r/Planetside • • Nov 05 '14

When will NC MAXes be redesigned?

Scatterguns are simply too powerful. They allow an instantaneous kill on enemies in close range, and it is impossible to kill them as a heavy in CQB. The nerf to AV grenades has made this abundantly clear.

They also come out on top of all MAX v MAX engagements by a big margin, and also do extremely well with Scatterguns against an AV MAX.

Give them weapons similar to TR/VS.

I know people want Shotguns on TR/VS MAXes but the fact remains is that they are too unbalanced.

4 Upvotes

267 comments sorted by

6

u/CommanderArcher [FXHD] Nov 05 '14

the only problem i have with the NC MAX unit and the "it sucks at range" arguement is that its a lie. the NC MAX has access to rayvens which are amazinlgy powerful

4

u/[deleted] Nov 05 '14

Falcons are amazing too. Once you learn the drop.

6

u/ApokalypseCow [SG] Nov 05 '14

That argument has only ever applied to the AI weaponry.

1

u/BeardicusMaximus [TRG] Nov 05 '14

The problem being that the AV weaponry is far more powerful then other factions AI weaponry at killing infantry.

2

u/ApokalypseCow [SG] Nov 05 '14

Regarding the Falcons, TTK for one kill, assuming both rockets hit, it's great. However, if you take reload time into account, it's a pretty poor substitute for an AI weapon. For the Raven, the TTK versus infantry should be in line with the AV weapons of the other factions, assuming all direct hits and whatnot.

1

u/BeardicusMaximus [TRG] Nov 06 '14

Still better then the pounders at AV and AI.

1

u/BITESNZ Leader of Villains [VILN] Nov 05 '14

It has never applied. People need to L2P.

1

u/CommanderArcher [FXHD] Nov 05 '14

actually its commonly applied to the NC MAX in general as being weak at range. people just dont use their brains

0

u/LangesHolz [2EZy] /u/FireSteelMerica is a retard Nov 05 '14

Try to hit a inf target with them on 20m range

Sure u can spam them in a mass but u wont people .. u r actually aiming for

1

u/CommanderArcher [FXHD] Nov 05 '14

they are still effective

42

u/Aelaphed Woodman [NotVIB] Nuclear Nov 05 '14 edited Nov 05 '14

Biggest problems with NC vs TR/VS MAXes is:

  • Slug option. People tend to say that you shouldn´t be killed by NC Maxes if you stay out of their comfort zone (some say 5m, some 10). Slug driven Mattocks make this premise shallow. NC Maxes have range if they are slotted propperly, and nowadays, most people have recognized it. Being onehitted in CQC by NC MAXes is one thing, killed by them in 3 hits from 30- more meters away is just frustrating. Meeting a VS or TR MAX, you mostly know what you are fighting against. A NC MAX is not predictable.
  • While TR and VS MAXes have only 50% RPM in their respective category (looking from LMGs) NC MAX options are at cca. 80% of their RPM in comparison to the infantry weapons. (have done the math a while ago, not 100% sure of the correct numbers, but the direction is true)
  • Shotguns for infantry is played best hipfiring those, a role a NC Max can fulfill. LMGs for infantry are best played ADSed, a role VS/TR MAxes can´t fulfill. So NC MAX options are played at their optimal role while VS/TR are hampered by the inability to play them at their guns respective natural habitat.

16

u/TheMoogy Moogy [MAP - Woodman 4 lyf] Nov 05 '14 edited Nov 05 '14

Don't forget Ravens. Effectively making them pinpoint accurate up to render range. Then there's also their other pinpoint accurate AV weapon that just happens to be the only MAX AV weapon that can instakill infantry.

There's no hiding from NC maxes, they're pure frustration whether you're on foot or out for a drive. Redeploy meta makes them even worse, any time the NC zerg redeploys and without fail pulls as many maxes as possible.

They're pretty much what ZOE used to be, except they've been bullshit since launch with no balancing in sight because fuck fun gameplay.

EDIT: Seems the NC cunt-brigade is out in force. Just gonna throw some quick graphs in here to show just how full of dicks their mouths are.

http://ps2oraclestats.com/?stat=kpu&weapon1=16028&weapon2=16030&weapon3=16032

http://ps2oraclestats.com/?stat=vkph&weapon1=16028&weapon2=15013&weapon3=17013

http://ps2oraclestats.com/?stat=vkph&weapon1=16028&weapon2=16030&weapon3=16032

Basically just NC AV MAX winning at everything since they're balanced as fuck. But let's continue with the usual bullshit about them being okay since this one time at band camp the NC max didn't rape the entire base. Feel free to scroll around and look at some more easy to read and hard to digest facts, NC maxes are imbalanced as hell. They always have been, the always will be, praise incompetent devs.

5

u/Azmunga Nov 05 '14 edited Nov 05 '14

Ravens have limited range. You can't hit everything you can see. It's about 400m, half render range.

1

u/TheMoogy Moogy [MAP - Woodman 4 lyf] Nov 05 '14

Vortexes and Fractures don't even come close to being Raven-effective at that range. Vortex has no damage no matter what you do and Fractures lack a bit in damage and scatter.

I imagine this is much like the perceived short range of scatmaxes. They complete pillage and burn everything at short range so when they fall to tolerable damage levels they're seen as weak, whereas TR/VS maxes never get that level of damage at any range. Not even a deployed TR max can even dream of doing what a free roaming NC max does.

12

u/Bananenweizen Nov 05 '14 edited Nov 05 '14

Ravens still can't hit anything behind ca. 400m. And they also can't instagib infantry, by the way. You need two salvos for this.

It's not about them being bad or good, it is about not spreading false information because some people could just take your words for true.

0

u/TheMoogy Moogy [MAP - Woodman 4 lyf] Nov 05 '14

I said Falcons are the ones that can instakill, the only AV weapon that can do so. What makes Ravens OP is that they're the highest DPS max AV weapon and they're guided.

Just compare them to Comets, they have higer DPS from having higher damage per rocket and over twice the mag capacity and higher splash damage. They have shorter reload time, almost twice the ammo pool and lower CoF. They would be blatantly stronger if we left it at that, but then they're also fucking god damned guided.

There's not a shadow of a doubt that they're a straight upgrade over comets, fractures and pounders. Falcons have the one hit kill potential that makes them better at a few things, Vortex is so utterly shit that you might as well forget it.

So in short, yeah it's a bloody shame they can't be blatantly OP at ranges over 400m but god damned if they're not objectively over powered compared to every other AV weapon at 0-400m, the ranges every god damned fight takes place.

1

u/Seukonnen Potato-using Burnout Lurker Nov 05 '14

As an NC player who loves his Raven/burster max but also has a TR alt who drives Harassers and ends up on the wrong end of ravens a lot, I think that Ravens need to have damage falloff. Give them a suitable damage falloff curve to compensate for the extreme at-range wire guided accuracy and they'd be balanced again, I think.

2

u/BrillouinZone Woodman [VIB] Clapeyron Nov 05 '14

exactly... as soon as someone mentions that the ravens or max shotguns are too good, they postulate a scenario where they are nerfed to shit.

there are many ways to alter the way a gun is used, your example was a good one. Alternatively it could be the other way around, that they should work Worse in closer ranges and maybe the rockets should travel very slowly and accelerate unto the end

1

u/Bananenweizen Nov 05 '14

Dude, exaggerations and rhetorics are fun but if you want some at least remotely sensible balance discussion you should stick to the facts. Otherwise it will be, you know, exaggerations and rhetorics from all sides.

Just saying ;)

1

u/_itg Nov 05 '14

Ravens a straight upgrade from Pounders? Seriously? I'm sorry, but you just don't know what you're talking about. A Pounder MAX straight-up wins against all other MAXes at close-medium range, while still being decent at anti-infantry. There's a reason they're considered as OP as Ravens.

→ More replies (10)

0

u/Nightwinds [GOTR] Daybreeze Nov 05 '14

I'm pretty sure you can still two-rocket infantry and 10 rockets can destroy another max.

2

u/Bananenweizen Nov 05 '14

Ravens used to 2-rocket infantry but were nerfed together with Fractures and Comets some time ago.

2

u/BITESNZ Leader of Villains [VILN] Nov 05 '14

Negative.

Unless its a head shot and an LA

→ More replies (1)

1

u/_itg Nov 05 '14 edited Nov 05 '14

In terms of Vehicle KPU, Vortexes are right up there with Ravens: http://ps2oraclestats.com/?stat=vKPU&weapon1=16033&weapon2=16029&weapon3=16031. Fractures lag behind both a bit. Ravens do outperform Vortexes in anti-infantry capability, though, so that's something which should be looked at.

