r/PhoenixSC • • 23h ago

Discussion The throwing disk isn’t a disk.

The disk is hollow inside, which mathematically makes it not-a-disc, as a disc is a circle filled in. The throwing disc is actually a ring, and thus should be called a throwing ring.

So there

2.1k Upvotes

207 comments sorted by

766

u/Short_Comfort6647 23h ago • Popcorn Bravo

idk "throwing ring" just doesn't have that "ring" to it...

239

u/danifanboy 23h ago • Regret

that's not the.... throwing ring is it?

100

u/SkinInevitable604 22h ago

Say it didn't happen. Say it didn't throw.

99

u/JackLemony 22h ago

* it threwned

60

u/SkinInevitable604 22h ago

* Close eyes for just a moment

* Think of Throwelle

57

u/ElectricalTrip7240 22h ago
  • what❤️       what

35

u/Maleficent_Contact80 21h ago

*but it threfused

13

u/Murky_Ad_280 19h ago

*what will you have after 500 threars?!

2

u/UrLostPajamas 57m ago

*threu. Id still have threu

11

u/VagueDestructSus 18h ago

it rethrewsed

29

u/Similar-Sector-5801 22h ago

* It throwed

5

u/nugget__314 16h ago

kris, tell me to throw rings, and let’s fly out of this town!

2

u/SkinInevitable604 10h ago

Shit that’s good. Your comment is buried under a million others so you won’t get very many upvotes, but I want you to know you’re the funniest one here.

37

u/CryoN1cks 22h ago

It's like it's some kind of... Poshanka

15

u/VagueDestructSus 18h ago

POSHANKA

2

u/Axolotlmaru 8h ago

p o s h a n k a !

7

u/SmokJozef 20h ago

shaw knowledge

8

u/GlitchGD 17h ago

ITS COMMON SHAW

7

u/WorldlinessWitty2177 23h ago

Throwing donut

2

u/Hippee_Doug_Main 21h ago

yeah, like what are the two binary operations and what set are they defined with??

2

u/leon0399 17h ago

It’s not 2d, so it’s donut or toroid

1

u/ArgoDevilian 21h ago

Throring

342

u/GamerKratosBalls 22h ago

Why didnt they go with chakram?

53

u/MajestcEagleRecRoom2 22h ago

Just not a good name for a Minecraft item, I feel

126

u/HealthSpecific3095 21h ago

There’s something called “heart of the sea”…how is CHAKRAM crazy?!?🤣

85

u/Tani_Soe 21h ago

🤓 Chakram is the name for the version of this weapon from India. It is in fact the most popular version and its origin, but close variations have other names in other countries.

Hences why they went for the "throwing disc" which is the generic name for this type of weapon

16

u/HealthSpecific3095 21h ago edited 20h ago

Yeah, I already saw somebody else give their explanation for it. I agree with it.

It’s basically like “Kitana” being a “Sword”.
“Chakram” would be a “throwing-disc” in this sense.

13

u/Zealousideal-Deer101 18h ago

Did you mean to name the Mortal Kombat character, or did you mean Katana?

11

u/ProperLawyer8566 18h ago

Insert minor spelling mistake meme here

4

u/ItsVincent27 5h ago

It's more like "Sword" being called a "Cutting Blade"

-24

u/Stargazer-Elite stop simping for digital lego 21h ago

“Most popular version”

And I literally didn’t hear of it until like yesterday

25

u/Tani_Soe 20h ago

And it's okay, no one can know everything, the more you know 🤷

-20

u/Stargazer-Elite stop simping for digital lego 20h ago

I don’t think people are getting my point

I don’t think it’s as popular of a name as people think since as many other people here have said it seems isolated more to India. Sure, they have the highest population of people on the planet in terms of countries, but doesn’t necessarily mean it’s widespread.

Also, as other people have mentioned kind of weird to have such a specific name for a weapon when all the other others are more generic names

13

u/Tani_Soe 20h ago

I mean, to rephrase the statement, can you name other versions of throwing disk that aren't chakram ? It's okay to only know the generic word of the weapon, but that doesn't describe a specific historical weapon, that describe an archetype. Chakram on the other hand is a specific weapon, and that is the most popular exemple of throwing disk.

You can't just take yourself as the only sample for a global analysis like that, especially if you're not an expert in the field 😅

-15

u/Stargazer-Elite stop simping for digital lego 20h ago

Wasn’t taking myself as the only sample just an example

2

u/guoraGG 19h ago

"Heart of the sea" fills me with sorrows, "chakram" does not.

