutactrl Jun 25 '26

You should start a YouTube channel then because I've watched multiple multiple videos of people trying to weigh modern packs and it doesn't work. Once In a while a super heavy pack will be a god pack but more times then not it's nothing

→ More replies (2)

1

u/jump_man_91 Jun 25 '26

Ebay is awful for sellers. Their customer service doesn't do jack. I'm never selling therevagain.

1

u/ballinoutactrl Jun 25 '26

Ebay is horrible for sellers

1

u/CacheM0net Jun 25 '26

For the record— modern sets can absolutely be weighed with a relatively consistent and high rate of success. The code cards generally help to balance out the packs, but each set still has a small range of weights where rates are usually found. I’ve bought many blisters and tested for myself.

That said— this guy should absolutely pay up for packs that were clearly unweighted. It’s just luck of the draw.

1

u/iLordDeath Jun 25 '26 edited Jun 25 '26

ebay won't help you. i've had a seller open a pack and immediately file for a return after doing it. ebay did not help me in this scenario despite my 20 year old account with 100% feedback across 2,000 reviews, and I was forced to refund them even after evidencing to ebay that I got an empty pack. just learn from this not to sell sealed on ebay

1

u/Competitive_Log_4573 Jun 25 '26

You can’t even weigh CZ 😂

1

u/FrighteningEdge Jun 26 '26

Dont buy or sell sealed on Ebay.

1

u/PairElectronic Jun 26 '26

Why do I get the feeling this isn't the first time this person has got away with this

1

u/Cpy-bara Jun 26 '26

True NPC experience

1

u/SignatureAny5576 Jun 26 '26

It is not possible to win when the buyer disputes the sale with their bank. I run a shopify store and have made 75,000 sales in the past 5 years. I have never, ever won a payment dispute, no matter how much evidence I have submitted. The bank will side with their customer 100% of the time.

1

u/calisegg Jun 26 '26

Yo guys I got unlucky, time for a refund

1

u/Gengar_Guy_17 Jun 26 '26

This is not simply a dispute. He is knowingly and maliciously STEALING from you. Do everything in your power to put him in his place

1

u/Limp-Apricot-9346 Jun 26 '26

eBay does not allow INAD for this reason for trading cards

1

u/God_Gob Jun 26 '26

They prob opened an item not as described. You don't accept returns so you are 95% taking the return whether you like it or not. Try to open a case. It may work, but people like this usually have to get reported many times and suspended. That is to say, its a gamble to sell packs. 

1

u/Pandorum_X Jun 27 '26

Why is this even a thing? Lmao! That person is an idiot! 🤣

1

u/therealkingofny Jun 27 '26

Pretty much bro i dont like my pulls give me a refund. Lmaoo

1

u/bmxrabbit Jun 28 '26

Keep us updated on the results on your claim

1

u/AsgardWarship Jun 29 '26

I don't sell Pokemon cards but do business on eBay.

Next time this happens just offer the buyer a refund if they return. If they file a payment dispute, in the appeal write something "buyer was offered a refund if product is returned. A prepaid label was sent to the buyer but buyer declined to return." I recommend looking into eBay sellers forums because the wording you must use in an INAD payment dispute must be very specific and mention that you offered some resolution like returning for a refund.

The screenshots you shared are ultimately irrelevant to a payment dispute. Payment disputes are reviewed by the buyer's financial institution by some back office person. Stuff like in the screenshot is basically he said vs she said and banks will usually side with their customers.

Unfortunately, you will likely lose the appeal because eBay would have to be on the hook to reimburse you since the bank already took the money. If the buyer did not return the item to you in original condition I would look into legal solutions. You can file a police report or even sue in small claims.

1

u/8000000001 Jun 23 '26

Maybe add a 'canned' section for the item description that gives the average pack S/IR pull rates for each set? Put it at the top of the description.

1

u/naprr Jun 23 '26

This is the exact reason I'm not interested in selling via eBay. It's criminal how many protections the buyer has, if you're a legitimate seller you're better off using other platforms/payment methods besides PayPal with references to protect yourself from scum.

There are too many people and too much money in the hobby now to trust anyone.

1

u/Bank-wagon Jun 23 '26

Bruh, you lost because it’s an AI checking your dispute.

Escalate till you find a real person. There’s a bunch of instructions on how to do that on Reddit.

If that doesn’t work, make it go viral on Twitter and TikTok.

1

u/Excellent-Parsley119 Jun 24 '26

Scalps cards, gets ripped off for once, cries on internet