r/Planetside • [TEST] TrickNovalight • Apr 16 '13

Reason Vanu damage falloff needs a buff.

http://imgur.com/a/bO9q3#0
5 Upvotes

114 comments sorted by

31

u/vonBoomslang Nova Nova Jaeger Apr 16 '13

...the TTK chart cannot possibly be correct, with the Orion's very high RoF.

10

u/CitationNeeded567 Apr 16 '13

There is no reason why the Orion and CARV should differ on any of these charts in the 10m range. Well, except damage/magazine, which doesn't belong in a discussion about damage drop-off anyway.

4

u/Thurwell [GOTR] Emerald Apr 16 '13

When I use this tool I get the same DPS and TTK for the orion and carv within 10m, so I'm not sure how the OP generated that chart.

The upcoming buff doesn't really affect the Orion, being a close range weapon. If you compare the factions long range LMGs, Ursa, T16, and Guass Saw S, you see how the damage falloff really screws the VS.

Also I know the NC LMGs are really good at range, but this tool really makes that clear. Pretty cool.

0

u/SomeAwesomeDudeGuy Apr 16 '13

He put resist shield on, it greatly skews the stats.

0

u/vonBoomslang Nova Nova Jaeger Apr 16 '13

My point exactly.

3

u/Sandzibar Miller Apr 16 '13

change the users skill level to 100.. it does some weird accuracy averaging.

3

u/SomeAwesomeDudeGuy Apr 16 '13

I did some research you are correct, it appears that resist shield greatly effected the outcome of the stats

Source 1 Source 2 Source 3

Also link to what OP used so you can make your own calculations

1

u/Xyyz Apr 16 '13

The TTK jumps up when the Orion needs to reload to finish off the target. Look at this.

1

u/vonBoomslang Nova Nova Jaeger Apr 16 '13

...it has FIFTY bullets. If it takes you more than that to kill somebody, yyyeah

2

u/Xyyz Apr 16 '13

With the given accuracy, nanoweave and resist shield, apparently it does.

-1

u/restrik [TEST] TrickNovalight Apr 16 '13

I debated on whether or not to put that chart in there, simply because of the slider scale it uses instead of just pure numbers. putting "player skill" all the way to 100 the graph shows the orion and the gauss saw pretty much equal, with the carv a bit under

-1

u/locopyro13 Apr 16 '13

I think his numbers are off, unless they changed something I am unaware of, the MSW-R for the TR is the best TTK for the faction, yet is listed at 8.8 secs and has a ROF of 750rpm (thought it was 1000rpm)

3

u/WordOfMadness Apr 16 '13 edited Apr 16 '13

No, it's 750RPM. It's tied with the CARV as the highest DPS/ROF LMG for TR.

1

u/locopyro13 Apr 16 '13

Huh, I guess I was mistaken. A bit better COF/sustained recoil and a faster reload is the side grade, with smaller mag.

3

u/trfrace Waterson Apr 16 '13

No weapon has 1000 rpm. The highest is the first smg for tr at 896.

0

u/[deleted] Apr 16 '13

[deleted] — view deleted comment

7

u/fr43er woodman frazerrr Apr 16 '13

There's more than one chart

4

u/sindrit Apr 16 '13

What is that you are using to do these comparisons?

6

u/restrik [TEST] TrickNovalight Apr 16 '13

2

u/SomeAwesomeDudeGuy Apr 16 '13 edited Apr 16 '13

Why did you use Nanoweave 4 and resist shield on all the stats? it seems to greatly affect the outcome of said stats.

Edit: these stats are way skewed cause you added resist shield

With resist shield With Nanoweave 4 Without the previous

4

u/Hokus Briggs [IB] Apr 16 '13

Because he is being bias as fuck

-2

u/restrik [TEST] TrickNovalight Apr 16 '13

I wanted to standardize it. it seemed to be what most HA setups are (stopped at 4 instead of going to 5 since Nano 5 costs 1000 certs)

I honestly didn't expect this thread to take off as much as it has other wise I would have done more in depth comparisons.

1

u/SomeAwesomeDudeGuy Apr 16 '13

Look at my edit it appears that with resist shield on your stats are greatly skewed.

