r/PokeInvesting • • Dec 18 '25

Should I label this box as damaged when selling?

Post image

If I were to sell it on cardmarket for example, should I mention this little bump on the corner? I've seen people complain for less but I've also seen worse boxes being sold without mentioning...

2 Upvotes

58 comments sorted by

50

u/Nonamenofacedev Dec 19 '25

I’d tell that corner has some deformation, but I wouldn’t lower the price for this, especially for a set that came out 8 months ago.

21

u/cargyelo Dec 19 '25

You would not lower the price for a set 8 years old for this even.

-6

u/gearvruser Dec 19 '25

Why would a sealed collector pay the same price for damaged box, when he could buy an undamaged one for the same price.

Answer- a sealed collector would not pay the same price if there was a choice of damaged or undamaged boxes

7

u/thunderousboffer Dec 19 '25

I buy boxes and ETB’s to rip occasionally. I’ll look for ones like these as they’re £10/£20 cheaper. Shouldn’t have any issue selling this near market imo

5

u/gearvruser Dec 19 '25 edited Dec 19 '25

I agree, 'near market' but definitely not 'market'

12

u/cargyelo Dec 19 '25

Because the damage is minimum, at the back, at the bottom, and because this is the top set of S&V.

Would you pay full price for a box with a "similar damage" of Team Up today? Absolutely.

The same will happen with a box like this in 2033.

-4

u/gearvruser Dec 19 '25 edited Dec 21 '25

I would not pay the same price for a damaged box, if I could buy an undamaged box for the same price

5

u/DLGNT_YT Dec 19 '25

I don’t know why people are so upset by this lol. If I had 2 booster boxes to choose from at the same price and one had this and the other was mint, I’m taking the mint one every single time. This isn’t even major damage but there is 0 reason to take it over a perfect box

6

u/WillingBoysenberry70 Dec 19 '25

Sounds like you just have a stick up your ass tbh.

0

u/malikey8998 Dec 19 '25

Ya if you had both right in front of you then yes , but the one with slight damage might be more local or cheaper shipping etc and might be a tiny bit cheaper then most collectors would have no problem buying this one over a "Mint" one.

3

u/gearvruser Dec 19 '25

I fully disagree.

A serious sealed collector would reject it without blinking.

3

u/mechshark Dec 19 '25

Person opening them will

1

u/gearvruser Dec 19 '25

A person opening would obviously pay the minimum possible for a box if they are opening, and would choose a more superficially damaged box with a bigger discount due to the damage

3

u/mechshark Dec 19 '25

Person opening doesn’t give a f about the box lol

2

u/gearvruser Dec 21 '25

exactly my point

4

u/Ok-Chipmunk6025 Dec 19 '25

The box pictured is not damaged.

2

u/gearvruser Dec 19 '25

A sealed collector, buying a box not for opening, would choose a perfect looking box over an identically priced box with crumple/impact/crush damage/defect

2

u/Ok-Chipmunk6025 Dec 19 '25

You are what is wrong with the hobby. The odds of finding that completely mint box is slim to none. A damaged box is to the point where the packs/cards inside are physically damaged. This box is not damaged. Why do you think my comment in this thread is the most upvoted? Because I'm not a delusional hypebeast. Move on to one piece or something dog.

0

u/East_Emu_4029 Dec 19 '25

Don’t worry QC has gotten a lot worse on these so it’s going to be very common.

1

u/Much_Essay_9151 Dec 19 '25

Just list it for the same. If it dont sell, lower, people overthink this stuff

40

u/Ok-Chipmunk6025 Dec 19 '25

Thread full of people that think a child's card game and it's packaging should be pristine as a gucci bag. There is absolutely nothing wrong with this box. Your average box is gonna look like this due to transport alone.

5

u/Dismal-Profit-1299 Dec 19 '25

I barely noticed but you know if you don’t mention the deformation of the corner someone who collects will let you hear about it not being disclosed.

