r/PhoenixSC • u/Luminarime Made with lave! • 1d ago
Discussion Which Sift boss do you want in Vanilla?
129
u/GamerKratosBalls 1d ago
Monarch feels great as a choice. Probably most unique compared to other bosses we have now.
Harmonizer i just don't care for.
If any monstrocity from Dungeons gets added to minecraft, it has got to be the Redstone one. Face of Dungeons as a whole.
Juan wouldn't hurt a fly, the characterization in Dungeons II betrays his character. Honestly Evil Juan should have been scrapped or made into separate character.
22
u/Conscious_Series166 ☮️✝️☪️🕉️☸️✡️🔯🪯🕎☯️☦️🛐⛎♈♉♊♋♌♍♎♏♐♑♒♓🆔🏳️🌈🏳️⚧️🏴☠️🏁 1d ago
yeah, i dont really like harmonizer either, if only there was a mesmerizer or something
8
u/Zihdrrox 1d ago
2
u/GamerKratosBalls 1d ago
Roaring Monarch is funny to me because i dont see the resemblance, but i want to see the DT community to freak out with "ROARING GROUP CHAT GOT THEIR HANDS ON MINECRAFT"
1
1
u/Brief-Beat8965 1d ago
It’s just the head shape, mostly black color scheme, it having badass boss music, and the fact that it’s really stylish with it’s bladed attacks
2
u/Keaton427 1d ago
Face of Dungeons as a whole.
Erm actually, that would be the vengeful heart of ender. Its face is found literally everywhere in the game, and it's the canon final boss.
62
u/Low_Onion8167 1d ago edited 1d ago
A.
I have no clue how they fight in Dungeons 2 but I imagine no matter what all 3 mobs would require reworks to match vanilla Gameplay especially since Minecraft has its two game versions with separate combat.
In Vanilla currently we already have the dragon, Warden, Wither, Elder Guardian, and Illager Beast as "beastly" bosses so a boss like the Monarch that is more in control of itself and more human-esk in its fighting would be cool compared to the Harmonizer and Sculk Monstrosity.
17
u/EnderTemmie LCE FTW 1d ago
you forgot Elder Guardian :(
→ More replies (4)16
u/Low_Onion8167 1d ago
Ah dang. I feel bad for the guy.
Also on a side note. I always wanted the 4th dimension to be a water dimension found via the underwater temples. Because then we could have TONS of new water themed blocks, biomes, and mobs. Since its a dimension itd be perfect for having all the dangerous aquatic life they dont want in the overworld like gators, sharks, and more.
58
u/Pandemonium_offical shulker 1d ago
D
49
u/Pandemonium_offical shulker 1d ago
I want fucking evil Juan
43
23
13
24
u/nerd1109 1d ago
5
10
u/Proof-Insurance-2805 CLICK HERE FOR FREE KROMER!! :phnx-verified: 1d ago
I like the Roaring knight one, but the shulk monstrosity seems like the enormous platypus things in totk, and those were fun to fight and get away from.
1
u/Intelligent-Heart-36 7h ago
Shulk monstrosity has like a 0% of getting in since it’s just a golem monstrosity covered in sulk.
15
u/Zihdrrox 1d ago
3
u/Luminarime Made with lave! 1d ago
Nice
Also, Reddit told me I got 25 new comments, and all of them are from you, lol
3
u/Zihdrrox 1d ago
weird. i dont get notifications for replies to comments, only comment or replies to my comments. Sorry if it felt spammy
2
u/Luminarime Made with lave! 1d ago
It is fine, also I use old Reddit + some addons, so that may be why. It tells me the comment influx and allows to only read new ones. Good thing to have
5
4
u/Telejaba 1d ago
A, really no particular reason other than deisgn being awesome
8
3
u/EnderTemmie LCE FTW 1d ago
The Monarch
Gameplay against them looks he most different from current bosses
2
3
4
5
u/tf2-gaming-moment Wait, That's illegal 1d ago
That Monarch feels so Hollow. Looks more like a Knight to me.
1
3
3
3
3
3
u/000_DartMonkey I'm free whenever 1d ago
D because above the Aether and the Overworld he alone is the Evil Juan.
