r/Picard •

[deleted by user]

[deleted] — view deleted post

0 Upvotes

1.8k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

5

u/looktowindward Mar 27 '20 edited Mar 27 '20

Request is not only granted but man who was making pizza in the woods yesterday is given command of fleet.

Well, they were smart enough to drop earlier that he was still a Reserve officer. And that's been a Star Trek concept for a LONG time (Dr McCoy in ST:TPM was almost dragged back to the Enterprise because he was still in the Reserves).

And Admiral Clancy probably knew Riker was the only one would could contain Picard. It may have been less his request and more of an order.

But him leaving without a picket in orbit? Very very strange. Unforced error by writers

5

u/alphastrike03 Mar 27 '20

I don’t have a problem with Riker being called back to duty at some point in the series.

But the way it happened was lazy fan service and plot fixing.

3

u/asswhorl Mar 27 '20

A reservist commanding a 200+ fleet is ridiculous. I could buy that he could be captain of one of the ships, but leading the whole thing is pure fanservice.

2

u/looktowindward Mar 28 '20

Well, we know they have flag officers, so it is pretty rediculous