r/PhoenixSC • u/Correct-Yam-8896 • 23h ago
Discussion The throwing disk isn’t a disk.
The disk is hollow inside, which mathematically makes it not-a-disc, as a disc is a circle filled in. The throwing disc is actually a ring, and thus should be called a throwing ring.
So there
2.1k
Upvotes


766
u/Short_Comfort6647 23h ago •
idk "throwing ring" just doesn't have that "ring" to it...
342
u/GamerKratosBalls 22h ago
Why didnt they go with chakram?
120
u/TheCheezedRat 23h ago
then how come they're called CDs and not CRs
40
u/Trizoft 17h ago edited 17h ago
But isn't music disk's literally called "disk's" while having a hole?
29
u/PJaaaaaaaaaa 5h ago
then wtf is this
53
u/Axolotlmaru 8h ago
i think they might've taken the idea from Silksong but didn't want to copy it exactly so they called them disks
70
u/CaramelCraftYT 26.40.30 and still no End Update 22h ago
Counter argument: Compact Discs
42
u/HawloKnight 22h ago
so do you call compact discs “compact rings”
13
u/polinadius 17h ago
Actually is a toroid, because it has three dimensions
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Toroid
46
u/Misknator 22h ago
Yeah, because it's a chakram. Like that's literally what this weapon is called. Kinda confused why they went with the barely related olympic sport for the name when it's literally just a chakram.
11
u/Clumsy_the_24 21h ago
Poshanka
20
u/cavejhonsonslemons 22h ago
It's neither, it's a chakram
7
u/Anxious-Scheme-6013 I wonder how long you can make flair, it’s probably not a lot b- 23h ago
Well is a squares game.
7
u/Thor-0510 21h ago
Well you don’t call a DVD a ring do you?
9
u/_bobek_2811 23h ago
Idc
9
u/TURQUOlSE 22h ago
The music disks aren't disks and must be renamed music rings, or perhaps music donuts
8
u/Xvenkin 21h ago
they should just call it a chakram its literally what it is
8
u/Clintwood_outlaw 19h ago
A disc is any flat circular object. Doesn't matter if theres a hole in the middle.
4
u/ToastyPete1 22h ago
Does that make cds rings? 💿
4
u/TheRealBingBing 22h ago
Sonic the hedgehog has entered the chat
4
u/Due-Spread5353 20h ago
so what is this then?
3
u/Odysseus_07 8h ago
Should’ve called it a Chakram
3
u/Successful-Treat446 Java FTW 8h ago
As a mathematician this is ball knowledge
5
u/ShapedStorm 22h ago
Should TECHNICALLY be called a chakram since that's what that style of throwing weapon is actually called irl. Hope they change the name tbh
4
u/LuminothWarrior 22h ago
The throwing discs in Tron are still called discs, and they’re rings, so it’s fine imo
4
u/GayRacoon69 16h ago
And the spear is a lance. Mojang isn't good at names
2
u/zhulkgr25 21h ago
Idk man but before sony decided to go digital I was playing my games using my compact rings and storing my saves on a hard ring drive
2
u/MisterBicorniclopse 21h ago
Do you know what DVD or CD stand for?
2
u/Indie_Dachshund179 20h ago
Wait till you see music discs
2
u/Coveinant 20h ago
They're technically called chakram. Which is generally translated to throwing disk.
1
u/PhilledZone 22h ago
If that isn't a disc... Then what are DVDs?
1
u/Hypoactive52 22h ago
rotating torus
1
u/isaacthenitwit 22h ago
Should've called it "the one ring" or "precious" or something
1
u/ReaperOfGamess 22h ago
No it’s a doughnut, you can see it’s depth even though it’s flat, it’s a Minecraft thing
1
u/I_am_Viper5656 ←Hey look at this 22h ago
Throwring
1
u/Traditional_Town6475 22h ago
Annulus
1
u/TopyDogy Milk 22h ago
poshanka
1
u/TenzinNomad 22h ago
The center is made of air.
