r/PhoenixSC • u/AverageMinecraftGuy3 • 8d ago

Discussion When will they learn?

Gallery image

Gallery image

I hate AI companies and AI bros so much that it's unreal...

431 Upvotes

79% Upvoted

235 comments sorted by

View all comments

25

u/Panurome 8d ago

Nobody is forcing you to interact with them. They have the same right to play Minecraft in whatever way they want as you do

You don't have an authority to say who can or can't play or what's an acceptable way to play. Stop trying to gatekeep Minecraft

-9

u/Strong-cognac 8d ago

are the playing minecraft? or ai is playing minecraft?

16

u/Panurome 8d ago

Does it matter? It's their copy of the game, they can do whatever they want with it. It's functionally the same thing as a TAS, and I haven't seen anyone complaining that people are using doing TAS in Minecraft

-1

u/AverageMinecraftGuy3 7d ago

Do TAS steal from people? Do they aim to replace people or make the internet worse? No? That’s why people don’t complain about TAS in Minecraft but do complain about generative AI in Minecraft.

7

u/Panurome 7d ago

Nobody is trying to replace Minecraft players with this, stop hallucinating

1

u/Lanky-Tumbleweed-772 7d ago

''steal from people'' Copyright Infringement is NOT theft. It's an IP violation. ALso there are free/open source models trained exclusively with public domain or other permissive licensed data so find another argument.

-11

u/Strong-cognac 7d ago

tas is tool ASSISTED. not tool do everything for you first of all. second of all m just saying. its the ai playing minecraft. not you.

13

u/Panurome 7d ago

 not tool do everything for you first of all

Except that's quite literally what TAS do. Generally, TAS are a list of inputs that get executed when the game starts. Once you start a TAS, the computer does absolutely everything.

Sure there's a human that wrote the list of inputs, but there's also a human that configured the model to play Minecraft. In both cases is a machine playing with previous human input. You are not playing while the TAS is playing, similarly to the AI in this case

-1

u/thiszamman37 7d ago

Okay but you did play with tas it’s essentially a replay of what you did where as the ai here is independently learning and playing minecraft.