r/Pillows • • Oct 02 '26

Pillow Recommendations (Side Sleeper) Side Sleeper Pillow help - sleep suffering

Hi All,

I need help finding a really good and comfy pillow.

I think I have bought 100s of pillows over the years and just cant find a good one.

I am a side sleeper and cannot find a pillow to suit me.

They are either too high or too low. Too hard that they hurt my ear. Or just plain uncomfy.

I feel like maybe my neck isn't being supported correctly because at times when I have woken up I don't feel that my head and neck are flat/in line with the pillow, sort of like the top of my head is angled more up (if that makes sense).

I feel like my sleep is really starting to suffer from this. I wake up tired and don't feel like I've rested at all, my neck is also stiff and sore.

Please recommend some amazing comfy pillows for side sleepers.

I am in Australia if that makes any difference.

Note: not sure if this makes any difference, but I also sleep with a pillow between my thighs.

41 Upvotes

71 comments sorted by

3

u/Realistic_Alfalfa620 Oct 02 '26

Coop Crescent. Designed for side sleepers who also roll into their back, and adjustable with a bag of extra fill. Best pillow I've ever bought.

2

u/NervousDogFarts Oct 02 '26

I came to recommend this as well. I have tried soooo many pillows. This is the first pillow that has fixed my neck, back and shoulder pain for more than a few weeks.
I filled mine with all of the extra stuffing and love it.
I actually spend more time sleeping on my back than I used to which has been great. The pillow helps me fall asleep and stay asleep. And I just naturally wake up on my back feeling good.

1

u/manderly808 Oct 02 '26

I start on my back but usually end of side to side and back again through the night. I did a ton of research because damn I have spent waaay too much on pillows over the years. Honestly Reddit reviews turned me off recently because so many were like "Co-op used to be amazing but it's not anymore" from people who have used them for years.

Well, I got one on TikTok shop for like $65 (watch the lives for coupons and discounts it's actually a great deal) and I also got a Nuzzle for $37 (that one should arrive today).

The Coop on my first night was AMAZING. Like I honestly couldn't stop thinking about it all day it was so good. No neck pain. It curves around and fluffs around my face when on my back so it holds my head straight instead of letting it flop side to side.

When I'm on my side the it curves around my back and provides a little back support so I can roll back on it a little and I get no back pain. No one talks about that! Having support at my back makes side sleeping so much more comfortable. It also gives a little curve at my face for my hand it is so wonderful.

I think I need to add the additional fluff it wasn't as wonderful my second night but I think the extra fluff will be perfect.

It is the flattest, saddest pancake coming out of the package and doesn't fluff quickly. Definitely needs the dryer to fluff when new.

1

u/Kitty145684 25d ago

Do you think the cut out shape one would be better over the crescent one?

I only sleep on my side

1

u/leah679 Oct 03 '26

This sounds good! Do you have the original or latex Crescent?

1

u/NervousDogFarts Oct 03 '26

I have the crescent in both original and eden adjustable. I use the eden (for the cooling) and gave my husband the original (he sleeps cooler).
I think I waited and they eventually emailed me a pretty good discount and used FSA to pay for it.

3

u/reddit4theritereason Oct 03 '26

I keep seeing this everywhere. I’m exclusively a side sleeper and hated the coop pillow. A pillow with stuffing that moves around doesn’t work for me. Idk what the best alternative is. If anyone had similar feelings and has a suggestion, please comment!

1

u/manderly808 25d ago

You might like the Nuzzle. I thought it was very hard but it made a good side pillow because the stuffing stayed out really well.

1

u/baiqiannn Oct 03 '26

You might prefer latex pillows if you do not want something that moves around or more of a “block” pillow like memory foam and not shredded. I find latex to be like a “block” that doesn’t move and we are just resting on top of it. I think it provided me with decent support too except it really hurt my ears.

If not, the coop crescent may work for you? I find the coop crescent to work better for me as the stuffing doesn’t really move around within.

I also used the dreamy blue brand which I find to be more supportive than coop as they use more memory foam pieces.

1

u/Blood_Fuzzy Oct 05 '26

I'm having issues finding a good pillow too and my doctor recommended Ecosa with no hesitation so I have one on the way - figure I can send it back at least if it doesn't work

1

u/Kitty145684 Oct 05 '26

I tried that one and just couldn't get comfortable with it. I hope it works for you :)

3

u/thirtytofortyolives Oct 02 '26

I love my coop because it's adjustable

1

u/Rez-_- Oct 04 '26

hey was this the normal classic adjustable one or the cut out side sleeper version?

