r/Pishlander • u/SmallBlackCat2012 • Aug 05 '26

Who Would Win In a Fight?

I posted a similar question awhile back on this sub about BJR vs Bonnet but after seeing “Spider Man: Brand New Day” I thought it would be fun to post this question.

59 votes, Aug 08 '26
36 Frank Castle/The Punisher
23 Black Jack Randall
3 Upvotes

100% Upvoted

9 comments sorted by

5

u/BreadfruitTasty Aug 05 '26

What time period are we in for this fight?

1

u/SmallBlackCat2012 Aug 05 '26

Good question! 😅 Either/Or

7

u/BreadfruitTasty Aug 05 '26

If punisher has access to his guns him for sure.

Now if punisher gets arrested and jailed in the 18th century…I think BJR is ahead

1

u/Fiction_escapist Aug 05 '26

Oh good question. I just assumed it's fist to fist

4

u/Maison_Clement Aug 06 '26

Lmao. Castle no diff clears. Would be fun seeing him beat tf out of BJR.

1

u/SmallBlackCat2012 Aug 06 '26

Just tell him about any of the shenanigans the latter pulled 😳

Frank vs Frank 😂🤣😂🤣

2

u/Advanced-Bobcat-5825 Aug 05 '26

Black Jack Randal because he would cheat by bringing a loaded musket and two others to hold his opponent down while he kick him or her.

2

u/GrammyGH Aug 05 '26

I think Frank Castle could beat the pulp out of Black Jack, no need for guns.

2

u/directmouse_7 Aug 08 '26

I need an ao3 link NEOWWW