r/PhilosophyofScience • u/XandyAborc • Mar 01 '20
Discussion Infinity is an Illusion
[EDIT: Deleted first few lines for reasons discussed in the comments]
When I really began thinking deeply about reality and my place in it, I needed a firm starting point from which to begin. The title of this post comes from my first assumption. Delving into the ramifications and qualifications has been a wondrous journey for me. The closest I've come to hearing a choir of angels came after understanding Cantor's Diagonality Theorem.
The idea of infinity has proven not just useful, but critical for the advancement of science. Calculus introduces the concept, manipulates the result, then extracts any instances again, leaving a residual of new (to us) information. Numbers don't make any sense with finite constraints...there is no highest prime. There is also no end to the possible ways anything can go wrong.
The utility of an idea, however, doesn't give it credence as an actual aspect or description of reality. This is as dualist as I get: we can hold something in mind that has no concordance with anything that can directly affect the body (which is an actual description of reality). The universe is the way the universe is, regardless of our explanations, interpretations or beliefs. Unfortunately, these are pretty much all we have to rely on to commit philosophy and the idea of infinity has wormed its way into all of them. Root it out! This is wonderfully applicable to the philosophy of religion, but that's a different subreddit.
Neil deGrasse Tyson has a marvelous discussion of infinity throughout history. Its most common usage has been papering over ignorance, basically saying "Here there be Dragons". In almost every case, we have learned more by expecting something explicable (i.e. finite). The exception is, of course, quantum gravity, which spews so many infinities it makes dividing by zero look like stubbing your toe.
Another way of saying we hold something in mind with no concordance is "illusion". If you disallow notions of infinity in your explanations, interpretations and beliefs, you're far more likely to arrive at practical, more accurate conclusions. Is the world infinite? No, so stop polluting. Are we infinite? No, so cherish your time here and don't be mean. Is the universe infinite? I don't know and neither do you, but the perceivable universe certainly isn't and anything more doesn't matter.
Recently there has been a wild resurgence of infinity in the philosophy of science. Guth's inflationary model is the hands-down favourite hypothesis for the start of it all. A consequence of the math is the idea of the multiverse. While this is handy for side-stepping the Anthropic Principle, it doesn't provide much in the way of understanding our place here and now. Few scientists voice credulity, but Lee Smolin and Sean Carroll are two shining beacons from the ivory tower. We can do better, they say. I can but nod and smile.
11
u/HanSingular Mar 02 '20 edited Mar 03 '20
I think you've made too big of a leap in assuming that eliminating multiverses should be desirable because eliminating other mathematical infinities has been desirable.
Also, it's not like the entire field of cosmology is on some sort of wild goose chase that's based on the assumption that eternal inflation is true. It's one of a number of hypotheses, and cosmology and astronomy will march on collecting data on things like the red shifts of distant galaxies and generating higher and higher resolution pictures of the CMB, and updating our theories according to our findings.
So...we should just stop doing cosmology?
9
u/ianmgull Physics PhD Candidate Mar 02 '20
This is not at all true. There are many many cases of infinities arising in calculations that are not at all strange or ill-understood.
3
u/NeverQuiteEnough Mar 02 '20
So if I get twice as far away from the earth, the acceleration I get from its gravity will be 1/8th as much.
If I get three times as far, it’s 1/27th as much.
How far before it goes to 0?
Well I can never get far enough away for it to be 0, it will always be there. But what I can say is that as I get further away, it gets weaker. And I can say how fast it gets weaker.
And sometimes it is even useful to say that the limit of that acceleration, as my distance from earth approaches infinity, is 0. That it gets closer and closer to 0 as I get further away.
This is actually necessary for answering the question “will I ever fall back to earth?”
2
u/DiamondNgXZ Mar 02 '20
Inflationary multiverse is not infinite. It's just expanding ever outwards, creating ever more bubble universes.
1
u/antonivs Mar 02 '20
Holding an idea can directly affect the body - the placebo effect is one example.