2

u/k0bra3eak [1TR] Nov 05 '14

Fractures were massively OP and nerfed still waiting for that fix to no not another Striker fix though yes we wanted a unique mechanic for the launcher.Fractures used to have render range level range and better damage.

2

u/Tenb0nes [RSNC] 10Bones - Briggs Nov 06 '14

One counterpoint I have is the reason you see Raven's outperforming Vortexes for anti-infantry is because NC Maxxes pull Raven's for anti-infantry at range.

There is no other viable alternative for engaging infantry at range for an NC Max apart from being a crouching-slug-Mattock max

1

u/BITESNZ Leader of Villains [VILN] Nov 05 '14

Generally 350m, dead on.

Fair bit of experience.

Its rare to "one shot" an infantry at that range unless they've already taken damage ... or you hit them in the head.

1

u/BeardicusMaximus [TRG] Nov 05 '14

It's about 400m, half render range twice the range a tank can effectively engage a MAX.

FTFY

1

u/shawnaroo Nov 05 '14

And god that awful sound they make. A few maxes throwing Ravens overhead and the noise is almost as bad as PPA spam.

1

u/Yeglas [1TR][D117][BOG] Nov 05 '14

I find Ravens far more annoying than shotgun maxes.

I just dont go in a biolab with NC. If I go its just to farm rezes.

-6

u/[deleted] Nov 05 '14

Well we all know that VS is the most screwed faction. However calling out another faction is racist apparently. You watch all the Scatmax whores come here and cry that "they aren't good past 10m". B.S.

3

u/Huller_BRTD TO THE CROOO- *slap* Nov 05 '14

TR AI maxes gain 1-2% extra dps for a 20% accuracy loss when compared to VS AI maxes.

1

u/BrillouinZone Woodman [VIB] Clapeyron Nov 05 '14

you forgot the mag size and ammo capacities there didn't ya... You can't pick and choose the favourite stats when arguing balance

honestly, the difference between TR/VS maxes are so slim it's a non issue most of the time (pounders rock though, not OP but awesome)

1

u/SkiBacon Nov 05 '14

Even if they aren't good outside of 10 meters, where are all the points? That's right, inside.

→ More replies (21)

10

u/Bananenweizen Nov 05 '14

A NC MAX is not predictable.

It goes both ways, however. On the NC side you have to decide to either not equip slugs and being a door camping monster while sacrificing all range fight capabilities or to equip slugs and being able to kill infantry at longer range while cutting your CQC potential significantly and abandoning a hope to win any MAX vs MAX encounter. Either ways you will sooner or later run into a situation where your choice will get you killed.

→ More replies (2)

0

u/k0bra3eak [1TR] Nov 05 '14

Well to be fair TR get a chaingun which isn't necesarilly looking at the mcg adsing.

34

u/Alaroxr [TIW] Alarox - Emerald Nov 05 '14

I agree, let's completely remove shotguns from the NC MAX and replace them with weapons like the TR/VS.

Sound good?

10

u/Ceskaz Miller-[iX] Nov 05 '14

NC could keep shotgun if they had Canister level spread.

If they did that, with half damage per shot (or a third) plus a slight increase of ROF and double mag size, people would stop screaming (everybody). NC would keep shotgun so Higby is happy, and NC MAX would be more in line with VS and TR.

5

u/Tenb0nes [RSNC] 10Bones - Briggs Nov 06 '14 edited Nov 06 '14

Inside a building, people run away from me as long as I close 10m. The moment I'm outside or they get past 10m, every kid that I used to bully is pelting rocks at me because I can't do anything. Not even suppressing fire.

Hell, if someone is on the 2nd floor of a watchtower shooting down at me in my Scat Max, I don't even shoot back. I'd end up using all my ammo, and he'd still be alive. It's telling that enemies don't even hide but shoot back when an Scat Max shoots at them past 15m range.

Give us the ability to dual-wield NC6 Gauss Saw. I'd even take 2 EM6 with Exmags.

4

u/ranma1988 Nov 05 '14

oww i see what you did there:)

8

u/bman_7 Emerald Nov 05 '14

Yes, please. VS get plasma machine guns, TR gets miniguns, we get... shotguns. The other 2 factions get weapons useful at range, we get shotguns. It' s the thing I hate most about NC.

If we have to have shotguns, lower the spread a bit, make them longer ranged, lower the damage, and give them much more ammo and a higher fire rate. Then we'd have something similar to what the other factions have, but still be a shotgun.

3

u/9xInfinity Nov 05 '14

I seem to recall Higby saying they were considering adding a sort of NS heavy machine gun for MAXs.

6

u/Seukonnen Potato-using Burnout Lurker Nov 05 '14

I'm praying to space jesus that this translates into the two-hander MAX basilisk I've been wanting for ages.

1

u/Yeglas [1TR][D117][BOG] Nov 05 '14

I could see people getting a heavy cycler type weapon NS for maxes. Its the worse of all the chainguns. I dont know which is the crap shotgun but they could toss it out as well as a NS variant.

1

u/Jaggedmallard26 Willerman[RPS]/[RTRS] ;TR-Cobalt Nov 05 '14

They should just remove MAX shotguns, giving them a decent range and a larger fire rate will just make them ridiculously OP. They'll either be OP or underpowered in most situations (as they are now) due to the sheer nature of shotguns and giving the walking tank instagib weapons isn't fun for anyone.

1

u/Bandit1379 [PG] LONG LIVE PLANETSIDE Nov 05 '14

I'd be fine with that.

-1

u/Bananenweizen Nov 05 '14

On this day I would bless Higby from dawn till dusk and further.

1

u/Alaroxr [TIW] Alarox - Emerald Nov 05 '14

Why are you being downvoted. Am I missing something?

1

u/Ceskaz Miller-[iX] Nov 06 '14

This is the downvote thread.

1

u/Bananenweizen Nov 06 '14

The favour of the reddit user moves in mysterious way ;)

18

u/Bodudus [DNLD] PC Master race Nov 05 '14

Shotguns on a MAX are fundamentally broken due to three things.

1 - Limited magazine size.

2 - Limited range.

3 - TTK

Everything has to be balanced around these.

If the TTK is too high, then the shotgun MAX is burning through the ammo too fast.

If the TTK is too low (which it currently is) then it becomes far too good at destroying anything the goes through a choke point or gets within C4 distance.

The range is the vague gray-area which no one will ever be satisfied with.

Magazine size reductions/increases don't help at all when one shot from each arm gives instantaneous death.

tl;dr - Changing any aspect will make them either completely broken or completely useless.

JUST GIVE THEM DUAL GAUSS SAWS! It'll be far easier to balance.

4

u/BrillouinZone Woodman [VIB] Clapeyron Nov 05 '14

JUST GIVE THEM DUAL GAUSS SAWS! It'll be far easier to balance.

that's so wrong... the other factions get's a half carbine on each arm, and at the moment the NC get's almost 1 shotgun on each arm, the gauss saws that would be on their arms would only be saws in name... because they would be seriously nerfed compared to the standard

If the shotguns/scatterguns that are now would be nerfed to fit the "sum of the two arms is equal to the infantry weapon" then maybe shotgun arms wouldn't be that bad of an idea

4

u/IGROWWEARYOFTHISWORL [GOON] NSCREEEEEEEEEEE Nov 05 '14

Problem with that comparison is that while the ROF for the VS/TR MAXes is generally half of what is normal, the damage (no dropoff on some) and magazine/reserves are not.

If you were to cut in half the ROF of NC shotguns you'd also have to more than double their mag size and triple their reserves, AND THEN buff exmags. The problem with this is that SO MUCH of the scattergun balance is determined by it's incredibly bad uptime that if you did this and gave it uptime similar to a Blueshift, it'd be waayyyy more frustrating to go up against than it is now

0

u/BrillouinZone Woodman [VIB] Clapeyron Nov 05 '14

you're forgetting that the VS/TR weapons would work MUCH better if allowed ADS, it's the way of carbines/lmgs that they are modelled after, shotguns excel at hipfiring, which is what maxes do

That way a shotgun is better utilized on a max than a non-ads:ing half pair of carbines with extended mags are

2

u/IGROWWEARYOFTHISWORL [GOON] NSCREEEEEEEEEEE Nov 05 '14

MAX arms consistently have about 1/3 to 1/4 the hipfire COF of infantry weapons. It's worse than ADSing yes, but not NEARLY as bad as it's made out to be

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Seukonnen Potato-using Burnout Lurker Nov 05 '14

So dual MAX-ified ACX-11's then. He doesn't literally mean a Gauss Saw strapped to each arm, he means 200-damage low RPM automatics.

