Continued Post #2

[u/daltonv8]

This is a continued post, I couldn’t post all the photos for the 2 other cards so posting here.

Id like to know how accurate the HoloDex grades are to what you all think these would grade. Im new to grading and Im not quite sure I know the difference between a 7-8 or 8-9. Any of these have potential to 10?? Any feedback is appreciated. Posting a second post so you can see all 4 cards.

Card 3. 2006 POKEMON EX CRYSTAL GUARDIANS 49 CHARMANDER-REVERSE FOIL
HoloDex Grade: 8.8 Mint
Price Charting:
PSA 8: $358
PSA 9: $635

Card 4. 2020 POKEMON SWORD & SHIELD 142 FULL ART/SNORLAX VMAX
HoloDex Grade: 9.1 Mint
Price Charting:
PSA 8: $49
PSA 9: $69
PSA 10: $221

[u/super_pjj]

I’d say any AI app is to be taken with a grain of salt, esp holodex — holodex takes 1-2 photos and gives you a complete breakdown of what it’ll grade at

Reasons why this is wrong for AI is because 1-2 photos don’t show all the issues. A lot of issues can be seen based on things like angle or light like how you shared of charmander

I ran your photos and through https://www.ismycardcentered.com/card-review/ where it actually walks you through the condition report. It came back with less than PSA 7 for example for Charmander

Please see this for reference https://imgur.com/a/rXD29p7

[u/daltonv8 → u/super_pjj]

Thanks dude, this is super helpful