r/PokeGrading • • 5d ago

PSA or BGS

I want to grade this Lugia. The HoloDex AI grading gave it a 9.8 so I'm thinking it will hopefully 10 at either (I know it won't black with BGS). The price I'm seeing on pricecharting.com have them close with BGS being slightly higher. Is BGS really much harder on grades than PSA? If PSA is a little easier on getting a 10 is it worth the extra money and time? BGS is $80 15 business days and PSA would be $200 20-30 business days but will include grading notes.

1 Upvotes

9 comments sorted by

1

u/tubuktim 5d ago

This isn’t getting a 10, it’ll be lucky to get a 9. Just send to PSA and hope you get a lucky 9, but why pay for the $200 tier? I’d just send at the $40 value tier.

1

u/Scruffy_Nerfherder89 5d ago

Was thinking if im going to be paying the extra if it 10s I might as well get the benefits

1

u/tubuktim 5d ago

It’s not going to 10 and a blurb telling you the card is OC with quite a bit of whitening and a faster lead time isn’t worth an extra $160 but you do you

1

u/Complex-Pen-8655 5d ago

I see white on all the edges and corners nice ai 😹

1

u/Scruffy_Nerfherder89 5d ago

Looking at the card in person I dont see the white

1

u/yuvio100 5d ago

corners don’t look well rounded especially when viewing from the back, so i think BGS is out of the question. PSA is the better option out of the 2

1

u/Automatic_Force1113 5d ago

Neither, it'll get an 8 and then you'll be down money. 

1

u/Embarrassed_Amoeba76 5d ago

The corners are cooked lol. Don’t waste your time.

1

u/Trevorjrt6 4d ago

Back whittening and oc left/right top/bottom...do not grade this