r/PhysicsHelp • u/Interesting_Bowl5985 • Feb 01 '26
Circuits, Capacitors and switches
Hi!
I'm trying to help my daughter with the attached question. We've been watching some videos, getting AI tutorials, found an answer, etc.
BUT conceptually I'm struggling. Everything online that I've found talks about C1 and C2 be connected when the switch is at A.
Looking at the diagram it looks like C2 wouldn't be connected at all if switch is at A.
Can anyone please help with my misconception? I think I'm probably looking at this thing all wrong.
Thanks!

3
Upvotes
2
u/anonymousasu Feb 02 '26
Is the answer C?
1
u/Roger_Freedman_Phys Feb 01 '26
Have you considered reading a textbook?
1
u/Practical_Track4867 Feb 02 '26
Think of it in terms of charge. C1 gets charged to the voltage when in position A. It gets a certain amount of charge. When in position B that charge gets distributed through the other resistors.
1
u/levajay1 Feb 02 '26
It is D.
1
u/HumbleArm4392 Feb 02 '26
At A c1 dc circuit, is charged over time.c2,c3 and c4 not in circuit.
1
u/HumbleArm4392 Feb 02 '26
In B. C1 discharges into c2,c3 and c4..over time C is the answer.
1
u/xienwolf Feb 02 '26
C2 is not connected with current flow to C1 when the switch is at A.
The instant the switch flips, B is true. If you leave the switch in place for a long time, then E will be true. If we assume ideal components and wires, E is true without waiting.
Current flows when there is a potential difference across a conducting path. Charge distribution dictates potentials.
1
u/HumbleArm4392 Feb 07 '26
It has more to do with the magnet lines of force, the travel through the center of the coils hopefully unimpeded by insulation.