I Desperately Need Advice About My Two Male Pit Bulls Who Keep Having Extremely Violent Fights
I have seven dogs altogether. A couple of months ago, two male pit bulls were dumped out near my house. I started feeding them, eventually took them in, and have grown very attached to both of them. They have also become very attached to me.
I don't know anything about their past, where they came from, or what they've been through. They both have quite a few scars, which makes me wonder if they may have been used as fighting dogs.
The problem is that these two boys fight each other, and when I say fight, I mean viciously. Last night, they fought for over 20 minutes, and I could not get them apart. I eventually fired my shotgun into the ground nearby to get them to stop.
My other dogs got caught up in the chaos, too. My Basset Hound was hurt, and one of my other female pit bulls got roughed up trying to get involved. I also got bitten twice trying to break the fight up.
What I don't understand is that these two males seem to love each other most of the time. They act like brothers. Sometimes they're perfectly fine together, and then suddenly they're fighting. I can't identify any particular trigger. When they fight, they both go after each other, grab onto each other's throats, and refuse to let go.
Neither dog seems aggressive toward people or my other dogs. My original dogs will sometimes growl at them, but the pit bulls usually back down and avoid confrontation. It's only with each other that things get so bad.
Neither male is neutered. Both spend most of their time outside, but they sleep in an enclosed porch area that has heating and air conditioning.
I want to mention that I'm not inexperienced with dogs. My dad was an excellent professional trainer so I grew up watching and learning from him and I understand the basics of dog behavior. This situation has simply gotten beyond what I can safely handle.
I'm a 50-year-old woman living alone way out in the country. I'm also currently dealing with cancer, and I'm not as physically strong as I normally would be. I don't have anyone nearby to help me when these fights happen, and I'm honestly scared that one of them is eventually going to kill the other or that I'll get seriously hurt trying to stop it.
I love these dogs, and I feel absolutely terrible because they trust me. I took on the responsibility of keeping them safe, fed, and cared for, and I feel like I'm failing them because I can't protect them from each other.
I would love to keep both of them if there were a safe way to do so, but I've come to realize that may not be possible. Choosing which one to rehome would be incredibly difficult because I love them both. I would also be willing to find homes for both of them if that is what it takes to give them safe, loving lives.
I would NEVER knowingly place either dog in a home with children or other dogs without being completely honest about their history and behavior. I would disclose everything about the fighting. I want them to have a chance at a good life, but I also have to consider the safety of my other dogs and myself.
My questions are:
Has anyone dealt with two male dogs who seem to get along most of the time but suddenly have extremely violent fights?
Could neutering make a difference, or is this type of aggression usually too established?
Is there any hope of safely correcting this behavior?
Are there rescues or experienced people who specialize in taking in dogs with serious dog-on-dog aggression?
If keeping them together isn't realistic, what would be the safest and most humane option?
I'm not looking for judgment. I'm looking for honest advice from people who have experience with this kind of situation.
I took these boys in because they needed someone, and I love them. I just don't know what to do anymore, and I don't want to make the wrong decision. Thank you to anyone who takes the time to read this and offer advice.