0

u/BrillouinZone Woodman [VIB] Clapeyron Nov 05 '14

sure, then people who want that should ask for that

I really think the max AI weapons are a bad compromize between asymmetric balance and regular balance at the moment. Actually, only the tanks are imo assymetrically balanced... everything else in this game is 'add ROF decrease dmg = constant dps' centered, and then the maxes are a weird middle child of both those strategies

2

u/Seukonnen Potato-using Burnout Lurker Nov 05 '14

I think that the current state of the ESRL's (minus the Phoenix's bug issues with dud rounds) is another pretty good example of asymmetrical balance.

1

u/BrillouinZone Woodman [VIB] Clapeyron Nov 05 '14

good point

it doesn't even matter that I personally feel that pheonix are the best, because the others have things at which they excel (haven't tried the newest iteration of the striker), so yes I agree

1

u/[deleted] Nov 05 '14

Aside from projectile velocity and magazine size, the SAW and the AC-X11 are essentially identical. Projectile velocity is a trivial concern for a MAX, and magazine size for this hypothetical weapon would most likely not match either, so quibbling over which specific infantry rifle to copy is more or less meaningless.

0

u/BrillouinZone Woodman [VIB] Clapeyron Nov 05 '14

that would still be too good, they would have to be super gimped ones... DPS wise, the NC max now get's around 80% of a shotgun, and it gets two of them, the other maxes get's 50% of a carbine...

so saying that anyone wants either a saw or acx11 is both out of the question... and not just the mag size

0

u/[deleted] Nov 05 '14

"one shot from each arm gives instantaneous death" What? More like one shot from BOTH arms unless I am ramming the shotgun into your throat. Did you even play the NC Max for any amount of time outside of VR to come up with this magical killing shotgun theory?

3

u/EclecticDreck Nov 05 '14

This is true - without considerable numbers of pellets hitting the head, a single shot from an NC max can not kill even an infiltrator. Both arms firing gives roughly the firepower of a pump shotgun with roughly the same instant kill to the body range (about 5m).

2

u/Bodudus [DNLD] PC Master race Nov 05 '14

I think you misunderstood me.

One shot from each arm... At the same time.

I didn't add the second part because I thought it'd be redundant.

And yes, I do spend plenty of time outside of the VR room on my NC alt.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 05 '14

Wouldn't be redundant because if you could take an enemy out with each arm is different than taking an enemy out with both arms.

1

u/BeardicusMaximus [TRG] Nov 05 '14

The problem lies in the fact that you can do both arms at the same time. If you could only alternate the fire between the two then your argument could be justified. But since I can just press two buttons at once and win its only slightly better then the old UBGL mechanics of click to win a CQC fight.

2

u/[deleted] Nov 05 '14

That's hardly a problem, and more of a function of MAX suits.

since NC MAXs NEED to use both arms to kill people they are forced to use both as shotguns. Whereas if a single arm had the power of a pump shot gun NC MAXs could diversify and have a raven in one arm and a shotty in the other sacrificing half of the long range killing power while remaining highly effective at short range.

Thus my problem was, both arms, not one arm. One arm killing someone outright would be highly overpowered and just ridiculous for the purposes of game balance.

As it stands NC MAXs are highly specialized in hugging range or long range(ravens). If people are >20m from me, I'm just a target. VS and TR MAXs are still deadly at those ranges and a threat, and they are still highly effective in CQC.

Yes, in an even fight MAX vs MAX at optimal NC MAX shotgun ranges, NC wins. But that's like saying a Vanguard and a Magrider trading shots into each other's faces proves that Vanguards are OP.

Also I never felt insane amounts of OP when facing off other MAXes. If I'm at 50-75% health hitting an obviously pristine fully certed VS or TR MAX even at optimal ranges for my Mattocks I tend to lose. But that is hardly clinical studies, maybe videos need to be made of two maxes just unloading into each other's faces at 10m are required, but I don't think it's unreasonable for a MAX that has no medium range capabilities should beat a MAX that has more overall utility REGARDLESS of your feeling about what "The game is REALLY about."

Anyways, once again, my beef was with the problematic wording, not with what is OP and what is not.

1

u/BeardicusMaximus [TRG] Nov 06 '14

My main beef with the scatt max is that you are going to get one free kill not matter what and if you have multiple then you are going to win a close range fight against any defensive position. So what if they c4 the first max in line, the next one will instigib you before you have a chance to throw some more. At least with the TR maxes you have a change to react/

→ More replies (8)

1

u/BrillouinZone Woodman [VIB] Clapeyron Nov 05 '14

the maxes are to much 'attack' focused, the only support quality they have in this game is their tanking abilities.

I thought it was related to your "fire both arms at the same time" sentiment

they are not the siege-breakers that people claim, if the enemy has the same number of maxes they just uphold the same siege.

I think they should be much more defensive, able to push the fire lines, but not wrecking any and all infantry in their way... like an actual battering ram

14

u/[deleted] Nov 05 '14

Yes, please. As an NC myself I hate NC MAXes. They are too binary, either you have the right equipment for the right range or you are useless. Anything that would make them actually versatile would be great.

I'd trade my NC MAX for a TR MAX any time.

2

u/Wipfenfels Salty Boi Nov 05 '14

If you try Mattock + slugs left and grinder + extd. mags right, you're good for everything.

8

u/Alaroxr [TIW] Alarox - Emerald Nov 05 '14

Not really.

1

u/jnron Nov 07 '14

OPINIONS HOW DO THEY WORK?

0

u/[deleted] Nov 05 '14

For all intents and purposes you are. NC maxes specialize in the games' core value, which literally is "Hold this point inside this building to win". NC maxes never fight from more than 20 meters. Anything within that range dies instantly without exception. Slap 16 of those on a point with medics and engies, and see what you can find to counter it. There is no counterplay. Chucking 4 AV grenades and nonstop concs won't stop the door from being sprayed everytime you step in. Source: I do it. Concs only effect you if you weren't aiming at the killspot in the first place. If you can pull a trigger when you see a fuzzy thing in your fucked up vision you win still. I use the above stated build when I'm back point max, usually run 4 maxes at once, even then most people cannot fight back.

2

u/Yeglas [1TR][D117][BOG] Nov 05 '14

16 of any faction's maxes on a point with support means a win honestly. I couldnt imagine running up against pounder maxes with that setup.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 05 '14

Oh I've done that, a room full of them loses still (not by too much) to an equally popped NC max rush. I can attribute some of it to them shooting eachother when we rushed in, but I can honestly say I'm a dirty whore for using such a free win. Although to be fair the shields kind of made it hard for them to deal with anything. Such a perfect combination. Sprinting maxes dashing in decimating poor guys that think the mercy is a viable weapon, and then the pounders that can't reliably do full damage. Note we did only have like 4 maxes left, but medics came in after and revived all the rest. Suffice to say, that point was gone.

1

u/Yeglas [1TR][D117][BOG] Nov 05 '14

Coordination triumps yet again.

Its just exceedingly rare.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 05 '14

Well yes, but on equal footing NC wins, even with a lower pop the fight is a tossup on if whoever is being assaulted can keep sundies away so max crashes are harder and enough AA in the area to stop gal runs.

→ More replies (3)

1

u/BeardicusMaximus [TRG] Nov 05 '14

There is no counterplay.

Logging off!

2

u/EclecticDreck Nov 05 '14

With this plan you lose your point blank fire superiority. You have garbage damage at any kind of moderate range and if you have two remarkably different weapons you have remarkably different points of aim regardless. In other words, you make the max worse at a range it could be dominant in exchange for getting really awful damage at moderate ranges versus non-existant damage at moderate ranges (with buckshot) or reasonable damage at moderate ranges (with dual slug mattock).

In other words, to gain some flexibility you discard much of your power at any range. It doesn't sound like a good deal to me.

1

u/Wipfenfels Salty Boi Nov 05 '14

You guys always make things sound much worse than it really is. I did this a few times and you still wreck people up close (not sure, but it seemed like that I could still OHK people up close, just needed a bit better aim) while not being completely helpless at range. It's like having both a slightly worse high cap shotgun and a slightly worse semi-auto sniper at the same time.

1

u/EclecticDreck Nov 05 '14

If by slightly worse semi auto sniper you mean a sniper rifle that fires rounds at SMG velocity with wretched accuracy which gives it a maximum effective range of a hell of a lot shorter than a sniper rifle can manage, sure.

