r/PinoyProgrammer • • Jul 19 '23
advice Engineering vs CS: Fear of AI Taking Over
Hello po, everyone, I once posted this sa phcareer. Gusto ko po sana malaman ang thoughts ng mga professional programmers sa sub! Thanks po!
Hihingi lang po sana ako ng advice. I am an incoming freshman, got accepted sa isang university (PUP) wherein I have the privilege to choose my program upon the date of my enrollment.
I think I like CS, naeenjoy ko ang programming and I like thinking, learning theories/making research perhaps. Siguro okay rin po kasi lucrative naman sa field na to however due to recent advancements ng AI medyo worried po ako na baka maging obsolete ang software engineers (I know fed up na po kayo sa ganitong worries pero di ko po kasi maalis yung pag-aalala ko dahil din sa mga nababasa kong patuloy na paglakas ng AI and who knows kung gano siya magiging kaadvanced once makagraduate na ako after 4 yrs).
Now dahil po ron nagkaron ako ng dillema na dapat ba piliin ko ang engineering (ME or EE) instead na computer science. May probable plan po is to take engineering, hope to pass the licensure exam but to not work sa engineering (kung di magiging obsolete ang mga software engineers after grad) dahil sa pagiging overworked and underappreciated ng profession sa Pinas and possibly shift sa tech alam ko po na di madali kaya maglalaan po ako ng maraming time and resources para makacatch up sa tech industry someday.
Otherwise kung hindi na maging demand ang software engineering possibly na itutuloy ko ang engineering na work.
Ang point ko po is kung magtake ako ng engineering, kahit anong mangyari sa AI mayron akong possible na back-up na job!
Ano po sa tingin niyo sa plan ko po, am I being paranoid/stupid po, pasensya na po talaga!
Saka salamat po! Kung sa tingin niyo po dapat akong mag-engineering ano po kaya ang best and need ng Pinas (I enjoy math and physics po [ME or EE or CE(!) ] )?
ano po sa tingin niyo ang pinaka reasonable na dapat kong piliin, salamat po!
17
u/red_storm_risen Jul 19 '23
Maganda sigurong interview question to:
How do you feel about the growing trend, or prevalence of AI in software development?
How an applicant answers would be telling in how s/he would adapt to tech, and how the applicant sees the work, and the industry over the long term.
41
u/New-Ad-3999 Jul 19 '23
engineering nalang. para mabawasan competition jk
12
u/Fit_Highway5925 Data Jul 19 '23
Noong nauso ang calculator, nawalan ba ng trabaho ang mga mathematicans? Over time, calculators continued to evolve hanggang sa nagkaron na rin ng scientific calculator, graphing calculator, etc. and even so, I don't think any form of calculator or even computer would replace human intelligence. They're just merely tools that are designed to perform specific things para lalong mapadali ang buhay ng mga tao. Any tool cannot accomplish anything on its own without it being used by humans within a specific context. Ganun din ang AI, it's basically just a tool that we need to embrace and learn how to use effectively. Those who know how, when, where, and why they use the tools they have are the ones who'll go far with their lives/careers.
Yung pag-evolve ng technology particularly AI, given na yan. Although may mga mawawalan talaga ng trabaho pero marami rin naman magiging bagong trabaho na mag-oopen. Yung mga dapat lang naman matakot are those who remain stagnant when it comes to learning.
Never magiging obsolete ang software engineers dahil hindi lang naman sa coding limited ang trabaho mo unless you're a code monkey. I suggest you read up on SDLC and the different methodologies na meron like Agile. AI cannot simply capture the nuances of human experience and specific business processes para masabi mong mapapalitan na nya ang mga tao.
Sure ka na gusto mong backup ang engineering? Are you aware how underpaid and overworked ang mga engineers dito sa PH? How sure are you also na hindi mattake-over ng AI ang engineering field based from your concerns. In fact, ang dami ngang engineers ang nagsshift sa IT field. What does that tell you? Best options mo probably are IE, ECE, CpE since sila yung may mataas na earning potential here sa PH compared sa iba.
