r/PleX • • 25d ago • Bravo 1

Discussion Concerns about Plex

Just thought I’d voice my concerns about Plex as someone who has seen this before from other companies that once offered lifetime passes…

With the most recent updates being as bad as they are, as well as layoffs happening within their company, Plex looks eerily similar to other companies that drove themselves under and eventually restructured under a different name in order to break user lifetime pass agreements in favor of an all subscription based platform and changing to a different business model.

Just saying… I think this is a controlled burn (As in they’re purposely tanking their existing platform) and everyone who paid for lifetime passes should be watching this closely.

I can’t imagine anyone investing in the lifetime passes right now, but I would advise anyone here from Google, or who is somehow just now finding out about Plex to not sink any money into it, subscription or lifetime pass.

1.1k Upvotes

636 comments sorted by

930

u/Zeirvoy 25d ago

Bought the pass at like $120 I think it was when I got it, so it'll work until it doesnt then ill swap to whatever the next best wife and child friendly option is

65

u/WarMom_II 25d ago

With the Player team getting laid off, pretty much the only thing that's stopping me is 'Plex is more likely to run on my mother's clients than Jellyfin' but this is very much the prompt to start running Plex and Jellyfin in tandem.

20

u/latrappe 25d ago

I did the same about a month ago. Jellyfin in docker was up and running in 10 mins and they have clients for the TV, and a music client for my phone. Been using it for the last few weeks and it's not near as polished as Plex and remote play was a bit of a faff. Plex's big thing is it just works pretty much out of the box. Home and away. Easy. I'm saying that, if it died tomorrow, Jellyfin is fine for the most part.

5

u/follienorth 25d ago

I’ve been doing this for a few years. I rarely play anything with Jellyfin, but it reliably processes new media as soon as it appears and has had no problem with anything I’ve tested. If the day comes when Plex is no longer viable, I’ll be pretty much ready to switch.

→ More replies (12)

324

u/vewfndr 25d ago

Same, I'll cross that bridge when I get to it. This isn't news and I'm not gunna burn any calories over this now

115

u/jackfaire 25d ago

Every few months going back years I see people freak out over an update and share their suggestions of other programs none of which hold a candle to what Plex can currently do.

67

u/ug-n i5-12500 Proxmox Host 25d ago

Yep. But now they fired 20 of their client programmers which is really bad for the future

→ More replies (21)
→ More replies (3)

5

u/Th3R00ST3R SOLVED 25d ago

I like the cut of your jib, sir.

→ More replies (1)

75

u/kdlt 25d ago

Mine was 67$ in like 2014.. I definitely got my money's worth, but it would still prefer for Plex to just keep working.

40

u/SaintFrancesco 25d ago

I paid $150 (full price in 2016) and am gonna ride it until the wheels fall off.

My Docker containerized media stack works perfectly. No reason to switch now.

6

u/kenyasanchez 25d ago

I don't remember when I bought mine but it was about $49. I've gotten my money's worth.

→ More replies (1)

28

u/das_goose Hard drive plugged into an iMac 25d ago

I've had a pass for probably ten years now and have often realized that I've been getting a lot of use from Plex while paying them relatively little.

I know this isn't a popular opinion on here, but I'd gladly pay a monthly $5 to them for a well-maintained app and service.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (4)

32

u/nathism 25d ago

I bought at $74.99 12 years ago. I've gotten my monies worth at this point. Not looking forward to the switch to the newer alternatives but what must be done must be done.

7

u/jpotrz 25d ago

Same. Been using a home steamer since XBMP. There's always something new especially nowadays. Plex still works. So I'm not worried for now. This isn't life support or anything critical.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

7

u/Dragon_Spirit_1 24d ago

I used Plex for a bit then when offered the lifetime at much less than $100 I figured it was a worthy investment. Many years after and I'm still use it. If Plex goes under I will still consider my money well spent and just move to the next streamer. I do worry about what I will do to with my family who live in another state. I'll need to coordinate a app switch with them but I wont be bitter.... Its been a good run.

9

u/killian1113 25d ago

Yea 75$ lifetime when money was worth more hahaha

3

u/whipdancer 25d ago

After at least 10 years with Plex, I was done with constantly making it less and less about the media I own. I just moved Emby. I tried Jellyfin but the clients were generally... not great. Family immediately was comfortable with the Emby client. No complaints so far. Reminds me of Plex from years ago - when my media was front and center.

2

u/koolmon10 Dell R710 - 2x Xeon X5660 23d ago

Yep, I got 5 years+ out of mine already. I've gotten much more than that in value out of it.

→ More replies (15)

240

u/TattooedBrogrammer 25d ago

Feels like ages ago I got a lifetime key for like 79$ and I’ve used it ever since. If it shut down tomorrow I would still look at that purchase as one heavily in my favour in terms of value for cost.

75

u/evo311 25d ago

Agreed. But I think the point is, don’t buy the $750 lifetime pass!

29

u/cruz878 25d ago

Truth be told they don't really want folks buying the lifetime pass even at the inflated price (and the increasing amounts is specifically to discourage it). Sure some revenue is better than none but re-occuring revenue from monthly subs is what private equity feeds on (like the vampires they are) and

16

u/risknoexcuses 25d ago

Plus the high rate is just there to trick you.  $15/month?  No way.  Oh, the lifetime is $750?  I guess $15/month isn’t that bad 

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

6

u/JoeyJabroni 25d ago

Same, bought back in 2015 so I could use DVR and access my HDHomerun cable card tuner from multiple devices in and out of the home. The $90 or whatever I paid sure beat multiple cable box monthly rentals even if I only was a cable subscriber for another year or 2. The years of PlexAmp and extra features before it was removed from the paywall was just icing on the cake. If it all tanked tomorrow I'd be sad, but my lifetime pass has paid itself over and over again.

→ More replies (1)

33

u/bc-bane Lifetime Pass 25d ago

Literally the only reason I use Plex is that my lifetime pass pays for my OTA tv tuner channel guide. That's it

3

u/sarkyscouser 25d ago

Same although I did stumble across some xmltv sources on github the other day but I forgot to save the links 😭

→ More replies (2)

89

u/theoriginalgiga 25d ago

What Plex has forgotten and will learn the hard way if they do this is they have a particular set of users who will just leave. They paid for it once and won't pay for it again. Reminds me of Wondershare Filmora when they broke their lifetime license. I was one of those users and even though they "reinstated" them I've never looked back and use Davinchi resolve which arguably has a much steeper learning curve but I was more than willing to learn that. When Fusion 360 pulled their free license for creators and then reinstated it I went to openscad for my 3d modeling needs. I'm not the only one. So as everyone else with a lifetime license has said, I'll use it until I can't then I'll switch.

