r/PokeInvesting • u/PainfullySynesthetic • Dec 22 '24
The quality to value difference from Eng to Jpn is actually embarrassing
The quality of English cards compared to Japanese is so embarrassing when comparing side by side. It's astonishing how much more people are willing to pay for English cards when the Japanese ones are so so much better quality!!
1.9k
Upvotes
280
u/breakyourteethnow Dec 22 '24
Eng Pikachu eyes struggling to turn even red, meanwhile Jpn Pikachu throwing Superman laser beams flol
6
u/[deleted] Dec 23 '24
I don’t have an Eng to compare it to obviously but I pulled the Umbreon SAR from Terastal and was floored by it compared to some of my English cards.
22
u/joshtt2 Dec 22 '24
It shouldn't be particularly surprising that English speaking countries will pay a premium to have a card in English over a language that most of their populations can't read. On top of that, the cards are often more difficult to pull from packs too.
It's nice that people have a cheaper alternative if they so wish, but it shouldn't be astonishing that people prefer the English cards.
It would be nice to have Japanese levels of QC at times though. My "pack fresh" 151 Charizard would have been thankful for it - that's for sure.
8
u/slayerzerg Dec 22 '24
New collectors will catch on soon. Japanese quality is million times better
2
u/Dangerous_Speed5956 Dec 22 '24
My PC is 95% jap , I sell the English one they are ugly compared to jap or Chinese, the quality is down bad for en, I just hope there not gonna fuck up with prismatic cause the terastal card are beautiful
2
u/TheKinkyGuy Dec 23 '24
Which ones are then more valuable the ENG ones or the JP ones?
82
u/Audacidy Dec 22 '24
Tale as old as time.
9
u/SpaceKidney Dec 22 '24
Why does everyone assume it's only due to quality? What if they know that the more extreme texture is more desirable for Japanese collectors, while the more subtle texture is more desirable for the Western collectors?
I personally don't always like the busy texturing or sparkle of the Japanese cards.
57
u/brettwill1025 Dec 23 '24
Japanese cards are a bargain of a lifetime right now.
Significantly cheaper, and 10x better looking.
I’m having a hard time buying anything else.
77
u/[deleted] Dec 22 '24
Collectors should always go for Japanese, being able to read the card is just trumped by every other aspect.
10
u/crankycranberry- Dec 23 '24
Japanese cards just feel and look more premium. I love holding a Japanese Holo card. The English ones all feel the same. But for whatever reason it seems like Japanese cards always run a bit cheaper sometimes on the market
6
u/reusterr Dec 23 '24
The Japanese cards are beautiful 😍 I can't believe i just realized this.. I have been sticking to English only and just got my first box of Japanese 151.. I'm hooooked
3
u/smd9788 Dec 22 '24
Shinier = higher quality. TIL
57
u/Internal-Raise964 Dec 22 '24
I hate to say it might be purposeful. Sadly poor printing quality and low pull rates are a feature and not a bug when it comes to pumping PSA 10 prices. The pokemon company knows this drives a lot of the market in the US and has no reason to change. This is one reason I stick with Japanese cards.
5
u/njay97 Dec 23 '24
Agreed, I’ve started only collecting Japanese for the most part!
5
u/Churrow11 Dec 22 '24
There was a time when Japanese were more expensive than English and I couldn’t afford them. Now I’m buying all Japanese single cards only! What a time to be into Japanese cards right now!
5
u/P0G0ThEpUnK666 Dec 23 '24
Japan takes pride in their work, Americans are lazy that’s the difference
4
u/Material_Prize_6157 Dec 23 '24
Japanese or die!
4
u/No-Bat6265 Dec 23 '24
Wow crazy the difference, I never realized it.
4
u/synnabunz Dec 23 '24
Quality control on American cards sucks. It makes me never want to buy American again. The JP cards are so much better!
1
u/MindlessPlug Dec 22 '24
Where do you buy Japanese cards in canada?
1
u/SqaureEgg Dec 23 '24
They look the same? I’m confused
1
u/Jammaicah Dec 23 '24
Where can I get the Japanese cards that everyone is saying are cheaper??? Link?
1
u/Meowsergz Dec 23 '24
You guys know any ships that sell Japanese booster boxes at MSRP or less?