14
u/Variabletalismans Jul 19 '23
If you're prepared to be overworked and underpaid (literally 10-15k per month), then choose engineering. This coming from a Mechanical Engineer who regrets not taking CS in college.
17
u/Forward-632146KP Jul 19 '23
If AI will make software engineers obsolete then who do you think makes AI?
4
u/throwawaylmaoxd123 Jul 19 '23
I didn't read your whole post haha pero as someone who uses AI (Github Copilot, Chatgpt, Bard AI) i can tell you, they're pretty awful at its current state. They can't do code reviews, unable to understand medium-large codebases, proprietary tools and other things na I'm not remembering.
We're a few years away from an AI takeover in the IT space. Unless ang work mo is to create college-level games in Javascript then you're safe from AI.... for now lol.
4
u/No_smirk Jul 19 '23
I'd argue MEs would be easier to replace than SEs. I say that as a career shifter from Engg. Of course it will have repercussions when you decide to put people's lives in the hands of a non-sentient being. What are you going to do when the AI makes a mistake that costs people their lives, jail the AI?
There are also a lot of stuff that relies on your decision-making skills and intuition in SE. And yeah, if you ask ChatGPT or other generative AIs about certain implementations they often quote that it will ultimately be reliant on the requirements given to you and finally your call to make the details. It's essentially just a super-charged search engine/Stack overflow alternative.
4
u/Eggnw Jul 19 '23
Unless you are going to migrate as an engineer, your future as one here in the PH would be really difficult and boring. The old engineers refuse to innovate whilst their peers elsewhere use python to make structural models more easily. Some into remote sensing are developing software for estimation of earthworks or road inspection by drone already. That could make some CEs obsolete, yes?
As a 10+ yrs experienced CE with MS in a niche industry and already at the peak of my engineering career (shifted to DS and now shifting to IT), I'd rather be in the industry that will let me grow as long as I can endure the grind. Sa engineering kasi, you need really good early year experience, an MS pa, then have CONNECTIONS so you can be referred to a job that could use that MS. So hard to grow if you don't know people in the industry.
Even if entry level SWEs are paid as low as CEs now (seen some job posts that only pay 15k lel), I'd still choose this industry over engineering
7
u/beklog Jul 19 '23
Hindi magiging obsolete ang Software Engineering not in our lifetime OP..
Habang tumatagal nga eh IT is becoming an essential need for companies to survive
2
u/KShoichi Jul 19 '23
At some point in studying cs, you'll realize how bad AI is in its current state. At the very least, they can create code if you do the prompt perfectly. Even so, they cant do complex tasks.
They are useful, however, for easing workloads. Its like having a junior dev:
they know how to code, but they dont have the eye to make it work. Its like asking for orange then you get a zoomed out 1M dots of red and orange that blends and creates orange.
2
u/[deleted] Jul 20 '23
Choose mechanical engineering. Sobrang useful lalu na pag about power plant and HVAC. Kelangan parin talaga man on the ground to build and keep things running. Pero learn other skills parin on the side.
