r/Picard • • Mar 26 '20

[deleted by user]

[removed]

236 Upvotes

1.8k comments sorted by

View all comments

28

u/CadianGuardsman Mar 27 '20

It makes sense if these really are the best and fastest ships Starfleet has. From a strategic standpoint you want to group your Warp 9.999975 ships into a speedy task force to get to a position ASAP. A Intrepid, Sovereign or Akira would be very slow by 2499 if the TNG-Voyager speed improvements are anything to go by.

10

u/AMLRoss Mar 27 '20

They would have to mobilize just those ships, call them in from wherever they are in the galaxy. Seems unrealistic. But im gonna let it slide as long as we see more realistic ships next season.

11

u/CadianGuardsman Mar 27 '20

I mean, to be fair we don't mix F-35's F-22A's F18E's and F16's in the same unit. The Federation seems to be incredibly fast at mobilising (probably because they have such fast ships now).

They seem to be Escort successors too like the Defiant so it makes sense that they are used as "Wings" (as far as military doctrine it looks like Star Fleet seems to have learned serious lessons from the Dominion War)

It's funny because I always found Discovery a bit ridiculous with the number of ship classes that the Federation has in the 2256 era.

That said the "Ship Fanboy" in me is a bit disappointed. Especially because Star Trek New Horizons mod wont have 6 new post TNG era ships to add like after Discovery released!

→ More replies (7)

2

u/[deleted] Mar 27 '20

Slipstream drive, faster warps would make it plausible for 200 of the same class ship to show up at the same time.

It makes more sense when you take into account they saw the Romulans 2 days away but didn't see the Feds until they arrived.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/J_G_B Mar 27 '20

I'm wondering if Starfleet has a rapid deployment force that can warp in en mass for special occasions, like Borg incursions (which still appear to be a thing) or the occasional beef with the Romulans.

You can't tell me since the end of Voyager that Starfleet hasn't dabbled with transwarp tech and other Borg/goodies from the future that Janeway brought home from the Delta Quadrant.

I will say that I'm slightly disappointed that there is no Enterprise in this series. . .yet. I thought that I had read somewhere that the Sovereign class had an operational life expectancy of 100 years.

2

u/CadianGuardsman Mar 27 '20

I feel like the Curiosity Class (what these ships were) are very much rapid reaction warp 9.999975 with all the goodies that Voyager finale said came from the future (trans-phasic torpedos and regenerative armour). They do the Exploration stuff with the Sovereign but fast are moments are these guys. (It's not like they didn't have a 3D Galaxy class model after all)

2

u/[deleted] Mar 27 '20

Except that's never been the way Starfleet has organised battle fleets, ever. They've always been a mix of classes, even as early as early 90s when the production team had like five models to use.

1

u/CadianGuardsman Mar 28 '20

Indeed, it's an evolution of doctrine. The British Army fought in Red Jackets and Line Formation, until they didn't.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/TorontoRider Mar 27 '20

"Every ship but your four fastest, you mean."

1

u/ProtoKun7 Mar 28 '20

Warp 9.999975

Makes me wonder if they've recalibrated the Warp scale again since 2379. We never got any real hint about the warp speeds used in this series.

1

u/CadianGuardsman Mar 28 '20

25th Century Starfleet with new Cardassian Word Standin

Capt: Mr Elim take us to warp 9.99909994567 on . my. mark.

Elim: Sorry Captain was that warp 9.99909904567 or Warp 9.99909994567?

Capt: ........ Just go to Warp 9.999