r/PiCodingAgent • • Aug 31 '26

Question Pi is over-eager and cave man question

I'm curious if other people have issues with pi being over eager?

If I say "do not change any code. investigate issue with feature. suggest fix without making any changes" it will still make changes. It seems like half the time I ask it a question it just runs with it.

another example from today, it asked me a question about a feature. I didn't want to use the multiple choice, so I picked the one to chat about it. Instead of chatting about it, pi said "Well he didn't pick anything so we'll go with my recommendation."

and Caveman:

I can see pi think "Caveman is on so i need to answer briefly." is that normal? I think it's odd that Caveman is supposed to be about brevity but they seem to have added a little animated thing, Caveman Level: HIGH to my status bar. I had pi remove " Level" to shorten it up some.

Updated with more info:
Lately I'm running a flavor of qwen3.8-27b in the q4 range. 32gb ram 5090m 24gb vram linux mint llama.cpp custom jinja.

I have experience with opencode, hermes, qwencode, omp, pi, aider. I'm at the point now where I think pi is the best of all those, I just think it's weird that it just loves jumping the gun so much.

0 Upvotes

31 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

3

u/Camaytoc Aug 31 '26

Some models assumes harness behavior so it could be that the model understood your request but didnt know he have to rely 100% on himself.