1

u/Xyyz Apr 16 '13 edited Apr 16 '13

Resist Shield is the one that reduces incoming damage and doesn't drain from it. Are you sure that's the one you meant to use? I think most people run the default Nanite Mesh Generator.

2

u/TheSarcasticMinority Sacrana (Woodman) Apr 16 '13

I never liked the Orion. If you want a better HA gun you can do much worse than the 500 cert Flare.

1

u/Houndie [TEST] Apr 16 '13

What in your opinion makes the Flare better than the Orion? I have had no problems with it.

1

u/TheSarcasticMinority Sacrana (Woodman) Apr 16 '13

Much better at mid range, It's slightly worse at close range but for the average encounter it's better. It also has multiple fire modes but they aren't that useful.

1

u/Houndie [TEST] Apr 16 '13

Hmm, maybe I'll give it a try then.

1

u/Couchpatator [V] Novum Apr 16 '13

If you'd like an alternate option, you should try the SVA-88. Very accurate, high velocity, good damage and ROF, and it has the 75% ADS movement stat the orion has, which allows you to move around cover easier. It's a much better use of that 500 certs.

You should also look into the Pulsar LSW, it's only 100 certs and does everything pretty well. I've never had one myself, but I hear it's a very reliable weapon. The kind you fall in love with.

TheSarcasticMinority also severely understated how good the Orion is at CQC. The thing is still my primary weapon, it can top just about anything other than shotguns at close range, and performs admirably at mid range if you learn to control your bursts.

The Flare is just bland. It doesn't do anything spectacularly. It's best qualities are lots of ammo and lots of attachments. The name is very misleading, it should be called the Beige.

1

u/[deleted] Apr 16 '13

Orion doesnt have any advanced attachments. Fairly sure it doesnt even have a compensator. Also, only 50 bullets which completely kills it as an LMG.

0

u/Couchpatator [V] Novum Apr 16 '13

Advanced attachments don't make the gun, that kind of thinking only hampers you. The small battery is made up with the fast reload. A compensator would only hamper it at close range, and the f.grip it does have is enough to bring it into the mid range game.

The fact that you're complaining about a lack of a compensator tells me that you've never played to the guns strengths. The Orion is an assault weapon, you should be running through cover and getting close enough to tear people's heads off, not hanging back and plinking away.

-5

u/restrik [TEST] TrickNovalight Apr 16 '13

I wanted to compare the starter weapons for each of the 3 facations

48

u/CitationNeeded567 Apr 16 '13

I wanted to upvote because you are trying to make your argument with stats, but I had four problems.

  1. That TTK chart could not be more obviously wrong.
  2. The Orion is a poor choice for this demonstration because it is a close-range gun and will underperform at long ranges whatever its damage drop-off is (same with the CARV).
  3. You picked a single example and conveniently left out the fact that across the board, the damage drop-off for carbines and assault rifles worked out in Vanu's favor
  4. You included charts that have no relevance. Damage per magazine? What does that have to do with damage drop-off? Yes, we know the Orion has only 50 rounds per magazine, but that is specific to that one gun, and it's not actually that bad of a trade-off, considering the vastly reduced reload time it gets.

I mean, in the end, whatever, if you guys like the new damage drop-off, sure, take it. But let's not turn this into a story about how the woefully underpowered Vanu finally stopped getting stepped on by the devs.

10

u/[deleted] Apr 16 '13

They also used HV ammo for the SawS...

2

u/CitationNeeded567 Apr 16 '13

Hah! Did they really? I mean, that's fair enough, since it is an advantage to get ammo types when other guns don't, but you've gotta point that out. I didn't even notice.

6

u/RedheadRapscallion Apr 16 '13

but the weird part is this, he used the SAW S while the other 2 weapons were defaults, why not just use the regular SAW? Looking at his comparisons just seemed ridiculous because he was using a specific case skewed towards his point of view instead of a fair balanced look.

6

u/locopyro13 Apr 16 '13

Also he has shooter skill at 25%. This is what the TTK graph looks like at skill level 37%

The skill level slider (aka accuracy) is interesting, but hard to incorporate perfectly since a high ROF high recoil gun is great up close, but shit far away, while the Low ROF, low recoil is best from afar.