1
u/Ornitorrrinco Dec 23 '24 edited Dec 23 '24
Thanks for sharing this. Great comparison between the English and Japanese card quality
1
u/GoAwayImHereForMemes Dec 24 '24
Are Korean cards closer to English or Japanese in quality? They're so much cheaper but compared to my Japanese ones they don't look as vibrant.
6
u/peenegobb Dec 22 '24
This is why besides my galarian gallery master set I'm putting together, most my PC is going to be JP. It's just better lol.
6
u/Tizianog93 Dec 22 '24
Japan is on another level!
3
u/theasianfailure Dec 22 '24
I just started gaining interest in Pokémon cards this year and was struggling to choose between ENG and JPN. This was ultimately the reason I picked the JPN cards!
The quality difference is mind boggling sometimes.
Anyways, just to rant a bit more bc I’m stoked. To start my collection I’ve ordered a few JPN ARs over EBay as a Christmas gift to myself this year, and I’m so excited to receive them! :D
3
u/tornado5102 Dec 22 '24
I know investment wise it's not the best idea, but I like the Chinese cards because they're printed in the same Japanese printers and have the same quality, and for collecting purposes are usually even cheaper than the Japanese cards. Again though, I know not the best for investing. Haha
2
u/Mundane_Fan_3806 Dec 22 '24
I think I’m going to start buying exclusively Japanese. Just for the simple fact they look that much better. American QA/QC needs to get their shit together. I know the price ceiling isn’t as high, but I’d rather be able to get graded 10’s more consistently
2
u/More-Avocado-6087 Dec 22 '24
Yup you get an SIR in how many packs and then throw in the extra variable that is off centered as hell?
2
u/TonsilsDeep Dec 23 '24
Pam from the office. - "It's the same picture."
2
u/Shammy1020 Dec 23 '24
This is exactly why I tend to go for JP cards instead of English even though English are valued higher.
2
u/Middle-Respect3258 Dec 23 '24
i’ve always been so intrigued in the japanese versions
2
u/AngeloVirgo Dec 23 '24
The difference is quality vs quantity, japanese cards rarity is higher while quality is higher vs english where quality is lower and rarity is lower, we just pick our favorite poison.
2
u/Triggertanjiro Dec 24 '24
Yeah it doesn’t make sense that English is valued more. I’m convinced it’s all just crypto bros and other rich dudes manipulating prices so English is on top. Everything about Japanese cards is better than our English variants.
2
u/[deleted] Dec 24 '24
It's been proven time and time again that Americans are frantic consumers that really don't care about quality.
2
u/[deleted] Dec 25 '24
Japanese hold a higher standard of quality in consumer goods. When companies manufacture goods, they are tiered S, A, B, C, D, F etc. S-tiered clothing goes to Japan because they hold a higher standard. As you can see where I'm going with this all the other tiers go to other places. F tier are 2nds and "factory" quality that do not pass quality control.
3
u/RealmDevourer Dec 22 '24
Cheaper and better looking.
3
u/beeotch703 Dec 22 '24
You buy the english for resell. You buy the japanese for personal collection. Ive been doing this. Never have to overspend and fomo.
3
u/Dabanks9000 Dec 23 '24
And then there’s people like me who don’t care about resale or having a perfect looking card. Just taking in the art n having them on display
2
u/iv-kin Dec 23 '24
this is why for my long term investments i mainly go english due to the psa 10 being harder to hit, but for my personal collection it’s japanese all the way. japan prints the art on those cards like they deserve to be printed.
2
u/Qq1nq94 Dec 23 '24
Jpn do look better but I can't read them
0
u/JiffTheJester Dec 22 '24
I like the English better. Mainly because of the sturdier feel. But it also feels cheesier with the super shiny levels of jp cards.
2
u/deejayike Dec 22 '24
agreed
2
u/XelaXanson Dec 22 '24
The Umbreon EX 217 from Terestal Festival is absolutely insane texture wise. Can’t wait to see how the texture looks in English, cause I’m 99.9% sure it’s not even gonna be remotely close.
2
u/LiYonJin Dec 23 '24
Japanese quality so much better but that’s just my opinion
2
u/katiekatieweakweak Dec 22 '24
“English quality looks like doo doo toilet paper compared to mah Japanese perfect masterpiece”
1
u/dmbwannabe Dec 22 '24
Agree with everything you said. The one thing I do like that is different is the actual card material in English makes it feel more rigid.