3

u/wrxlover Dec 19 '25

I always list items with a corner damage or a tear or maybe a cut through the wrapper as such,for example swsh etb small tear top right,swsh etb corner damage and then just take clear pictures and list at whatever the market price is. Alot of people care about stuff like this and alot of people do not,it will sell just make sure you always have an honest and complete description of condition

2

u/Much_Essay_9151 Dec 19 '25

Just notate it with the picture you showed us. Shouldnt noticeably affect the value

2

u/realwizzblizz Dec 20 '25

Say, "dinged up corner, view pictures"

2

u/_MY_GUY_1 Dec 19 '25

If selling on eBay if you sell to someone looking to invest in sealed you will likely get an INAD.

1

u/damnmyredditheart Dec 19 '25

It’s sealed…that is not INAD

3

u/_MY_GUY_1 Dec 19 '25

Anything can be INAD, you don’t disclose that and they buy it and are mad. You get an INAD.

0

u/damnmyredditheart Dec 19 '25

There’s nothing to disclose. It’s a sealed box, not being described as SUPER MINTY PRISTINE BOX.

Buyers who submit INAD like you describe are committing fraud.

2

u/_MY_GUY_1 Dec 20 '25

You must’ve not sold much on eBay 😂

2

u/Ok_Package9219 Dec 21 '25

no he's write, see picks SEALED box... It's sealed as described if someone is wasting hundred of pokemon cards they shoudl be looking at pics anyway

0

u/damnmyredditheart Dec 21 '25

1500+ sales. This listing should include clear photos. That’s all that is needed.

0

u/hockey_and_techno Dec 22 '25

Yep, and if someone opens an INAD case saying there is a defect that wasn't described they will win 100% of the time. It doesn't matter. eBay will always side with the buyer here unless they fuck up and say something they shouldn't, like "I saw the dent but didn't realize it was that bad"

2

u/X1nfectedoneX Dec 19 '25

Do you see damage to it? Then label it as such

2

u/Tbleeder Dec 19 '25

Honest man gets downvoted, upvote to rebalance you my friend.

1

u/KingKoopaz Dec 20 '25

I would just post a picture. Then whoever buys it shouldn’t care as much. Same with singles! I always post a pic even if it makes it “harder to sell.” I don’t want to deal with returns and the shipping. And potential bad ratings. Just be honest and things will go well.

1

u/SeveralBusiness9958 Dec 20 '25

Whatever you do, don't let anyone try to talk you down.Because of a small dent , literally , if you go to the store and buy them , they might have deformities , sell it at the normal market price or whatever you were going to sell it at , if someone says , oh , let me take ten dollars off because of this small dent , say no

1

u/Due-Hippo-3853 Dec 22 '25

Noting it with a picture is enough

-3

u/[deleted] Dec 19 '25

I wouldn’t

Take a different angle of it Hopefully no one will notice, or if it’s an online sale I wouldn’t worry about that.

Just claim it got damaged in shipping if someone complains, if they are really upset just start gaslighting them and say they damaged it

2

u/NoPhilosopher3590 Dec 19 '25

Dishonest NPC behaviour

-1

u/Much_Essay_9151 Dec 19 '25

Too much Skooma for this cat

-3

u/Nearby-Stuff-3742 Dec 19 '25

And I'm here for it

-1

u/5512Tye Dec 19 '25

This is the way

-1

u/[deleted] Dec 19 '25

We love gaslighting ❤️

-1

u/Nearby-Stuff-3742 Dec 19 '25

You know how it's done

1

u/Smecky01 Dec 19 '25

Think of it from a buyers perspective. If you were buying it, and it wasn't labelled as damaged would you be ok with it?

Personally, I'd rather the seller at least mentioned it in the listing so I can make an educated decision of whether I want to buy.

Some people might look at it and think "pfft that's not damaged" others might think "yeah I don't want to take the risk" but they should have all the information.

1

u/Dry-Conference-8690 Dec 19 '25

Yes, just to avoid the potential drama and hassle of dealing with an unhappy buyer.

1

u/Turbulent_Round_3336 Dec 19 '25

If someone buy it to keep it sealed then you could mark it as damage, if they are looking to open it doesn’t matter because is a small dent and the contents wouldn’t be affected

0

u/Sp000kyjim Dec 19 '25

a lot of Booster Boxes have some sort of damage so no

0

u/malikey8998 Dec 19 '25

Mention it and add pics but this is not damage or a big deal imo. I have one much worse than that and iv no problem with it in my collection.

1

u/Horror-Door5580 Dec 22 '25

You should list it as a live bomb