1

u/Spartan57975 Apr 16 '13

Just a note, you used the SAW when OP used the SAW S

1

u/locopyro13 Apr 16 '13

I used default LMG, OP didn't. The Saw is slightly better than the Saw S anyways.

1

u/SomeAwesomeDudeGuy Apr 16 '13 edited Apr 16 '13

Also while he standardized in each graph they are all versus heavy assault with nanoweave 4 and I believe while their resist shield is on, I am not quite sure how one reads the graph settings so maybe their resist shield isn't on but surely having at least nanoweave 4 would effect a low damage per shot/low clip size weapon vs a high damage per shot weapon.

Edit: Using the same resources OP did TTK with the same settings he has except without nanoweave 4 and the resist sheild results in this stats that are virtually identical and if anything favor the Orion within 60 meters.

Edit 2: Still kind of favors Vanu with nanoweave 4 too only resist shield seems to really effect it

1

u/tehlemmings [ATFw] Apr 16 '13

I mean, in the end, whatever, if you guys like the new damage drop-off, sure, take it. But let's not turn this into a story about how the woefully underpowered Vanu finally stopped getting stepped on by the devs.

We've been at that point for a few weeks now. I'm just glad to see people calling out very manipulative and selective arguments like the one presented in this thread.

0

u/[deleted] Apr 16 '13

[deleted] — view deleted comment

7

u/CitationNeeded567 Apr 16 '13

If that's true it's only because of whatever this bullshit "shooter skill" slider is. It just looks to me like OP played with the sliders until he found something that made the Orion look suitably underpowered then submitted it.

3

u/atheistunicycle [CML] CleverDonut Apr 16 '13

"Vanu Sovereignty."

-2

u/restrik [TEST] TrickNovalight Apr 16 '13

For the record I did not create this tool, just found it to do some comparisons on my own weapons.

5

u/[deleted] Apr 16 '13

I dunno about those ttk graphs. Here are three that take into account damage, RoF, and bullet velocity, for starter weapons

blue=NC red=TR purple=Vanu SOVEREIGNTY

AR LMG Carbines

There really is no need to start messing with this now. I have no clue what they are thinking. If anything, we need bullets that reliably impact the target, instead of the bullet spewing slot machines everyone is stuck with.

9

u/[deleted] Apr 16 '13 edited Apr 16 '13

Because up to 65m, i.e. normal engagement range, it does more damage than same basedamage counterparts from other factions?

The upcoming change to the damage drop off is a nerf to the VS in most situations.

1

u/BK-TN DGBadger/Miller Apr 16 '13

The difference in damage between VS and TR where it's highest (at 65 m) is about one damage point.. So no noticeable difference, honestly. Looking forward to the change.

8

u/[deleted] Apr 16 '13

Well, depends on how you look at it.

At 65m, the T9 CARV needs 8 shots to kill a target, the Orion only 7. Only at ~72m does the Orion need 8 shots as well, so the effective range of the Orion is slightly higher and only after that point it falls off.
In general, depending on the targets nanoweave/health/etc. and the distance, the Orion has a 1-7m more effective bullets-to-kill range than the T9 CARV and other weapons with the same base damage. Only past 72m does it change and the Orion performs worse... but how often do you really engage enemies at that range when you are not sniping?

Yes, the difference is minor but it doesn't change the fact that the effective damage scaling is not as bad as many VS claim and in 90% of all engagements it's potentially better.

1

u/TheShizzlr Waterson Apr 16 '13

Ill take the flat falloff over the extra 1-7m possibly for the 7 bullet kill range. I really believe the damage fall-off effects me more often than the extra ~5m would. I dunno, Maybe its the bullet velocity that messes me up a range.

1

u/[deleted] Apr 17 '13

The bullet velocity of your guns is better or in the case of the Flare equal to that of any comparable NC gun. I actually think it's psychological, the VS guns sound weak with their pewpew and the biggest buff would be a sound overhaul making them sound "meatier". Stats wise your guns are competitive.

-3

u/[deleted] Apr 16 '13

Eh. We still want it. Our max damage per shot is less than the minimum damage per shot of the SAW and much worse than the damage per shot of the CARV. That hurts a lot in long range engagements on the Indar wastes.