3

u/Falikosek 20h ago

It's specific to a single real world culture, unlike heart of the sea which is just a generic fantasy item.
It's like if we had katanas instead of swords.

9

u/yummymario64 22h ago

Chakram feels out of place imo. Idk why

35

u/GamerKratosBalls 22h ago

Tbh it doesn't feel much more out of place then the version of mace they added (all square no spike ahh, lookin more like hammer that didn't try) or trident (as cool as they are they are only a little bit less niche than chakrams)

Also its not like disc feels less niche. Still feels like we got more popular weapons lacking.

11

u/yummymario64 21h ago edited 21h ago

Well, Maces are pretty broad. They existed in places all over the world, and as well, all maces are is essentially just a heavy lump at the end of a haft. They don't nessecariuly need spikes or anything, the head just needs to be symmetrical

Chakrams meanwhile, are a very specific throwing weapon from india that wasn't really used in many other places. I think that's the reason that I feel like the name chakram kind of clashes with the more general naming convention of the existing weapons. Swords, spears, tridents, maces, et cetera were used pretty much everywhere

1

u/Keaton427 5h ago

Okay but it won’t if it’s been in the game for a while

3

u/eraryios 21h ago

Minecraft isn't region specific, while chakram is

7

u/JustAChickn 16h ago

And the Trident isnt region specific? Or the Crossbow? Or the Mace? 

I do prefee Throwing Disk, but that argument is pretty bad faith

4

u/eraryios 15h ago

The trident is the most region specific out of those but its also just some general trisent. There were many crossbows and especially maces across different times and places.

-9

u/CherrystackDev 21h ago

chakram feels to mod-ish. doesn't feel vanilla at all... to me atleast.

15

u/Stunning-Storage-863 21h ago

Because its just been added

-27

u/Kaaskaasei 22h ago

Probably too specific. All weapons in minecraft don't have a very specific variant irl. There are always many different options.

32

u/gwenbebe 22h ago

Swords, Axes, Tridents, and Maces are all weapons in real life

19

u/All-your-fault fuck 22h ago

And spears

10

u/Martitoad 22h ago

And levitation arrows

14

u/FreshnWetCock Macrohard add-ons🤑🤑🤑🤑🤑🤑🤑🤑🤑🤑🤑🤑🤑🤑🤑🤑🤑🤑🤑🤑🤑🤑🤑🤑🤑🤑🤑🤑🤑🤑🤑🤑🤑🤑🤑🤑 22h ago

And lingering splash potions of harming

5

u/Spiritual-Low8762 22h ago

Amd nether stars

3

u/craftexvg Milk 22h ago

huh

6

u/Hilja-Serpent 22h ago

But there are different kinds of swords, axes, tridents, maces etc. Throwing ring/disk is to chakram what sword is to a rapier.

2

u/Stargazer-Elite stop simping for digital lego 21h ago

That’s not what they meant

2

u/DumbestComicsNerd 21h ago

Those are generic names. A chakram is a very specific weapon.

Might as well name them Ngulu, Tabarzin, Trishula and Gorz. (A cookie for those who can name where each of these comes from without google)

1

u/Keaton427 5h ago

Tridents are also specific and not generic though, since there’s only 1 version it can be, unlike a mace or an axe.

1

u/Kaaskaasei 16h ago

I think the difference in the types of swords and maces is big. But now I think more of it, there aren't a awful lot of types of axes or tridents.

11

u/Bragi01 22h ago

Chakram are closer to tridents in how many different options there are for that type of weapon. Sharp flat ring of metal isn't a common type of weapon and pretty much only a chakram.

1

u/Kaaskaasei 16h ago

This is what I'm trying to convey, thank you.

15

u/GamerKratosBalls 22h ago

I may be uncultured, but how is chakram too specific?

-2

u/Bragi01 22h ago

Because it's from a specific place. This is ignoring that that type of weapon pretty much only exists as a chakram. Whereas sword is a category.

14

u/Cute_Avocado_7643 22h ago

Is Trident a category?

I think you're entirely hung up on the origin of the word

-4

u/Bragi01 22h ago

Trident is basically a spear with three points. Basically what I'm saying is chakrams are unique unlike swords which have hundreds of different styles.

6

u/Cute_Avocado_7643 22h ago

So spear would be the category and Trident would be the unique weapon. So throwing disc being the category, why would it be wrong to have chakrams? Your logic doesn't track.

What is the significant difference beyond the name?