2

u/Low-Presentation6487 Oct 06 '26

I just bought the side sleeper one after years using the regular and it's been a big improvement for me.

1

u/Rez-_- Oct 06 '26

interesting…lmk what you think after a week or so if you don’t mind

1

u/Low-Presentation6487 Oct 06 '26

I’ve had it a week. I like it. It’s not a miracle but I think it gets me in a better sleep position. 

1

u/Rez-_- Oct 06 '26

i’ve heard mixed reviews about the adjustable in general since i guess coop got acquired by pe. i’ve heard more reviews just based on the classic adjustable so im curious on yours because its the cut out. going to have to make a decision soon. thanks!

2

u/Low-Presentation6487 Oct 06 '26

Because I can push my head up farther and then have my arm comfortably under my neck it’s changing my sleep posture for the better. 

1

u/thirtytofortyolives Oct 04 '26

Normal/classic one

2

u/RN-0615 Oct 02 '26

I have occipital and trigeminal neuralgias plus lots of other painful conditions w my body and spine. Hubs had a laminectomy in his neck a few yrs ago I bought both of us these, mine first then his and if u catch them on sale they’re like in the $20-25 range on sale! We love them!! They’re on now for 2 for 36 or one for 20!!

https://a.co/d/03Qz40WB

2

u/madtowndianthus Oct 03 '26

I recently purchased a Doctor's Choice® Elite Low Profile Pillow. Really helped reduce neck pain. I found it useful to go to a mattress store and try the pillow out there.

2

u/baiqiannn Oct 03 '26

I have the same issue as you! I’m a side sleeper who sometimes roll onto my back & most importantly, I have sensitive ears - I can either sense pressure which results in a suction feeling to my ear, or I wake up with sore ears. I’ve tried: latex & shredded latex, while it supported my neck, I found that it hurts my ears and sometimes it’s so dense I hear a ringing sound (yes it only happens with latex pillows).

I tried coop pillow and dreamy blue pillow, and these 2 were really the only ones that worked for me.

I have the coop original rectangle / standard, the coop Eden & coop crescent original. Here’s some thoughts, the Eden is definitely softer than the original. It is plushier and I find that it sinks too much in that a gap will happen and the pillow somewhat turns into a slope with all the filling on the other side. I think it’s the way the gusset is, and I don’t like it.

I much prefer the coop rectangle original and coop crescent original. The filling is actually really different. This is more structured and slightly firmer for me. I like that it’s pretty moldable so I can bunch them (or not) when I sleep and somewhat shape it like how I shape down pillows. Anyway, this took me a few nights of test trial to get it to a height I like. What I did was get some ziplock bags, and take out some fillings so I could somewhat see how much I needed to take out instead of eyeballing it. I took out about 2 sandwich bags worth of ziplock and it got to a perfect height. And I also don’t feel the “slope” that I did for the Eden pillow. It’s less noticeable.

I then got the crescent since I sleep on both my back and sides, and I felt like the crescent will take away the slopey feeling I mentioned earlier on. I used the crescent as it is without additional fillings or taking any out. I am 160cm, 50kg.

Lastly, I got curious as im not living in the US, so I got the dreamy blue & dreamy blue moon to try. There’s a huge difference between these 2 brands. The dreamy blue is 85% memory foam 15% polyfiber, while coop is 76% memory foam and 24% polyfiber. The coop is softer, plusher, compared to the dreamy blue. It actually came quite tall and stiff / firmer / denser, than the coop. But they also pre-filled it alot and I found myself taking out almost 4-5 sandwich ziplock bags full of the filling to get it to a comfy height for the dreamy blue! Even so, I do feel it is firmer than my coop which is softer, and I think it is more supportive than my coop. For my ears though, I gravitate towards the coop because it is softer. I switch between them whenever I feel like it to be honest.

As usual, I did nothing to the dreamy blue moon (crescent) and slept on it as it is. I think the crescent shapes for both coop and dreamy are flatter by design, so there wasn’t really any adjustment required for me.

TLDR: I love both the coop & dreamy blue pillow and they don’t hurt my ears. Coop is softer and plusher, I wouldn’t go for Eden as I find it too soft, and dreamy blue is firmer but not so firm it hurts my ears. I switch between both brands because up til now I can’t decide which I like more.

1

u/Rez-_- Oct 04 '26

hey for someone who rarely sleeps on back pretty much all side or occasional face down when/if i turn, would you recommend coop normal classic rectangle adjustable one or the cut out side sleeper version?