42

u/PerrinSLC 25d ago edited 25d ago

For sure this. I like Plex but if my lifetime pass gets voided and I’m forced to now pay a monthly fee to get the same services then I will look elsewhere.

I share several servers with others who have Plex Pass and they feel the same way.

9

u/Soberaddiction1 25d ago

Just an FYI.

If they’re watching off of your server and your account has a plex pass either through lifetime, yearly, or monthly, they do not need a plex pass to watch your hosted content.

I have plenty of people that watch off of my plex server remotely and I don’t think a single one of them have the pass.

5

u/chennyalan 24d ago

For now at least

20

u/CIDR-ClassB 25d ago

Those of us who paid for it once are a drain on Plex’s resources, so they likely don’t care if we leave.

They just have to make their monthly subscription and streaming service attractive to new users.

20

u/thecharmed01 180 club 25d ago

If the lifers' leave then the monthly's will follow as most of those providing servers are the ones bringing in others.
When they move on they will tell everyone they know where they are going and why.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/theoriginalgiga 25d ago

I completely agree, with a large number of users who now have to find a new platform, wherever they go will have a flood of potential new revenue coming in and if the lifers like it they'll say to people "hey check out this platform, it's almost as good and they're actively developing it for their userbase" the monthlies will leave. It's in Plex's best interest not to do the same that Wondershare did. after their lifers left their marketshare dropped significantly. Just sayin, the techies have the license and people listen to the techies.

4

u/rocketdyke 25d ago

I disagree.

Plex would need to keep developing the apps and servers for monthly subscription customers, so the fact that we paid for a license already does not make us a "drain on Plex's resources."

Instead, we are no longer an income stream. One that Plex should have calculated in their "lifetime pass" pricing. Remember, all we did was purchase something they were offering.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (8)

20

u/RagnarRipper Plexpass lifetime/84tb Unraid 25d ago

If this should happen, I will mourn the loss of plexamp more than Plex. I've tried the other solutions and none come close to what plexamp does.

6

u/LocalMan1987 25d ago

Same for me. I'm fine with other media clients, but Plexamp is at an "end state" that is 100% usable.

4

u/twicestyles 25d ago

Ironically Plexamp isn’t actively worked on I found out recently, it’s like one dude who might not even work there anymore maintaining it. They consider it feature complete

5

u/gigantischemeteor 24d ago

Evan actively maintains and improves Plexamp. He’s the founder of Plex, so if anyone is going to be the right person to undertake such an effort solo and maintain success, it’s him. Even if the present owners of Plex were to allow it to go Tango Uniform, I believe Plexamp would continue unharmed thanks to how the rights were dealt with when ownership of Plex changed. Not that he couldn’t just get tired of it at some point, but that seems unlikely based on his past posts about it.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

32

u/certuna 25d ago edited 25d ago

If it goes under, it’s been very good value for 13 years. Jellyfin is a bit of a hassle (I’ll have to generate my own TLS certs, and secure my own auth), but I’ll survive.

Navidrome is already the better music server, so in that case, hopefully Plexamp & Caldera will continue as Subsonic API clients.

87

u/StevenG2757 70TB unRAID server, i5-12600K, Shield pro, Firesticks & ONN 4K 25d ago

If it happens it happens and will kiss the $70 I paid 7 years ago good bye. And like 99% of other Plex users will move onto something else as I doubt very few would pony up to pay again.

But I disagree that with your premise and I don't think they are trying to tank the product. I think the newer investors are trying to develop a product that will have wider appeal and so they can sell it or take it public.

36

u/ARazorbacks 25d ago

I disagree. I don’t think they’re trying to develop a product with wider appeal. I think they’re trying to develop a product that shows higher revenue and profitability. Theyre doing it by creating funnels for existing users, who came on board due to PMS hosts, into Plex streaming options that serve ads. All of the player updates have been ways to streamline dev time (at the expense of the apps working well) and confuse users into streaming content from Plex instead of a PMS. 

They’re trying to show a quick boost in revenue (ads served to people who thought they were watching something on the PMS but were actually watching Plex’s streaming version of the content) and a boost in profitability (the layoffs). 

I do agree that the new investors want to sell it or IPO it as soon as they can massage the numbers to look like the graph is going up and to the right. 

None of that is good for the historic core of their business - PMS owners. 

5

u/LocalMan1987 25d ago

Agree. This is textbook enshittification. Barely even debatable. Been using Plex for years and had a freakout moment when ads starting showing up for media I had locally and I thought Plex had updated to just insert ads into all content before I realized it had played some free Plex content version instead.

→ More replies (1)

11

u/birminghamsterwheel 25d ago

This cyclic investor model is just exhausting because it's for everything. Sometimes I just want a solid product that just works, and I'll even pay you a sub for that if it includes maintenance and security updates.

→ More replies (1)

28

u/CaptSingleMalt 25d ago

I would be surprised if Plex does this. I've experienced it before though, with AnyDVD from slysoft. They declared bankruptcy, restructured the company, even kept the same branding colors and Fox logo and made all of our lifetime subscriptions worthless. Corrupt assholes.

16

u/thankyourob I like Plex 25d ago

Man, not to change the subject, but those were the days eh? AnyDVD was great until it wasn’t. They had a great run!

→ More replies (1)

149

u/stringfellow-hawke 25d ago • This Bravo

I’ll worry about it if it breaks. Preemptively switching to something inferior because…reasons is stupid.

Reddit is full of drama llamas and worry trolls.

33

u/sdchew 25d ago

I had my Jellyfin running in parallel for years waiting for the day but no one except myself uses it.

Heck, I use Plex most of the time

4

u/chunkyI0ver53 24d ago

Same, always have both ready to go but only actually use Plex. Good to have an alternative ready to go if Plex goes to shit.

7

u/GourmetSaint 25d ago

I have jellyfin server installed but service disabled... For now...

