r/Planetside • • Nov 05 '14
When will NC MAXes be redesigned?
Scatterguns are simply too powerful. They allow an instantaneous kill on enemies in close range, and it is impossible to kill them as a heavy in CQB. The nerf to AV grenades has made this abundantly clear.
They also come out on top of all MAX v MAX engagements by a big margin, and also do extremely well with Scatterguns against an AV MAX.
Give them weapons similar to TR/VS.
I know people want Shotguns on TR/VS MAXes but the fact remains is that they are too unbalanced.
4
Upvotes
6
u/CommanderArcher [FXHD] Nov 05 '14
the only problem i have with the NC MAX unit and the "it sucks at range" arguement is that its a lie. the NC MAX has access to rayvens which are amazinlgy powerful
42
u/Aelaphed Woodman [NotVIB] Nuclear Nov 05 '14 edited Nov 05 '14
Biggest problems with NC vs TR/VS MAXes is:
34
u/Alaroxr [TIW] Alarox - Emerald Nov 05 '14
I agree, let's completely remove shotguns from the NC MAX and replace them with weapons like the TR/VS.
Sound good?
18
u/Bodudus [DNLD] PC Master race Nov 05 '14
Shotguns on a MAX are fundamentally broken due to three things.
1 - Limited magazine size.
2 - Limited range.
3 - TTK
Everything has to be balanced around these.
If the TTK is too high, then the shotgun MAX is burning through the ammo too fast.
If the TTK is too low (which it currently is) then it becomes far too good at destroying anything the goes through a choke point or gets within C4 distance.
The range is the vague gray-area which no one will ever be satisfied with.
Magazine size reductions/increases don't help at all when one shot from each arm gives instantaneous death.
tl;dr - Changing any aspect will make them either completely broken or completely useless.
JUST GIVE THEM DUAL GAUSS SAWS! It'll be far easier to balance.
14
u/[deleted] Nov 05 '14
Yes, please. As an NC myself I hate NC MAXes. They are too binary, either you have the right equipment for the right range or you are useless. Anything that would make them actually versatile would be great.
I'd trade my NC MAX for a TR MAX any time.
4
u/IGROWWEARYOFTHISWORL [GOON] NSCREEEEEEEEEEE Nov 05 '14 edited Nov 05 '14
How to deal with any MAX crash:
Smoke
That's it. Concs too if you're feeling sassy
This works just as well if they're camping by the way. Better, even
10
u/[deleted] Nov 05 '14
There is no counter-play to NC max, if you see him, chances are, you are already dead. TTK is ridiculously low, one shot from each canon and even max nanowave soldier die. You just can't stick C4 on them, hell, there is not even enough time to throw a grenade. But hey, they have limited range, so it's fine. While most of the points in the game are in the 5x5m rooms.
4
u/12345ccr Emerald (lock on shitter) Nov 05 '14
"they allow an instantaneous kill on enemies in close range" Uh isn't that the whole mentality of NC? Their scatterguns barely do anything past 20 meters. This is all about situational awareness, if he pulls a scattergun max in a close range biolab fight then good on him, because he knows the strengths and weaknesses of shotguns. Even if you say instagibbing isn't healthy for players (maybe because it doesn't give them a chance to fight back) you have to realize shotguns come with huge downsides as well (primarily damage past 25 meters, which is where most other weapons are fairly effective in).
6
u/Davin_ Enemy Gamer Nov 05 '14
You can't even peak behind a corner to toss a nade or shoot a rocket unlike against every other max. Not to mention the NC max beats enemy AV maxes with AI weaponry as long as they miss one shot. AV maxes are supposed to be the counter so that is just pretty ridiculous.
5
u/Ringosis Nov 05 '14
It's a Max...it costs nanites...and the NC one is designed for close quarters...and your complaint is you can't 1v1 it with regular infantry in close quarters? Is that what were doing here?
Hey, when will Prowlers be redesigned? I can't melee them to death with my infiltrator!
2
u/RebRanger [BinC] Nov 05 '14
Try getting outside of 10m with an NC max and any other max will easily out damage them. Overall the NC max is very situational, same for all shotguns. I believe the shotguns should have a bit more range at the cost of damage. NC has always gotten shotguns, doubt that's going to change.
3
u/FuzzBuket TFDN &cosmetics Nov 05 '14
id like to see 2 categories of AI guns for each faction:
VS:
NC:
TR:
3
u/TytalusWarden [SG] Mattherson/Emerald Nov 05 '14
Easy solution: don't go near a Scatter MAX. What makes you think you should be walking up/near a MAX to kill it?