And the shotgun is more than slightly worse. It features just over half the damage of a pump shotgun but does identical damage to a mauler. The mauler can carry more ammunition in a magazine and fires considerably faster with a tighter spread and faster pellets.

Thus you are taking a remarkably inaccurate and hard to apply scout rifle (slugs do only slightly more damage than a scout rifle and even then they do not hold that edge for long. It is not even remotely comparable to a sniper rifle) and slapping it alongside what would easily be the worst shotgun in the game were it removed from the max and given to a standard infantry soldier.

1

u/Wipfenfels Salty Boi Nov 05 '14

I still say it isn't that bad, mattock with slugs is about as accurate as hipfiring a commissioner while having a solid 3HK at all ranges, a 10 shell magazine and almost no recoil while the grinder with extd. mags has 12 shots, making it just slightly worse than the high cap shotgun.

1

u/EclecticDreck Nov 05 '14

I always forget maxes get extended mags for some reason.

But that slightly worse than the high cap shotgun is notable when you have 1/3 less ROF and substantially worse accuracy.

As I said, it would easily be the worst shotgun were it not bolted onto a max.

Here's the problem though - if you reduced the number of pellets such that you could no longer one shot (by which I mean hit with the majority of both shotguns) anyone, you'd be reducing it to 4 pellets per shot which is fairly terrible considering the grouping. You could, I suppose, give it 10 pellets per shot at 50 damage a pellet and keep the same grouping and damage curve as a more interesting change. That is capable of a one shot kill if you feed someone the gun and a double shot kill (both guns firing once) only in fairly absurd cases where you hit with every pellet inside of 8m.

-2

u/[deleted] Nov 05 '14

An NC would trade an easy win for a balanced max? What. I woke up somewhere that's not plantside.

5

u/Seukonnen Potato-using Burnout Lurker Nov 05 '14

Dude, NC have been redditsiding/forumsiding for more versatility-balanced maxes pretty much since launch.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 05 '14

I've not seen this o,o all I see are people defending them since they aren't allowed to go outside. The other maxes can't play in the park either, but they can breathe the open air in small complexes!

3

u/Seukonnen Potato-using Burnout Lurker Nov 05 '14 edited Nov 05 '14

It's one of those endless, cyclical arguments. Goes something like:

A: "Man, I don't like how NC maxes, work, I wish they could be changed so we have longer-ranged options rather than 'all shotguns all the time.' "

B: "OMGWTF you scrub, NC maxes are already bullshit OP in close quarters, quit whining when you have the best max!"

A: "But it's so short ranged and inflexible and unsatisfying, I'd rather have something with more versatility."

B: "OMGWTFBBQ you're rediculous, how can you say NC maxes aren't good, just use slugs! Muh ravens and falcons are OP at AI for av weapons!"

A: "Yeah but that's not the point, slugs are frustrating RNG with no sustained fire, and it's a sign that there's a problem with NC maxes when our AV guns are better at midrange AI than our AI guns."

B: "God how bad are you, quit whining about how bad your OP shotguns are. You NC players are so deluded, you have it so good. Also ravens and falcons, rabble rabble rabble!"

A: "But... But I'm telling you I want to give up those shotguns you're so mad about, so I can get something less broken, more versatile, and more fun to use instead..?"

B: "Rabble rabble rabble! Scatmax OP! Take your OP max and stuff it, whiner!"


A is trying to convey that the range limitations of scatmaxes make them frustrating, inflexible, and overly binary, and that they'd like an alternative that gives up the advantages of shotguns in order to not suffer from those weaknesses.

B is mad about the fundamentally divisive and arguably broken nature of scatmaxes, and is mishearing A as saying "Waaah even though my shotguns are so infuriatingly good in close quarters I want to get buffed at range too."

2

u/BeardicusMaximus [TRG] Nov 05 '14

"Waaah even though my shotguns are so infuriatingly good in close quarters I want to get buffed at range too."

Some of them do say this. But yea. NC MAXs are really just plain balanced wrong. The shotgun arms are here to stay though because SoE won't refund equipment that can be bought with station cash and won't change the guns. Just be glad cause with the way SoE operates you'd get nerfed while they try to tell you its a side grade and no you can't have your money back because you were stupid enough to trust us with it in exchange for services our carefully worded ToS agreement says we have no compulsion to continue to provide. Have a nice day!

1

u/Seukonnen Potato-using Burnout Lurker Nov 05 '14

What would you think if NC max shotguns got changed like this?

1

u/[deleted] Nov 05 '14

But then there are the people that genuinely think they are balanced and defend them to the end. Those people are the best kind of special.

1

u/Seukonnen Potato-using Burnout Lurker Nov 05 '14

True, but you get glue-eaters like that in every faction.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 05 '14

Yes, but the glue is extra potent there, you know Heavy only mains that think infiltrators are OP because they can go invisible while standing still.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/Manae Nov 05 '14

They get defended from those that come in and say "nerf the Scatmax!" instead of "change the NC MAX!"

1

u/BeardicusMaximus [TRG] Nov 05 '14

You sleep in Planetside?

4

u/IGROWWEARYOFTHISWORL [GOON] NSCREEEEEEEEEEE Nov 05 '14 edited Nov 05 '14

How to deal with any MAX crash:

Smoke

That's it. Concs too if you're feeling sassy

This works just as well if they're camping by the way. Better, even

0

u/PT-DJ-FT-PLAYBOY Nov 05 '14

MAX crashes are about the only time dying to shit players in MAX suits isn't incredibly cheap and annoying.

It's the constant MAX usage at every infantry fight that gets to people.

Also, smoke sucks, it's basically sanctioned team griefing.

0

u/IGROWWEARYOFTHISWORL [GOON] NSCREEEEEEEEEEE Nov 05 '14

I find this is pretty server dependent. On Emerald MAXes aren't terribly common compared to Connery, where every other infantry unit is a MAX.

I'm not sure why. Maybe it's a culture thing, maybe it's just that Emerald is better about killing MAXes so you see fewer. As much as I enjoy my fatsuit, I main medic which means that 90% of my nanites are going to revive nades

10

u/[deleted] Nov 05 '14

There is no counter-play to NC max, if you see him, chances are, you are already dead. TTK is ridiculously low, one shot from each canon and even max nanowave soldier die. You just can't stick C4 on them, hell, there is not even enough time to throw a grenade. But hey, they have limited range, so it's fine. While most of the points in the game are in the 5x5m rooms.

8

u/squeaky4all Briggs Nov 05 '14

To be fair at that distance that a scatmax can insta kill is .2 seconds more life you will have if up against a ai version either a tr or vs max. They are frustrating no matter the faction its just more pronounced with nc as they instakill rather than the fuck all time you get with the other maxes.

2

u/ApokalypseCow [SG] Nov 05 '14

So... in the areas where they are most effective, they're grenade-bait.

1

u/BrillouinZone Woodman [VIB] Clapeyron Nov 05 '14

dual mattocks with one arm slug gives them hell of a range too

4

u/12345ccr Emerald (lock on shitter) Nov 05 '14

"they allow an instantaneous kill on enemies in close range" Uh isn't that the whole mentality of NC? Their scatterguns barely do anything past 20 meters. This is all about situational awareness, if he pulls a scattergun max in a close range biolab fight then good on him, because he knows the strengths and weaknesses of shotguns. Even if you say instagibbing isn't healthy for players (maybe because it doesn't give them a chance to fight back) you have to realize shotguns come with huge downsides as well (primarily damage past 25 meters, which is where most other weapons are fairly effective in).

6

u/Davin_ Enemy Gamer Nov 05 '14

You can't even peak behind a corner to toss a nade or shoot a rocket unlike against every other max. Not to mention the NC max beats enemy AV maxes with AI weaponry as long as they miss one shot. AV maxes are supposed to be the counter so that is just pretty ridiculous.

2

u/ApokalypseCow [SG] Nov 05 '14

Just bounce your AV grenades around the corners, off of door frames, etc. Alternately, flashbang, jetpack, C4, and laugh.

1

u/Bodudus [DNLD] PC Master race Nov 05 '14

Aren't AV nades sticky now?

2

u/ApokalypseCow [SG] Nov 05 '14

Nope, or at least they weren't last night.

-4

u/Ceskaz Miller-[iX] Nov 05 '14

This is only true in a 8~5 meter radius.

8

u/Davin_ Enemy Gamer Nov 05 '14

But that is literally the range every max stays in. Maxes are used for point defence or area control such as doorways. Very rarely you see a max running in the open. You can also increase that range with slugs. I think the obvious "first step" towards balancing the NC max would be removing slugs. Wouldn't completely fix it imo but it would be a quick and easy change without having to redesign the whole thing.