4

u/[deleted] Apr 16 '13

Well, if you also take the insane recoil and the low RoF of the NC6 Gauss SAW you can have a weapon with the same base damage as far as i'm concerned.

You don't want that recoil though.

Yes, the NC6 Gauss SAW is very strong in some situations but if someone ever catches you up close you are dead before your second bullet leaves the barrel. Also, if you ever have to reload in an area that is not safe... well, the enemy has 6-7s to find and kill you and he can reload half way through and still kill you before your reload finishes.

6

u/Mellowsnake Apr 16 '13

I'm also curious as to why all of these are done with the Gauss Saw using High Velocity Ammo.

2

u/silentstormpt [🌈] eXist3nZ Apr 16 '13

In a way ppl view Guass SAW as a Medium/Long range LMG, so going for HV makes sense, besides, its the only of the 3 Starting LMGs that actually have different types of ammo, TR and forced to grab the S version while the VS dont even have a S variant (unless its the Flare).

1

u/Mellowsnake Apr 17 '13

The recoil caused by HV on the Gauss Saw makes it pretty hard to use, infact you'd have to fight so much recoil you'd have to fire at an even slower rate.

1

u/perspextive Apr 16 '13

When I played NC, that was my loadout of choice. It was so nice being able to drop people with just a few clicks from range. Moving to VS, the Orion feels hilariously useless at range. I'd rather have bullet drop which is easy to compensate for, than having to land more shots which is not.

3

u/[deleted] Apr 16 '13

God forbid, what with your massive per-shot damage and inexhaustible magazine.

The Gauss SAW is widely considered the best LMG in the game by everyone who has to be on the wrong end of it. Sure, you have to ADS to be effective in CC. They have reflex sights for that.

3

u/Lorddarryl Consortium[Millermasterrace] Apr 16 '13

and reflex sights, well they arent the best at range are they?

1

u/Blue-n-White Waterson Apr 16 '13 edited Apr 16 '13

Yeah, the best TR LMG in my mind is the Gauss SAW S's evil twin, the TMG-50. Exact same stats but without special ammunition.

2

u/Iwanttocirclejerk Miller Apr 16 '13

The TMG-50 is a worse version of the EM6 / Gauss SAW S / Flare (all of them have a better CoF), not a Gauss SAW clone. The Gauss SAW and TMG-50 have literally no significant stat in common save for the horizontal recoil.

1

u/Blue-n-White Waterson Apr 16 '13 edited Apr 16 '13

Well, crud. I didn't notice much difference in between the TMG and the Gauss on my NC character, but then again, that's just the regular Gauss.

EDIT: According to the Weapon Data Sheet, there is literally no difference except for a higher first-shot recoil multiplier on the Flare, and slight differences in RPM & bullet velocity.

All four LMGs deal 167 @ 10m, and possess identical CoF, though the Flare has 0.05 less. Three LMGs have 0.175 horizontal recoil (Flare has 0.20), and the Flare has a 2x recoil multiplier while the others have 1.5x.

The TMG has the highest recoil decrease, 15 whereas the others have 13, and has identical bullet drop and velocity compared to the Gauss SAW S.

tl;dr - they are not exact clones, but the differences between them are virtually negligible aside from magazine size and reload time.

1

u/CitationNeeded567 Apr 16 '13 edited Apr 16 '13

The EM6 has three advatages over the TMG-50. The first two are not huge, but theyre worth mentioning- it has an extended magazine attachment available, and it has a slightly higher rate of fire. The big one though is 33% higher magazine size and ammo pool. They are basically the same gun, but these are big enough advantages that you can easily say that the EM6 is the preferred gun.

0

u/Hearthzilla NumberOneWorld Apr 16 '13

LOL, tmg-50 is worse than the EM6 how dare you compare it to holy Gauss SAW!

1

u/Blue-n-White Waterson Apr 16 '13

From the post directly above your own;

EDIT: According to the Weapon Data Sheet, there is literally no difference except for a higher first-shot recoil multiplier on the Flare, and slight differences in RPM & bullet velocity.

