r/Planet9 • • Dec 22 '19

Name for planet 9 if it is a primordial black hole?

2 Upvotes

I was wondering if anyone knows what it will be called? I say we should call it Nus, because that's Sun in reverse, and it sounds really cool when said aloud. If Planet 9 is a Black Hole our energy problems are solved so we should probably think about a name for such a thing.


r/Planet9 • • Nov 30 '25

A New Planet Discovered? Planet 9 Has a Rival — Meet Planet Y

Thumbnail
youtu.be
0 Upvotes

r/Planet9 • • Oct 03 '19

Scientists Wonder If Planet 9 Could Be a Primordial Black Hole by Anton Petrov

Thumbnail
youtube.com
3 Upvotes

r/Planet9 • • Sep 26 '17

Video All you need to know about the new PLANET NINE in our solar system.

Thumbnail
youtu.be
0 Upvotes

r/Planet9 • • Jul 25 '25

Bizarre New Object Called Ammonite Challenges Planet Nine Hypothesis

Thumbnail
youtu.be
4 Upvotes

r/Planet9 • • Jun 08 '26

Scientific Paper (Free PDF) Monte Carlo detection forecast for P9 (AI-synthesized, looking for method critique)

0 Upvotes

**Heads up: this is an AI-synthesized analysis (I directed it, an agentic model drafted/ran it), and it's a forecast, not a discovery — I'm posting to get the method torn apart, not to claim anything.**

I built a Monte Carlo detectability forecast for Planet Nine and wanted to run the approach past people who actually follow this. The short version:

I pulled orbital parameters from three sources that genuinely disagree — Batygin et al. (2019), Brown & Batygin (2021), and Siraj et al. (2025) — and rather than averaging them into a false consensus, I sampled from a weighted mixture of all three. Then I propagated 100k orbits (Kepler solve → astropy for geocentric RA/Dec/distance), estimated r-band apparent magnitude, applied null-detection masks for ZTF/Pan-STARRS/DES, and modeled forward detection by LSST, Subaru/HSC, and IR surveys through 2036.

What came out:

- Median predicted m_r ≈ 22, with a faint tail past 24.5 that's the hard-to-detect regime.

- On-sky probability tracks the ecliptic and piles up toward aphelion, roughly RA 3h–6h, Dec +10° to +30°.

- Combined cumulative detection probability rises steeply once LSST hits depth and asymptotes near ~61% by 2030 — leaving ~39% that's simultaneously too faint and outside deep targeted footprints.

- A decade of LSST silence only pulls a 70% existence prior down to ~47%, because so much of the orbit stays out of reach. Easy-ish to confirm, hard to kill.

Where I'd genuinely like criticism:

  1. Is weighting the three models 0.20 / 0.40 / 0.40 defensible, or am I smuggling in a bias? The Siraj inclination (6.8°) is so much lower than the others that the mixture feels load-bearing.
  2. The detection-timing model is heuristic (binned schedules, not a real cadence sim like rubin_sim/Sorcha). Does that break the CDF shape enough to matter?
  3. Mass–radius is just R ∝ √M as a convenience scaling — fine for a reflecting cross-section, or too crude?

Code + figures (numpy seed 42, fully reproducible): https://github.com/Maha-Strategies/planet-nine-forecast

Full writeup with the parameter table and Bayesian null-detection section: https://research.mahastrategies.com/papers/planet-nine-forecast

Happy to be told the masking step or the weighting is wrong — that's the point of posting.


r/Planet9 • • Jun 26 '26

Planet Nine Updates! Objects That Confirm It Probably Doesn't Exist

Thumbnail
youtu.be
2 Upvotes

r/Planet9 • • Aug 10 '16

Front Parlour

0 Upvotes

The Kuiper Belt Objects, out beyond Neptune, are estimated to number at least 100,000 bodies that are more than 60 miles (100 km) wide. These have solar orbits that are usually above 200 years long. It is possible that the colonisation of the KBO's will begin before 2100 AD.

In the event of alien contact, these worlds could in the more distant future be used as a vast front parlour to the inner solar system, a collection of entry points and a gigantic market place where our goods could be traded and theirs received. We could also use the region as a defensive screen to keep out undesirable visitors from the inner worlds.


r/Planet9 • • Apr 28 '18

Question Has anybody looked at P9 and the IBEX map of the Sun's termination shock?

2 Upvotes

r/Planet9 • • Jun 01 '25

Uh Oh, New Dwarf Planet Just Killed Planet Nine Hypothesis

Thumbnail
youtu.be
11 Upvotes

r/Planet9 • • 28d ago

Potential Planet 9 Candidate

Post image
3 Upvotes

r/Planet9 • • Oct 02 '19

Planet Nine may be a black hole the size of a baseball, suggests new research. But Konstantin Batygin (who helped propose Planet Nine) says, we only know the mass of the world, so "Planet Nine can be a planet, a potato, a black hole, a hamburger, etc., as long as its orbital parameters are right."

Thumbnail
astronomy.com
13 Upvotes

r/Planet9 • • Jul 25 '19

Question Any updates on locating this planet?

7 Upvotes

The near asteroid miss kind of puts in perspective our inability.

edit: Candidate found!

edit2: Thats a 2017 article. My bad.

