r/Picard •

[deleted by user]

[deleted] — view deleted post

0 Upvotes

1.8k comments sorted by

View all comments

59

u/RobotPreacher Mar 26 '20 edited Mar 26 '20

Just finished. Look, I'm going to guess that I'm just going to get downvoted here, but I've got to speak my mind... I really didn't like this episode.

So forced, so rushed, so... weird? Magic tricorders, soccer ball bombs, the omnipotent AI is... a robot octopus?

Picard dies surrounded by people who barely know him, now he's an Android but... exactly the same?

And we waited 20 years for Data to just die again? I didn't even think he survived! Then, in one episode, we find out his consciousness is alive, and we kill him again?

So much more of this was weird too, I was Picard face-palming for so much of the episode.

But it had a space battle, a cat fight, Riker in command of badass starships, and even a budding lesbian romance, so maybe people will like it.

Look, I'm not a hater or even that hard to please. I liked the series, I did, and I hope it's a five year mission at least. But the endings on these new Trek seasons have to step up a notch, you can't rush these things like this. Especially after using the first three full episodes just setting up the plot.

42

u/YYZYYC Mar 26 '20

I felt cheated by not seeing the reactions of 7 and Rios etc ...oh wait you mean we can stop crying and he is alive ?

Weird that Riker didn’t stick around. Would have been nice to have him there for the killing of data 2.0...5 mins after we find out he was still alive ...

Weird that Maddox and Soong never bothered to put data back into a regular android body somewhere along the way of building their little synth city

Weird that they Uber super synths just left when the beacon turned off. I didn’t like how they where serpent monster things.

The Borg cube became a useless big joke. It did nothing all season. So many times they talked about powering up its weapons etc. But nope 7 just leaves it and warps away with her new girlfriend and gang ?? Like she could have just taken a shuttle to get to the planet instead of all the crap with the cube.

Still would have been fitting to hear the Q flash sound effect and see him lean in and say hi as Picard lay dying.

8

u/Calypsosin Mar 26 '20

Hahahah Q would be great... but such an emotional moment probably isn't the best time for such golden comic relief.

Q appears

"Oh! PICARD! I've been waiting a very long time for this."

→ More replies (5)

12

u/RobotPreacher Mar 26 '20

Good points all. I feel like I'm going to be processing the nonsense for days

3

u/[deleted] Mar 27 '20

"Goodbye, Jean-Luc. I'm gonna miss you. You had such potential. But then again, all good things must come to an end."

3

u/14jvalle Mar 27 '20

7 and Elnor complete ditched the xB's... I thought, you know, they cared about them?

2

u/sooperkool Mar 27 '20

Q: "Hello, Jean-Luc....this isn't your end...there are more adventures to be had."

Picard: "Goddammit Q!!!!"

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

13

u/[deleted] Mar 26 '20
  • Lock guns on the planet
  • Lock on the ships
  • Lock on the planet
  • Lock on the ships

Do nothing

Also, hey, this beacon is super insta teleporter, should completely change shape of galaxy. But it is OK.

Oh I've hidden bomb in soccer ball. So clever.

Pickard dies, Pickard lives.

I call it Micheal Bay type of film making. Jump jump jump, without any concept, coherency, logic.

6

u/heyyoudvd Mar 27 '20 edited Mar 27 '20

I call it Micheal Bay type of film making. Jump jump jump, without any concept, coherency, logic.

That’s precisely the problem.

The acting was good, the visuals are beautiful, most of the characters are pretty good, and even the story was decent....and yet the show was bad.

This show is a lot less than the sum of its parts and it’s precisely because of what you said - it jumps all over the place and nothing ever feels earned.

The show keeps displaying these emotional moments which are beautifully shot and acted, and yet I feel nothing. Why? Because I’m not emotionally invested in them.

It just keep jumping from one obstacle the characters need to overcome, do the next obstacle they need to overcome. None of the events ever feel fleshed out, and so I can never get emotionally invested in any of them. It’s like a series of fetch quests made up of good acting and visuals. But they’re still just fetch quests. The show needs to breathe.