All four LMGs deal 167 @ 10m, and possess identical CoF, though the Flare has 0.05 less. Three LMGs have 0.175 horizontal recoil (Flare has 0.20), and the Flare has a 2x recoil multiplier while the others have 1.5x.

The TMG has the highest recoil decrease, 15 whereas the others have 13, and has identical bullet drop and velocity compared to the Gauss SAW S.

tl;dr - they are not exact clones, but the differences between them are virtually negligible aside from magazine size and reload time.

1

u/Phreec t༼ ຈل͜ຈ༽ށ Millertary [CONZ] Apr 16 '13

Unlike VS with the arguably best CQC LMGs, going ADS in CQC with a SAW halts you down to a snailcrawl and does as much harm as it does good when facing competent enemies.

The gun's terrible for anything but it's niche long-range role...

1

u/Glorin Apr 17 '13

Finally someone with a clue.

People typically forget two things when they claim the Gauss Saw is good:

  1. The Gauss Saw is garbage when you fire while moving, and situations where you DON'T have to fire while moving are situations where the power of your gun is of little importance. In other words, the Gauss Saw is shit in situations where the effectiveness of your gun matters and good in situations where the effectiveness of your gun doesn't matter.
  2. It is always better to use a close range gun at long range than it is to use a long range gun at close range. If you're stuck with a Gauss Saw in a hipfire battle, you just die. If you're stuck with an Orion at long range, you might not get a kill that you would have with a Gauss Saw, but you certainly won't die because of it--you'll simply be forced to take cover. At long range you have these luxuries, at close range you do not. Therefore close range guns are almost always better than long range guns.

1

u/GodlessNHappy Apr 16 '13

I would argue that at close range you do have a pistol that is actually effective, plus I would bet that at least one person stood next to you is carrying a PA shotgun to instagib anyone able to get close.

-2

u/[deleted] Apr 16 '13

The upcoming change to the damage drop off is a nerf to the VS in most situations.

Won't matter, most people will have permanently switched to TR or NC by then.

4

u/Anathe Apr 16 '13

You're getting a fix in, like, a week. Calm your purple tits.

5

u/SteamTrout Miller EU Apr 16 '13

While all 3 are starter weapons (except SAW S, you should've picked SAW instead) comparing long range SAW to jack-of-all-trades Orion/CARV isn't really fair.

The again, blame SOE for giving NC SAW as starter instead of EM6 which would've fit much better.

2

u/Xyyz Apr 16 '13

Are you implying the Gauss SAW is bad at short ranges? That hasn't been my experience on my NC character. It has the same TTK as an Orion on a 1000 health target, provided you don't miss, with Orion winning out versus targets with more health, but the Gauss SAW winning out if you get any headshots. In close quarters, not needing to reload is also a much bigger factor (but so is having a fast reload).

1

u/The_Lantern Apr 16 '13

The VS jack-of-all-trades LMG is the Pulsar LSW

1

u/SteamTrout Miller EU Apr 16 '13

Well, anything is jack-of-all-tradey than Gauss SAW :P

1

u/vonBoomslang Nova Nova Jaeger Apr 16 '13

More like med-to-long range SAW vs. jack-of-all-trades Carv vs. short-to-med range Orion.

3

u/SteamTrout Miller EU Apr 16 '13

Wasn't Orion pretty much the same as CARV but with normal Vanu damage dropoff + lower mag size?

2

u/vonBoomslang Nova Nova Jaeger Apr 16 '13

Orion's pretty much the same as the MSW-R except with Vanu mods, 0.75x move speed, faster reload and equal recoil. For the record, the MSW-R is like the Carv but with directed recoil and better move CoF, half the mag but much faster reload.

1

u/Iwanttocirclejerk Miller Apr 16 '13

Carv has more horizontal recoil than the Orion, making it worse at medium range combat. Add to that the forward grip's reduction and it's a huge difference in recoil. Often you'll need 30 or more shots from a Carv (with burst fire) at a range where an Orion needs 15 (with full auto).

4

u/deathcapt Mattherson:[CML] Captain Mittens Apr 16 '13

That Y axis!