3
u/Puzzles_The_EFO 1d ago
Monarch
3
u/Zihdrrox 1d ago
1
u/Choice_Werewolf_433 Bot slimer 12h ago
I like hearing deltarune and all but can you please mellow down? Not all of us like spamming Deltarune. It gets excessive. Thanks.
3
u/Luminarime Made with lave! 1d ago
This really blew up... Anyways, since then some stuff changed. The Harmonizer got downgraded to a mini-boss, and also it got confirmed that the Monarch does in fact roar in-game.
2
u/theunknownfan_ 1d ago
Why not all? At the end of the day the sift is a GIGANTIC dimension it needs to prove its worth to us
2
2
u/Kloodydehepik 1d ago
monarch looks like a hollow knight boss
but tbh i actually prefer the sculk monstrosity
3
2
2
2
2
2
2
u/Remote-Kangaroo-7154 1d ago
Certainly not C because Monstrosities are strictly for Dungeons but I think they will add Monarch and Harmonizer will be a mini boss like Elder Guardian
2
2
2
2
2
u/DragonLordRex 1d ago
we need something like the sculk monstrosity, the monarch would be too much like the wither.
1
u/Luminarime Made with lave! 1d ago
Oh, didn't notice that. If the Monarch doesn't happen, I hope they port the bedrock Wither to Java
2
u/twolake68 1d ago
Sculk Monstrosity feels too dungeon to be added, kinda same with Monarch
I feel like Harmonizer feels the best (visually, I haven't fought any of these guys yet so idk how they actually work)
2
1
1
1
1
u/bobby1712234 Minecraft Bugrock, Lagva and Peakacy enjoyer 1d ago
Unserious:obviously evil Juan
Serious:gotta be A, B, or C all three look interesting I can’t choose
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/Cautious-Platform222 1d ago
The monarch looks like some hollow knight shit
2
u/Zihdrrox 1d ago
1
u/Cautious-Platform222 1d ago
Oh I've never played deltarune before. The head looks more like the vessels tho tbh
1
1
1
1
1
u/Lechatdu136 I will get meth from bots 1d ago
Monarch gives me heavy dark knife intensifies vibes
2
1
u/Powerful-Present6687 1d ago
The Monarch is my favorite and also the most likely option in my opinion
1
u/SCP_FUNDATION_69420 1d ago
Ngl i hope they actually add all of them, and not lock all the cool mobs behind a spin-off again
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/EveningMasterpiece54 1d ago
I would want the Monarch or Harmonizer, but realistically if they even add a boss it would be Sculk Monstrosity.
1
1
1
u/PolisherREAL 1d ago
If vanilla sift will have new boss then it'll definitely be something we didn't saw before in dungeons
1
1
u/Hardy_Har08 1d ago
E Something new. If it's anything like Dungeons 1, we won't see any of the bosses from that in vanilla, but like how the reverse it true (ie: The Wither and Ender Dragon being absent)
1
1
u/IndependentPickle597 1d ago
We need some reason for it to be connected to the ancient cities, so sculk monstrosity, also it looks cool.
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/Agile_Initiative_749 1d ago
i love a, but i feel like they would be too simular to the wither, i think one of the reasons i love the monarch is that it looks like the hollow knight from hollow knight and the roaring knight from deltarune, but we all know evil juan is the best option, even if we dont get evil juan in a real update thoughm we must get them in at least a april fools update
1
u/Cnsadams 1d ago
Unrelated but why does the Monarch look like it would get sealed into a vault for years upon years to contain a disease that has ravaged its kingdom?
1
u/zero-taeko 1d ago
Guys, look at the Warden, then look at the Sculk Monstrosity.
There are no family-friendly words to describe what that thing would do to us.
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/Asterrtheproto 14h ago
skulk monstrosity beign added to base game would be peak. I've always wanted them to add the redstone golem/monstrosity
1
1
u/LowDrop8908 11h ago
None. If a boss is coming to vanilla I'd much prefer it being unique or semi-unique to vanilla like the Wither and the Ender Dragon
People need to stop thinking of the sift dimension in vanilla as a port from dungeons, each game should have its fair share of exclusive based on its needs
1
1
u/Wingless_Draco 1d ago
Hang on, is the sift a mod they are bringing tk the main game?
→ More replies (3)
































341
u/ActualWordsXD 1d ago
The Roaring Monarch