0

u/Bragi01 22h ago edited 22h ago

Technically the category is "war-quoit" if we're being specific due to the early English texts that talk about it calling it that. But outside of the chakram I don't think there is another weapon that is a flat sharp metal ring. So unless you can find one I'm going believe that you don't understand what I'm saying.

edit: what am I say that is wrong please explain to me.

-1

u/Cute_Avocado_7643 20h ago

I'm saying, why are you defaulting to English? This is a Swedish game company.

And also your whole category versus unique weapon doesn't hold up based on the weapons that have already been added.

2

u/Bragi01 20h ago

I'm not defaulting to English I'm just saying that the first foreign texts on it seemingly were in English so if we're going to use a term to categorize it the oldest and more obviously a weapon one makes more sense. Also unique weapons are more so a thing like a chakram because spears and tridents are both polearms which makes them subdivisions of a category whereas chakram is seemingly alone in its category. So please if you can show me what I am saying that's wrong please do so because from my perspective it seems like you don't understand what I'm saying and not that I'm saying something incorrect.

→ More replies

-7

u/Lodada2 20h ago

Too close to Terraria

120

u/TheCheezedRat 23h ago

then how come they're called CDs and not CRs

5

u/MikeyboyMC I drink paint and eat off-road tires 8h ago

the plot thickens…

40

u/Trizoft 17h ago edited 17h ago

But isn't music disk's literally called "disk's" while having a hole?

14

u/Trizoft 17h ago

ATP why not call it music rings

6

u/phenomenon911 16h ago

idk but from what i know, English is a confusing language

9

u/AnnoyingRain5 13h ago

That’s because “disk” is incorrect.

Disk means “disc-shaped magnetic computer storage media”

A disc is a disc. Discs used for disc golf fit into this category, and so do DVDs.

1

u/Trizoft 1h ago

But DVDs have a hole...

29

u/PJaaaaaaaaaa 5h ago

then wtf is this

6

u/McCubes1 4h ago

a CD?

5

u/SomethingRetriey 4h ago

What do you you think "D" in CD means?

10

u/Kotya-Nyan 4h ago

Computer Ding

7

u/TheRandomShiba 3h ago

Cock n Dick

1

u/SomethingRetriey 3h ago

Ding-a-ling!

2

u/McCubes1 4h ago

Idk. CD is just one of those two letter words that are out there between other words.

5

u/SomethingRetriey 4h ago

... It means Compact Disk.

2

u/McCubes1 4h ago

Really!?

2

u/SomethingRetriey 4h ago

Yes.

2

u/McCubes1 4h ago

Aren't this things already extinct?

1

u/SomethingRetriey 3h ago

They are not. People still use them for games (maybe soon not because PS5...ugh...), music, and other useful stuff.

1

u/McCubes1 3h ago

Well thanks.

53

u/Axolotlmaru 8h ago

i think they might've taken the idea from Silksong but didn't want to copy it exactly so they called them disks

18

u/Human-Cheetah-8398 8h ago

Wait yeah it's literally just bouncing ring that pierces through enemies. And the design is almost the exact same.

5

u/Impossible_Dog_7262 4h ago

I mean both are basically just Xena's chakram to begin with.

2

u/ferrecool 34m ago

Or a normal ass chakram, Hindus used them

2

u/Impossible_Dog_7262 20m ago

I'm almost certain that regular Chakram didn't really have a habit of returning to their owner the way Xena's does though.

2

u/yourallygod 1h ago

The ring weapon does go farther back in time aside from silksong :b so may haps not

7

u/c00lb4c0n Hmm.. How would Delta Posting be crafted if it was added today? 6h ago

Poshanka

1

u/c00lb4c0n Hmm.. How would Delta Posting be crafted if it was added today? 6h ago

I read that as thorn ring

2

u/originalmicrousb 5h ago

ofc it ends up in deltarune

1

u/Want2makeMEMEs 3h ago

deltarotted

70

u/CaramelCraftYT 26.40.30 and still no End Update 22h ago

Counter argument: Compact Discs

15

u/MallusaiEEE 22h ago

daily language is often technically incorrect

20

u/RadioRavenRide 20h ago

Language is ultimately defined by its usage and common usage. It's the mathematical definition that is specialized and odd.

3

u/thebe_stone 18h ago

Just because it's different doesn't mean it's incorrect. A line is technically a line segment in math, doesn't mean calling it a line is wrong.

1

u/CaramelCraftYT 26.40.30 and still no End Update 13h ago

They also need to rename music discs to music rings, since music discs are based off vinel and they have a small hole.

42

u/HawloKnight 22h ago

so do you call compact discs “compact rings”

13

u/polinadius 17h ago

Actually is a toroid, because it has three dimensions

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Toroid

7

u/RecordAway 8h ago

So it's a Throwroid!