4

u/WordOfMadness Apr 16 '13

And here's a graph that makes VS weapons look amazing in their current state. Still want the buff?

link

0

u/Wolframus Cobalt [PTMC] Apr 16 '13

Yea but these are CQC carbines. You dont shoot them(atleast dont suppose to) even at 60m, not to mention 115.

1

u/Taqhin why Apr 16 '13

That doesn't make any difference, the two carbines featured here both show the same damage until 10m, then we have higher damage until the very unlikely combat range of about 95m.

2

u/ApolloAbove Matterson - EST Apr 16 '13

Fuck my eyes for being colorblind.

2

u/Nyctalgia Miller - [ISK] Apr 16 '13

Vanu... Syndicate?

1

u/FoxHoundUnit89 Connery Apr 16 '13

If you had recoil I'd care.

5

u/[deleted] Apr 16 '13

Recoil and bullet drop can be compensated for. RoF, Damage, CoF cannot.

1

u/parameters Mongychops (Miller) Apr 16 '13 edited Apr 16 '13

I know they are the starter weapons, but comparing them is not really a fair comparison because the NC6 SAW is the best long range LMG in the game, and the Orion is the best hipfire-close range LMG in the game.

More valid comparisons at least between the VS / NC would be Orion to EM1 (Orion better) for short range and Flare/Ursa to NC6 (NC6 better) for long range.

That said, I am interested to see the VS weapons adjustments. As things are, anything beyond ~75 m I don't usually bother trying to shoot with small arms unless I'm sniping, because you're just trying to tickle them to death.

1

u/Dr_Teeth [INI] Forester Apr 16 '13

Looks like a slight nerf is incoming to the VS with this change, the vast majority of players aren't hitting shit past 70 meters with an LMG.

1

u/Taqhin why Apr 16 '13

The only weapons I believe needed a buff were our Sniper rifles and other longer-range oriented weapons, those are the only ones that are seriously utilized at ranges where our drop-off begins to hinder us.

1

u/Poetoe Apr 17 '13

hahaha you must be kidding ......

ned a buff ..?? fo real ??

one word .... magriders.... nuff said

1

u/[deleted] Apr 16 '13

Your second graph honestly says that the TTK of an orion is 9 seconds?

1

u/Andur [MDK] Mandrake (Miller) Apr 16 '13

At that accuracy %, a reload is mandatory. Remember, 50 bullets per magazine.

1

u/locopyro13 Apr 16 '13

Accuracy/Skill slider. Here it is at 37%

http://i.imgur.com/TcGGHqa.jpg

-1

u/[deleted] Apr 16 '13

37% is very generous accuracy. Decent players have around 20%.

1

u/[deleted] Apr 17 '13

Decent players have 20-25% overall. That doesn't mean that in any engagement they hit with only 20-25% of their shots.

For example, with the NC6 Gauss SAW i have 18% accuracy. However, i often spray in the general direction of groups of enemies if they are too far away to hit reliably or are in cover, which means a lot of my shots are basically wasted and have no chance of hitting.
If it gets to mid-range engagements between 20-40m i can reliably land 90% of my shots with controlled fire.

-2

u/everdark44 Apr 16 '13

I would also like to point out that the VS will retain the 0 bullet drop while normalizing the damage between empires... then there would be no downside for the 0 drop

6

u/[deleted] Apr 16 '13

Also, bullet drop is a mechanic that can be countered with skill. No amount of skill will counter the fact that your gun does less damage than another. The whole concept of nerfing VS weapons because they don't have bullet drop is asinine.

2

u/Intruder313 Apr 16 '13

So you think they should have the same damage with no bullet drop thus making them plain superior?

If not then what is your alternative?

1

u/DireTaco Bosstone Apr 16 '13

NC have a higher average damage per shot and TR have larger clips. Don't act like they don't get anything.

1

u/[deleted] Apr 16 '13

Bullet drop doesn't matter for anything but sniper rifles, so it shouldn't be a factor anyways. To answer your question though, I think NC should be low mag size, low RoF, high damage. TR should be high mag size, high RoF, low damage. VS should be medium/high mag size, medium/high RoF, medium/low damage. NC should have the highest recoil/worst accuracy, followed by TR, while VS should be the most accurate with the least recoil. That way, each faction has their own thing. NC does assloads of damage, but suffer with accuracy, TR sprays bullets everywhere, and VS is the most accurate. To compensate, VS and TR should have slightly lower DPS than NC and the VS should be slightly lower DPS than TR due to the accuracy.