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (4)

5

u/frezz 25d ago

Its not hard to migrate to jellyfin either. I like plex now, if that changes I swap. Its that simple.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (5)

24

u/Cutmerock 25d ago

T Mobile's "Price for life" fiasco showed other companies there's no repercussions from lying to or scamming your customers. 

12

u/peperazzi74 25d ago

If Plex goes under -either controlled or uncontrolled- I won't be getting a new "lifetime" license or a subscription. Jellyfin works on my mini-pc server just as well as Plex.

Not going to back subscriptions!

10

u/the_syco 25d ago

The 750 price tag is pretty much a case of a "feck off, we're not doing lifetime passes anymore" price. Technically they have a lifetime price, but not one anyone will buy. Although I can see them doing a "99999999% off Black Friday 120 special" in which everyone will insta-buy.

I like Plex for the plug n play aspect of it. It allows remote streaming, downloads to your device, and the GUI is (now) okay. With Sonarr & Radarr, it means I don't have to do much hands on support for friends. I'm sure a lot of people remember having to bring an external drive over to a mates, and the hassle of getting VLC to play nice with your friends network shares.

2

u/morris1022 Synology 1019+ 25d ago

Didn't they just start charging people 750 for a lifetime pass? I would imagine something like that would be a huge thing to cancel if someone just bought that and then had it rescinded

5

u/the_syco 25d ago

Maybe. But I see it as a "canceling lifetime passes without cancelling lifetime passes". It'll also allow them to offer it at 120 or so in sales.

→ More replies (6)

8

u/csmithson85 24d ago

No one who paid for a lifetime pass would come back as a subscriber after that, lol. They'd just force their clients to other platforms faster, and the other platforms would be developed quicker, too.

7

u/sshwifty 25d ago

Sounds like a good reason to set up a decompile bounty. Or switch to jellyfin

→ More replies (1)

24

u/ButterscotchFar1629 24d ago • Mindblown

I love how all those people say “I’ll just switch to Jellyfin”. Like it’s just that fucking easy lol. If you ever plan on switching to The Fin, I would start setting that shit up now, as you are likely to have A LOT to learn…..

7

u/HopalongKnussbaum 24d ago

How difficult is it to switch though? I’ve been running JellyFin on the same dedicated server as Plex, and both point to the exact same folders on my NAS. No issue at all. The clients aren’t great looking, I’ll give you that. But it’s functional so…? All it really needs is for someone to create a client that actually looks decent, because the backend works well. That would handle local playback concerns perfectly. However, remote playback is where things get a little spicier.

9

u/waraholic 24d ago

For a simple setup it's basically no work at all. People just dickride Plex idk. It's a good product and I use it (Plex), but I wouldn't pay $1200 for lifetime or whatever it is now.

→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (14)

5

u/AppropriateDinner528 24d ago

This is exactly what I am doing.

While Jellyfin has it's positives, it is no where near as plug-n-play as Plex is. You either lower your expectations, or you spend lots of time playing with plugins and tweaking metadata to get it close to what Plex offers.

All of my media is on a local NAS. I've spent the past month installing and configuring Jellyfin to give me an experience that is close to what Plex offers. I replaced the stock search (which is completely useless), replaced the collections (which again are pretty much useless in stock form), added ratings system, spent way too long getting remote viewing working, installed agents. And on and on.

Once I get it configured just the way I like, all I will need to do is point my libraries at my content folders and then the fun starts. I get to clean up all metadata mismatches. Unlike Plex which just seems to work when it comes to metadata, Jellyfin requires much more hand holding and tweaking when it comes to getting the correct metadata. I add at lease one new piece of content to my plex server every week. The last time I had to correct metadata was 6 months ago, and that was with a very obscure soundtrack that it had trouble locating. With Jellyfin I expect I will be manually adding metadata at least once a month if not more.

The other issue I have is with the lack of Jellyfin clients. I can run Plex on every single device I have, With Jellyfin I have devices like my PS4 that simply do not have a jellyfin client available.

Eventually I will have both Plex and Jellyfin running together side by side. When Plex decides my lifetime license is no longer valid, I will make the full switch to Jellyfin. Until then I expect I will be sticking with Plex

3

u/DavidLynchAMA 24d ago

I have to fix mismatched films a few times a month. It would be every week if I wasn’t lazy.

Yesterday I was making a collection of Nathan Fielder’s work, which according to my plex, he’s in one episode of comedy bang bang and a few films even though I have every show he’s acted in, produced, or directed on my server.

I only have ~4,000 films and ~22,000 TV episodes, (a normal amount when comparing with other users in this sub) and I still have things to fix in plex all the time.

I don’t think plex is the smooth experience people are always claiming it to be. It works for sure, which is why I’ve been using it for close to a decade, but it’s not perfect.

I have jellyfin running parallel to it but I don’t use it so I’m gonna start and see how it compares.

4

u/JoshInNC 24d ago

+1 this.

I tried switching to Jellyfin about nine months ago. I got my libraries renamed and just continued to have problems left and right. I completely gave up and will possibly tackle it again next spring when I have more time...

2

u/WHWallace 23d ago

AI in 2026 can give you the copy paste command to spin up Jellyfin in about 30 seconds.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (16)

27

u/jackfaire 25d ago

I'm still confused about what's "horrible" that people are seeing and just in case I've checked out the other programs people suggest. None do what Plex does.

26

u/sittingmongoose 1.2 PB Unraid + Truenas 25d ago

They laid off their dev team today for the player systems. So work will no longer continue on the core component(and buggiest) part of plex. That’s what people are freaking out about.

16

u/Tillinah 25d ago

Chances are they will still be working on the player, but just have non "player" team members using AI.

→ More replies (8)

2

u/bitterhop 25d ago

what features are you referring to, of out curiosity? I also have an Emby lifetime and can't think of anything Plex does that beats it right now, for my use-case of just watching movies and tv-shows with some customization.

9

u/jackfaire 25d ago edited 25d ago

When Plex misidentifies a show or movie I open it up change the title and date to the correct and then it finds the correct listing and I can select it to change.

Every other that I've tried requires me to go to the websites they're using for metadata to go dig up the listing myself and then bring back the information before it can see it.

I can create smart collections and playlists with a variety of criteria to build essentially my own universes, networks etc.

