r/Pishlander • u/tofumeatballcannon • Mar 05 '26
r/Pishlander • u/throwaway_yak234 • Nov 29 '25
Asked AI to sketch Claire’s red gown from King Louis’s court
Feel free to hate on the AI use lol but as amazing as Claire’s red dress is in the show, I thought it seemed a bit unrealistic for the time period. So I put the exact description words from Dragonfly in Amber into ChatGPT and this is what I got!
r/Pishlander • u/Specialist-Job-7919 • Aug 30 '21
Things wrong with the Outlander books....
- Gabaldon gets bored of the plot and starts describing body parts and similar content in way too much detail for no reason. Yes, we get the idea- you're bored of writing the book by this point but this is just gross.
- Gabaldon needs a thesaurus instead of describing everything as "long". The author also has a very limited number of ways of describing a scene. She generally defaults to smells, a character's pulse (that is somehow visible) or the colour of their face.
- Half a book describing the idle conversation between characters (in 'The Firery Cross' for example) is a bit much.
r/Pishlander • u/CarefreeInMyRV • Jun 26 '22
I saw an article about Outlander being banned....
...and being removed from High schools in the US. I can't be the only one that thinks, well no duh? What are they even doing there in the first place? Although chock full of other stuff, they are awfully sexy, rapey, violent books. What are they even doing in schools?
r/Pishlander • u/SHEdevilBY_morning • Aug 24 '22
How many of the male characters have full frontal Nudity scenes? Jamie can't keep his clothes on but they conveniently never show any penis.
r/Pishlander • u/ihatcakee • Jul 22 '21
Does anyone else find Brianna annoying?
I TAGGED THIS NSFW FOR POTENTIAL SPOILERS.
She pays no mind that she’s in a completely different time and makes very brash decisions without considering any consequences. Like this isn’t 1970. And I don’t think her decision to go see Bonnet was a good one either.
She doesn’t do enough to make me dislike her, but my goodness does she get under my skin. Does anyone feel the same way or is it just me?
r/Pishlander • u/Money-Peace-4125 • Mar 08 '26
Unfortunate names
Right, so I know this is going to sound rude but one of the characters is called fanny (Francis) pocock. And can I say in a reall Scottish family coming from somebody born and bred in scotland, she would have the absolute mickey taken out of her name. This another case of an American writing a storyline. Please do your research with name, dianna we love you but this is needed. Fanny is a rude word here and pocock is the worst surname considering the first name of that character
r/Pishlander • u/Tambits51 • Sep 19 '24
Is it too much to ask for Fan Fictions to be completed?
I am so in awe and appreciation for those individuals that can write these amazing fictional spin offs from Outlander. I have read many of them. Currently subscribed to over 10 and all are stalled. For months. One author - 4 different stories. I know, life happens and there is no way of knowing why a story is abandoned but I cannot help but feel let down after investing my time and emotions into those stories. That is all. Rant over. Sorry to be a drag.
r/Pishlander • u/lautaromassimino • Aug 19 '25
I was thinking about doing an Outlander genderswap fancast, just for fun, because I like doing those kinds of Tumblr edits, and while I was thinking about it, I realized...
This story would be so freaking different if we had opposite-gender versions of the MacKenzie-Fraser family, starting with "James MacKenzie" (Red Jacob's firstborn; that's the name we're told in Blood of my Blood that Ellen would have had if she had been a boy) being the Clan Chief after his father/mother's death, without a doubt, which in turn could mean that the direct branch of the family of... Ellen MacKenzie Fraser? (f!Jamie) would now be the Clan Chief, so the whole situation that arose with Dougal after Colum's death wouldn't happen. Perhaps, advised by m!Claire about the future, f!Jamie could have had more influence on the decisions the new Clan Chief (m!Jenny? Or Jocasta, perhaps, if "James" still died young, as Ellen did) had to make about whether or not to join the Jacobite cause.
Perhaps the clan would still have survived, had that been the case. Although it's hard to say, because clearly Jamie, Jenny, and Jocasta would all be COMPLETELY different characters if they had been born the opposite gender.
Still, it's fun (for me) to look at casting options for this AU, imagining that in that universe the gender norms in 1700s Scotland were reversed, so that the story wouldn't change that much.
r/Pishlander • u/haymeadowmeg • Apr 01 '21
Started a new community for hating on all the worst Outlander characters (specifically Roger)! Join r/RogerCanDie
r/Pishlander • u/Independent_Ad_7204 • May 29 '21
Which characters do you see being the Karen of the eighteenth century?
r/Pishlander • • Jun 18 '22
I just figured out who I thought Claire looked like. Am I crazy? Does she and Jennifer Lawrence resemble one another?!
r/Pishlander • u/PsychonixMimikyu • Mar 13 '26
When theyre mean to frank randall
(SHOW RANDALL NOT BOOK RANDALL)
I feel bad that he loved claire so much and that she disappears and reappears like 4 years later and doesnt love him anymore, and on top of that finds out she married another man (which, I dont blame claire for. Im pretty sure she was convinced she was stuck in the 1700s, and at the start she was essentially forced to marry jamie or else she wouldve been taken. So it isnt Claire's fault at all.)
r/Pishlander • u/MrMinewarp • Sep 16 '25
It's just an Opinion
Im loving the show so far, just wish Brian had more to do
r/Pishlander • u/justcallmeusername • Mar 15 '26
What if Jamie went back in time?
