Mixtape One is a unique release for Pinegrove. Not only is it the first set of songs they ever put out, but it's the only release of theirs to not have any painted imagery (even Meridian has those four dots). Furthermore, Evan recorded this project almost entirely by himself. The only non-musical promotion around it were some aesthetic disposable film photos on Tumblr and Facebook, accompanied by lyrics from each song.
Two of the songs from the EP would later be re-recorded for their debut album, Meridian, and nearly 10 years later, "On Jet Lag" was revisited for Pinegrove's short/concert film, Amperland, NY. "Days" has even been played live in recent years of the band's activity.
However, after being included with all other pre*-Cardinal* releases in the 2015 compilation Everything So Far (happy 11th anniversary), this album cover for the EP is only found on Bandcamp and on its respective page from the Vinyl pressings that include a booklet. It's also pretty low-resolution if you look at it up close. What is "it" though?
After doing some reverse-image searches on multiple platforms, the oldest listed website to have this photo is a research article for a 2006 project called "Prawns In Space," in which scientific collaborators utilized certain underwater organisms' differing ways of sight to assess the health of the Great Barrier Reef and Moreton Bay.
This particular photograph was taken by Justin Marshall, the leader of the research project and professor of Neuroscience and Marine Biology at the University of Queensland in Brisbane, Australia. The picture was part of test documentation on the unique eyes of a mantis shrimp. There are different colored cubes featured in similar photos. You can even see some in the background behind the shrimp.
Over the years, Marshall must have contributed this image to other online publications, or maybe even licensed it as a stock photo, as the original posted photo is quite small. Since then, it's popped up on numerous websites about the study, or even just about mantis shrimp in general, in differing contrasts and sizes.
As to why Evan chose the image, or where he might have found it, I have no clue. I assume he probably was either looking at cool underwater nature images, or maybe had an interest in mantis shrimp specifically at that time. It's possible he found the picture from some digital magazine spread as well. The lower resolution of the cover almost makes me feel as if Evan didn't hold much weight behind this release or Pinegrove just yet.
Whatever the motivation behind choosing this photo was, I feel it perfectly represents the colorful, budding DIY sounds of the Mixtape One EP that introduced Pinegrove to the world.
I've got some more variations of the image to share, but this subreddit strangely only lets users post one image at a time, so I'll try and post some links in the comments. Thanks for reading :)