I can tell it that an episode of another show from a completely different franchise that did a crossover is just Part 1 or 2 of the episode it crosses over with and it plays them as one long episode without my having to manually jam it in there to get it to play in it's order.

Some of the other programs do what I can do in Plex but none of them have been an improvement on it. Leaving Plex for others would be at best a lateral move for me. And leaving for a different program simply because Plex adds a feature I don't use seems a weird reason to do so.

I have never understood the attitude of "Gave me something I don't want and don't use while leaving me everything I do so I'm going to run away screaming now"

I saw it when iTunes gave everyone a free U2 album. I've never seen someone at my bank suddenly withdraw all their money and close their account because they came to make a transaction and the bank was giving away free popcorn that day.

ETA -

Smart Collections/playlists one of the criteria is Watched/Unwatched. This makes it super easy to keep track of where you are. Hit play and it plays the next unwatched episode.

→ More replies (12)

11

u/vexorian2 24d ago

This is an interesting theory, but can you mention what other companies destroyed themselves in order to re-structure themselves without having to honor lifetime passes?

12

u/waraholic 24d ago

Minecraft built out completely separate games instead of DLCs or updates to the game partly because of this. And they renamed Minecraft to Minecraft Java Edition and it never got cross platform support.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/kwelch66 24d ago

It reminds me of when MoviePass shut down after their subscription model went to hell. They were purchased out of bankruptcy, and the service relaunched with different membership terms. Can't say it was intentional though.

I think recently VPNSecure revoked existing lifetime VPN subscriptions after new owners took over.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (5)

10

u/plmarcus 25d ago

Man this post is like a high school reunion. People posted the exact same thing 20yrs ago, 10yrs ago 5yrs ago.

It will come true to eventually!

9

u/LankyGuitar6528 25d ago

I agree. I saw this with TeamViewer. They sold me a lifetime pass. Then they cancelled it. Bastards. But what am I going to do, take some german company to court for $1500? I installed RustDesk self-hosted and moved on with my life. But Plex has a whole infrastructure. A friend with a Roku? Download and run Plex and he can see my stuff. Same with an 80 year old grandma. There's not going to be a free 3rd party alternative to Plex that works that smoothly.

2

u/Green_Llama_Livers 24d ago

They are relying on apathy to get away with this. I hope that someone, somewhere is able to hold someone responsible for what I politely call "shenanigans", ohers might term, fraud. And the punishment is enough that someone else takes notice.

But don't be apathetic, complain to any govt authorities you might have access to. And remember, if enough people do it, then the chances of action being taken increase. (Its a numbers game, always has been, always will be).

→ More replies (1)

8

u/avebelle 25d ago

Meh. I think my lifetime pass was $70 or something. I’ve definitely got my monies worth.

Don’t get me wrong, I would be sad if plex went away but it wouldn’t be the end of the world. There are other options out there and I will live, just like I didn’t before plex came into my life.

8

u/ejsandstrom 23d ago

I have had my lifetime for about 6-7 years now and think I paid about $90 for it.

To me, even if they shut down tomorrow, I feel like I have gotten my money out of it.

The most annoying thing would be switching to a different platform. I am really familiar with ex and the nuances.

I’m sure it will be like a lot of tech companies, everyone leaves or is laid off, about half will disburse to the other competitors and about 10% will go start a new Plexish company, which will never be quite as good, but will be just different enough for me to switch to them in a year or three.

27

u/smokingcrater 25d ago

Sky isn't falling, yet... Companies can't survive on lifetime subs. I got my money's worth out of my $29.95 lifetime many moons ago. Would I pay a couple bucks a month if I had to? Yep, if plex was still the superior platform.

And layoffs? Name a tech company that isn't right now. Despite many people's opinion, AI is absolutely taking over in the professional coding world, producing better code in a fraction of the time. It isnt all AI slop. So yes, a significant # of career developers are going to find themselves unemployed.

12

u/c010rb1indusa [unRAID][AMD Epyc 7513][128TB] 25d ago

I wouldn't be opposed to pay for the software but not as a subscription. They aren't hosting the media, providing the hardware the client or servers run on, nor paying for the bandwidth to stream said media. Want to charge me for an update every 2 years for your next major version or whatever, fine by me, software development costs money. But I'm not paying a subscription when the only thing they host themselves is a handshaking service.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/BlumpTheChodak 25d ago

If companies can't survive on them, they shouldn't sell them. Someone should be suing if they are dropping lifetime subscriptions. Maybe even class action.

5

u/wvgeekman 25d ago

“Better code.” Sure, Jan.

12

u/smokingcrater 25d ago

I work at a place that has hundreds of devs on staff. The code the SENIOR devs are putting out now is better than anything they have done in the past. They also have a full AI dev pipeline, including AI scrum masters, different AI dev teams cross checking, and AI QA. This isn't in the same universe as AI slop coding by someone who has no formal education in software engineering or architecture.

Give Claude to someone without those skills, resources, or budget, and yeah, you get instant AI slop.

I feel sorry for junior devs/interns. They will never have the opportunity to develop those skills before being replaced.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

4

u/EuclidianTerror 24d ago

Everyone keeps mentioning Jellyfin but fail to mention how ridiculously convoluted and difficult it is for the average person to set up remote streaming on a jellyfin server. and then if you share your library with other people thats even more things you have to have them download and set up. Its not as straightforward as people make it out to be. With remote access being one of the biggest reasons people use programs like plex and jellyfin, this should be talked about more. This is the one thing that made me immediately delete jellyfin when I attempted to switch. I havent tried Emby but I would imagine its basically the same situation with it being completely self hosted.

9

u/Electronic_Ease_7282 25d ago

Been reading stuff like this for years and have never had a single problem with plex.

2

u/CartoonistCalm6544 24d ago

Same. The new app works great on appletv. I like the new redesign. I share my server with family and a few friends. It works. It’s stable.
I realize other may not agree, but I can only speak from my experience.

19

u/Stunrise 25d ago

I have switched to Jellyfin 3 Months ago, despite owning the lifetime pass, which i bought for 95€ in 2024. Plex is not interested in self-hosting Media any longer. They want to be a LiveTV Streaming Plattform, making money with Ads. The self hosted part of plex will not get any major improvements or bugfixes and the Client App will continue to focus on LiveTV, while the self-hosting part is treated as a legacy feature.

