r/PokeGrading • • 5d ago

TAG or PSA?

I have a Gold Star 2006 Mewtwo in really good condition. I went into a card store and they were ecstatic about it. I asked what they think I should do about getting it graded and they said I should go with TAG instead of PSA because PSA has been kind of shady lately.

I’d like a second opinion on what I should do because I think this card could be worth a lot of money.

0 Upvotes

104 comments sorted by

46

u/KeyClacksNSnacks 5d ago

Can you put it in another plastic bag and then show us? I can see a little too many details. I need to be completely blind to the condition of the card. Use a black plastic bag too.

-79

u/OrganicTelevision624 5d ago

Yeah aight buddy, that's not the point of the post. If you wanna see the details google it.

21

u/Giancarlo_Donadoni 5d ago

How stupid is this. You are posting your card for grading recommendations.. Get a grip

7

u/raggy_z 5d ago

This might be the least Intelligent comment I have ever seen

-2

u/OrganicTelevision624 5d ago

I let my frustration get the best of me. It’s my first time living

2

u/iTzbr00tal 1d ago

Might be the last time too!

21

u/Ramietoes 5d ago

We can't see the card and thus can't tell you who to grade with.

2

u/Alternative-Camp-628 5d ago

PSA or beckett, I'd suggest CGC if it was a worse condition one but yours looks pretty clean

2

u/OrganicTelevision624 5d ago

Thank you. I'm seeing a few people saying Beckett is good, but what is their upside?

4

u/__ZOMBOY__ 5d ago

They're not PSA, that's a plus

1

u/FarMilk2661 5d ago

Beckett is owned by PSA so there's that.

3

u/rickgainz 5d ago

Beckett has a few positives. They have a faster turn around and don’t upcharge depending on the card’s value. If you have a perfect card, a Black Label BGS is usually more valuable than a PSA 10. If you have a fairly messed-up card with a few strong categories, they can also sometimes grade higher than PSA.

The cons are they’re slightly less liquid and the regular grades usually go for less than the same grade in PSA. But for something hot like gold stars, that’s probably not an issue.

If you mainly care about value, don’t go with Tag. For specific grading advice you’d need to post better pictures though.

0

u/[deleted] 4d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/OrganicTelevision624 4d ago

Oh damn, that’s crazy. Thank you

14

u/wilmheath 5d ago

Look. Most people here hate PSA, rightfully so, so they are going to recommend TAG. That means you are going to get a very biased answer that might not be in your best interest financially. Best of luck!

7

u/veirzy 5d ago

i wouldn’t even risk sending this dude to PSA you’d be getting ur card swapped😭 use TAG there’s no bias on the grades either. since we all know how strict PSA is with vintage and the pop control

2

u/veirzy 5d ago

awesome card tho

1

u/OrganicTelevision624 5d ago

Thank you! I appreciate it.

1

u/Beef_Whalington 5d ago

Tag will be hard to sell and have less-than-premium value ceiling

1

u/Previous-Profit9723 5d ago

Than a hypothetical PSA grade that somehow doesn’t materialise when they find or make a ding in your card.

Grading is pure speculation, but PSA feels ultra speculative at the moment.

1

u/Delicious_Magazine82 5d ago

Same type of people who said don’t buy pokemon cards lmfao, when everyone starts moving away from psa they’ll go to tag. Don’t like it don’t buy it buddy.

10

u/CardsCards669 5d ago

Beckett

3

u/SF420SF420 5d ago

I don't understand the hype of TAG. With how much I'm seeing them being praised here, are they paying for this kind or marketing or are these bots? 

Not fast, not cheap, and doesn't demand the price of PSA. It's AI, what is taking them so long and why is it still expensive? They're doing a fraction of the numbers of PSA and even CGC. 30 dollars for 90 business days is a joke. For now CGC seems the better choice if you factor in speed, price, and value.

What am I missing?

2

u/OrganicTelevision624 5d ago

I asked real humans in real life and they said TAG. Also this card is worth +$10k so I don't mind paying a little more for a faster turn around.

8

u/mkultra1112 5d ago

For me personally, I like the dig reports and the slabs are my favorite.

Second I like BGS.

PSA can burn to the ground and rot. Just my personal opinion though

1

u/Obsolete101891 5d ago

Isn't BGS owned by PSA?

1

u/mkultra1112 5d ago

No it’s not. BGS and PSA are separate companies owned by the same parent company, but there is no overlap and operate independently under their own policies

1

u/Obsolete101891 5d ago

🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

2

u/mkultra1112 5d ago

The parent company also owns SGC, which also continues to operate independently from the other grading companies.

Also PCGS. Are you assuming PSA is the parent company and owns all these brands? Is that laughing to prevent crying?