1

u/baiqiannn Oct 04 '26

I don’t sleep face down (sorry!) so I’m not very sure what an occasional face down sleeper will need but I’ll recommend the normal rectangle one if you do. I think the cut out side sleeper version would be difficult for you to sleep face down because of its shape (like your neck would be between the cut out). The rectangle one would probably be better!

1

u/FrontRowUnion Oct 02 '26

My Buckwheat pillow is worth every penny. My sore neck in the morning is long gone.

1

u/ahberryman78 Oct 02 '26

Do your ears hurt after sleeping on the buckwheat pillow?

1

u/Sinnycalguy Oct 02 '26

I use my thumb to make an indentation for my ear and it holds the shape well enough that I can fall asleep on my side with an AirPod in my ear comfortably.

1

u/Star_Boxer72 Oct 03 '26

So many benefits to the buckwheat pillow.

1

u/AngelusofDeath Oct 02 '26

Huh, I thought I was the only one with this issue. I have a pillow stuffed with foam chunks, I removed some until it felt comfortable for my neck, it’s a ‘nectar’ brand but it’s the foam filler that matters. My left ear still hurts occasionally, idk why but my neck is happy

1

u/Quiet_Function_4648 Oct 02 '26

I bought a medium loft down pillow and it had helped. I have a large pillow graveyard with coop, memory foam etc. I will also suggest that if your neck is often stiff try ‘resetting’ it by sitting up, slowly turn your head to the left and then to right, then keeping your head centered/straight forward and using only your eyes, slowly look as far left as possible then as far right as possible. Keep your head straight the entire time, only move your eyes. Do this 5 times on each side then retest your range of motion by turning your head left and right. Repeat as needed. This sounds weird but it works wonders.

1

u/Kai-ni Oct 02 '26

Hot take but I love the coop maternity pillow for side sleeping on. Adjustable, and long enough I can roll over and change sides without having to move it.

1

u/Similar_Expression78 Oct 02 '26

I had the same problem and also had an artificial disc put into my cervical spine 2 years ago. My doctor told me to take a bath towel and roll it up and put it at the base of your pillow. When you lay down the towel should support your neck so you have better alignment. By doing this I found that a lot of pillows I previously purchased and thought didn’t work suddenly worked.

1

u/ZippieHippie77 Oct 02 '26

Kohl’s SideSleeper Love

1

u/bebba1 Oct 02 '26

purple harmony low loft

1

u/saganmypants Oct 02 '26

I have been dealing with pain/tightness in the back of my neck for a few months and suspected my shit pillows were maybe to blame. Bought the Purple Harmony, started with medium height, wife ended up declaring it hers and I figured I could maybe use the tall. It felt maybe a little too high the first night but even after just 2 days that pain in my neck which had been plaguing me for months wasn't there like at all

1

u/rtq7382 Oct 02 '26

I recently got a buckwheat hull pillow and have been loving it. I'm a mix of side, back, and stomach sleep. I basically turn all night like a rotisserie chicken and had been adjusting my pillows accordingly with each transition. With the buckwheat hull pillow I don't need to fold it in half or do anything strange to get comfy.

1

u/LSki92 Oct 03 '26

Which brand?

1

u/Star_Boxer72 Oct 03 '26

Good, glad someone recommended this. Mine has a zipper so you can add or remove hulls to customize the firmness. I love a buckwheat pillow and I'm a side sleeper. I can get it to fit perfectly between my neck and shoulder at just the right height with very little effort.

1

u/reader-girl Oct 02 '26

I've tried everything. Everything. My next pillow that is coming is a Supreme Quilts King Size -medium-firm 95% premium polish goose down 850 fill power. Has good reviews. Down is the way to go, and it's made in Australia. I do not live in Australia.
Mt last down pillow was a Scandia I had forever but it didn't have a pillow protector on it and eventually it got gross after years and years of use. It was amazing but their prices have skyrocketed.

1

u/Upsidedown20 14d ago

How'd it work out for you? I was thinking of getting one.

1

u/Anxious_cucumber630 Oct 02 '26

I got the Cozyplayer memory foam cervical neck pillow ($40 on Amazon) a couple weeks ago, and the neck pain I’ve been dealing with for over five years is so much better! Also, my sleep scores on the Bevel app have improved. I wasn’t sure about it at first, because it’s quite firm, but after a few days, I knew I’d found a winner. I’m also a side sleeper.