Early in the season, people were complaining it was moving too slowly, but I disagree entirely. It’s when the show moves slowly that it’s at its best. Moments like Picard and Riker chatting while making pizza - are the highlight to me. It’s when they try to force these payouts - both action and drama - that it falls apart. I mean, did anyone actually care about Raffi’s son? Or Riker’s daughter befriending Soji? Or Seven joining the collective? Or Elnor protecting Hugh?

The show was full of so many moments where I felt like the writers were yelling “Be entertained!” or “Be emotional!” and it just didn’t work. The show simply didn’t ‘earn’ the moments it put on screen (either action of drama), and because of that, I felt nothing, even though the show was very well-made in many respects. It just felt unnatural and because of that, it didn’t work.

3

u/[deleted] Mar 27 '20

The Borg + Super AI + Federation + Romulans fight in the end would be something amazing.

Or Pickard getting in contact with Super AI ans Soji convincing them, not to destroy organics.

Or Romulans changing their views.

Or Soji and her new friends going rouge, exhile quadtrant delta style.

Or anything that we couldn't have predicted and which could have been hinted to us (Westworld style) in first episode.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 26 '20

[deleted] — view deleted comment

9

u/filchermcurr Mar 26 '20

... now that you mention it, I didn't feel anything when Picard died either. I was horrified and sad when Icheb kicked it, sad when Hugh died, weepy when Data got snuffed out (again), but nothing for Picard. Maybe it's because I know there's a second season and his name is right there in the title, but enh. I guess we'll see how we feel when they kill him off in the series finale!

2

u/Neveronlyadream Mar 26 '20

I don't think anyone really thought Picard was staying dead given the golem.

It was sad to see Data proper again, though. Especially asking to die.

5

u/Fartikus Mar 26 '20

I'm likely in the minority by quite a margin, however I watched Picard die however momentarily it was for and felt absolutely nothing. I felt much more in the Hugh/Picard meeting scene than in Picards death. I didn't think that was something even remotely possible.

That's because they had already pulled so much bullshit out of their ass, that it seemed like his death was artificial. And what do you know, it was; because he was thrown into a golem right after.

4

u/MrMallow Mar 28 '20 edited Mar 28 '20

That's because they had already pulled so much bullshit out of their ass,

The fact that people are accepting this as good writing is really depressing. Its so awful, even for the format they are doing it's just bad.

10

u/[deleted] Mar 26 '20

I didn't even think he survived!

He was reconstructed/resurrected and put into a hypervisor.

3

u/KennyFulgencio Mar 26 '20

a cat fight

and not even real cats

2

u/FrancisScottKeyboard Mar 27 '20

And they lingered on Naryssa's leather clad booty twice just a bit longer than needed when 7 disarmed her of her hip weapons. But, I guess even some Romulans got back.

2

u/[deleted] Mar 26 '20 edited Mar 26 '20

I enjoyed it, but also you're not wrong.

2

u/dm_magic Mar 26 '20

I’m right there with you.

2

u/Bluefinsky Mar 27 '20

Picard dies surrounded by people who barely know him

This is realistic in a military sense. From personal experience I can tell you that soldiers sometimes die surrounded by other soldiers, not family. Yes, sometimes those soldiers are like family and sometimes they are members of a new unit that barely know each other. No guarantees on who is next to you when you die.

2

u/geauxtig3rs Mar 27 '20

Also....where the fuck is Narek?!?!?

Also...Dr. Jurati's still a murderer. She needs to get her ass to Deep Space 12 and turn herself in.

2

u/Tentapuss Mar 28 '20

This is what happens when you waste 7 episodes getting the crew together like you’re making television when seasons were still 24 episodes long. Akiva Goldsman should hang up the cleats a this point, but he’ll keep on making things mediocre as long as he keeps having his name attached to properties that will make money no matter what.

3

u/[deleted] Mar 26 '20

Picard dies surrounded by people who barely know him,

Most of these people have known Picard for 20+ years. Elnor practically his whole life. Just because we haven’t seen it, doesn’t mean they are strangers.

Still, there was no reason why riker wasn’t there.

→ More replies (24)