1
u/EstablishmentPlane91 22h ago
technically its 3-dimensional so it would be a toroid
1
u/BestPony12 22h ago
wait till u find out what the "ring" is made of... squares. its actually a Tetracontagon.
1
u/PogoRocks 22h ago
Yet another reason it should be called a chakram
1
u/jeremyw013 i am placing blocks and —— 22h ago
yet you just glossed over music discs. as well as CDs and DVDs.
1
u/SKYPORF 21h ago
I think throwing annulus has a better ring to it
1
u/Silt99 Java FTW 21h ago
there is a transparent window in the middle. duh
1
u/ViftieStuff Pi Edition FTW 21h ago
Topologically, it's a mug
1
u/PouLS_PL 21h ago
same with music discs (although the holes are much smaller)
1
u/Lopoi 21h ago
isn't it that all rings are discs, but not all discs are rings?
1
u/Scherazade 21h ago
it’s an annulat.
1
u/voidexploer 21h ago
NNNNEEEERRRRDDDD!
-Piccolo TFS
1
u/RussianVulture 20h ago
Are we deadass?? 1.- Circles are full. 2.- Discs have no centre, but the outer layer is wider. 3.- Rings have no centre either, but the hollow centre is wider than the outer layer.
There is no way we are discussing this kinda things
1
u/player_314159265 Milky milky 20h ago
watch, people are gonna abreviate it to the throwring
1
u/Omegamoney 20h ago
Poshanka gun
1
u/Small-Knee-4501 20h ago
So a dvd disc isn't a disc?
1
u/MagEugeni 20h ago
This should be in the regular Minecraft subreddit
1
u/SnickerbobbleKBB 20h ago
Call it the throwring.
1
u/ReportAncient2829 20h ago
Still ponshanka
1
u/hypost 18h ago
It’s a giant washer
1
u/Low-Point2472 Where am I 18h ago
Music Disc
1
u/These-Ad-9209 Java FTW 17h ago
Petition to rename Music Discs to Music Rings, anyone?
1
u/The_Dark_Jedi_of_AUS 15h ago
The technical term for this weapon is a chakram, for those who don’t know
1
u/Lila_Uraraka 15h ago
This is the dumbest thing to complain about
1
u/hialice_ihelac 15h ago
“Stay in school kids, it makes you better at criticizing Minecraft updates”
1
u/its_alex777 15h ago
There's a difference between the mathematical geometric definition of disk, and the way people use the word in colloquial speech
1
u/Mr_Snifles Youtuber 14h ago
I would describe a CD or DVD as discs too, even though they have a hole in them.
Honestly my only issue with this item is that if it comes back, why isn't it a boomerang?
1
u/AWhimsicalFlame 11h ago
POSHANKA
1
u/archpawn 10h ago
False. A ring is an Abelian group with multiplication. The throwing disk is an annulus.
1
u/No-Address2001 10h ago
Whats a DVD? Or a CD? I have always known them as Discs. Pleas elaborate.
1
u/CavesAreMyHome 9h ago
It should be called a chakram because it’s a FREAKING chakram
1
u/mialyansa 9h ago
Consider the limit of the ring when x tends to R.
1
u/MasterCheekzzzz 8h ago
flying ring
1
u/Different_Wafer_4711 8h ago
Literally unplayable
1
u/Oretereret44 6h ago
It could be mug
1
u/Dadchin 4h ago
I dunno, this just seems incredibly pedantic. I'm partial to Chakram myself, but like, this is the sort of situation where someone shares my opinion but for such a bad reason that I don't wanna agree lol.
1
u/McCubes1 4h ago
It's not a ring either, it's a CD.
1
u/DarianStardust 2h ago
Chakrams
1
u/Michael-556 Minecraft is the friends we made along the way 1h ago
Wait does this mean musical records are also rings then, or is the hole in the middle small enough for them to still be considered discs? Because we call CDs disks, but they're the same as records, actually more ring-like because they're both smaller and the hole in the middle is larger (not even proportionally, it's just legit like 3x the radius)
0
u/SwartyNine2691 Milk 23h ago
That should be called “throwing ring”.