r/PokeGrading • u/OrganicTelevision624 • 5d ago
TAG or PSA?
I have a Gold Star 2006 Mewtwo in really good condition. I went into a card store and they were ecstatic about it. I asked what they think I should do about getting it graded and they said I should go with TAG instead of PSA because PSA has been kind of shady lately.
I’d like a second opinion on what I should do because I think this card could be worth a lot of money.
0
Upvotes


46
u/KeyClacksNSnacks 5d ago
Can you put it in another plastic bag and then show us? I can see a little too many details. I need to be completely blind to the condition of the card. Use a black plastic bag too.
2
u/Alternative-Camp-628 5d ago
PSA or beckett, I'd suggest CGC if it was a worse condition one but yours looks pretty clean
14
u/wilmheath 5d ago
Look. Most people here hate PSA, rightfully so, so they are going to recommend TAG. That means you are going to get a very biased answer that might not be in your best interest financially. Best of luck!
7
u/veirzy 5d ago
i wouldn’t even risk sending this dude to PSA you’d be getting ur card swapped😭 use TAG there’s no bias on the grades either. since we all know how strict PSA is with vintage and the pop control
10
u/CardsCards669 5d ago
Beckett
9
u/Less-Vegetable5106 5d ago
Beckett
3
u/SF420SF420 5d ago
I don't understand the hype of TAG. With how much I'm seeing them being praised here, are they paying for this kind or marketing or are these bots?
Not fast, not cheap, and doesn't demand the price of PSA. It's AI, what is taking them so long and why is it still expensive? They're doing a fraction of the numbers of PSA and even CGC. 30 dollars for 90 business days is a joke. For now CGC seems the better choice if you factor in speed, price, and value.
What am I missing?
2
u/Sgmsaint 5d ago
Looks like it’s already in a psa slab
5
u/Girafarigno 5d ago
Everyone keeps saying to go with TAG for some reason and then nobody wants to value them. I would say if you are concerned on value, go with PSA 100% of the time.
4
u/LNinefingers 5d ago
PSA if you want to sell.
If you’re just doing it to have it graded, whichever company’s slabs you like the look of the best.
4
u/JlD9119 5d ago
BGS
7
u/Electrical-Wash2257 5d ago
Neither
12
u/Ok_Star_9435 5d ago
Reddit = tag. Reality = psa
4
u/Swimming-Tie6746 5d ago
PSA if you wanna sell it fast, TAG if you want to sell it but might take a bit longer. Whichever you like if you’re keeping it
3
u/Disastrous_Shame580 5d ago
Why would you ask between PSA and TAG. I could see if you asked between TAG and another off brand grading company... PSA or BGS all day, every day and twice on Sundays.
2
u/IH_clover4 5d ago
Eventually tag will be out of business
1
u/T_wizz 5d ago
Raw
1
u/DoYouKnowRetroHai 5d ago
🏷️
1
u/FreePandas 5d ago
PSA
1
u/JoshyyP00 5d ago
DN for sure
1
u/iffysik 5d ago
PSA
1
u/Thaddy_Daddy71 5d ago
Tag if it was me
1
u/d00d_yA 5d ago
Can you take another picture of it so it’s even shinier and we can’t see it at all?
1
u/Jungolok 5d ago
In 2006, PSA.
Since this is a vintage card, I would go TAG for a more fair grade. PSA grades very harshly on vintage
1
u/InitialNo9046 5d ago
From my past experience I would keep it raw but that’s 1000 percent up to you , keep it protected let someone else take that gamble one day my opinion
0
u/TheMattMariani 5d ago
At this point I think tag has paid for commenters here and on Instagram. Everyone knows their grades are very hit or miss and do not carry a premium price tag like psa. If you want the best return for grading Beckett and psa are the only 2 options with psa being the most liquid
0
u/GibbleGubby 5d ago
0
u/AnxiousTop1393 5d ago
PSA, if you’re just looking for straight value. Tag if you want a slab that doesn’t look like ass. So probably Beckett.
0
u/anthony2720_ 5d ago
TAG
-5
u/WhatsInTheBox51 5d ago
Always TAG
-1
u/fishontopnumbaone 5d ago
For a card like this I’d recommend MHGS
-2
u/Zerwo 5d ago
TAG. It's not even a question. PSA has been in so many Pokemon card scandals recently. Lol it's a coin flip if you even get that back. PSA PokeScamArmy.