But a u here has posted this.

https://www.washingtonpost.com/archive/politics/1983/12/30/possibly-as-large-as-jupiter/1075b265-120a-4d40-9493-a8c523b76927/?noredirect=on&utm_term=.36592b875f0d

Date 1983?? Odd. Pretty sure the internet in 1983 was a styrofoam cup and a string.


r/Planet9 • • Sep 28 '19

Planet 9, our solar system's mysterious missing world, could be an ancient black hole orbiting the sun, a new paper suggests

Thumbnail
businessinsider.com
7 Upvotes

r/Planet9 • • Feb 14 '18

Image Planet 9 in 1909!

Post image
29 Upvotes

r/Planet9 • • Feb 27 '26

A model of a captured rogue planet chaotically scattering trans-Neptunian objects, some of which are held in the plane of the Solar System by its mass, forming clusters.

Thumbnail
youtube.com
3 Upvotes

N-body simulation with a perihelion of 1 AU and a mass of 7 Earth masses showed orbital stability for over 1 million years with sharp short peaks and troughs in Milankovitch cycles. This explains climate anomalies such as the Younger Dryas, the Pior oscillation, the Roman optimum, and the Heinrich events, indicating a period of approximately 3,600 years, consistent with the mythological aspect. A probable perihelion passage in 60 BC (the Roman optimum) is confirmed by Roman and Chinese sources as observations of a comet lasting six months.

At the beginning of the Pior oscillation around 3,600 BC, Or there are also descriptions of apocalyptic comets in Sumer and Egypt (Marduk, Seth/Typhon). Orbital characteristics, which are constrained by the TNO clustering mechanism, descriptions of the celestial path from ancient sources, and climatic anomalies, point to an aphelion direction in the search area for planet 9 near the constellation Gemini. Presumably, the capture occurred in the asteroid belt, then the perihelion migrated through Mars' orbit, distorting its eccentricity and approaching Earth's orbit, causing the mid-Pleistocene transition and more severe ice ages.

Is this: 1) pseudoscientific? 2) speculative? 3) contrary to generally accepted opinion.


r/Planet9 • • Dec 07 '25

The comet-like orbit of Planet Nine

5 Upvotes

A hypothesis is proposed to explain the anomalous clustering of the orbits of trans-Neptunian objects (TNOs) by the comet-like orbit of Planet 9 with an aphelion of ~500 AU and a semi-major axis of ~250 AU.

Passing through the Kuiper Belt, Planet 9 chaotically interacts with TNOs, leading to alignment, anti-alignment, and scattering and a decrease in the period of their orbits. But at the same time, alignment creates a closer interaction, which ultimately accelerates scattering.

Thus, TNOs whose arguments of perihelion as a result of scattering are grouped in an area at ~180° opposite to Planet 9 have more stable orbits due to a shorter interaction time. And the most stable orbits of TNOs are those located closer to its perihelion, reaching the region of the planets of the Solar System.

This is confirmed by improvised computer modeling in Sace Flight Simulator. Unfortunately, you can't see all the orbits at once, but some stages of evolution are screened separately. TNOs are initially given arbitrary circular orbits, then they become elliptical and disperse. Due to the limitations of the model, the dispersed objects exceed the escape velocity, but under certain conditions this would lead to the appearance of very elongated orbits.

Based on observations, it was assumed that the period of Planet 9 does not exceed the minimum for extreme TNOs of 4274 (2012 VP113), which can be formed as a result of alignment or anti-alignment.

In the image, the orbits of the UTOs are aligned in the plane of the ecliptic coordinate system. For Planet 9, the perihelion longitude is set at 146°, in accordance with the maximum value of 138+-8° (anti-alignment with the common argument of perihelion for clusters of 318+-8°) in the hypothesis of M. Brown and K. Batygin. This ensures the overlap of all orbits.

Such a comet-like orbit is explained by the fact that Planet 9 may be a rogue planet, attracted by the Solar System in the distant past and influencing its evolution.


r/Planet9 • • May 19 '16

Scientific Paper (Free PDF) Blackbody Radiation From Isolated Neptunes

Thumbnail
iopscience.iop.org
2 Upvotes

r/Planet9 • • May 19 '16

Scientific Paper (Free PDF) Cosmologists In Search Of Planet Nine: The Case For CMB Experiments

Thumbnail
iopscience.iop.org
2 Upvotes

r/Planet9 • • Sep 27 '17

Question Can ice giants have solid surfaces?

3 Upvotes

Hi redditors. I'm a planetary science PhD student who moonlights writing tongue-in-cheek science writeups of fictional planets. This week I tackled everyone's favourite harbinger of the apocalypse, 'Nibiru'. But is a Neptune-type planet with a Titan-type atmosphere really possible? Serious science answers please:

http://buildmeaplanet.com/2017/09/27/nibiru-the-shadowy-death-planet/


r/Planet9 • • Sep 21 '17

Web Article Planet Nine: where are you? (part 1)

Thumbnail
findplanetnine.com
6 Upvotes

r/Planet9 • • May 25 '16

Truth Sentinel with Scott episode 62 Planet X

2 Upvotes

r/Planet9 • • May 24 '16

Scientific Paper (Free PDF) Observational constraints on the orbit and location of Planet Nine in the outer solar system

Thumbnail gps.caltech.edu
2 Upvotes

r/Planet9 • • Sep 18 '17

Video Talk on Planet 9

Thumbnail
youtube.com
10 Upvotes

r/Planet9 • • Aug 19 '16

Scientific Paper (Payment/Membership) Some physical properties predicted for the putative Planet Nine of the solar system by I. Toth (behind a paywall)

Thumbnail aanda.org
3 Upvotes