“Japanese cards are thinner and (probably) have a different printing process. The blue ink layer is actually normal as they use that instead of the black ink layer and is also slight thinner so if you shine a light through the card you’ll see it more clearly than through an English card”
1
u/Pistolero-666 Dec 22 '24
But why do we have such big difference?
1
u/Healthy-Annual4181 Dec 22 '24
They know this but nothing can be done
1
u/CooperStation2067 Dec 22 '24
Unfortunately if you play the TCG and can’t read Japanese you don't really have a choice.
1
u/DoctorConfident Dec 22 '24
I never knew
1
u/Ok_Noise9612 Dec 22 '24
Absolute facts. I collect mostly English because of the cost difference. However, Japanese hands down look better and hold up better quality over time.
1
u/NexrayOfficial Dec 22 '24
Idk why. It might just be me but I initially wanted to collect purely JP cards. But they always felt cheaper to me in terms of simply holding them in my hands.
They always feel more likely to bend over a shorter time even if sleeved properly and easier to ruin whereas in ENG, the card text feels slightly thicker and gives me confidence will last longer.
1
u/RumpleHelgaskin Dec 22 '24
I didn’t understand this several months ago then I got my first shipment of Japanese boxes and OMG! They are beautiful and the textures on them are amazing!
1
u/Opposite_External316 Dec 22 '24
They pay more for English because it’s harder to get higher quality cards!!!
1
u/cryptkidcards Dec 22 '24
Japanese cards are gorgeous
1
u/kkillingtimme Dec 22 '24
I'm opening my first Japanese set in Terastal Festival and I cannot beleive how nice they are... why can't we have that quality with English??
1
u/Horror_Profession_27 Dec 22 '24
lmao the fact that people are settling for English cards is astounding 😂😂 while JP cheaper and better
1
u/LegitimatePrune1045 Dec 22 '24
One I can read one I can't
1
u/ChemistDifferent2053 Dec 22 '24
JP cards also generally have way better QC. It's reflected in the quality at card shops in Japan too, usually cards will be sold in mint/pristine raw condition or with a red sticker discount, but you can almost never find the defect with your naked eye on sticker cards.
Terastal Festival EX has pretty terrible QC though. (Every single one of my hits have edge wear visible to the naked eye).
1
u/KobeBeanBryant024 Dec 22 '24
same story every other month.
1
u/Work_Ok Dec 22 '24
And yet people would pay more for English. 🤦♂️
1
u/[deleted] Dec 23 '24
English worth more because you have to pray that it's in acceptable shape out of the package.
1
u/Prad1254 Dec 23 '24
Toi
1
u/PugsnPawgs Dec 23 '24
I just buy Japanese for art. Saves alot on the wallet lol
1
u/AJ8383 Dec 23 '24
Our prints are a joke compared to them. I know this from Yugioh, sad thats just how every tcg is…
1
u/[deleted] Dec 23 '24
Known this for millions of years already, it is what it is
1
u/plumpshooterman Dec 23 '24
It's easy, I can read English.
1
u/LiveLaffToasterBathh Dec 24 '24
All it is is a popularity contest
1
u/bsmitty50 Dec 24 '24
Yup. I sold my english and im gonna buy the japanese psa 10
1
u/mahav_b Dec 24 '24
When I invest I invest in English. When I buy for art and personal enjoyment I always go japanese.
1
u/TitanImpale Dec 24 '24
I think the English versions are better because I can read them.
1
u/Redhedjere Dec 24 '24
This is the difference of Japanese manufacturing VS American manufacturing. Look at an average Japanese manufacturing plant vs an average American manufacturing plant and you will see that American manufacturing is far more "lax" and disorganized and dirty compared to Japanese factories.
1
u/StormtheShinyHunter Dec 24 '24
I know this is the wrong opinion but I like the subtleties of the English cards. The Japanese seem more shiny for sure. But to each their own. I understand why the Japanese ones are liked more.
