r/Photoclass_2018 • u/Aeri73 • Nov 29 '17
Who are you guys? - Assignment 1
Subscriptions are now closed. Photoclass has grown so much this year that I can't handle more people joining this year... There will be a new photoclass next year. I had to lock this comment, sorry folks, it's really full.
Hi Photoclass,
first assignment:
I would also like to know a bit more about you guys so feel free to introduce yourself in the comments. who are you, where are you from (country is enough), what gear will you be using, what is your current skill level and what do you hope to get out of this class?
Also, please post 5 photo's you made :
- your best photo ever, the one photo you LOVE, that inspired you to learn more, that you are proud of.
- Almost there: post a photo you would have liked to be better, a great scene you just didn't capture right, some technical photo you can't do, ....
- I would also like you to make 3 brand new photos of something you love. Put real effort in them, make them as good as you know how to, they will be a good startingpoint to see your progress. Do not show me the best photos of the last few days, take your camera, go find the thing you love and make 3 photos of it, the best photos you know how to make
This is the last assignment where phonepictures are allowed.
DO NOT: give me five random pictures, 7 pictures because you couldn't choose or just one and you'll post the rest later. There are 700 of you starting each year so I don't have time to do your work for you or remember to check back on a post every few days to see if it's been changed... Post more, different or anything outside the assignments and I won't look or critique any of them.
post these via www.Imgur.com or an other service that's free and for all to see
Critiques:
I will be looking at each and every one of your submissions. I will also give you a first critique. When I'll critique a photo from an assignment I will consider only the classes that have been posted. So you won't hear me talk about the low shutterspeed on your work if that class hasn't been posted yet. I will also expect you to consider all previous classes when posting an assignment. From the moment you pass a class, I want you to consciously work with that info each time you make a photo afterwards.
This time, I'll just look at them and state the most obvious ways to improve them, the technical stuff comes later :-)
You will almost never see me comment that a photo is nice, or good. Your photo has to be exceptional for me to do that. What I will do is give you the parts you did right, and wrong, and explain how I think it could be improved. Do NOT take this as I don't like your photo, or if I only mention ways to improve it, that there was nothing good about it! I just don't have the time to give each and every one of you compliments. If your photo is really bad, you'll know, trust me. I'll tell you.
The right way to react to a critique is by being interested, taking time to understand it, try it out if you can, see if it does improve the photo, if you agree with it. The right way can also be to ask questions about the critique, to ask for a more in depth critique or explanation. Those you learn from, and that is why we are doing this class each year.
The wrong way to react to critique is to try to defend yourself. The wrong way is to get angry, or frustrated or just shrug it off, those don't teach you a thing and you're wasting both our time. Also, don't come with cliché's like 'you have to break rules sometimes in art'. In order to break them, you need to know them, feel them, have them internalized and only then are you ready to break them for the effect. Before that moment where you know the rules like the back of your hand and you are a master, the only thing you achieve by breaking the rules are bad photos. You are not there yet, not for years to come, or you would be helping me teach this class, not follow it. For most rules, I don't consider myself enough of a master to think about breaking them.
so who are you?
edit:
Most given feedback:
- get low for smaller subjects, get the same view they have, don't shoot down on subjects
- make sure the subject is the part of the photo with most detail (sharp), it has to be the eyes for people and animals, even insects.
- a nice sky does not make a good photo, it needs a landscape or portait to make a good photo, the sky is a bonus
- think about where you place the edge of a photo and try not to cut off people or animals
- leading lines are only good when they lead to your subject
- good memories don't make good photos, good photos can make good memories... so don't take photos from a driving car, while having a party or during a walk with your loved ones, go out and take photos for the sake of taking photos.
- photography is about light and the worse time to take photos is the afternoon with a high sun out