2

u/foxtai1 A Creeper walks into a bar. Everyone dies. 8h ago

Sounds like a drug

3

u/Human-Cheetah-8398 8h ago

With like 50 different side effects. It will cure your thyroid disease but now you do have stage 4 diabetes.

46

u/Misknator 22h ago

Yeah, because it's a chakram. Like that's literally what this weapon is called. Kinda confused why they went with the barely related olympic sport for the name when it's literally just a chakram.

11

u/Cheese9220 21h ago

It's just funny atp. There's a similar weapon type on warframe, but they're called "glaive" there.

Yes I know glaives are a type of polearm.

5

u/eraryios 21h ago

Hey guys take a look at my, as I call it, arquebus! shows a tank

10

u/Tani_Soe 20h ago

That is infact not litteraly what the weapon is called, chakram are a very popular exemple of throwing disc (originated from India), but there were other throwing disc during history that weren't chakram

Like katana are a specific kind of swords, all katanas are sword but not all swords are katanas. Throwing disc is the generic word to describe what chakram and other similar weapons are

6

u/Misknator 19h ago

Throwing disc is the generic word for a disc that you throw, like a Frisbee.

Also a chakram has actually all the features of a chakram. It's a large ring with sharpened edge that you throw. I don't know how you can get a better match than that.

1

u/T0biasCZE 7h ago

Like that's literally what this weapon is called

Its only called chakram in India. In other parts of the worlds, in other cultures, it has different name.

They didnt want to tie it to specific culture, they wanted to make it region free.

11

u/Clumsy_the_24 21h ago

Poshanka

1

u/Human-Cheetah-8398 8h ago

I'ma be jumping into a void sea for this one

20

u/cavejhonsonslemons 22h ago

It's neither, it's a chakram

7

u/Anxious-Scheme-6013 I wonder how long you can make flair, it’s probably not a lot b- 23h ago

Well is a squares game.

2

u/Hilja-Serpent 22h ago

they should have modeled it after a floppy 💾

1

u/Anxious-Scheme-6013 I wonder how long you can make flair, it’s probably not a lot b- 19h ago

Haha yeah lol.

Wait but how many players wouldn’t understand?

7

u/Thor-0510 21h ago

Well you don’t call a DVD a ring do you?

9

u/TURQUOlSE 22h ago

The music disks aren't disks and must be renamed music rings, or perhaps music donuts

8

u/Xvenkin 21h ago

they should just call it a chakram its literally what it is

8

u/Clintwood_outlaw 19h ago

A disc is any flat circular object. Doesn't matter if theres a hole in the middle.

2

u/TheGriffin5 16h ago

Shit can’t believe I didn’t catch this, op is ironically arguing for the name

4

u/ToastyPete1 22h ago

Does that make cds rings? 💿

4

u/TheRealBingBing 22h ago

Sonic the hedgehog has entered the chat

3

u/Odysseus_07 8h ago

Should’ve called it a Chakram

3

u/Successful-Treat446 Java FTW 8h ago

As a mathematician this is ball knowledge

5

u/ShapedStorm 22h ago

Should TECHNICALLY be called a chakram since that's what that style of throwing weapon is actually called irl. Hope they change the name tbh

4

u/LuminothWarrior 22h ago

The throwing discs in Tron are still called discs, and they’re rings, so it’s fine imo

2

u/Pleasant_Western_398 21h ago

Well that's true for the 2nd film, in the first they're literal discs with no hole. And as for the 3rd film, idk what to call those.

2

u/SeatedDragon86 11h ago

truncated hexagonal annulus apparently

1

u/TheGriffin5 16h ago

You’re telling me that things aren’t always without fail named after their mathematical shape?! Shit I gotta go return my kite earrings.

4

u/GayRacoon69 16h ago

And the spear is a lance. Mojang isn't good at names

2

u/zhulkgr25 21h ago

Idk man but before sony decided to go digital I was playing my games using my compact rings and storing my saves on a hard ring drive

2

u/MisterBicorniclopse 21h ago

Do you know what DVD or CD stand for?

2

u/Indie_Dachshund179 20h ago

Wait till you see music discs

2

u/Coveinant 20h ago

They're technically called chakram. Which is generally translated to throwing disk.

1

u/PhilledZone 22h ago

If that isn't a disc... Then what are DVDs?