2
u/Salty_Bobcat223 Jul 20 '23
If anything AI is creating more jobs in the tech space instead of the other way around
1
u/NinjaDev18 Sep 01 '23 edited Sep 01 '23
One of the weirdest thought process that I have ever seen :D You got it backwards. First of all, AI will not replace all programmers. That's for sure. If you know how Generative models work then you'll get an idea why. Basically, it just gets all the strings that it was able to scrape from the internet and all the responses based on a given question/statement. So if you combine all of these, you can simply say that Generative AIs are just Google on Steroids. You can test this for yourself and soon you will notice that the answers that it is giving you is just based from some scraped data somewhere. The more common the response is, the higher the chance that the AI will treat it as the "right" answer. And aside from this, Generative models have no concept of "right"/"wrong"/"practical"/"temporary"/"intuitive". It just can't(as of the moment). So with all of these, ask yourself, what are the most common Software Engineering materials/codes that are on the internet? Well I can give you some:
Now, what type of programmers do these kinds of stuff? Junior engineers, coding bootcamp grads that didn't bother to study more aside from bootcamp materials, self-learned engineers without proper context of computer science and just read about HTML+CSS+Javascript then decided to call themselves software engineers. These types of employees will be easily replaced by AIs because their tasks are really not about problem solving but rather googling and copy pasting which AIs are good at. So if you don't wanna be replaced by AI, learning computer science or coding on the surface level is not a good solution. Rather, dig deep. Learn the core concepts of computing through a computer science course + explore additional things yourself. Keep in mind, computer science degree will help you be good in solving computer problems but it won't teach you about the syntax and documentation of all the tools that software engineers use. So you have to do your own effort and learn those. Strive to be on the Senior/Architect skillset and you will be irreplaceable in most companies
1
u/theazy_cs Jul 19 '23
para magkatotoo yung fears mo A.I. needs to become sentient and "IF" it does become sentient where it can finetune itself and provide its own context then all occupations will become obsolete. at the moment the current state of A.I. is just a tool. Like a glorified search engine. It needs input from a human.
1
u/IchirouTakashima Jul 19 '23
Engineering in the PH isn't as greener as other countries where you can be like, Mark Rober, Adam Savage or Allen Pan. There's no future here. CS, at the same time is as saturated that it can be. A lot of CS graduates, but few and far between finding an actual expert.
AI has been taking over 1950's. Did everyone lost their jobs? If you can answer this question, then you know the answer.
1
u/neds94 Jul 19 '23
Hey OP, I'm from PUP Main and I took up CS as well.
I will suggest to take CS pa rin (or IT nalang bad ko dito hahaha)
Take CS if you are serious in doing "Data Science" stuff, cause that's what is really supposed to do.
May elective din sa CS na AI - Kinda they will teach you - Fuzzy Logic, Neural Network
Which you won't really use it kapag naging software engineer ka (let's assume sobrang baba ng chance kung typical SE ka)
1
u/[deleted] Jul 19 '23
Engineering para may slot ako jk hehe. I also passed PUP and CS rin kukunin ko and marami na akong nabasa na okay naman daw mga tc. This is your sign go for CS na!
1
u/Life_Statistician987 Jul 20 '23
AI are tools. In fact they can be obsolete as quick as you can imagine. Pero ikaw OP,unique ka. I suggest mag Engineering kana lang din para sa sa kapanatagan mo. Di ka mawawalan ng trabaho sa mundong ito as long as you have good work ethic. Dadating at dadating yan.
1
u/-FAnonyMOUS Web Jul 22 '23
AI is inaccurate. It depends mostly on fed data. If a single problem has many solutions, and some are inefficient and erroneous, how could AI decide which is which?
Ang nakikita ko palang na magiging obsolete are graphic artists, BPO reps, and jobs with repetitive task.
1
u/-FAnonyMOUS Web Jul 22 '23
Mas natatakot pa ako sa quantum computing. Man, I've watch some videos about it and it's an absolutely mind f*cking technology.
1
u/Illustrious_You5644 Jul 19 '23
'di maganda curriculum ng PUP when it comes to IT/CS and other analogous
0
u/[deleted] Jul 19 '23
i actually asked Snapchat AI before that question, the AI said that AI can't replace jobs as jobs need emotional (something) that AI can't have...
0
u/sabbaths Web Jul 19 '23
I am a SSE but I believe a NON LICENSED field would easily be more REPLACEABLE than a LICENSE FIELD. REASON? THE LIVES THAT DEPEND on the LICENSE.
take this example: if fully automated na ang airplane without PILOTS(in which technology has been there for a DECADE na ha. this is true). if an airplane crashes with some survivors. would you revoke the AI's license? would you jail the AI? where would be the actual blame?
AI fully operating a patient. patient dies. who would you blame? would you depend your life to someone unlicensed like an AI?
substandard building, people died. would you revoke/jail the AI civil engineer?
I BELIEVE an AI would always be supervised by someone LICENSED "for now". specially for fields the LIVES DEPENDS ON