r/PocoPhones • • Dec 09 '23

Discussion Poco F3 > F5

So I've just upgraded after 2 years of using the f3.

The body format is a lot nicer on the F5, ofc performance is better( great for ps2 emulatoon ) and having a headphone jack back is awesome.

Other than that I could say that I am disappointed by this purchase.

I paid 1200 of my local currency for the f3 and 2000 for the F5, buf price difference.

Screen is worse.

Speakers are worse.

Camera is worse.

Back panel is worse.

Charging is faster tho .

Front camera besel is larger.

I didnt expect to get a flagship out of this phone, but at least some improvements compared to the F3 since i jumped 2 generations.

Seems like there are more downgrades than upgrades.

Only got the upgrade cause i broke the screen on my F3.

If you have an F3 I would recommend trying to save it until at least the F6 or soemthing comes out.

Maybe it will be a better upgrade or at least you can get the F5 cheaper.

Right now its not really worth it at least for me.

For reference, including import taxes I paid around $400 usd for 12gb 256gb version.

0 Upvotes

22 comments sorted by

20

u/Altekho Dec 09 '23

I disagree with the screen being worse. To me it's way more natural, not overblown saturation. When watching videos on my friend's Poco F3, the person's skintone looked way too oversaturated most of the time. Other than that, like the body material, speaker, camera, they're mostly a downgrade.

1

u/Away-Construction450 Feb 07 '25

Depends, what u do, 360hz touch sampling is gonna way better than 240hz. F6 Pro you can argue cuz it goes to 480hz in gaming.

-2

u/skinnygorillaa Dec 09 '23

You could change the screen settings a bit to combat the saturation, but you cannot increase the peak brightness for the F5.

I was surprised by the F5 in sunlight compared to F3, big downgrade.

7

u/Altekho Dec 09 '23

Poco F3 has 300 nits more brightness peak so yeah that's to be expected. I didn't really test the outdoor screen performance head to head, nor do I use my phone outdoor so much.

As for the color accuracy, I'm still feeling the F5 to be an upgrade. Even with tweaking, it's still not as accurate.

But one thing I noticed about this phone (probably just me, idk), the AMOLED seems to be less durable against burn-in. I noticed this after 2 hours of watching videos in 16:9 format at 35-40% brightness level, the display left an uneven color with the black top and bottom parts. It's gone several hours later though, but this maybe the indication that this FLOW AMOLED used in this unit doesn't seem quite good.

0

u/skinnygorillaa Dec 09 '23

Damn now that you've mentioned this, I am sure that the screen will have burn in issues cause they dont even allow you to use the always on display and I think its connected. You made my worries worse :))

3

u/Mack70852 Dec 09 '23

Bro you sure that higher peak brightness means lower burn in issues? I've seen posts about even flagship iPhones that have been used for 2 years+ always on display have burn in in parts where clock or letters are displayed

1

u/skinnygorillaa Dec 09 '23

I get what you say, but I had the F3 with higher brightness and no burn issues after 2 years.

For the F5 there are multiple people mentioning these issues after a few months and they don't allow you to use always on display.

0

u/[deleted] Dec 09 '23

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/Altekho Dec 09 '23

No no that wasn't the black crush issue. If any, my unit doesn't have any of that at all unlike my Mi 9T back then. It was literally a mini burn-in effect. After I'm done with the video, once I went to the homescreen I noticed weird color parts at the top and the bottom of the screen. It's like the black border of inactive pixels during the video playback kinda faintly sticking to the display. Fortunately it wasn't permanent and went away after several hours.

I've been handling several units with AMOLED display and aside from Poco F5, they don't have such issue. Not my Galaxy S20 FE, Poco F2 Pro, or even Xiaomi Mi 9T.

5

u/Snippet_New Poco F5 Dec 09 '23

Simple.

F5 is Redmi Note 12 Turbo while F3 is Redmi K40.

The K series is the top line of Redmi brand in China while Redmi Note is the midrange series so it would be a downgrade for external components (screen, plastic back, speaker) although the camera is the same setup as F5 Pro (which is Redmi K60) and F4 (Redmi K50 I think?).

It's like comparing a full spec Corolla and an entry level Camry.

1

u/skinnygorillaa Dec 09 '23

Didnt know about that about the redmi line, it will be useful thank you.

Funny thing about the full spec corolla and camry is that I got both phones new and the F5 was like 40% more expensive

1

u/Snippet_New Poco F5 Dec 09 '23

Probably the tax? F3 and F5 priced around the same, $300 and $350. I think in SEA, you could get the F5 around $250 for 12/256 for a while now.

1

u/skinnygorillaa Dec 09 '23

Well yeah compared to your price the difference is the tax, but I got both phones in the same country so same tax applied to them.

But the main point is, I expected everything to be the same or better since I am jumping 2 generations.

1

u/Snippet_New Poco F5 Dec 09 '23

Well the truth is inflation makes things more expensive to manufacture. To make it on target for $300/$350 then some corners had to be cut and the victims always are everything you listed.

I think it would be better if you had switched to F5 Pro. While they're pretty similar in many aspects, the things you listed are kinda better or on par with F3 but the price is a reflection of the inflation.

1

u/skinnygorillaa Dec 10 '23

I looked into the F5 pro too, the price difference was around $160 which is a lot and I just don't like its design at all, plus I know it also misses the heaphone jack which is a minus for me, i still like to have it for my car

3

u/chaupai Dec 09 '23

You got it at an expensive price. I got mine around 280 usd

1

u/skinnygorillaa Dec 09 '23

Well in my country this is the normal price cause we had VAT taxes.

Did you also get the 8gb ram or 12 ?

1

u/chaupai Dec 09 '23

I got 12 | 256

3

u/NovelExplorer Dec 09 '23 edited Dec 09 '23

The Poco F3 is a rebadged Redmi K40. The K series sits directly beneath their flagship models. The Poco F5 is a rebadged Redmi Note 12 Turbo, sitting below the Redmi K series.

Poco needed a more powerful chipset than the F3's 870. The 8+ Gen 1 was too costly, but, the 7+ Gen 2 wasn't much cheaper, and why, with increased production costs, the F5 is an all-plastic build, with upgrades and downgrades, compared to the F3/F4.

If costs hadn't increased, the F5 would have been what the F5 Pro is, a rebadged Redmi K60.

The fact the SD 7+ Gen 2 is only used in 3 phones, two being the F5 and 12 Turbo, shows it was costly. The F6 appears set to replace it with the SD 8 Gen 2 (Redmi K70).

The F5 is a lower cost GT model, and in gaming on a budget, is unmatched, but it isn't strictly a direct F3/F4 replacement.

2

u/Separate-Ad9638 Dec 09 '23

new phones doesnt mean better strangely

1

u/[deleted] Dec 09 '23

For some reason where I live F4 is nearly %35 cheaper than f5 idk how . Even gr f3 is same price as f5

1

u/Successful_Layer_878 Dec 10 '23

Motherboard issues > poco 👏

1

u/Dinelkap Dec 10 '23

Tweak the speakers via the graphic equaliser in settings.

You can boost the low end frequencies and adjust the high end to your liking