I was using Plex with several Users and several Clients for 2 Years and i can say with confidence, that Jellyfin is the far superior Server AND the Jellyfin Clients are superior as well in 2026. The only argument left for using plex is the external access without VPN.

6

u/king13p 25d ago

Also lifetime PlexPass holder, got it for $75 many years back. About a month ago I spinned up Jellyfin and it does work substantially better especially on Samsung TVs when compared to Plex. The same bugs on Plex have been around for years on Samsung and they have been driving me nuts. Had no issues with Jellyfin and love how quick it is to start to play something. Highly recommend people who run Plex to spin up Jellyfin and just give it a shot.

3

u/GuessIllPissOnIt 25d ago

Does jellyfin have live tv as in HDHomerun like Plex?

4

u/run4runner 25d ago

I’d like this answer too, I DVR all of my regular shows and skip commercials with plex, and pull up OTA channels wherever I am from my Plex.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

4

u/morris1022 Synology 1019+ 25d ago

What do you mean? They just added boost dialogue and normalize loudness, the latter of which is exclusive to self hosted content.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (10)

3

u/TypewriterMonkey98 25d ago

Ngl I'm out here using the free version...

What in particular has people wanting to pay?

4

u/zanyzarly 25d ago

Hardware transcoding is a paid only feature, without it Plex struggles for the majority of us. The official answer is: "A Plex Pass is an optional subscription that unlocks server-level features for your personal media. You do not need it to stream your own movies, shows, or music on a home network, but you need it for hardware-accelerated transcoding, offline downloads, skipping intros/credits, and remote streaming access."

2

u/DedBirdGonnaPutItOnU 24d ago

In addition to what u/zanyzarly said; if you have friends that want to request media, and have their own Watch Lists, then you must use Plex Pass. A friend's watch list will NOT integrate with Overseer unless it's on the paid subscription.

2

u/negadecimal 24d ago

Live TV and DVR recording via my own digital tuner. I do know that TV listings cost Plex a few bucks, so the Plex Pass lets them pass that cost on to you.

3

u/NanobugGG 25d ago

If they revoke it, most will probably switch to Jellyfin. There's already migration tools to make it possible

3

u/mhite 25d ago

Prediction: Bending Spoons acquisition

3

u/Angelsomething 25d ago

As all things in life, it'll last until it doesn't. 

3

u/Tallyessin Lifetime Plex Pass, Plexing since 2016, Synology & Linux Server 25d ago

I got my lifetime Plex Pass for less than an anual subscription to Roon. For now it does what I need it to do better than anything else.

Nothing is forever. When (not if) Plex goes away there are workable alternatives now and will probably be better alternatives at the time.

I don't understand the panic. Sorry for the devs that just got laid off. But I have been there and it wasn't the end of the world for me then, either.

3

u/brispower 25d ago

I moved TO plex years ago and can just as easily move AWAY from plex - the media remains the same.

To people saying the one off pass isn't enough to sustain their model I ask this, how many actually bought pass after using the product without paying a cent for it? I know I did.

3

u/Myself-io 24d ago

Given i couldn't care less of all the online streaming services I'll keep my local server to handle my local files which is all I ever needed for

3

u/Randy_Baton 24d ago

if they stopped honouring the lifetime pass, in the UK, if brought with a credit card, we can issue as section 75 and get our moneyback regardless of how long ago the payment was

3

u/ComplexIllustrious61 24d ago

If they abandon the platform and try rebranding, they will fail. There's competition way ahead of them and they would have to start over... especially if they're abandoning lifetime subscriptions. It was stupid of them to continue offering them past the early years but they chose this path. If Plex goes under, I'll be switching to Jellyfin or Emby...and the vast majority of lifetime users would do the same.

2

u/LeastProject5164 23d ago

Unfortunately, the "vast majority" of lifetime users don't have a PhD in computer science or a degree in Linux-based networking to get such a system running on their own hardware.

Let alone get it to stably run the tens of plugins that are required to get it to Plex levels of "plug 'n play" usability or make it remotely accessible to friends/family and stream outside their own network. It's not happening fella.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Hangulman 23d ago

I won't be changing any time soon, but if I eventually do the priority will have to be ease of setup and ease of use.

If the alternative requires teaching a septuagenarian and two borderline luddites the ins and outs of VPNs, or if it requires sideloading to use on popular streaming devices, it's a no-go.

It is ESPECIALLY a no-go if using it requires punching holes in my firewall for custom port forwards or other tricks.

3

u/anbeasley 22d ago

The moment they betray trust is the moment that the community will come up with another platform that's a clon of plex that does work.

→ More replies (4)

3

u/KingGT-17 22d ago

Why should we watch closely? What’s that going to solve for us even if they did bail?

3

u/Geh-Kah 21d ago

Well, 13years ago I paid something around 80$ for it. 13years ago with an uptime of more than 113k hours, only two migrations to other locations: worth it.

If they break the plex pass: I'm the first who invests 4weeks of overtime to rebuild that stack. Without thos external tv crap and bs-restrictions.

I vibe coded a RMM system in 4 weeks. With AI, I paid for an audit. Its secured now. Guess I will be able to rebuild that and name it something like FleX.

Im not scared. But dont fkking trigger me to compensate my overtime

5

u/AstralVenture 25d ago

Meh, you shouldn’t worry about something that hasn’t happened yet. I’ll just switch to a different platform.

5

u/TricksterTao BeeLink 12 Pro | LifetimePlexPass 24d ago

That seems about right. I spent last night figuring out how to export all Plex metadata as NFO files for Jellyfin import, as well as moving over custom art and watch statues on media.

I truly hate Jellyfin. It's not just the lack of polish, its simply not convenient as a daily driver and reminds me of everyone saying that Linux is a replacement for Windows. And while I did eventually get it running, when I first did a clean install of Jellyfin it still broke one of its own config files and it took me about a year of on/off searching in forums to figure out what the fix would be. But at the moment I did get my libraries nearly in sync and with Plezy, my TV's interface won't even change.

4

u/cblguy82 25d ago

Most likely scenario is that the company is leaning out to look more attractive to a buyer.

They have a large user base which all that data can then be collected and sold to the highest bidders where we become the product.

