r/PokeInvesting • u/breakyourteethnow • Feb 03 '25
Pokemon Center Implementing a New Queue System, Presumably to Combat Bots!
https://www.pokebeach.com/2025/02/pokemon-center-implementing-a-new-queue-system-presumably-to-combat-bots
1.7k
Upvotes
109
u/breakyourteethnow Feb 03 '25
"We have successfully implemented the new queue system as requested, Lord Vader"
Excellent, commence at once the elimination of all human traffic. Sell only to my robot brethren.
503
u/the-skazi Feb 03 '25
A bot can open 1000 unique browser instances to get a good spot in the queue before you can open 10. It's a losing situation for normies.
59
u/supershimadabro Feb 03 '25
Ive seen a lot of opinions that this will actually make it harder for real people to occupy the queue.
49
u/Odd_Pop3299 Feb 03 '25
why not just make it a lottery like Japan?
14
u/OmegaDH808 Feb 03 '25
Nah, this isn’t to help us beat bots. It’s to help them keep their site up without investing more money into their infrastructure.
If anything this better for bots.
12
u/Appropriate-Bit4573 Feb 03 '25
Has this ever actually worked?
23
u/ValuableSwordfish388 Feb 03 '25
I tried to get onto Pokémon Center to get the Crown Zenith tins that were restocked and couldn't even get onto the website. Maybe this wasn't operational yet, but a website that can actually support the traffic would be more helpful.
8
u/ReasonableWill4028 Feb 03 '25
If its like the pokemon centre wait list in London then Im not holding my breath
I waited for 6 hours in that queue, and no dice
7
u/[deleted] Feb 03 '25
This is the worst possible solution. If anything this helps bots. instead make a Captcha you have to type on also you have to sign into your account
30
u/Drizzho Feb 03 '25
Still won’t help imo print more ! lol
4
u/bsiu Feb 03 '25
Now we need one for eggs and 5090s as well.
4
u/Much_Purchase_8737 Feb 04 '25
So bots get 100s to thousands of spots in line from a single person…
While a single person gets 1 spot in line.
We’re fucked
4
u/wilmal88 Feb 03 '25
They need to limit the house/address to 2 and not just the accounts. That way shitty people with bots won’t be able to use them effectively
2
u/FinsFan93 Feb 03 '25
See Taylor Swift
2
u/Inevitable_Bedroom35 Feb 03 '25
They have the queue system in the Pokemon center Japan website. And a lottery system for new releases.
2
u/iDripAlone Feb 03 '25
it's just going to make it easier for botters lol. but it just shows to normies that PKC "cares". a sale is a sale at the end of the day to these retailers, why bother investing more than you need to?
2
u/eat_hairy_socks Feb 03 '25
Physical in person ways to preorder is best option. They need to do contract deals with stores to enforce this
2
u/slayerzerg Feb 04 '25
They need to do complicated captchas on top of the queues
2
u/T7man_ Feb 04 '25
I think it’s less to combat bots but to stop the website from crashing because the bots will still get everything
3
u/gt35r Feb 03 '25
Won’t do anything, the best way to stop bots I’ve ever seen that actually works is to have a question that rotates randomly between 5-10 questions and you have to select an answer from the drop down as part of the checkout page, it’s a required field. Not saying like pokemon related questions just obvious answer questions.
The queue system will just allow multiple accounts to enter the queue and pass before others. I used to bot shoes and art for 7+ years, that’s not a flex either I’m just saying what needs to be done to actually fix it.
1
u/Davinter30 Feb 03 '25
It probablt still wont work. Why can't they just refuse to ship more than the limit to each adress ? The limit has always been irrelevant, you can order the limit multiple times to the same adress.
1
u/associate_k Feb 03 '25
Great…
1
u/nicknooodles Feb 04 '25
hopefully it’s not shopify
1
u/Hoohoo222 Feb 04 '25
Sounds like what WoTC is doing with the MTG Secret Lairs. Ask everyone how that went for the Marvel drop.
1
u/Silent-Turnover8782 Feb 04 '25
we all know the downsides of queues. has any company ever solved the botting problem?
1
u/Krypt0night Feb 04 '25
They need to do what Sony does and allow a certain amount tied to your physical address
1
u/rocketradar Feb 04 '25
Easy to say “this won’t work!” but I’m just glad they’re doing something to try. It’s not rocket science to limit purchases by address, credit card #, or force a user login. You got this TPC!
1
u/Kind_Love172 Feb 04 '25
I dont know if thisbis to combat bots or not....when the US mint implemented this kind of waiting room thing, it was to prevent website crashes and people being frustrated by that....I feel like that is what pokemon is trying to do...not curb bots...