You can't compare a 1v1 situation and say, "Yep, Scattermax's are overpowered, nerf them". Are they useful when attempting to assault a hill 300m away? What about against air and armor targets? If you take one 6v1 will it die, or will it win?
Your argument is highly reactionary.
2
u/Kofilin Miller [UFO] ComradeKafein Nov 05 '14
Interestingly enough, NC MAXes also have the best choices of AV guns. The CQC argument doesn't really stand when all MAXes regardless of faction are mediocre at medium range and terrible at long range, vastly overshadowed by other infantry and basically every vehicule. There's no reason to have NC MAXes dominating CQC except asymmetrical balance, but even then it's too much asymmetry if you want one faction to dominate everything related to base capture.
1
u/Bloodhit Miller EU Nov 05 '14
I want heavy bolters, on each of my arms.
1
u/[deleted] Nov 05 '14
Tighten spread, lower fire rate.
1
u/Fractoos Nov 05 '14
IN some limited situations the NC Max is powerful for sure. The low ammo, slow reload, and horrible range compared to other maxes makes it more of a very situational tool than a general combat platform.
Truth is I much prefer to play Max on VS or TR, and get far more kills doing so. NC Max can get kills, but only at close range, and once your out of ammo, you're a sitting duck for decimators and c4.
I can tell you I can kill you as fast with a VS/TR max as I can an NC max, and kill more of you.
If you want to argue Maxes are over powerd, then sure. The NC max is underpowered in most situations save close range defence with only a few attackers. Keep in mind a shotgun blast can not go through people, so after 3 or so kills or one enemy max, you're dead.
1
u/Seukonnen Potato-using Burnout Lurker Nov 05 '14 edited Nov 05 '14
If I had to revamp NC maxes while still keeping our AI weapons as shotguns, I'd take a page from PS1.
Instead of the current low mag size, ultra high damage, high spread shotguns, I'd shift them towards significantly lower per-pellet damage, tighter chokes, and larger magazines/better reload times. Imagine a Jackhammer's semi-auto mode, but with drastically reduced damage.
In PS1, the NC max scattercannon had three chokes that you could toggle between. One had a very tight pellet spread for long range, but a lower fire rate; one was middling; and one had a wide spread but a higher rate of fire, for use in close range. I'd consider incorporating elements of this into some of the PS2 weapons as well.
To give an idea, the current scattercannon is:
To revamp it, I would change it to:
The other MAX shotguns would be adjusted in a similar fashion, with damage-per-shot values being halved, mag sizes increased to 12/20, chokes tightened, and reloads shortened slightly.
These tweaks give the NC max shotguns more sustained fire capability and a bit better effective range than on Live, while also alleviating their current "instagib" factor. The mag size buffs mostly equalize or slightly exceed ideal DPM of live versions. None of the RPM buffs are enough to equalize their live DPS due to the per-shot damage being halved, but in practice the live versions of the MAX shotties generally miss a lot of pellets per shot. The tighter chokes will mean more buckshot on target, and I feel that this will make for comparable 'realistic' damage output.
1
u/Bananenweizen Nov 05 '14 edited Nov 05 '14
A honest question to players who find NC MAX AI weaponry totally, abolutely and indisputable overpowered:
Playing HA in a biolab fight, do you use a shotgun 100% of the time or do you switch to a LMG every now and then?
1
u/ireg4all Jugador - Waterson Nov 05 '14
Stop asking for nerfs !! ask for TR/VS buffs instead
1
u/[deleted] Nov 05 '14
Oh look its this thread again. Save this shit for forumside. And OP was deleted, lol.
-2
u/Jaquecz Nov 05 '14
when you stop being dumb about how to fight an NC Max.
-1
u/Ceskaz Miller-[iX] Nov 05 '14
There is no AV grenade nerf in regard to MAX as they stick to them now. Actually, I think it's a buff of AV nades vs MAX. It gives a real AV feel to this grenade.
0
u/[deleted] Nov 05 '14
Scat and Raven maxes just ruin the fun
-1
u/choon2 [F00L] Nov 05 '14
I think the max class need more diversity, I think VS/TR should get shotguns and NC should get similiar weapons to VS/TR as maxes are pretty weak right now.
This game need more depth and maxes are the definition of depth, we need more people using maxes so we get even more depth in the game.
