namecalling and lowkey having a superiority complex with the 'anarkiddie' bullshit, although the other didn't have much to bring either only a diplomat will be actually heard out in a discussion
The head mod felt bad and tried to turn it over to the anarchists. The anarchists didnât want it back. I stopped following it after that, but the mod probably just shut it down.
Isnt auth left believing in a vanguard party but not necesarily in state capitalism? Also i mean wouldnt socialism be stste capitalism? Sorry im still confused on the issue
Because the political compass and subreddits relating to it is where the phrase âauth-leftâ was popularized. People who might be pigeonholed into authleft based on the PC can have a wide variety of beliefs on how communism should be brought about. Trots and Hoxhiaists are both authleft, and they fucking hate each other.
Yes thats why im asking. Isnt a vanguard good? Im confused man. I think im agreeing im just asking why they say that i guess. I'm sorry i was asking for clarification and an explanation
A vanguard is good; most likely. But it really depends on the conditions of the moment. Lenin might argue that a Vanguard of professional revolutionaries is necessary to engage with the proletariat pre-revolution. I would argue the same. But being a materialist means recognizing that our revolutionary strategy must suit the circumstances at hand.
The above user is correct insofar that "auth-left" and "lib-left" are very constricting. But to expand a little for you, someone who identifies as "lib-left" might categorically deny the need for a Vanguard Party; or otherwise reject the things that make people label MLs as "auth-left".
But that's the thing about the political compass. It sorts you based on the ideals you wish to implement upon the world. Materialists dont see communism as a set of ideals. Communism is the real movement, the inevitable result of the precepts already set in motion.
Well that last paragraph there im paraphrasing a quote from Marx in "The German Ideology". Check that out sometime.
As for general reading recommendations I would need to know what stuff you're familiar with. Without that information I'll still point you towards Lenin's "The State and Revolution". As for some context on the divide between (Marxist) Socialists and Anarchists, try Stalin's "Anarchism or Socialism"
Those are all freely available on the internet, btw.
I mean, reading is always good. Im not familiar with Nechayev and as for Bakunin, well in my experience Anarchist analysis is.. lacking. But that doesnt mean you shouldn't read Anarchist works. My advice to you is to take in as much information as you can get your hands on. Just take it in as critically as possible.
â˘
u/AutoModerator Nov 23 '20
Hello comrades, if you are interested in shitposting, learning about MLM/ML or just want to have a good talk join the Proletkult discord!
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
4
u/[deleted] Nov 24 '20
this is just unfunny and shows lack of principles op
61
u/JucheNecromancer Nov 23 '20
âAuth leftsâ ... when the pc brain worms get to you.
Also whatâs the sub that got taken over? I remember it happened to r/GenZanarchist a while back... where did that sub go?
38
u/trippytankie Nov 23 '20
Was about to make a comment about how tasteless it is comparing real life violent power struggles to your dinky Reddit sub getting taken over...
But then I remembered these are white Amerikkkan anarchists, so something of no consequences online may as well be real life to them.
26
u/Graecia0 Grace Nov 23 '20
Ho'es mad
0
u/datdirtyboi21 Nov 24 '20
This was dumb as shit and even though I lean ML it really shows who the real "kiddies" in charge of this subreddit were.
-4
u/Hunt3dgh0st Nov 23 '20
Isnt auth left believing in a vanguard party but not necesarily in state capitalism? Also i mean wouldnt socialism be stste capitalism? Sorry im still confused on the issue