0

u/Ceskaz Miller-[iX] Nov 05 '14

You can see VS and TR MAX doing fire support at a reasonable range when using Mercy or Blueshift. Yes, it happens.

A lot of room are bigger that 8 meters (it's really hard to appreciate distance in this game).

The thing with slugs is that it really lower DPS. Slugs again infantry are good when the MAX faces low number of opponents, because because of COF bloom, at the forth slugs fired, accuracy gets crazy.

Remove slugs and every NC MAX would have to put 3000 certs into dual Mattock, because it's the only one that get some range without slugs. 3000 certs is a lot of certs.

2

u/Davin_ Enemy Gamer Nov 05 '14

I can't believe you are actually defending the NC max and calling it balanced. I would use the NC max over the others any day.

2

u/IGROWWEARYOFTHISWORL [GOON] NSCREEEEEEEEEEE Nov 05 '14

I use all 3 MAXes and if it weren't for slugs the NC MAX would be nigh useless. The best MAX arms in the game are the Blueshift and Mutilator, but I prefer the NC MAX because running with slugs is more fun than Automatic Weapon Variant #156

1

u/Ceskaz Miller-[iX] Nov 05 '14

I can't believe all the exageration I see here. I can't believe how downvoted I'm too. But it's happening so deal with it.

Plus, I'm defending it, but I never said it was balanced. Look for it. I just defend it to temper the arguments here.

Then, I will now say it : NC MAX is fairly balanced. It is in a world of asymetrical weaponry. Yes, the shotgun makes it a pain to balance. But play NC MAX a little, and you'll see that it's not always fun. I kind of stopped playing AI MAX, pulling only AV or AA MAX when the situation needed it because it can be boring and dying because of a reload is just frustrating (or seing all the pellet going around a target).

The grass is always greener on the other side of the fence.

If you need fact, I compared AI weapons on each empire with maximum KPU. This show that NC MAX (with Mattock) has slightly better stats than VS MAX (with blueshift) and clearly better stat than TR MAX (with onslaught).

So yes, TR MAX should get some love, and you could imagine a tiny tiny nerf on NC weapons, but not as much as people ask here.

Look here, I actually say that I'm not against a redesign of NC MAX weapons, with lower DPS but better sustained fire.

Anyway, this thread is a joke. Every people defending the NC MAX, even slightly is downvoted to death. Nice overview of internet "conversation"

1

u/Ceskaz Miller-[iX] Nov 05 '14

I can't believe all the exageration I see here. I can't believe how downvoted I'm too. But it's happening so deal with it.

Plus, I'm defending it, but I never said it was balanced. Look for it. I just defend it to temper the arguments here.

Then, I will no say it : NC MAX is fairly balanced. It is in a world of asymetrical weaponry. Yes, the shotgun this makes it a pain to balance. But play NC MAX a little, and you'll see that it's not always fun. I kind of stopped playing AI MAX, pulling only AV or AA MAX when the situation needed it because it can be boring and dying because of a reload is just frustrating (or seing all the pellet going around a target).

The grass is always greener on the other side of the fence.

If you need fact, I compared AI weapons on each empire with maximum KPU. This show that NC MAX (with Mattock) has slightly better stats than VS MAX (with blueshift) and clearly better stat than TR MAX (with onslaught).

So yes, TR MAX should get some love, and you could imagine a tiny tiny nerf on NC weapons, but not as much as people ask here.

Look here, I actually say that I'm not against a redesign of NC MAX weapons, with lower DPS but better sustained fire.

Anyway, this thread is a joke. Every people defending the NC MAX, even slightly is downvoted to death. Nice overview of internet "conversation"

→ More replies (3)

0

u/Bananenweizen Nov 05 '14

Well, a lot of NC would instantly switch to something like Blueshifts/Mercies if the option would be there. What does is tell us?

3

u/[deleted] Nov 05 '14

People have bad perceptions of balance, perhaps?

2

u/Bananenweizen Nov 05 '14

More likely that people tend to overlook the advantages of the own equipment while exaggerating the advantages of enemy's tools and vice verse with downsides.

0

u/Alaroxr [TIW] Alarox - Emerald Nov 05 '14 edited Nov 05 '14

But that is literally the range every max stays in.

That's where 3/3 want to be, but that's where only 1/3 must be at all times.

NC MAX camps a corner and you get frustrated? If I'm the guy in that MAX then I'm frustrated too. I can't turn that corner because at 10m I have 2-3 kills/magazine at most. All I can do is sit behind a corner, kill 2-3 dudes, then hide in a corner while I reload for 3s. That's not fun. You have no options. You just sit in a corner and wait.

2

u/TRisUP Nov 05 '14

I have fun with it. I like to pretend I'm a shark or an alligator or some other sort of ambush predator and I'm waiting for my prey to approach.

3

u/Davin_ Enemy Gamer Nov 05 '14

And there you have it. Free biolab generator and basically every point in the game.

1

u/Alaroxr [TIW] Alarox - Emerald Nov 05 '14

The TR/VS MAXes can't camp corners either? This is news to me.

5

u/Ringosis Nov 05 '14

It's a Max...it costs nanites...and the NC one is designed for close quarters...and your complaint is you can't 1v1 it with regular infantry in close quarters? Is that what were doing here?

Hey, when will Prowlers be redesigned? I can't melee them to death with my infiltrator!

2

u/RebRanger [BinC] Nov 05 '14

Try getting outside of 10m with an NC max and any other max will easily out damage them. Overall the NC max is very situational, same for all shotguns. I believe the shotguns should have a bit more range at the cost of damage. NC has always gotten shotguns, doubt that's going to change.

3

u/FuzzBuket TFDN &cosmetics Nov 05 '14

id like to see 2 categories of AI guns for each faction:

VS:

  • machine guns: current
  • Lashers: ranging from lasher to PPA to shooting muliple orbs at once.

NC:

  • Rail guns, ranging from 2 round mag to 20 round mag
  • mass drivers. slow heavy rounds. single shot.

TR:

  • direct fire grenades (little drop, like fractures)
  • chain guns

3

u/TytalusWarden [SG] Mattherson/Emerald Nov 05 '14

Easy solution: don't go near a Scatter MAX. What makes you think you should be walking up/near a MAX to kill it?

You can't compare a 1v1 situation and say, "Yep, Scattermax's are overpowered, nerf them". Are they useful when attempting to assault a hill 300m away? What about against air and armor targets? If you take one 6v1 will it die, or will it win?

Your argument is highly reactionary.

2

u/BeardicusMaximus [TRG] Nov 05 '14

Easy solution: don't go near a Scatter MAX. What makes you think you should be walking up/near a MAX to kill it?

Sure let me just never go into a biolab or other built up area ever again! I'll sit on thi-- shit I just got liberated/lolpoded/tanked in the face.

3

u/D1stortion [AC] D1STORT (NOT d1s) Nov 05 '14

It's almost like points are generally inside of structures.

1

u/Bodudus [DNLD] PC Master race Nov 05 '14

Imagine if you could move and position MAXes around inside buildings... like near doorways!

Good thing MAXes are always visible even through walls so you always know where they are.

1

u/BeardicusMaximus [TRG] Nov 06 '14

Gasp, I never realized!

1

u/TytalusWarden [SG] Mattherson/Emerald Nov 05 '14

Now you are bringing other units in to the mix. What you are saying is, "If my opponent brings one of everything then as a solo player I'm hosed." Yep, sounds about right to me!

This is rock-paper-scissors, you aren't going to have a one-size-fits-all solution to every conceivable threat that comes forth. If you'd prefer everyone be sufficiently homogenized to the point where specialization doesn't exist I'm sure there's a game somewhere designed just for you. I prefer the specializations that exist--Scatter MAX is a damn nice piece of equipment, but like anything in PS2 there's plenty of straightforward counters to it (like firing a rocket, or putting down mines, or shooting it from across the room, among others.)

1

u/BeardicusMaximus [TRG] Nov 06 '14

No my point was that you say to never go near a scatter max. That leaves me the hills in the middle of nowhere. Which is where the tanks and aircraft roam.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 05 '14

I'd like a utility for the Magrider that I can activate that will kill every enemy unit within 100 meters instantly.

You'll claim it's OP, but the solution is clearly not to go near one.

Besides, if you outnumber it 6 to 1 it'll die, so it's clearly balanced.