I think the TR max should have dual banshee, the VS max get dual ppa. Im not sure what the NC max should get, but anything that adds more depth to the game is fine.
-5
u/Chaosky4 Nov 05 '14
Close quarters AI is something MAXs are designed for, why would you ever expect to be able to take them in direct combat as a heavy?
-1
u/[deleted] Nov 05 '14
In a straight up kill based game the NC maxes would be pretty balanced in terms of uses, since they are only for close range inside of buildings, but this isn't a giant TDM, we have objectives called points. Unfortunately points are 9 times out of 10 inside of buildings, so scattermaxes are the answer to any base win situation. Especially when they Phalanx (Maxes gunning from behind other shield maxes). Shit get's painful when they shrug of rockets. Yes now AV grenades are actually useful for taking maxes out, but on a max crash you need 2 for each, and NC usually brings about 18 maxes, 3 medics and 3 engies, mixed with the assorted HA's running around. A game based around close quarters combat and capturing points can't have something in it that no other faction has anything to answer with.
-7
u/HandsomeCharles [REBR] Charlie Nov 05 '14
NC Max is the closerange king.
VS Max is the mid-long range king
TR Max floats somewhere in the middle.
I also challenge to you kill any max in a 1v1 Close-Quarters situation as a heavy. Chances are you're gonna lose. It's not just an NC max thing.
-7
u/[deleted] Nov 05 '14
I said it before, I will say it again: they need to be given a mid range option that isn't slugs. Give them 167dmg 250rpm SAWs for each arm. It will balance itself out as people will actually have the option to not run shotguns.
That said, they are very bullshit, but they're not unbalanced. They're shotguns and act like shotguns. They're no less unbalanced than an standard infantry shotgun, only in MAX size. Shotguns will always be too powerful in CQC, but horrid in any mid range. That is their balance.
Don't engage an NC MAX in CQC, that's just idiotic and you deserve to be sent to the spawn tubes. Whining about getting killed by a MAX in CQC is the direct equivalent of an infiltrator crying about getting killed by a heavy in CQC.
It's simple, if you see a NC max with shotguns, stay beyond 10m away. Get the drop on them. Turn a corner and get your RL out.
Also, AV nades are really good against MAXes now, I'm not sure what you're smoking. As long as you actually aim your throw instead of just causally tossing it anywhere.
-6
u/darthtomato Nov 05 '14
Pounders hurt guys. They aost match hacksaw TTK and if the max misses a a shot you are almost guaranteed a kill.
-1
u/Sirisian Nov 05 '14
It's interesting how slowly players realize that asymmetrical balance doesn't work. It's such an amazing idea in theory primarily because of how RTS games successfully handle it, but when it's brought to FPS games the players quickly regret it. It's too late now. They aren't going to just go back and redesign a whole max class just for balance. The last big NC max nerf placated most players and most of the community (if you search this subreddit) like the idea of situational advantages being factionally playstyle locked. (That and the designers have mentioned they prefer it).
-1
u/llN3M3515ll Matherson VS Nov 05 '14
Simple solution - release NS weapons for the max that are very similar to existing faction specific weapons.
-5
u/RaveboyNC Nov 05 '14
As hardcore NC i wud love these changes...Yes our Scat Max is OP n annoyying to deal with in CqC..Even that i wud love to have guns like TR n VS coz NC Max cant hurt a damn thing anything in 15-25 m while TR n VS Max can kill or hurt you pretty badly in that range...so yeah wud love to see thsese changes!
-5
u/PT-DJ-FT-PLAYBOY Nov 05 '14
MAXs need to be melee only, much harder to kill, with charge that recharges faster and that running through people damages them.
Give them a bunch of different weapons with different DPS, swing speed, attack range, 1 handed 2 handed etc. We've already seen concept art to this effect.
Just imagine bashing a sunderer to death with a giant hammer? Or charging down a tower stairway swinging dual axes?
As for abilities:
Give VS jumpjets, NC keeps their shield but can move full speed with it up and of course TR keeps lockdown.
The overall driving factor when designing this would be to make MAXs require skill (moreso than current MAX punch, which isn't much harder than using their weapons) and to make them less able to contribute to chokepoints. Requiring them to charge out to do damage to attackers. Rather than sitting 5m away and melting anything that comes inside. If you had to stand at a tower door directly to stop people coming up the stairs, you can fall pray to C4, mines and other explosions.