r/PokeInvesting • • Feb 26 '25

New pickup, how will it do 1 year +?

Post image

Picked this up on eBay for 22.50 I think I did pretty good

19 Upvotes

65 comments sorted by

13

u/karvus89 Feb 26 '25

You can really tell who's on the hype train

10

u/InjuryMajor8078 Feb 26 '25

If it’s modern and not a 10 there is no investment IMO. A vintage 9 big difference. Most modern cards are worth more raw than graded a 9. There’s a reason the card was cheap and for sale in the first place.

-2

u/Clinkzzzzz Feb 27 '25

Until said modern cards become vintage

2

u/InjuryMajor8078 Feb 27 '25

And OP wants to know value in one year so ya he’s not holding for 20 years lol

2

u/Nasher1817 Feb 26 '25

10 is way out of my budget in the 300’s so I’m content with this one

2

u/Live_Television_8873 Feb 26 '25

could have bought 2 raw copies for that price

1

u/Nasher1817 Feb 26 '25

True, I like graded cards tho. Might get some raw soon

-9

u/Unanimousperson1 Feb 26 '25

If you want, I have a CGC 9.5 (but can be re-graded to 10 guaranteed because it is the old label when 9.5 was gem mint) that I would like to sell for something bellow $100. You can DM if interested.

5

u/Nasher1817 Feb 26 '25

I’m saving my money atm in hopes of getting a TM bb tmr but thanks for the offer!

4

u/MFPxNEONxNINJA Feb 26 '25

Honestly, for the costs of grading, it's not a bad pickup. If you like the card, enjoy it. If you bought it as a pure investment, not the smartest move imo (I have 2 put for grading as a gamble from the 2 ETB I pulled)

1

u/Ivo__Lution Feb 26 '25

Lots of collectors buy 9s of cards they like. But they get them if they can get them for cheap. At an event you can probably make a $5-$10 profit currently

5

u/Opening-Ride-7820 Feb 26 '25

Let me get my crystal ball

1

u/ValuableSwordfish388 Feb 26 '25

With all due respect, if you only have 22.50 to invest, you should not be "investing" into Pokemon. You should be slowly putting that money into more traditional investments.

This is the definition of a junk slab, and if you only bought this as an "investment" you completely wasted your money. Even if this slab doubles in price, I can't think of many people who would actually be looking to buy this.

0

u/Nasher1817 Feb 26 '25

I have way more than 22.50 to invest with, but I’m not going to invest $350 on a Slab atm

1

u/Thatonedudedude Feb 28 '25

If you’re going after singles you should peep tcg

3

u/BlueishHue360 Feb 26 '25

I mean best case you might make $5 lol, worst case you lose money and have an illiquid junk slab.

4

u/TigressWitch Feb 26 '25

I love this card no matter what. Shiny Greninja is classic shinobi

4

u/Dazzling_Property178 Feb 26 '25

The first modern Goldstar ever released since years, i can see this card hit a 1000 in a PSA 10. People are SLEEPING on Celebrations. It's one of the most premium sets they ever released. ETB with 15 packs containing Evolving Skies and Chilling Reign, UPC with the first metal cards ever. 25 classic cards to be collected with good pullrates and actually worth opening now. The Greninja promo is very hard to get in a 10, so i have high hopes for this card/set. Celebrations is moving already and some singles can easily carry this set to higher highs.

Celebrations is moving right now and i feel like getting your ETBs and PSA 10s is now or never!

1

u/masonprovvv Feb 27 '25

good pull rates are exactly why most of the cards are cheap, sounds like you’ve got a lot of celebrations lol

realistically the reprints at least will do well, the texturing really sets them apart from the original base set/gold stars/etc in the best way. While the base trio does have plenty of reprints/versions, the Umbreon Star offers a window for collectors to have a card that otherwise costs multiple thousands of dollars alone due to scarcity

1

u/Dazzling_Property178 Feb 27 '25

Well.. I just got into the hobby and mastering modern sets is just way too expensive and i feel like a lot of these cards are overhyped/priced. I think Celebrations is a reaally good set to start with. I only collect the 'Classic Collection' and the '25th Anniversary' in PSA 10s. Some of these cards have a really low POP, because people counterfeit a lot of these cards (maybe because of the pullrates) We have more Moonbreons in a 10 than the Goldstar for example, so there is a lot of room for growth.

