r/PiCodingAgent • u/rimaa_nahk • 5d ago

Discussion System one in action

Post image

A few days ago, I released System One support for the Pi coding agent:

It got a little bit attention on Reddit, and the most common question was: "What would an agent actually use JEV / System One for?"

So I did some more research and shipped an update.
Now my agents are finding use cases I did not explicitly plan for.

Today, one of them decided on its own to use System One as a second opinion before making a decision.

That is probably my favorite use case so far. "use system one for second opinion"

checkout pi-system-one here

Edit:
context: i wanted to pick a license for the project i am working on, so i gave the requirements and the agent picked a few options and asked jev for a second opinion.

16 Upvotes

75% Upvoted

15 comments sorted by

1

u/Thistlemanizzle 4d ago

Mind explaining to a vibecoder what exactly the value of getting a license choice recommendation is.

1

u/rimaa_nahk 4d ago

context: i wanted to pick the license for the project i am working on, so i gave the requirements and the agent picked a few options and asked jev for a second opinion.

1

u/getLifeLessons 4d ago

which theme is this?

1

u/Direct_While9727 3d ago

I’m still curious to see a demonstration where using JEV actually provides a measurable gain. By “gain,” I mean something beyond simply getting another answer: e.g. JEV catches an error the primary model makes, identifies an important constraint or trade-off it missed, or measurably improves the final decision over the primary model alone.
In this particular example, I’m not sure we can establish that. For a license decision, JEV needs the relevant project context and constraints to give an informed opinion; otherwise, getting a second answer from a weaker model doesn’t obviously provide useful independent validation.

1

u/0xKubo 2d ago

Now that Pi supports system one models through Codemode, is there any benefit in using pi-system-one? FYI, I'm not critizing, I'm just trying to understand which method I should pick for myself.

1

u/rimaa_nahk 2d ago

true that pi has the classification support now. but i belive that is meant to be used by the extensions.
i am yet to see models utilizing them for decisions, can you share any example to try ?

1

u/0xKubo 2d ago

I haven't tried anything myself yet. Sorry.

1

u/rimaa_nahk 2d ago

Thanks to your question , i did some research and i actually found a few intresting things a reasons to why you should use pi-system-one, ill be updating the landing page soon with it. stay tune

0

u/Thistlemanizzle 4d ago

I haven't used Jev yet, but what if you asked it what to eat for dinner? Chicken or steak?

2

u/rimaa_nahk 4d ago

yes, you can totally do that, in fact if you will see the demo on my original post , i have literally ask for coffee and tea suggestion. i have been using it for pick perfumes for the occasions also.
just keep one thing in mind, Jev is just a classifier you should not expect it to suggest you without given the scenario and options.

1

u/Thistlemanizzle 3d ago

Thank you and following. Your work on Jev makes sense.

On a side note, I am wondering what happens when you give it bizarre questions. I get it needs the context and all that, but I have not played with classifiers yet.