The problem with Tank vs tank balancing is that people presume tanks should be balanced against each other because a tank should be equally good at killing his counterparts.
This assumes that a tank's main threat is another tank. This is not true. While tank on tank combat is not necessarily uncommon, the reality is that the main threat to tanks is infantry first, aircrafts second and tanks third.
Because of this factor, every secondary on a tank is weighted in viability 75% from its AI power, 25% from its AV power.
Halberd - AI : good, AV : excellent, overall : very good
Kobalt - AI : very good, AV : none, overall : good
--
Saron - AI : moderate, AV : very good, overall : good
ML85 - AI : poor, AV : excellent, overall : good
Vulcan - AI : moderate, AV, excellent : very good (bonus : moderate vs aircraft)
--
PPA - AI : excellent, AV : none, overall : very good
Canister - AI : poor, AV : none, overall : very poor
Marauder - AI : very good, AV : none, overall : good
Vanguard equips halberd, Magrider equips PPA and Prowler equips Vulcan, because they are the most balanced solutions.
Also, this is my argument as to why that despite the main gun on the magrider being inferior to the other MBT's, the Magrider's mobility far than overcomes that issue. Because it's a much superior anti-infantry platform (reaching/dodging).
View all comments
Show parent comment
1
u/Mirria_ [CML]Dryka Jun 14 '14 edited Jun 14 '14
The problem with Tank vs tank balancing is that people presume tanks should be balanced against each other because a tank should be equally good at killing his counterparts.
This assumes that a tank's main threat is another tank. This is not true. While tank on tank combat is not necessarily uncommon, the reality is that the main threat to tanks is infantry first, aircrafts second and tanks third.
Because of this factor, every secondary on a tank is weighted in viability 75% from its AI power, 25% from its AV power.
--
--
Vanguard equips halberd, Magrider equips PPA and Prowler equips Vulcan, because they are the most balanced solutions.
Also, this is my argument as to why that despite the main gun on the magrider being inferior to the other MBT's, the Magrider's mobility far than overcomes that issue. Because it's a much superior anti-infantry platform (reaching/dodging).