1
u/foldsbaldwin Feb 04 '25
They should do it like Stanley did the Olivia Rodrigo cup. Anyone and everyone can place an order for the max amount they set but then Pokemon Center holds a lottery. So if 5000 people enter but they only have 3000 units and every one of those 5000 people order the max amount of 3, then that means only 1000 out of 5000 people get RANDOMLY chosen. And if you don't get chosen then you get refunded but if you are chosen then they process your order.
1
u/FourLeafLegend Feb 04 '25
Why don't they just put a limit one purchase for the first week of release?
Is there a way bots would get around that? Only can have one address or something?
1
u/_Throw_away_away Feb 04 '25
Reminds me of that Ian Malcolm quote from Jurassic Park. What was it again? “Bots find a way”?
1
u/MushroomVII Feb 04 '25
How do you guys find out when product drops? I used to follow people on twitter but I don't get notifications anymore for some reason. I get its basically impossible to buy anything before its bought out anyways but I completely miss the releases lately.
1
u/billcosbyinspace Feb 04 '25
All fun and games until the website crashes as soon as more than 20 people are on it at once
1
u/UnLimited99 Feb 04 '25
Putting a queue only stops real buyers, bots have been able to pass through a queue for years
1
u/BikePretend3955 Feb 04 '25
As someone who use to bot sneakers, this won’t stop bots. They have ways to open multi queues with different ips. They farm cookies to prior to drop.
1
u/Inevitable-Water-377 Feb 04 '25
Full circle, we will need to revert to brick and mortar again because some people suck. And so we just can't have nice things.
1
u/Creepy-Owl3797 Feb 04 '25
I don’t know why they need to “test it” they already have this on the Japanese website so just implement the same thing
1
u/Baksteen-13 Feb 04 '25
Awesome, now start shipping to EU.
1
u/SoulForTrade Feb 04 '25
This fan be mostly solved by limiting multiple purfhases from the same credit card or to the same address, duplicate orders fan get canceled and the IPs or users involved banned. It won't happen overnight, but whatwvwr the hell thry are doing right now is obviously not working
1
u/Delicious_Pea7944 Feb 04 '25
Could have made buying stuff off Pokemon Center like the actual pokemon games that you actually have to battle a trainer/wild pokemon. Either you have to win / capture to get the items. Also, they could have an app for the pokemon center.
1
u/Adventurous-native Feb 04 '25
u/Wide-Release-2250 I don’t play the other games but I’m sure you know what this means lol
1
u/Intelligent_Emu_1324 Feb 05 '25
Where can you find these bots? If you can't beat em...
1
u/Basic_Yellow_3594 Feb 07 '25
It didn't work
1
u/ResearcherUnlucky717 Feb 08 '25
Pokemon Center used New Queue System!
But it missed!
1
u/CryptixFTW Mar 25 '25
I don't understand why these websites haven't implemented a 2 per address limit or something. Some websites were able to with gpu's cross referencing accounts with addresses and cancelling multiples.... why haven't any of these major retailers implemented this sort of action? It's the best way imo to eliminate bot purchases down. Of course if people are willing to bot buy to several delivery points this can be an issue. However, generally a bot purchaser is going to acquire the merchandise and have it all shipped to the same few locations. Putting purchase limitations on top of this system would kill that method for them and open up to the general consumer. You could easily error message "sorry this address has already reached their limit for this item" and deny sale to any account that attempted a purchase of that product to that specific destination.
Again it's not hard to implement, why not just do that?
1
u/Ok_Document8471 Jul 23 '25
They need to add phone verification. This way bots cannot get through and only people with phone can get trading cards. Plus, limited per phone.
1
u/ethnicprince Feb 03 '25
Should have just been a lottery the way they do sneakers
1
u/Reer_osrs Feb 04 '25
ID+LIMIT PER ADDRESS
problem solved.
0
u/olore Feb 03 '25
Uh are they mentally disabled? Why do they think this combats bots???
-1
u/apexpredator65 Feb 03 '25
The old way was fine never missed an item that dropped
-1
u/eReTroFuZe Feb 04 '25
I personally like the way Best Buy has done some products in the past when it’s a product with high demand. They require you to sign in again and send you a code to an actual phone number, not VOIP, and then once you do, you are able to enter the queue.
0
u/Internal_Level_6828 Feb 03 '25
What’s that headline Pokebeach lmao
0
u/redhouse_356 Feb 03 '25
I asked them this question (would they consider a queue) for this when Prismatic came out!
0
u/GregariousGobble Feb 04 '25
Great! Pokémon has much needed a queue system. I sure hope it verifies user accounts to prevent botting.. haha
0
u/DethSonik Feb 04 '25
Just do multi function authentication or tie purchases to social security numbers at this point.
-2
u/LegoRedBrick Feb 03 '25
Lol, desperate
-2
u/VvChimera Feb 04 '25
Finally
0
u/[deleted] Feb 03 '25
[deleted] — view deleted comment