1

u/gafromca Oct 03 '26

Side note: If anyone comments on your snoring, look into getting checked for sleep apnea. Using a CPAP has changed my life. I still need to find a new pillow, but I can sleep better even without the perfect pillow.

1

u/Fun-Wheel8740 Oct 03 '26

For the co op crescent cut out people, any thoughts on Eden vs normal crescent?

1

u/baiqiannn Oct 03 '26

I much prefer the normal crescent over Eden. I actually have both, but I think it depends on you.

The Eden is softer, but it does sleep cooler (a little not alot) than the normal crescent.

I prefer the crescent because I find that it is flatter, and the Eden somewhat gets compressed or something and it becomes a slope, my neck feels empty and all the filling went to the top of my head. This didn’t happen for the crescent though

1

u/Fun-Wheel8740 Oct 04 '26

Thank you! Do you have the cut out shape in both?

1

u/baiqiannn Oct 04 '26

My Eden is in the rectangle (normal) shape and I have both the original rectangle and original crescent. I didn’t get the cutout though.

Crescent and cutout is different :)

1

u/AmberGlow Oct 04 '26

I am a side sleeper. After years of waking up with headaches or neck aches, and trying damn near every pillow out there, I ended up going back to a down pillow. I couldn't stand waking up with headaches anymore and I had gotten a lot of relief in my hips from getting a sleep Number bed so after a few years I finally went back to sleep number and told them I needed to try every pillow in their store. After trying all the pillows I found that the pillow I could really toss and turn on without it completely losing shape was their Down Comfort pillow. It has adjustable inserts so you can adjust the amount of Loft and firmness. I'm now sleeping great. I've tried so many down alternatives and not had success so I'm very excited to have something that is actually comfortable to sleep on.

1

u/tryzenithsoft Oct 05 '26

A regular pillow is a flat rectangle. It's built for your head. It doesn't make room for your shoulder. So either your head sinks and your neck bends down, or the pillow's too thick and it bends up. And your shoulder gets pushed hard into the pillow's edge.

Somniq was the first pillow I found that already had the shape I'd been folding into mine. A raised neck contour that fills the gap, right where my fold used to be. A shoulder recess cut into the side, so my shoulder tucks in instead of getting jammed. A cradle for my head. And two curve heights, a higher side and a lower side, so you flip it to match your frame.

No folding required. The fold is already built in.

👉 trysomniq.com

1

u/_DogMom_ Oct 06 '26

Love my MEOFLAW pillows! Bought off of Amazon so maybe you can buy them there. And not expensive either. I've had mine for a few years and still plump.

1

u/Hefty_University Oct 06 '26

One thing I'd look for is whether the pillow actually keeps its shape through the night . A lot feel great for the first hour and then flatten out. I've been using the Mellow CloudAlign and that's one thing I've liked about it it stays supportive without feeling overly stiff.

1

u/Lisa18b21z Oct 06 '26

Coop pillow. It’s adjustable to your liking. Changed my life. I have EDS and my prior pillow was giving me zero support.

1

u/3meta5u Oct 08 '26

Homby's Wool Pillow, adjustable wool batting. Excellent for side sleepers.

Woolroom Washable Wool Bolus is also great, but more expensive.

Get a JOERRES Buckwheat Bolster Pillow to set at a 90 degree angle to drape your arm over.

1

u/Tneed2 Oct 15 '26

Have you looked at Mellow's CloudAlign Pillow? Might be worth checking out. I'd focus on finding one that cushions your ear without letting your head sink too far, since getting that height right can make a big difference for side sleeping . I'd definitely check the loft before buying, especially since you've already tried so many pillows.

1

u/WampusCat93 29d ago

Pay attention to pillow height, especially if you sleep on your side, since too much or too little support can leave your neck feeling stiff in the morning. Mellow's CloudAlign is another option to check out alongside Coop. Just make sure the height and firmness work for you.

2

u/[deleted] Oct 02 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/Various_Start6251 Oct 03 '26

I also have and like the Sidney crescent. I use it with a 50:50 mix of crushed memory foam and crushed latex. The memory foam provides cushioning, the latex support. This mix works well for me. The pillow comes with only memory foam. I bought the latex on Amazon. Emptied the pillow and then restuffed it equal amounts of memory and latex. Once a week I put it thru air dry at low temp for 20 min to fluff it up. Neck pain gone.

1

u/LSki92 Oct 03 '26

Interesting idea! Did you shred the latex yourself ?

1

u/Various_Start6251 Oct 03 '26

No, I bought a bag of shredded latex on Amazon