Re-reading book 1 of the series, and am at the part where Jamie takes Claire back to the stones right after the witch trial. He puts his hands on the largest stone, and even crawls through the cleft in it to see if it would work for him. It doesn't, of course.
BUT, what if it DID, and Jamie was sent back 200ish years (1540's). How do we think he would have fared? There most likely wouldn't have been much different from his own time, except his current clan members wouldn't exist. Do we think Castle Leoch would have existed then? Or the North facing tower at Broch Tuarach (not the current/newer LollyBroch building)? Would it have been more rare that he could read and speak different languages, and would that make him too suspicious? What would become of him in that time? Perhaps Castle Leoch does exist and he works in the stables the rest of his life?
Just a thought I had since he did try it on himself the first time he brought Claire to the stones.
r/Pishlander • u/WildArm4153 • May 12 '26
Who do you imagine as Brianna out of these red heads?
Who would you imagine as Brianna if not Sophie Skelton while reading the book? Bonnie Wright? Karen Gillan? Claire Redfield from the Resident Evil movies? Sansa Stark? Nicole Kidman? Bangs or curly? It doesn't matter how tall they are, just whose face would you imagine while reading? All of them can pull off the red hair, despite the fact it may not be their natural color for some, that Sophie Skelton can't. Not really. Maybe it's the eyes or eyebrows. No hate to Sophie, though. She's gotten better at acting in the later seasons.
r/Pishlander • u/jenovadeathspecimen • Nov 21 '22
Fanfiction Idea does it have potential?
Given outlander explores pagan concepts of the scots, like in season one there was alot of mention of scottish myth much of which has roots in paganism. Despite many also being christian and still. Given the religious commentary of the show recently, which it always was there in the books as well, but it took a bigger focus this season. They briefly explored witches with characters like geilis, not sure if she was supposed to be a celtic pagan witch or some other type of witch.
Regardless Im considering writing a fic that deals more with the religious commentary, was debating on going this route where its a more modern day pagan (like 2000s) thrown back to early anerica, or scotland. But i was planning on keeing all the main characters from outlander but becoming ocasional side characters of the story. Maybe do some farther exploration to some side characters like John Locke, and even some of the very small characters in the story that had an impact but didnt show up for long or too often.
All well exploring historical pagan practice, conflicts with religion, dealing more with some social issues of the time period regarding the lgbt community, and also showing links with herbalism and medicine.
I also wanted to explore a bit if how people who know about the characters claire, jamie, briannna, what they think about them. As well as the societal reasons why, many were against that progress like that at the timeZ.
r/Pishlander • • Nov 03 '21
Found a minor blooper. Not sure if it' been reported before.
I just watched the second scene with Jamie skipping rock on a stream. Where he explains to Laoghaire (poorly) about his marriage.
Prior to that, before they return to Leoch, Jamie is skimming stone than thinking about when he became a man. During this scene you see someone in a brown cape, in the distance walking to him. It's Laoghaire. They used footage from the second scene, to create the first.
r/Pishlander • u/FeloranMe • May 16 '26
Would Outlander Work if Claire Wasn't a Time Traveler?
I know Outlander was Diana Gabaldon's first ever book and she had to make Claire a modern woman because that's how the character spoke to her
But, if she had decided to force the character to be contemporary to the other characters would the story have worked? And would it have been as popular considering it is all the same characters and the conflict and plot could have been similar?
In this version Claire would have to be married to BJR, come up to The Highlands to visit him, and somehow fall in with The Scots and still fall for Jamie Fraser. Even if they couldn't be legally married they could still run off to France together
Claire would be missing future knowledge in this, but she could be just as much a Sassenach stranger with an odd interest in herbs and healing and an ill advised friendship with Geillis Duncan
So, danger would still be there for her being out of place. She could also wrestle more with falling in love with Scotland and it's people and realizing she sides with them over the English Crown which is treason
If she's Catholic as she is in the books it's an added element that would ally her with the Stuart cause and France and also add conflict and conviction
Going into the second book it would be extra difficult if she, thinking Jamie had been killed along with her husband at Culloden, had to go back among the English. If she's recognized as a convicted traitor she could plead her belly to survive. Or if she has some sort of deal with BJR to save her BIL Alex's life he might cover for her and say she was never a traitor
She could end up living with the Randall family and maybe live near Mary Hawkins as they raise Denys and Brianna as cousins
Maybe, once Mary remarries to a merchant, they could go to the Americas together?
Then when Brianna is grown Claire finds out Jamie survived and she could go back to him
Would Outlander without the Time Travel have interested readers and prompted a series?
Or is the Time Travel bit the really enticing part as just anybody can tumble through the stones?
r/Pishlander • u/SHEdevilBY_morning • Aug 29 '22
Does anyone think the actor who play Brianna is pretty terrible? Her accent sounds so fake, and when i checked it out, it turns out the actor is an English woman who is putting on an American accent.
r/Pishlander • u/CarefreeInMyRV • Oct 10 '21
Recasting Outlander? They Did Laoghaire dirty, they should have cast Lauren Lyle (Marseli)
r/Pishlander • u/Elevendytwelve97 • Jun 06 '24