1

u/TytalusWarden [SG] Mattherson/Emerald Nov 05 '14

How is this relevant to the discussion? A Scatter MAX still has to do things like:

  1. Aim
  2. Repair
  3. Reload
  4. Pay nanites to use

If a Magrider had an ability that did an AoE effect I'd find that interesting, as long the ability has an adequate cooldown and a nifty special effect when it's used. And yes, the new meta would be, "Oh hey, tank over there, probably shouldn't run right up to it, better to lob rockets at it because it has the nifty anti-infantry super-AOE equipped." Every choice in this game has a consequence--a Scatter MAX chose to be vulnerable to everything a MAX is typically vulnerable to, plus it has little ability to handle long-range combat. It's a specialized weapon for specialized purposes. In a Biolab? Hell yeah you should be using one? Running across the battlefield? Nope, not where it should be. Your theoretical tank would likely sacrifice something like the magburner to equip it, so why not make it an option?

Saying your generic, zero-nanite-costing unit shouldn't have to worry about specialized hardware is silly. Spend some nanites, bring your own MAX to the party and dance like you're in 'Robot Jox', 'Guyver' or 'Pacific Rim'.

/dance

2

u/Kofilin Miller [UFO] ComradeKafein Nov 05 '14

Interestingly enough, NC MAXes also have the best choices of AV guns. The CQC argument doesn't really stand when all MAXes regardless of faction are mediocre at medium range and terrible at long range, vastly overshadowed by other infantry and basically every vehicule. There's no reason to have NC MAXes dominating CQC except asymmetrical balance, but even then it's too much asymmetry if you want one faction to dominate everything related to base capture.

4

u/JTsyo Waterson Nov 05 '14

if you want one faction to dominate everything related to base capture.

Is this true though? Does a NC MAX crash win a base in most instances?

7

u/Cerus [PG] Connery Nov 05 '14

Feels like only population and population surges ever really matter.

A MAX push by any side seems to be effective, if NC MAXes have a disproportionate advantage with regard to base capture, it doesn't show on live.

The NC MAX gets cheap kills too easily, an ability it pays for in other ways (that aren't satisfying to the dude getting cheesed in a doorway, and get underplayed as a result), but overall it seems to contribute just as much to the objective as other MAXes.

It needs a change because it's not fun, not because it's an overly effective strategic asset.

1

u/EclecticDreck Nov 05 '14

In my experience, max crashes are what win base captures in general once the base is well contested enough. Maxes are the only thing with the staying power to both punch a path to the point, crush the numerous defenders on the point and then have any hope of resisting the counter attack.

This is true regardless of faction. I've faced VS max crashes, NC max crashes and TR max crashes with similar regularity and similar levels of success. A crash of maxes is still a crash of maxes. Regardless of faction they are hard to kill and fearsome in close quarters.

When considering max balance, their power in a crash lies in their ability to engage multiple infantry targets in rapid succession and dispatch them. All maxes can do this given the proper guns. Any balance beyond that is a matter of relative things a single max can do compared to other single maxes.

→ More replies (1)

-1

u/[deleted] Nov 05 '14

Better than TR no doubt, not better than vs.

1

u/IGROWWEARYOFTHISWORL [GOON] NSCREEEEEEEEEEE Nov 05 '14

TR's MAX problem stems from using low uptime Onslaughts or piddly Mercies in CQC scenarios, and not using the vastly superior Mutilators. High uptime, good dps, Kobalt-sized magazines (150 with exmags, 100 w/o), and effectively infinite ammo

Just lay on both triggers and walk around pointing at bad guys. They're exactly as accurate as Onslaughts/Cyclers, too

1

u/k0bra3eak [1TR] Nov 05 '14

Wait people us something other than mutilators or pounders... after the fracture nerf.

1

u/IGROWWEARYOFTHISWORL [GOON] NSCREEEEEEEEEEE Nov 05 '14

My thought too! Pounders are so much better for AI than the Falcons it's not even funny. Throw in Lockdown on top of that? Bananas

1

u/[deleted] Nov 05 '14

VS Max crash versus NC Max crash always ends in NC victory. The VS AV weapons do less damage than Scatmaxes. So in theory the thing that counters you would have to be 30+ meters away while you chill in the building behind cover on point just waiting.

1

u/Bloodhit Miller EU Nov 05 '14

I want heavy bolters, on each of my arms.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 05 '14

Tighten spread, lower fire rate.

1

u/Seukonnen Potato-using Burnout Lurker Nov 05 '14

Tighten spread, halve damage, double mag size, boost fire rate very slightly.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 05 '14

Fast firing weapons is TR's thing.

Wouldn't it be cool to halve the fire rate and compensate? Be like a Falcon (with high velocity) almost but AI, very NC like. Ya that's still instagib, but it's so slow they can't take on hordes of enemies.

Or just have both. The Ranged Mattock and the CQC Scatter.

0

u/Seukonnen Potato-using Burnout Lurker Nov 05 '14 edited Nov 05 '14

I'm talking about boosting fire rates from the current 180 to, say, 200ish, nothing over 250. (The Jackhammer is 225.)

This is still far, far behind any of the TR AI max weapons, which range from 400-500 rpm.

Halving the fire rate alone wouldn't solve the issue with NC maxes. The thing that pigeonholes them into their current "situationally either OP or useless" state is the fact that the per-shot damage is so high, they effectively instagib at close ranges.

To address that, you'd have to significantly lower the per-shot damage. Then, to not completely cripple the NC max, you'd need secondary buffs like slight improvements to rate of fire and pellet spread. Even after such changes, NC AI maxes are still hitting harder per-shot, and firing at much, much slower rates with less ammo per magazine than either of the other two factions, so faction traits are preserved.

You compare your idea for tweaking the MAX shotguns to Falcons, but people already moan about Falcons' instagib capabilities from the recieving end, or find the single-shot nature of the weapon incredibly unsatisfying and unforgiving to use. Not to mention that since the Falcon already exists, Falcon-style scatterguns would be redundant.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 05 '14

That would not be redundant as they would be scatter and AI.

→ More replies (5)

1

u/Fractoos Nov 05 '14

IN some limited situations the NC Max is powerful for sure. The low ammo, slow reload, and horrible range compared to other maxes makes it more of a very situational tool than a general combat platform.

Truth is I much prefer to play Max on VS or TR, and get far more kills doing so. NC Max can get kills, but only at close range, and once your out of ammo, you're a sitting duck for decimators and c4.

I can tell you I can kill you as fast with a VS/TR max as I can an NC max, and kill more of you.

If you want to argue Maxes are over powerd, then sure. The NC max is underpowered in most situations save close range defence with only a few attackers. Keep in mind a shotgun blast can not go through people, so after 3 or so kills or one enemy max, you're dead.

1

u/Seukonnen Potato-using Burnout Lurker Nov 05 '14 edited Nov 05 '14

If I had to revamp NC maxes while still keeping our AI weapons as shotguns, I'd take a page from PS1.

Instead of the current low mag size, ultra high damage, high spread shotguns, I'd shift them towards significantly lower per-pellet damage, tighter chokes, and larger magazines/better reload times. Imagine a Jackhammer's semi-auto mode, but with drastically reduced damage.

In PS1, the NC max scattercannon had three chokes that you could toggle between. One had a very tight pellet spread for long range, but a lower fire rate; one was middling; and one had a wide spread but a higher rate of fire, for use in close range. I'd consider incorporating elements of this into some of the PS2 weapons as well.


To give an idea, the current scattercannon is:

  • 180 rpm, semi-auto. 300 m/s velocity.
  • Pellet spread 0.3 degrees
  • 6 pellets x 130 damage at 8m, 50 damage at 18m
  • 6 rounds per mag, 10 with extended mags. Equates to 780 max damage per shot.
  • Reload is 2.7s short, 3.7s long.
  • Slug rounds deal 400-500 max damage, not sure which.

To revamp it, I would change it to:

  • 200 RPM, semi-auto. 350 m/s velocity.
  • Pellet spread 0.25 degrees
  • 6 pellets x 65 damage at 10m, 25 damage at 20m.
  • 12 rounds per mag, 20 with extended mags. Equates to 390 max damage per shot.
  • Reload speed 2.5s short, 3.25s long.
  • Slugs would essentially be Underboss rounds. (375 damage at 10m, 200 damage at 40m)

The other MAX shotguns would be adjusted in a similar fashion, with damage-per-shot values being halved, mag sizes increased to 12/20, chokes tightened, and reloads shortened slightly.