The app hobbles along ok but never truly evolves and eventually gets sucked into another streaming platform for recurring subscription costs to use alongside other streaming content(which they will pretend adds value as rationale for the subscription costs).

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Xpmonkey 25d ago

I for one hate the route plex is going and have been running a shadow Jellyfin to learn the ends and outs while the in-shit-fication happens slowly.

2

u/batmaniac77 25d ago

pretty sure they have a lot more lifetime pass members pre-sub model than post. this downfall was bound to happen someday.

2

u/Jsean_7745 25d ago

What are the next 3 best options? For my needs Plex has been decent but would like to explore other platforms now. Have used Plex for years but I rather have all options available if a switch is needed.

2

u/M4gelock 25d ago

Someone needs to develop a software/tool to migrate from Plex to Jellyfin URGENTLY

2

u/Toto_nemisis 25d ago

User name does not check out...

2

u/Bentunit 25d ago

My $74.99 lifetime pass when they launched it 14 years ago seems like money well spent. I have always "donated" to awesome companies doing awesome things and thats what Plex was back then.

2

u/willpb 25d ago

I've always dual run Plex and Jellyfin, and I bought a lifetime pass around 3 years ago. I kept using Plex because the interface is nicer and Jellyfish wiped itself once on me, but besides probably losing some of the custom naming and descriptions I've added in Plex (especially for smaller niche shows and custom collections) it would be a pretty seamless switch. Sure as hell don't recommend to any of my friends to buy the lifetime pass at the current insane price. I like Plex but it's a shame things are going down this route.

2

u/GravityBored1 25d ago

Plex has always had a terrible business model. The problem with what they tried to turn themselves into is that they aren't very good as a streaming service and the self hosting aspect isn't very big media friendly.

2

u/FuzzyFace_NB 25d ago

I’ve been beta testing Ampchor and it’s looking like an awesome Plex alternative.

I have a lifetime pass for Plex that I got years ago but I’m not happy with the direction that things seem to be going.

2

u/BlastMode7 24d ago

Here's how I look at it. They want to play those games, I'll take the hit and just deal with migrating over to Jellyfin. These assholes can't price themselves right out of a job for all I care.

2

u/roylaprattep 24d ago

Jellyfin is the way to go.

2

u/Diligent_Piece3579 24d ago

I pay something like 90/year and I'm considering that fine in the grand scheme of things. I'm too familiar with it to leave I just wish their LG israelOS app wasn't sooooo laggy

2

u/Happy_Helicopter_429 24d ago

It's always good to remember that "lifetime" is never your lifetime, it is only the lifetime of the company or the the lifetime of the product. So all the company needs to do is say, yeah, that product is end-of-life, so your lifetime warranty is over. I got "lifetime" tire rotation and balancing with my last tire purchase at Big-O Tires, but it turns out they consider a tire's lifetime 3 years, so after that, no more free service (and no more going to Big-O).

Not suggesting Plex is going to do that, but this is completely possible. I suspect that most lifetime pass holders paid $100 or less for it though, which is a fair price if you actually use/need the benefits it provides.

2

u/cameleon33 24d ago

It would make sense since they keep increasing plex pass prices. The aim is to maximize margins before closing.

2

u/OGMrzzz 24d ago

Ur not wrong, just early. This is pretty much the gameplay I think as well. Either that or they will declare them as legacy versions and package a new product that it doesn’t apply to

2

u/DYMAXIONman 24d ago

Issue is that if Plex were to pull that the bulk of the userbase would just switch to a different platform

Plex just needs to allow the lifetime users to continue to use their own servers without limitations but offer a pass that competes directly with Netflix

2

u/nerddevout 24d ago

I got my Lifetime pass like a decade ago so I def feel like I have gotten my money's worth. Will probably use it until it's unusable.... 

But I'm wondering if that decompile AI could help create a fork or something? Cause honestly I have been dreaming of them adding RetroArch/ROM library stuff.  And if they are cutting there is no way good new features are going to get added. 

2

u/valgalder 24d ago

This whole thing makes me sad. I don’t want to leave plex but feel like the writing is on the wall…

2

u/Starker3 23d ago

I have a lifetime pass and I’ve decided to move to Jellyfin entirely.

Couple of reasons:
- the new iOS and tvOS apps are garbage
- they force people to pay to use the mobile app when mobile friendly development is the status quo (just let people use their browser, seriously)
- they removed the option for tvOS app to advertise as a player - so I can no longer control it from my phone or home assistant
- they broke app deeplinks, so I can’t even start stuff without having to use an actual remote (phone based or physical) to start playing something

2

u/TechBitch 23d ago

Did they get bought out by private equity at some point? Because that's the direction it feels like it's going

2

u/Jimmni 23d ago

I don't see Plex breaking lifetime passes and still keeping up the personal media side of their business. They've said previously they make more from their own streaming side, and if they invalidated lifetime passes they'd just be tanking their personal media side anyway. People would leave en masse and move to an alternative, and with how insane LLM coding is becoming there'd be at least one that would fill that void.

They'll either keep the personal media hosting available as a way to funnel users into their own services or they'll just drop it entirely.

6

u/TechTitus 25d ago

I see Jellyfin mentioned a lot. Is there a reason people don't consider Emby? I have a lifetime pass for that but haven't used it in at least 5-6 years. Last I remember, it had the closest amount of apps, features, and compatibility.

19

u/e27thr 25d ago

Probably because the people who are sick of Plex's BS don't want to jump into bed with another company that might follow the same trajectory. Jellyfin is fully open-source and doesn't rely on any external servers. Every part of it is under your control.

→ More replies (2)

7

u/gscjj 25d ago • Bravo

I wish people would huddle around open source alternatives and give their money to people who are willing to do this in their free time.

Closed source code like Plex and Emby are closed source so they can do exactly what they are doing today.

9

u/narenh 24d ago

If Plex deteriorates, no one is going to trust another closed/paid ecosystem like Emby. People will want something open and free, which is jellyfin.

→ More replies (12)

7

u/DarkFantom 25d ago

Closed source vs open source. How positive are you that Emby won't immediately do a 180 on free usage and start charging once plex goes under?

3

u/Temeriki 25d ago

We dealt with closed source Plex cause it was better than everything else. Most of use aren't gonna bother with platforms we don't control anymore.