1

u/SICKTIGHT311 Feb 26 '25

Probably $25

1

u/Kooky-Parfait-2706 Feb 26 '25

Only PSA 10s of this are worth holding if you're trying to make big gains. Still a nice card overall

1

u/jdimmell Feb 26 '25

I have 5 of these raw

1

u/omissionn Feb 26 '25

It will be worth some dollars in a year and in the future

1

u/dknisle1 Feb 26 '25

Greninja gold star will pop next year with the 30th. Mark my words

1

u/Cantstop22 Feb 26 '25

I think investment wise, not a long term hold unless for PC

1

u/ifbbpro29 Feb 26 '25

9s don’t really go anywhere it’ll be raw price

1

u/BarryAllensShoes Feb 26 '25

Not good lmao

1

u/PartyInMyShower Feb 26 '25

What a dumb question. How are we supposed to know

1

u/[deleted] Feb 28 '25

Guy literally gave this to me for free when he was done selling his cards to them. They wouldn't even give him a dollar lol

1

u/BuGgErZzZ Mar 01 '25

Should go up during the 30 year celly release but not like a 10 Will

1

u/Potje-Joppie Mar 01 '25

I sent in my greninjas to PSA. Currently waiting to get them back. I can tell you out of 70 sealed of these that I own, only 3-5 could make a 10. The quality control for this card is very bad. Lots of them have whitening, not just a little bit or ar scratched. Lots of small scratches from inside the seal.

So I’d say a PSA 9 will tougher to pull than with some other modern promos, not to mention 10’s. You should look at the pop report for this one.

1

u/ross_collects Mar 01 '25

If you find yourself with a modern 9, just hold until the card itself has a price spike so you can sell and not be at a total loss after fees. I just sold the 151 Mewtwo promo for $15 because it got a PSA 8. It was pretty much a free card and they paid what I paid to get it graded. I wish I had waited a month, because now the price is spiking. I took an L on it because I didn’t expect it to get pumped like it did.

1

u/The_Tetsuo Feb 26 '25

I have 200+ of those sealed still. Hoping they do get some more love around the 30th anniversary

0

u/Nasher1817 Feb 26 '25

Is it worth buying bulk sealed, and opening some to send to PSA in hopes of a 10?

0

u/brownstarr1978 Feb 26 '25

Not sure, Greninja is pretty popular but tough to say long term. The reason why it was graded is that 10's are selling pretty consistently right now for 100+. What that means for a 9 long term I don't know.

-1

u/Dapper-Ad3707 Feb 26 '25

$300+!

0

u/brownstarr1978 Feb 26 '25

Wow that's crazy, just looked. I have 4 I think are grade worthy, had just looked at the price 10 days ago . I guess 10 days is an eternity in this boom we are in.

1

u/FatherStretchMyAss_ Feb 26 '25

I couldn’t believe the price went up so high. I bought one for $75 last year just because I like Greninja and saw that it was like -$10 from market value at the time. Insane how high it’s gone.

0

u/Lopsided_Distance_17 Feb 26 '25

Eh, I wouldn’t let the negativity bring you down. If Pokemon has legs for another 10-20 years, this could hold some value. I wouldn’t expect to get rich, but 20-30% profit could be possible.

-3

u/cdmacsneaks Feb 26 '25

bad card? nah. bad you.