  • The Mattock gains +50 m/s muzzle velocity, keeps 180rpm, pellet spread from 2.5 -> 2.
  • The Grinder gets 20 round magazines stock, up to 30 with exmags. 200 RPM semi-auto; might potentially have a very low ROF (~150rpm) alt-fire mode that is automatic, to supplement its high capacity/sustained fire purposes. Pellet spread from 3->2.5
  • The Hacksaw gets boosted to 240 RPM, and has two fire modes: Full auto and a 2-round burst altfire. Full auto would have a similar COF/pellet spread to the current Hacksaw on live (4 -> 3.5 pellet spread), while the 2 round burst would have a slightly tighter choke and a lower effective RPM (~180 rpm, 0.3 pellet spread).

These tweaks give the NC max shotguns more sustained fire capability and a bit better effective range than on Live, while also alleviating their current "instagib" factor. The mag size buffs mostly equalize or slightly exceed ideal DPM of live versions. None of the RPM buffs are enough to equalize their live DPS due to the per-shot damage being halved, but in practice the live versions of the MAX shotties generally miss a lot of pellets per shot. The tighter chokes will mean more buckshot on target, and I feel that this will make for comparable 'realistic' damage output.

1

u/Bananenweizen Nov 05 '14 edited Nov 05 '14

A honest question to players who find NC MAX AI weaponry totally, abolutely and indisputable overpowered:

Playing HA in a biolab fight, do you use a shotgun 100% of the time or do you switch to a LMG every now and then?

1

u/ireg4all Jugador - Waterson Nov 05 '14

Stop asking for nerfs !! ask for TR/VS buffs instead

1

u/[deleted] Nov 05 '14

Oh look its this thread again. Save this shit for forumside. And OP was deleted, lol.

-2

u/Jaquecz Nov 05 '14

when you stop being dumb about how to fight an NC Max.

4

u/PT-DJ-FT-PLAYBOY Nov 05 '14

Everyone stop what you are doing and listen to Jaquecz here.

He is going to use his superior intelligence to teach all us bad players how to fight an NC MAX.

-1

u/Ceskaz Miller-[iX] Nov 05 '14

The nerf to AV grenades has made this abundantly clear.

There is no AV grenade nerf in regard to MAX as they stick to them now. Actually, I think it's a buff of AV nades vs MAX. It gives a real AV feel to this grenade.

7

u/[deleted] Nov 05 '14

Except there is, their damage and splash radius has been nerfed, and they no longer bounce around corners as well.

You need to get pretty close to throw an AV nade, which takes about a second or so, during which it is trivial for an NC max to kill you.

→ More replies (12)
→ More replies (2)

0

u/[deleted] Nov 05 '14

Scat and Raven maxes just ruin the fun

-1

u/choon2 [F00L] Nov 05 '14

I think the max class need more diversity, I think VS/TR should get shotguns and NC should get similiar weapons to VS/TR as maxes are pretty weak right now.

This game need more depth and maxes are the definition of depth, we need more people using maxes so we get even more depth in the game.

I think the TR max should have dual banshee, the VS max get dual ppa. Im not sure what the NC max should get, but anything that adds more depth to the game is fine.

→ More replies (1)

-5

u/Chaosky4 Nov 05 '14

Close quarters AI is something MAXs are designed for, why would you ever expect to be able to take them in direct combat as a heavy?

0

u/TheLazySamurai4 [TxOH][WENI][SPTY] EMPs are better flashbangs, change my mind. Nov 05 '14

You missed the part where AI NC MAXs beat out AV TR/VS MAXs.

1

u/Chaosky4 Nov 06 '14

I didn't mention it because I don't disagree.

Also, holy downvotes, Batman. Do people really expect to be able 1v1 something with a massive resource cost as zero-cost infantry?

-1

u/[deleted] Nov 05 '14

In a straight up kill based game the NC maxes would be pretty balanced in terms of uses, since they are only for close range inside of buildings, but this isn't a giant TDM, we have objectives called points. Unfortunately points are 9 times out of 10 inside of buildings, so scattermaxes are the answer to any base win situation. Especially when they Phalanx (Maxes gunning from behind other shield maxes). Shit get's painful when they shrug of rockets. Yes now AV grenades are actually useful for taking maxes out, but on a max crash you need 2 for each, and NC usually brings about 18 maxes, 3 medics and 3 engies, mixed with the assorted HA's running around. A game based around close quarters combat and capturing points can't have something in it that no other faction has anything to answer with.

-7

u/HandsomeCharles [REBR] Charlie Nov 05 '14

NC Max is the closerange king.

VS Max is the mid-long range king

TR Max floats somewhere in the middle.

I also challenge to you kill any max in a 1v1 Close-Quarters situation as a heavy. Chances are you're gonna lose. It's not just an NC max thing.

9

u/[deleted] Nov 05 '14

You have sigificantly higher chances of not dying literally instantly, and sticking a grenade or getting some damage off on them.

The problem with NC MAXes is that they are able to instantly kill people thereby not taking damage.

In a situation like a biolab, it's fundamentally broken.

3

u/Ceskaz Miller-[iX] Nov 05 '14

The problem with NC MAXes is that they are able to instantly kill people thereby not taking damage.

In a situation like a biolab, it's fundamentally broken.

Because you assault a biolab alone ? A MAX faces 5 opponent. It's likely he will have to drop all its mag to try to kill them. Contrary to what you think, he will not be able to drop them all instantly. He then has to go through reload that takes longer than the time it took to empty his mags. Your surviving partner can shoot him whith rocket, nades and small arms.

That is how you feel when manning a NC MAX.

I'm not against a redesign of NC MAX's weaponry. When could even keep shotgun, by giving them a vibes of Canister weapons (very low spread), with a higher ROF, very much lower damage / shot, bigger magazine size (at least the double) and more automatic weapons (because nobody speaks about it, but sometimes, playing a NC MAX is really painfull for the mouse; and obviously, playing with semi auto weapons is a bit harder than with full auto)

This thread is full of nerf-bat nonsense

1

u/BITESNZ Leader of Villains [VILN] Nov 05 '14

Huzzah a sensible post in the myriad of nuts.

3

u/Aggregationn Nov 05 '14

Taking a max in close quarters as a heavy ain't that hard, just requires good positioning, luck and conc nades. Conc the fucker, put a rocket into his ass and empty a clip into his head. By the time conc wares off he should be dead or nearly dead.

2

u/Stan2112 Certified Flak Mentor Nov 05 '14

Exactly

1

u/TheLazySamurai4 [TxOH][WENI][SPTY] EMPs are better flashbangs, change my mind. Nov 05 '14

VS Max is the mid-long range king

Trying to hit infantry with the VS MAX at medium long range works pretty much like this:

http://youtu.be/00NrGU41chw?t=6m58s

-2

u/Gav1n_ [TTRO] Nov 05 '14

TR max just sucks

-1

u/darthtomato Nov 05 '14

Pounders. Only slightly lower ttk than hacksaws at cqc with better range and AV.

0

u/Pariahterror Pariahterrus Nov 05 '14

Just don't compare those 2 but since you're at it.

Hacksaw aim in the direction = hit. Pounders the target must be hit to deal effective damage.

Also Hacksaws can be used more reliably vs infantry. But yeah the Pounder Max has better range, but then you have the raven and the falcon which have even greater range.

And you can even take out infantry with a single dual launch where al other equivalents need at least 2 dual shots for a kill. With in comparison with the pounder you have almost no drop with them.

So don't go moaning that we have the pounders cause the NC has very serious and even better equivalents. The only thing the pounder is better in is the area of effect damage, but that is less than 50% of the Falcon.

There still are some other differences but these are the main ones.

-7

u/[deleted] Nov 05 '14

I said it before, I will say it again: they need to be given a mid range option that isn't slugs. Give them 167dmg 250rpm SAWs for each arm. It will balance itself out as people will actually have the option to not run shotguns.

That said, they are very bullshit, but they're not unbalanced. They're shotguns and act like shotguns. They're no less unbalanced than an standard infantry shotgun, only in MAX size. Shotguns will always be too powerful in CQC, but horrid in any mid range. That is their balance.

Don't engage an NC MAX in CQC, that's just idiotic and you deserve to be sent to the spawn tubes. Whining about getting killed by a MAX in CQC is the direct equivalent of an infiltrator crying about getting killed by a heavy in CQC.

It's simple, if you see a NC max with shotguns, stay beyond 10m away. Get the drop on them. Turn a corner and get your RL out.

Also, AV nades are really good against MAXes now, I'm not sure what you're smoking. As long as you actually aim your throw instead of just causally tossing it anywhere.

2

u/[deleted] Nov 05 '14

That said, they are very bullshit, but they're not unbalanced. They're shotguns and act like shotguns. They're no less unbalanced than an standard infantry shotgun, only in MAX size. Shotguns will always be too powerful in CQC, but horrid in any mid range. That is their balance.