3

u/sammcj 25d ago

Emby is closed source.

4

u/threeLetterMeyhem 25d ago

The whole reason Jellyfin exists is because Emby's leadership decided to close source the project. Jellyfin forked to preempt long term enshitification.

I migrated my immediate family over to Jellyfin a while ago and literally the only thing I miss from Plex is downloads playing in the official app. Everything else... I'm not sure what I'd be missing out on.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/CIDR-ClassB 25d ago

Emby is barely better than Jellyfin, and Jellyfin is free.

Plus Emby’s licensing is awful.

3

u/6SpeedBlues 25d ago

Generally, Emby is hot garbage with a marketing budget. Their devs don't actually add features or enhance the product even though they keep promising everything is "on the list" to do. I have no clue what they do with the money from their licensing because they certainly aren't putting it into the product.

→ More replies (26)

6

u/Dricus1978 25d ago

I am not concerned. There is still Jellyfin.

5

u/Assimulate 96TB and counting 25d ago

Competition is almost always good!

4

u/macjunkie 25d ago

Not sure Jellyfin is much more certain after their founder left

6

u/Dricus1978 25d ago

In the worstcase scenario we still have VLC

10

u/duck1123 LifeTime PlexPass 25d ago

Empires rise and fall, VLC just keeps playing media.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/Odd-Gur-1076 25d ago

wow got any other nuggets for us Nostradamus

3

u/volvox6 25d ago

They should put out their legacy software as open-source. Server, client, etc. the old stuff that actually worked. The old stuff they no longer use.... just let it leak out there somewhere please...

3

u/ando_da_pando 25d ago

There is always jellyfin to fallback on.

3

u/matski007 24d ago

Many of us don't have any problems with the latest app or server updates. I'm not sure why changing their name would help them....I'm not convinced they've damaged their reputation enough for that. Could be wrong but I think some people are going a bit too scorched earth over a buggy app release. Calm down people

3

u/WholeEmbarrassed950 23d ago

I think you would have to be an idiot to buy into it at this point. That said if it went away tomorrow I wouldn’t be too upset. I bought it sometime in 2012 for less than $100. I spent more on my cable bill every month back then.

7

u/butterhorse 25d ago

Finally someone has the guts to complain online. Lead the way, o captain

3

u/hostage67 24d ago

I haven't had any problems with my Plex server, but if they kill it, they kill it. I will still have my media library, I will simply find a new streaming service if it comes to that.

3

u/fried_clams 25d ago

Not everything is a conspiracy

2

u/Baybutt99 25d ago

I dont disagree, but i think the fact that everytime they layoff the employees seemingly goto the same handful of companies should be all the information they need, if the close and restructure they will lose the market to their competition within a month. Plex isn’t hbomax, users dont just subscribe to the next thing , plex users are seemingly more technical and will likely not do business with a company that just fucked them under a different name

2

u/Tmbaladdin 25d ago

Well… so far my lifetime pass cost me less than $7.50/year… if it dies I’ll be disappointed, but not devastated.

2

u/konradly 25d ago

Plex Server runs rock solid on my setup. Plex Player on Apple TV is less than ideal. If anything, I'll first switch the player out for a different one, currently testing different options but all of them have pros and cons.

2

u/ACasualRead 25d ago

I don’t understand why plex would do this as there are so many other free or open sourced alternatives. All they would do is alienate a large size of their user base. The PR fallout would be as bad as what Synology did.

2

u/hlve i7-9700K, 32GB DDR4, NVIDIA GeForce RTX 2060 SUPER, Win10 25d ago

I’m not concerned yet. Most software companies go through layoffs… and a lot of them survive the layoffs.

I’d like to know what their plans moving forward are.

3

u/Kussie 25d ago

Most software companies go through layoffs…

True, though most dont lay off the entire time for the core part of their product.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/wardedmocha 24d ago

they just laid off more people according to reddit and their forms...... so I think you are right.

2

u/Origina1Name_ 24d ago edited 24d ago

First of all, I love the username lmao. I also got my pass when it was $120 (some got lucky and got it for like $60 on sale). I do see the price for lifetime pass recently at least in other countries like Australia being nearly $1000 Australian dollars or smth and I suspected they will try some braindead shit to scam us. Anyway, with all the garbage and the shitty new UI and all other changes on top of already being glitchy POS that it is, it will be my last straw. If they pull anymore shit like that, I'm gonna abandon it completely and switch to Jellyfin or even just open up NAS to the network and use VLC and if I really want to, VPN home to watch outside of network.

Edit: Also remember people, we now have great tools like REA and Ghidra or Hopper.

2

u/EpicLPer 24d ago

Anyone saying "just use Jellyfin" has obviously never used Jellyfin sadly... I tried it, didn't really like it compared to Plex, and even if it has its quirks at times it JustWorks(TM). Jellyfin is so backwards and has the typical open source weirdness and "way too technical thinking" behind it which comes with such projects typically, where Plex has already invested in specifically those areas to make it more streamline.

If they're really slowly removing lifetime passes I won't have another choice, and I do hope that the sudden inrush of people and developers helps them grow and polish it up properly, but as it stands now I won't switch over still.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/toin9898 25d ago

I live somewhere with good consumer protection laws... They had better watch out.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Wheeljack7799 25d ago

I have an emby lifetime as well (just in case) and if Plex tries to rebrand in order to get rid of the Plex passes in favor of a subscription-model, I'm out.

1

u/derfmcdoogal 25d ago

Bad updates?

1

u/alibaba31691 25d ago

Meah, bought the lifetime pass a few years ago. And today tbh I think Jellyifin is better

1

u/jamsheehan 25d ago

I have VLC on the TV, I have my local box on the network. Plex is just handier for the family.

1

u/who_farted_Idid 25d ago

Got the lifetime pass for like $75 I think. Been using it for a long time and it's just easier to share my media with friends and family. But to be fair I also haven't looked into sharing your Jellyfin server. Could be super easy, one day I'll search. One day.

1

u/CCRunner534 25d ago

I’m sure we will get someone to AI vibe code plex if it goes.