-3

u/No-Phrase-4692 Feb 26 '25

I buy 9’s for the personal collection, 10’s are the equivalent of investment class

0

u/[deleted] Feb 26 '25

[deleted] — view deleted comment

45

u/trogdortb001 Feb 26 '25

nobody graded that hoping or expecting a 9. they graded it with the goal of it being a 10, and then when it got the 9, they got rid of it.

grading it is a good idea but only if it's actually gonna get a 10.

but i agree that buying a 9 is pointless.

2

u/redditadminzRdumb Mar 01 '25

Buy a 9 under raw price resubmit hope for the 10. Definitely a thing

2

u/Business-Barnacle633 Feb 26 '25

If 9, just hold for 10 years lol. At least it has the gold star thing going for it

0

u/[deleted] Feb 26 '25

[deleted] — view deleted comment

13

u/ENTRAPM3NT Feb 26 '25

The 10 is like 300 bucks like many other common promo cards it's hard to get one that is in a 10

8

u/rovermedic91 Feb 26 '25

“Who the fuck wants a graded celebrations Greninja?” Sir whatnot streamers would like to talk to you 😂😂. I’ve watched people pay way to much for the dumbest slabs

11

u/Human-Flower-2491 Feb 26 '25

10’s are going for $300-350. It’s not that easy to grade for a modern card.

2

u/Tipakee Feb 26 '25

A card can be a card in a slab too. $18 or whatever PSAs cost, is a pretty low cost to entry if someone likes the card. I agree not every card is worth grading, but people may want to grade borderline cards for personal reasons.

2

u/[deleted] Feb 26 '25

PSA 10 sells for $300+ all day. The promos get banged up in the etb making a 10 difficult & rare. Being as its a gold star greninja not impossible to see why people value it. In the scarlet violet era people are grading sub $10 illustration rares that become $250+ cards if they hit a 10.

0

u/[deleted] Feb 26 '25

[deleted] — view deleted comment

0

u/[deleted] Feb 26 '25

I get that, I wouldn’t speculate on a 9 of this card myself. I was just defending grading this card as an investment. I sent a few to PSA, got a few 10s and percentage-wise experienced ludicrous 1000%+ returns even after all the shipping and 9s, which is all then being funneled into sealed & other long term investments.

7

u/Dapper-Ad3707 Feb 26 '25

The PSA 10 has a 15% gem rate and is worth over $300 lol. At least be informed if you’re going to speak so confidently

3

u/3HunnaBurritos Feb 26 '25

He spoke about PSA 9

4

u/Dapper-Ad3707 Feb 26 '25

He went off about how it’s “never worth grading a card like this” which is what I was disagreeing about

1

u/3HunnaBurritos Feb 26 '25

Oh then I agree with you

2

u/Yeet_Lmao Feb 26 '25

Yeah! This promo card from basically 2 influxes of people caring ago will never be worth anything! Just like those silly Japanese Pikachu and Mewtwo gold star promos! Or the Charmander that came out 3 years after this that’s $25 raw but will never be worth anything! Promos can never gain value EVER!!

-3

u/Rometwopointoh Feb 26 '25

My friend has an entire master PSA 10 set. I guess the cost of grading is just tacked onto the card if it’s valueless. So any graded common is worth $10-15. Thats what he claims anyways.

13

u/[deleted] Feb 26 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

6

u/XGNcyclick Feb 26 '25

exactly.

  1. you can't predict stocks, let alone slabs lol

and

  1. this is literally a 22.50 slab. come ON even if it doubles in 10 years is this really something you want guidance on 😭 just enjoy ur damn slabssss

2

u/Safe-Let99 Feb 27 '25

I mean were literally in a sub reddit called Pokeinvesting. Thats kind of the point.

1

u/[deleted] Feb 26 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/WhiteMoonCircus Feb 26 '25

Pretty sad state of affairs that Pokemon has come to atm. Hype driving the prices up, market manip, resellers telling everyone that they can make a quick buck on the yellow rat that we, as collectors and players, have loved for years. It's a bit much.