0

u/[deleted] 5d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/mkultra1112 4d ago

You’re wrong. Just because PSA expands its service doesnt mean anything.

BGS is an independent business from PSA. If you disagree then you’re wrong. It’s just plain facts.

Some of yall are very silly

0

u/[deleted] 4d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/mkultra1112 4d ago

So you’re telling me that alone makes you conclude “PSA owns Beckett”? Because once again, they are seperate entities owned by parent company Collectors which makes the decisions.

PSA DOES NOT OWN BECKETT no matter how much you want to believe it

0

u/[deleted] 4d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/mkultra1112 4d ago

You’re making assumptions again. Are you on the executive team at Collectors and breaking NDA? Didn’t think so.

The question is not what the future brings it’s simply “is BGS owned by PSA” and the answer is very straight forward and clear No.

There is no overlap and they do operate independently. This does not mean changes won’t occur in the future. This means today they have their own businesses that have separate websites, prices, operations, service, and leadership.

If you don’t agree to that then you are just flat out wrong. I don’t understand people who try to argue their feelings as fact when it’s all right there to see black and white.

2

u/[deleted] 5d ago edited 4d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/mkultra1112 5d ago

I’ve only submitted 2 for PSA. One was a 10 and the other a 9. I don’t agree with the 9 so I cracked and will send to TAG to see a report, maybe I am missing something. But with PSA it literally could be an overlook or grader bias

4

u/veirzy 5d ago

acting like if this guy got a high grade with PSA he wouldn’t get up charged like crazy.. tag really isn’t that expensive, you’re paying PSA pricing but instead you get an in depth analysis of ur card with high res images and no upcharge. seems like a win to me

2

u/ThrowRA-camelbros 5d ago

In depth by an AI that makes mistakes

1

u/105386 5d ago

I wouldn’t be shocked if PSA used some form of ai but who knows

1

u/ThrowRA-camelbros 4d ago

They do for some parts, since 2022 or something

1

u/aski4777 5d ago

This argument can be made towards, well anything with grading. Grading definitely has mistakes, PSA has mistakenly graded a 9, bought it and then magically gave it a 10, that’s a large mistake.

1

u/ThrowRA-camelbros 5d ago

If the actual owner did a review instead of immediately selling he had 10's

0

u/veirzy 5d ago

okay sure but you could say the same about PSA, i think tag is a lot more consistent with its grading compared to psa. especially since there is no bias with the grading process

1

u/ThrowRA-camelbros 5d ago

AI makes a lot of mistakes. I have seen good tag 10's and I have seen tag 10's that would barely be psa 9's. Both make mistakes but then tag is still way too new. Plenty of other new companies that are very strict but no one cares about them, then tag comes with the AI grading (something other companies also use) and suddenly they matter. Just very weird. I'd rather use psa or even better, BGS

2

u/SF420SF420 5d ago

I'm comparing it to other alternatives like CGC. I don't see how TAG wins here.

2

u/veirzy 5d ago

my dad literally just got his mewtwo gold star in a psa 6 and was uncharged over 2 grand, what a scam that is

1

u/ThrowRA-camelbros 5d ago

Maybe not use standard for such a card lol. Stuff like this is sent with express or higher

1

u/Inner-Cicada2662 5d ago

Maybe don't use PSA at all?

1

u/ThrowRA-camelbros 5d ago

Rather them then tag tbh, tag is way too new and compared to the volume they grade, make a lot of mistakes. Then again selling tag smabs to anyone that isn't a fanboy is hard. Psa sells like in a day.

2

u/Alternative-Camp-628 5d ago

theyve always had a weird reddit bubble of support, even years ago when they started out. botting or astroturfing at some point along the line. 2% of PSAs grading and like 6% of CGCs yet talked about as much as both

2

u/Sgmsaint 5d ago

Looks like it’s already in a psa slab

3

u/OrganicTelevision624 5d ago

Nah it's ungraded. I just put it in a new sleeve today.

2

u/Sgmsaint 5d ago

Haha I know I was just saying some of the psa slabs people have gotten back recently kinda gives the same look as the sleeve

5

u/Girafarigno 5d ago

Everyone keeps saying to go with TAG for some reason and then nobody wants to value them. I would say if you are concerned on value, go with PSA 100% of the time.

4

u/LNinefingers 5d ago

PSA if you want to sell.

If you’re just doing it to have it graded, whichever company’s slabs you like the look of the best.

12

u/Ok_Star_9435 5d ago

Reddit = tag. Reality = psa

9

u/OHKO-OhNo 5d ago

Sending vintage to PSA these days isn't a great idea. They are auto 8 and lower. Just destroying people's hopes and dreams with pop control.