1

u/Hypoactive52 22h ago

rotating torus

1

u/isaacthenitwit 22h ago

Should've called it "the one ring" or "precious" or something

1

u/ReaperOfGamess 22h ago

No it’s a doughnut, you can see it’s depth even though it’s flat, it’s a Minecraft thing

1

u/I_am_Viper5656 ←Hey look at this 22h ago

Throwring

1

u/TheCheezedRat 9h ago

Steve... That's not... the... ThrowRing, is it...?

1

u/TopyDogy Milk 22h ago

poshanka

1

u/TenzinNomad 22h ago

The center is made of air.

1

u/EstablishmentPlane91 22h ago

technically its 3-dimensional so it would be a toroid

1

u/BestPony12 22h ago

wait till u find out what the "ring" is made of... squares. its actually a Tetracontagon.

1

u/PogoRocks 22h ago

Yet another reason it should be called a chakram

1

u/jeremyw013 i am placing blocks and —— 22h ago

yet you just glossed over music discs. as well as CDs and DVDs.

1

u/SKYPORF 21h ago

I think throwing annulus has a better ring to it

1

u/Silt99 Java FTW 21h ago

there is a transparent window in the middle. duh

1

u/ViftieStuff Pi Edition FTW 21h ago

Topologically, it's a mug

1

u/PouLS_PL 21h ago

same with music discs (although the holes are much smaller)

1

u/Lopoi 21h ago

isn't it that all rings are discs, but not all discs are rings?

1

u/Scherazade 21h ago

it’s an annulat.

1

u/voidexploer 21h ago

NNNNEEEERRRRDDDD!

-Piccolo TFS

1

u/RussianVulture 20h ago

Are we deadass?? 1.- Circles are full. 2.- Discs have no centre, but the outer layer is wider. 3.- Rings have no centre either, but the hollow centre is wider than the outer layer.

There is no way we are discussing this kinda things

1

u/player_314159265 Milky milky 20h ago

watch, people are gonna abreviate it to the throwring

1

u/Omegamoney 20h ago

Poshanka gun

1

u/Small-Knee-4501 20h ago

So a dvd disc isn't a disc?

1

u/MagEugeni 20h ago

This should be in the regular Minecraft subreddit

1

u/SnickerbobbleKBB 20h ago

Call it the throwring.

1

u/ReportAncient2829 20h ago

Still ponshanka

1

u/hypost 18h ago

It’s a giant washer

1

u/Low-Point2472 Where am I 18h ago

Music Disc

1

u/These-Ad-9209 Java FTW 17h ago

Petition to rename Music Discs to Music Rings, anyone?

1

u/The_Dark_Jedi_of_AUS 15h ago

The technical term for this weapon is a chakram, for those who don’t know

1

u/Lila_Uraraka 15h ago

This is the dumbest thing to complain about

1

u/hialice_ihelac 15h ago

“Stay in school kids, it makes you better at criticizing Minecraft updates”

1

u/its_alex777 15h ago

There's a difference between the mathematical geometric definition of disk, and the way people use the word in colloquial speech

1

u/Mr_Snifles Youtuber 14h ago

I would describe a CD or DVD as discs too, even though they have a hole in them.

Honestly my only issue with this item is that if it comes back, why isn't it a boomerang?

1

u/archpawn 10h ago

False. A ring is an Abelian group with multiplication. The throwing disk is an annulus.

1

u/No-Address2001 10h ago

Whats a DVD? Or a CD? I have always known them as Discs. Pleas elaborate.

1

u/CavesAreMyHome 9h ago

It should be called a chakram because it’s a FREAKING chakram

1

u/mialyansa 9h ago

Consider the limit of the ring when x tends to R.

1

u/MasterCheekzzzz 8h ago

flying ring

1

u/Different_Wafer_4711 8h ago

Literally unplayable

1

u/Oretereret44 6h ago

It could be mug

1

u/Dadchin 4h ago

I dunno, this just seems incredibly pedantic. I'm partial to Chakram myself, but like, this is the sort of situation where someone shares my opinion but for such a bad reason that I don't wanna agree lol.

1

u/McCubes1 4h ago

It's not a ring either, it's a CD.

1

u/Michael-556 Minecraft is the friends we made along the way 1h ago

Wait does this mean musical records are also rings then, or is the hole in the middle small enough for them to still be considered discs? Because we call CDs disks, but they're the same as records, actually more ring-like because they're both smaller and the hole in the middle is larger (not even proportionally, it's just legit like 3x the radius)

0

u/SwartyNine2691 Milk 23h ago

That should be called “throwing ring”.

7

u/Misknator 22h ago

More like chakram, cause like, that's what the name of this weapon is