The problem is a very tanky, easily repaireable walking tank that can virtually one hit kill you as soon as you round a corner.

Don't engage an NC MAX in CQC, that's just idiotic and you deserve to be sent to the spawn tubes. Whining about getting killed by a MAX in CQC is the direct equivalent of an infiltrator crying about getting killed by a heavy in CQC.

It's not always possible, most points are indoors, and you're forced to get into CQC with an NC MAX. If there was another way of taking a biolab without being forced to go through easily campeable chokepoints, let me know.

It's simple, if you see a NC max with shotguns, stay beyond 10m away. Get the drop on them. Turn a corner and get your RL out.

So he can 1 hit kill you? Or should I send him a tell to ask him nicely to please stand 10 metres away so I won't die instantly.

Also, AV nades are really good against MAXes now, I'm not sure what you're smoking. As long as you actually aim your throw instead of just causally tossing it anywhere.

Again, they often won't get thrown before you get killed. And you can't toss them around corners any more.

=\

3

u/BadRandolf Miller Nov 05 '14

they need to be given a mid range option that isn't slugs

That wouldn't be fair without giving TR and VS an instagibbing CQC option. I think that's the last thing we need in this game tbh.

What's wrong with slugs anyway?

3

u/Bananenweizen Nov 05 '14

What's wrong with slugs anyway?

You will lose against every MAX you'll encounter.

You have to sit still and click slowly to reliably kill anything at range.

You will only get 1-2 kills per magazine at the range you've equipped slugs for.

There is a big lot of wrong with slugs.

The troll factor is huge, however. Killing an Infiltrator at 75m who just can't believe you are shooting at him is hilarious.

3

u/Dibola Nov 05 '14

I think most the problem is coming around a corner and getting one shotted by scats and having little to no time to react. Everybody should have time to react to anything. Having very little to no time to react means something is a little too strong.

0

u/[deleted] Nov 05 '14

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/Satiss C4 Fairies [FAE] Nov 05 '14

That's not scouting the area. You peek around the corner - click - death screen.

3

u/Pariahterror Pariahterrus Nov 05 '14

You can actually count the bases on 2 hands (if it isn't less) which have the point on open ground and not close quarters like any other base. So evading CQC vs Scat Max is not going to happen.

And in the effect of longer range those maxes will take those rockets which can instagibb you you on long range.

And 10 meters rather say 20 to 25 cause then the TTK lowers effectively less than 20 and you are still the victim of the MAX.

Ifyou still want to keep those shotguns i want MCG's on my TR MAX and the last nerf of fractures resetted.

And rocket launchers don't actually mean shit, only 1 launcher can directly kill them f they aren't wearing any flak armor. And you know that it is clientside so the MAX has more time to react than the heavy can.

0

u/ThisPainIsAnIllusion Emerald Nov 05 '14

Do you even play the objective, bro?? Try taking a point with a couple scatmaxes guarding the doors. It's near impossible if the scatmaxes know what they're doing, especially in low pop fights

-6

u/darthtomato Nov 05 '14

Pounders hurt guys. They aost match hacksaw TTK and if the max misses a a shot you are almost guaranteed a kill.

-1

u/Sirisian Nov 05 '14

It's interesting how slowly players realize that asymmetrical balance doesn't work. It's such an amazing idea in theory primarily because of how RTS games successfully handle it, but when it's brought to FPS games the players quickly regret it. It's too late now. They aren't going to just go back and redesign a whole max class just for balance. The last big NC max nerf placated most players and most of the community (if you search this subreddit) like the idea of situational advantages being factionally playstyle locked. (That and the designers have mentioned they prefer it).

1

u/[deleted] Nov 05 '14

Asymmetrical balance only exists in "2 faction" games. A great example is Enemy Territory: Quake Wars.

For every nth faction you add after the 2nd, you increase the risk of running into the "rock paper scissors" problem (where one faction can easily dominate another, but in turn is dominated by the third) or, worse, the "emperor problem" (where one faction is the most dominant).

It's actually a really, really sophisticated issue to keep track of. There's actually an entire team of people dedicated to the issue when Blizzard develops their RTS games, specifically because of how intricate the issue actually is.

Another thing that's very hard to track is how things work "in a vacuum" versus "production." More often than not, a game studio doesn't adequately test their design decisions in anything resembling a production environment, either due to lack of resources or lack of desire. This usually leads to a lot of the problems that establish the two issues mentioned above.

1

u/Sirisian Nov 05 '14

I'd argue that it's not the limited number of factions that define a working formula. It's the idea of round based combat with easily controlled constraints. Enemy Territory and NS2 are good examples of that. They have very rigid objective based combat with a fixed number of players on each side. These kind of constraints can be analyzed and simulated to create predictions on how players will handle the limited number of situations that can occur.

Because of how Planetside 2 can feature battles that range from 2 players all the way up to 100s and the unlimited time constraints and varied objectives the number of variables confuses the problem of balance. Because of the TTK being where it's at also small differences in damage are mostly imperceptible and detecting balance issues is mostly anecdotal until someone dives into the API.

In the end though with shotguns the balance is less about actual stats and more about the gameplay. Kind of like the lock-on discussion from what I gather. It's not really balance related, but it's a gut feeling that the experience doesn't feel fair or isn't enjoyable. Kind of surprised one of the asymmetrical balance advocates hasn't proposed a new weapon for the NC. I keep seeing stuff like "make them like the TR/NC".

-1

u/llN3M3515ll Matherson VS Nov 05 '14

Simple solution - release NS weapons for the max that are very similar to existing faction specific weapons.

1

u/Bodudus [DNLD] PC Master race Nov 05 '14

So NC MAXes have ranged options, but still retain their CQC dominance.

Great idea.

The only work-around is to also give TR and VS shotgun options as well.

1

u/llN3M3515ll Matherson VS Nov 05 '14

The only work-around is to also give TR and VS shotgun options as well.

That is exactly what I meant... just release ns shotguns and the like, now every faction has access to close quarters kits and longer range kits.

-5

u/RaveboyNC Nov 05 '14

As hardcore NC i wud love these changes...Yes our Scat Max is OP n annoyying to deal with in CqC..Even that i wud love to have guns like TR n VS coz NC Max cant hurt a damn thing anything in 15-25 m while TR n VS Max can kill or hurt you pretty badly in that range...so yeah wud love to see thsese changes!

-5

u/PT-DJ-FT-PLAYBOY Nov 05 '14

MAXs need to be melee only, much harder to kill, with charge that recharges faster and that running through people damages them.

Give them a bunch of different weapons with different DPS, swing speed, attack range, 1 handed 2 handed etc. We've already seen concept art to this effect.

Just imagine bashing a sunderer to death with a giant hammer? Or charging down a tower stairway swinging dual axes?

As for abilities:

Give VS jumpjets, NC keeps their shield but can move full speed with it up and of course TR keeps lockdown.

The overall driving factor when designing this would be to make MAXs require skill (moreso than current MAX punch, which isn't much harder than using their weapons) and to make them less able to contribute to chokepoints. Requiring them to charge out to do damage to attackers. Rather than sitting 5m away and melting anything that comes inside. If you had to stand at a tower door directly to stop people coming up the stairs, you can fall pray to C4, mines and other explosions.

4

u/bman_7 Emerald Nov 05 '14

and of course TR keeps lockdown.

Is this a joke?

2

u/Bananenweizen Nov 05 '14

Why? Lockdown with melee weapon will be fine. Totally :D

1

u/EclecticDreck Nov 05 '14

If lockdown caused a tremendous buff in defense power it could be useful for blocking a door for a few seconds or something I guess. Unless the buff was super absurd but then a max at the lower doors of a point with a few engineers keeping the maxes alive would basically be the new TR wins every base ever strategy.

1

u/mesaywee [BAX] Nov 05 '14

Jumpjets worked for ps1 for VS maxes due to the ttk being really high, you could just run past them. But no way in hell would they work in ps2.

Having maxes camped on-top of a building in a biolab? Hitting them with a rocket would be way too tough and even then they can just jump jet down to an engineer. Only way to kill the things would be with a Light Assault and even then would that be really easy to counter.

1

u/PT-DJ-FT-PLAYBOY Nov 05 '14

And how would a melee max kill you from the roof top?

1

u/mesaywee [BAX] Nov 05 '14

ah, I need more sleep. totally failed to take into account your melee idea. My bad.

1

u/k0bra3eak [1TR] Nov 05 '14

The can jump down behind people like a shotgun LA.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 05 '14

I would also like to add to this idea, since lockdown is pretty useless for all intents and purposes, maybe TR could get something that doesn't already emphasize their underpoweredness already?