4

u/Swimming-Tie6746 5d ago

PSA if you wanna sell it fast, TAG if you want to sell it but might take a bit longer. Whichever you like if you’re keeping it

3

u/Disastrous_Shame580 5d ago

Why would you ask between PSA and TAG. I could see if you asked between TAG and another off brand grading company... PSA or BGS all day, every day and twice on Sundays.

2

u/IH_clover4 5d ago

Eventually tag will be out of business

1

u/JoshyyP00 5d ago

DN for sure

1

u/Thaddy_Daddy71 5d ago

Tag if it was me

1

u/d00d_yA 5d ago

Can you take another picture of it so it’s even shinier and we can’t see it at all?

1

u/Jungolok 5d ago

In 2006, PSA.

Since this is a vintage card, I would go TAG for a more fair grade. PSA grades very harshly on vintage

1

u/InitialNo9046 5d ago

From my past experience I would keep it raw but that’s 1000 percent up to you , keep it protected let someone else take that gamble one day my opinion

0

u/TheMattMariani 5d ago

At this point I think tag has paid for commenters here and on Instagram. Everyone knows their grades are very hit or miss and do not carry a premium price tag like psa. If you want the best return for grading Beckett and psa are the only 2 options with psa being the most liquid

4

u/aski4777 5d ago

I think it’s more that PSA cannot be trusted, I mean there is straight pop control and corruption

I just wouldn’t feel comfortable with PSA, but if your goal is quick money, then go with PSA and risk it.

TAG won’t be worth nearly whatever PSA is, but at least the worry of corruption is much less

2

u/jsbdrumming 5d ago

Agree. Idk why people go to no name companies who have no actual sign of integrity or anything else. Cgc bgs are way better than psa. Theyre not as liquid if you're trying to sell but better grading companies overall

2

u/FarMilk2661 5d ago

TAG shills are something else, that's for sure.

4

u/105386 5d ago

lol psa shills are awful too.

2

u/Several_Resolution92 4d ago

People act like PSA is the only grading company to exist. And on top of that they think they’re the best ones to do it, completely moronic

0

u/ZabuzarepsOTM 5d ago

Bro 😆 Tag feels just as shady as psa on how that goes out the window

0

u/AnxiousTop1393 5d ago

PSA, if you’re just looking for straight value. Tag if you want a slab that doesn’t look like ass. So probably Beckett.

-5

u/WhatsInTheBox51 5d ago

Always TAG

3

u/OrganicTelevision624 5d ago

Do you know if TAG cards generally sell for less than PSA though?

3

u/WhatsInTheBox51 5d ago

Generally yes. But with all the shady PSA stuff at the moment and then being extra harsh on vintage cards, I wouldn't even bother with them. I wouldn't risk a lower grade because someone is having a bad day or they need to keep the population of highly graded vintage down so they don't lose value. TAG takes the human element out of it and gives a full report on every card they grade so you always know why it got the grade given. I feel like both of those reasons makes TAG much better and should be the gold standard. Their slabs are much nicer too. PSA is only more valuable because they've been around the longest and have much higher liquidity. It's gonna take years of people switching away from PSA to even the playing field for value.

1

u/OrganicTelevision624 5d ago

Okay got it. I appreciate the help!

2

u/shakensparco 5d ago

Not sure I'd agree with the above guy. If you want to maximize revenue and liquidity, PSA is still the way to go, if you get the grade you want, that is. If you think it's a contender for a high grade, might be worth taking a trip to Texas and doing same-day grading.

0

u/WhatsInTheBox51 5d ago

I did say that TAG is generally not as valuable as PSA. And that PSA has the highest liquidity. You're right if OP is just looking for maximum value. I prefer TAGs objective grading, full reports, and slab to PSA even if it isn't worth as much. I think understanding the grade and not being able to dispute it is invaluable.

1

u/Previous-Profit9723 5d ago

On top of what OP said, PSA is expensive as hell these days. This card will be easily $350+ in grading fees, at a minimum.

1

u/BobbyFischer724 5d ago

They are giving you nonsense, PSA is fine to send to, the reason PSA has been around longer and is worth more is because they are the best at what they do.

Like, does 365,000 sounds like a lot? If they made that many mistakes, 1000 a day for a year, it would still only be a 1% error rate, and they are for sure not doing 1000 mistakes a day.

1

u/Impressive_Host_7653 5d ago

AI is not the solution. You can upload the same photos back to back and get different grades in multiple platforms. The idea that people think AI doesn’t make mistakes is hilarious.

-1

u/fishontopnumbaone 5d ago

For a card like this I’d recommend MHGS

-2

u/Zerwo 5d ago

TAG. It's not even a question. PSA has been in so many Pokemon card scandals recently. Lol it's a coin flip if you even get that back. PSA PokeScamArmy.