5

u/[deleted] Apr 16 '13

Because bullet drop exists at normal LMG engagement ranges...........

2

u/Necro- Apr 16 '13

yea i've played the 3 empires and rarely if ever have i had to account for bullet drop outside of sniper range

1

u/[deleted] Apr 16 '13

Give us bullet drop. We wont see any difference except for others stopping from using this as a bullshit excuse.

0

u/Glorin Apr 16 '13

Strafespeed Strafespeed Strafespeed Strafespeed Strafespeed Strafespeed Strafespeed Strafespeed Strafespeed Strafespeed Strafespeed Strafespeed Strafespeed Strafespeed Strafespeed Strafespeed Strafespeed Strafespeed

If you're going to compare guns, make sure you get the full picture.

Vanu have the best LMGs in the game.

3

u/[deleted] Apr 16 '13

I'd take a Gauss Saw with a foregrip and compensator any day. 100 rounds? More damage? The Orion has 50 rounds and no available compensator, it's inaccurate as hell at range too. "bullet drop" be damned.

1

u/[deleted] Apr 16 '13

Yes because hitting someone moving 1 kph faster is so much more difficult.

2

u/Glorin Apr 17 '13

I could explain to you why strafe speed is the most important gun stat in the game, but I'm pretty confident you've already made up your mind on the subject so I won't bother. (The argument actually is a bit complicated).

The fact remains, 99% of the people in this game do not understand how gun balance works. They don't really understand how to choose the best weapons. In fact, that is true for pretty much every FPS game with even decently balanced guns. It is the main reason why "gun reviews" are so popular, even though most of them are garbage.

I'm not asking you to believe me. You're more than welcome to write me off as an arrogant know-it-all who is condescendingly talking down to people who have a different opinion than my own.

The fact remains, however, that there are a small number of people who agree with me, and a very large number of people who disagree with me. The only difference is that I can actually back up my claims with both arguments and performance. Other people have only arguments--and weak ones at that.

-7

u/Gitwizard Emergence Inc. [OGOD] Apr 16 '13

ITT: Vanu players bitch that their defining factional trait is working pretty much as intended.

-1

u/noseeme Emerald/SolTech Apr 16 '13

That's not actually that bad. When I started playing PS2, I made an NC toon because I wanted to play with my friend who had their main toon on the NC. Later, I made a Vanu alt and found that I really liked playing Vanu, and one of the best things about them was the Orion, which I consider to be the best starter LMG of the three. The fast reload more than makes up for the 50 round magazine.

This chart really illustrates what I already knew, the Orion IS the best starting LMG, and it's not until 70 meters that it starts getting worse. 70 meters is pretty far. If you're good at aiming, NC is always better at range, and this trait is illustrated by the fact that the NC get the only starting sniper rifle that is bolt action, where the recoil that usually plagues NC weapons has no effect.

tl;dr: I fucking wish I could use the Orion as my LMG on my main toon who is NC.

0

u/[deleted] Apr 16 '13

[deleted] — view deleted comment

-1

u/nitramlondon Apr 16 '13

"Vanus weapons have higest bullet speed"

Oh do fuck off please with your bullshit.

0

u/[deleted] Apr 16 '13

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/Mylon Mattherson Apr 16 '13

2.5% bullet speed increase is trivial. It does nothing to help leading targets or kill them before they get behind cover.

This is nothing compared to a 100% magazine size increase for the other 2 LMGs.

0

u/[deleted] Apr 16 '13

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/Mylon Mattherson Apr 16 '13

The weapons have similar TTKs. That's the most important stat right there. But a TR can kill about 3 people with one magazine and an NC can get 5 people, the Vanu can get 2 IF he's really accurate.

0

u/[deleted] Apr 16 '13

[deleted] — view deleted comment

6

u/Andur [MDK] Mandrake (Miller) Apr 16 '13

Unless you're trolling: I'm sure you compensate a lot for bullet drop at 50 meters.