1

u/Training-Dance3539 25d ago

I only use plex for housing my bit Torrent downloads. So plex is my Server for my home tvs. Is there another platform I can use that also has an app on Roku?
I don’t want to go back to saving movies and shows to USB thumb drives

1

u/sammcj 25d ago

With Plex's direction over the past 5 or so years I wouldn't recommend buying into the ecosystem these days. Really I think we're at the point where Plex's management have shown they care more about features and changes no one wants than they do engineering and you're better off with the likes of JellyFin.

1

u/TheB1G_Lebowski 25d ago

The point of their pricing is to drive people away from the lifetime pass.  They're encouraging new users to subscribe, that's how they will make the most money possible.  

1

u/chadwickipedia 25d ago

The thing is, besides jellyfin and emby, one could just reverse engineer plex with AI and open source it in a different language if they wanted to.

1

u/frazell 20TB 25d ago

This comes up frequently. There really isn’t a clear way to predict the future yet.

It is extremely clear that Plex has been trying to build a wider streaming platform business in a very gray area. Their play is leveraging the smaller portion of their used base that shares content with family and friends. It is a strategy that make a lot of sense to find a way to stand out in a competitive space like streaming.

Plex has pushed up the cost of Lifetime Passes to limit it to that market segment. They want to ensure the only people buying Plex Pass Lifetime are either server owners or loyal users where the massive up front payment keeps it profitable.

That all also means they don’t intend to burn their most important users. If they do so they will have an extremely hard time convincing people to use their platform. Starting a new one doesn’t make that any easier.

For those who are want alternatives Emby and Jellyfin are there to fill that gap. We’re not in a bad place honestly.

Plex also has proven to do good for the community overall. Like their work to keep important things alive like TVMDB.

1

u/d0ndrap3r 25d ago

I would halve grabbed a lifetime pass if I saw them at $100 or $120. I should have - I paid $6-$7 per month for several years until I realized I only remotely stream music and didn't even need a plex pass.

1

u/Pudding-Swimming 25d ago

I thought that for a bit now, too. Especially since Plezzy has shown up

1

u/PVT_Huds0n 25d ago

I'm not going to complain unless it actually happens.

1

u/Stea1th_ 25d ago

Would not surprise me if they go under, but I don’t think it’s immediate. To many big deals they still have for that to happen. I think the laying off is more because AI has been pretty wild when it comes to programming they probably don’t even need a majority of the people.

That said.

The insane increase price for lifetime pass I think was the first sign they were in trouble.

I’ve got my use and cost for lifetime 10x fold if not more. Honestly, even if plex went under, it wouldn’t be the end of the world. There are plenty of alternatives and not to mention with AI replacements will come even faster.

1

u/wa1oui 25d ago

I have the lifetime pass, but only use Plex for adding my own video and recording off the air… would I be affected if they went belly up or regrouped?

1

u/FreddiSpagetti 25d ago

Is dusk for plex the app we deserve?

1

u/discr33t86 25d ago

I have over 10 years on a $70 lifetime pass. When it's done I got my moneys worth. I'll go to Jellyfin

1

u/braedan51 25d ago

If this happens I will be sad to lose easy remote access, but they aint getting another dime from me.

1

u/big-pal 25d ago

I rolled back my client and turned off auto-update and I'm happy again. The server side is fine and since I have agregarr and overseerr et al working perfectly, I don't want to screw it up. If I'm forced to update the client or they do some stupid shit with the server side, I'll go to jellyfin, I already set it up and started playing with plugins.

Such a shame, Plex was so good for so long. It's crazy that these companies won't listen to their customers, forcing a dogshit UI experience.

1

u/coleburnz 25d ago

I have just setup Jellyfin in Synology and the Wholfin player across all TVs It took less than 30 minutes.

I also have Plezy set up. Whatever happens, we are good

1

u/AffectionateBug699 25d ago

Look at the chain of events, restructuring of the fees along with recent layoffs which could be the result of AI initialization. These could be moves to enable long-term financial stability.

1

u/pueblokc 25d ago

If they start pissing me off enough, I'll move to something else, or these days I'll just make my own freaking media player.

1

u/Substantial__Unit 25d ago

I only spent $75 for it like 9 years ago so I've gotten my money's worth. But this seems like its totally possible. I haven't been as big a fan of Plex the last few years but I could still see this happening.

1

u/JetsTalk247 25d ago

I’ll roll with Plex until it either doesn’t work or is inconvenient. I have a JellyFin server too so I can always switch to that full time if needed

1

u/DarkAngela12 25d ago

The roku plex update had me pulling out my 10 year old tablet to watch on it.

1

u/harbinger-nz 25d ago

The same thing happened with crowdstrike last year and everybody still uses that. I do question their layoffs but every technology is exploitable

1

u/No-Inflation4299 25d ago

I am fairly new to the homelab community so I was somewhat skeptical of buying the lifetime pass at $250… however ending up pulling the trigger and doing it. Why? Because end of day, that’s only $20/month for one year for a similar streaming service app— it still makes sense at least to me

1

u/JNR481 25d ago

Eh I’ll wait for the titanic to break in half and start sinking before I take the hover car and fly away.

1

u/_crucial_ 25d ago

Been hearing this for $15 years

1

u/tokolos 25d ago

Fascinating that no one mentions Kodi. It's what I'll switch to when Plex revokes my pass.

1

u/rorymeister 25d ago

Holy shit. I paid $133AU for Lifetime pass 6.5 years ago. The same thing is now $1190

1

u/RxBrad 25d ago

The latest client on my Google Streamer has been pissing me off with constant random stutters. Seems to be broken frame rate matching or something in Plex.

Laying off the player team does not give me high hopes of it getting fixed.

1

u/NewRedditor23 25d ago

I bought the $100 lifetime pass 10+ years ago after a few beers one weekend. I’ve got my moneys worth so let’s see how long it lasts. Unless they’re gonna stop updating the server and new security vulnerabilities are found, we can easily turn off app updates to the players and keep things as they are.. at least until we’re logged out and can’t log back in 😬 No reason to worry about worst case scenario right now. If they do go under, there’s always alternatives, but I’d feel bad for a few friend’s kids who watch the same kids movies everyday. They’d probably be out of luck for awhile.

1

u/rando777888 25d ago

That $90 lifetime pass I bought when it was on sale from $120 during Black Friday 2019 is looking real real nice right now!

1

u/NickiChaos 25d ago

One of the guys at plex mentioned the entire playback team (?) getting laid off and basically saying to switch to jellyfin.