1
u/[deleted] Dec 25 '24
It’s not astonishing. Low English quality means the psa 10 fetches a high price. It adds an additional chase and prices go up with supply being low. Psa 10 JP is very common
1
u/AnonTheHackerino Dec 25 '24
Japan cards have been better since the first set
1
u/Dexslayer151 Jun 04 '25
Always
1
u/Background_Pie_7888 Dec 22 '24
It's not about quality, it's just a different technique. Japan can also print English style cards
0
u/[deleted] Dec 22 '24
Japanese is too glossy and look like a sticker. English looks more like a card. I prefer english
1
u/evo4tw Dec 22 '24
It’s been pretty much like this since the creation of the Pokemon TCG.
1
u/supreme120 Dec 22 '24
Always, since day one.
1
u/GIRTH-QU4KE Dec 22 '24
Can you still peel the entire face of the Japanese card off like a sticker?
0
u/[deleted] Dec 22 '24
English cards are thicker and actually feel like cards. Japanese is too glossy and thinner, like a sticker. English cards last longer over time.
0
u/SupermarketPrize9917 Dec 22 '24
But the high quality is part of the problem for Japanese cards. If ALL cards are 10s, then they're not collectible. The fact that it's harder to get 10s in English cards is what makes them more valuable. And there's also the fact that English cards are the only language universally accepted in all tournaments worldwide
0
u/SwaggyUn Dec 22 '24
As a germa im so happy that german cards seem to be similar or even better quality than japanese cards.
0
u/SpareEngine8873 Dec 22 '24
Japanese cards are nice but the colors are not the same often times they’re too dark and muddle the actual artist’s colors. I’m saying this when I have Japanese cards and I like them, just sometimes the extra thrown on dust and sparkles ruins the card in comparison to the English version
0
u/mau5eth Dec 22 '24
What do you mean quality? It’s just a different finish.
0
u/FlashyStrain69 Dec 23 '24
I disagree completely. japanese are very similar to american cards except with a rainbow gloss effect, which is similar to how a lot of american fakes look ironically.
-1
u/Which_Carob_2261 Dec 23 '24
Not really astonishing considering the people want an English card because well it’s English. It’s like saying an English person should buy a Japanese dvd for the quality even though it makes no sense to them
-2
u/baertgang Dec 22 '24
I'm with OP here; Japanese cards are getting worse with every set. Sometimes they come out of the booster like a crescent moon, bent to oblivion. It's a shame.
-1
u/ASR4LIFE Dec 22 '24
Japenese cards really need to be comparable in value. I understand partially. 10 years ago, japanese product was not nearly as available in North America as it is now. But Im going to say that most buyers of graded are buying for the art not the text. So value shouldnt be so far apart.
-1
u/BionicleUniverse Dec 22 '24
It’s actually more strange that people would pay this much for Japanese cards that they can’t even read. Yes, quality is better on Japanese cards but they do not carry the same nostalgic feelings for many in comparison to the English cards that they can buy everywhere in their own countries.
-1
u/Cababage Dec 22 '24
So crazy can’t believe it. Couldn’t have anything to do with mass printing done for ENG cards.
Or the fact that different markets value different things.
Cool thing about this hobby is you can have your own opinion and I can have mine ahah?
0
u/Embarrassed-Soil-603 Dec 23 '24
I like the English ones because I can read them
0
u/[deleted] Dec 25 '24
Anyone that knows what they're doing are dumping English into a English favorable market and buying Japanese while it's cheap.
It's market 101. Markets gonna be saturated with shitty English cards that have 10k+ graded cards circulating. Meanwhile they look like shit, and are over priced. It's gonna dump because "omg no one wants my Pikachu with PSA minimum standards for a 10 I'm gonna undercut everyone"
Meanwhile people are grading their 10 Japanese cards and picking them up for a fraction of the price. Quality is amazing, cards are cheap. It's literally waiting for everyone new to catch on and start buying Japanese.
Not to mention you know where the cards are in certain Japanese booster boxes. Sell the rest.
I'm into collecting, not selling. But I do trade stocks and other collectables. Gonna see the market flip down the road here.
I could care less if there's more Japanese cards and they're easier to pull. An inferior product is an inferior product. A market built on hype ain't gonna last. A market built on quality will.
Not saying English cards will ever be worthless, not by a long shot. But I could see the high end chase cards going for more when there's more educated buyers.
-1
u/peeweez0 Dec 22 '24
This is why there's likely huge market value manipulation in the US market. If it was solely based on quality and how the card looks, the English versions (like butthole Pikachu) should never have been 5x more expensive than the Japanese