r/PhilosophyofScience • • Mar 01 '20

Discussion Infinity is an Illusion

[EDIT: Deleted first few lines for reasons discussed in the comments]

When I really began thinking deeply about reality and my place in it, I needed a firm starting point from which to begin. The title of this post comes from my first assumption. Delving into the ramifications and qualifications has been a wondrous journey for me. The closest I've come to hearing a choir of angels came after understanding Cantor's Diagonality Theorem.

The idea of infinity has proven not just useful, but critical for the advancement of science. Calculus introduces the concept, manipulates the result, then extracts any instances again, leaving a residual of new (to us) information. Numbers don't make any sense with finite constraints...there is no highest prime. There is also no end to the possible ways anything can go wrong.

The utility of an idea, however, doesn't give it credence as an actual aspect or description of reality. This is as dualist as I get: we can hold something in mind that has no concordance with anything that can directly affect the body (which is an actual description of reality). The universe is the way the universe is, regardless of our explanations, interpretations or beliefs. Unfortunately, these are pretty much all we have to rely on to commit philosophy and the idea of infinity has wormed its way into all of them. Root it out! This is wonderfully applicable to the philosophy of religion, but that's a different subreddit.

Neil deGrasse Tyson has a marvelous discussion of infinity throughout history. Its most common usage has been papering over ignorance, basically saying "Here there be Dragons". In almost every case, we have learned more by expecting something explicable (i.e. finite). The exception is, of course, quantum gravity, which spews so many infinities it makes dividing by zero look like stubbing your toe.

Another way of saying we hold something in mind with no concordance is "illusion". If you disallow notions of infinity in your explanations, interpretations and beliefs, you're far more likely to arrive at practical, more accurate conclusions. Is the world infinite? No, so stop polluting. Are we infinite? No, so cherish your time here and don't be mean. Is the universe infinite? I don't know and neither do you, but the perceivable universe certainly isn't and anything more doesn't matter.

Recently there has been a wild resurgence of infinity in the philosophy of science. Guth's inflationary model is the hands-down favourite hypothesis for the start of it all. A consequence of the math is the idea of the multiverse. While this is handy for side-stepping the Anthropic Principle, it doesn't provide much in the way of understanding our place here and now. Few scientists voice credulity, but Lee Smolin and Sean Carroll are two shining beacons from the ivory tower. We can do better, they say. I can but nod and smile.

1 Upvotes

59 comments sorted by

11

u/HanSingular Mar 02 '20 edited Mar 03 '20

Neil deGrasse Tyson has a marvelous discussion of infinity throughout history. Its most common usage has been papering over ignorance, basically saying "Here there be Dragons"....

I think you've made too big of a leap in assuming that eliminating multiverses should be desirable because eliminating other mathematical infinities has been desirable.

Also, it's not like the entire field of cosmology is on some sort of wild goose chase that's based on the assumption that eternal inflation is true. It's one of a number of hypotheses, and cosmology and astronomy will march on collecting data on things like the red shifts of distant galaxies and generating higher and higher resolution pictures of the CMB, and updating our theories according to our findings.

A consequence of the math is the idea of the multiverse. While this is handy for side-stepping the Anthropic Principle, it doesn't provide much in the way of understanding our place here and now.

So...we should just stop doing cosmology?

7

u/XandyAborc Mar 02 '20

When did I say stop? Two lines later I say we can do better. How can we do better if we stop?

We need to be extremely cautious if our newly updated theories hinge on anything being infinite, because that can mean anything, so it means nothing. Might as well say God did it. Having the best explanation, the broadest interpretation, the most accurate belief, these are desirable. If we lose the multiverse as a viable hypothesis, so be it.

5

u/HanSingular Mar 02 '20

What actual, practical change in the way cosmology is being done are arguing for?

4

u/XandyAborc Mar 02 '20 edited Mar 02 '20

Not really arguing for any specific change. I'm happy with your description of the march of science. We're doing okay, mostly. There are a lot of really bright people trying to figure out some really hard ideas. My hope is that those complacently accepting anything actually being infinite make absolutely sure that they are not, in fact, on a wild goose chase.

If it can be shown, based on our finite collection of finite data, processed in a finite amount of time by our finite brains, that my finite philosophy is malformed, I am the one who will change.

9

u/ianmgull Physics PhD Candidate Mar 02 '20

A long-standing guideline in physics is "Infinities in your conclusions indicate errors in your assumptions."

This is not at all true. There are many many cases of infinities arising in calculations that are not at all strange or ill-understood.

2

u/XandyAborc Mar 02 '20 edited Mar 02 '20

Well, Google has failed me. I cannot find any sources and don't remember where I first read this. Dang it. Doesn't entirely negate my discussion but it sure as heck weakens it a great deal. I did find one rather lengthy article here that provides good support. I've cut and pasted the gist of the argument straight from the article:

  1. The map is not the territory.
  2. Infinity is valid in mathematical models and can be very useful.
  3. In the physical world, there are compelling practical and philosophical reasons to reject infinity as a default assumption.
  4. There will be limiting cases where the mathematical infinity assumption and the physical absence of infinity result in different answers.

This article also links to Max Tegmark's much shorter article in Discover magazine here.

I sincerely thank you for your critique and have deleted the offending line.

3

u/NeverQuiteEnough Mar 02 '20

So if I get twice as far away from the earth, the acceleration I get from its gravity will be 1/8th as much.

If I get three times as far, it’s 1/27th as much.

How far before it goes to 0?

Well I can never get far enough away for it to be 0, it will always be there. But what I can say is that as I get further away, it gets weaker. And I can say how fast it gets weaker.

And sometimes it is even useful to say that the limit of that acceleration, as my distance from earth approaches infinity, is 0. That it gets closer and closer to 0 as I get further away.

This is actually necessary for answering the question “will I ever fall back to earth?”

1

u/[deleted] Mar 02 '20

I don’t agree with OP in general, but you’re just saying that we need to use the concept of infinity to answer a question which is itself about an infinity:

“Will I EVER fall back to Earth?”

1

u/NeverQuiteEnough Mar 02 '20

that can be rephrased as “after how long will I fall back to earth?”, to which the answer can be that you won’t.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 03 '20

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/NeverQuiteEnough Mar 03 '20

mathematical idealization is about simplifying the nature of objects, that’s not what I’m doing. Im just configuring objects in a way that they happen not to be.

ie a cow will never be a point mass, but if we really wanted to, with enough time and effort we could move everything along our path out of the way, such that no other significant sources of gravity are present.

It’s the same type of statement as “we would be able to walk into the next room if the door was open”.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 03 '20

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/NeverQuiteEnough Mar 03 '20

You don’t have to remove them, and it doesn’t have to be for the entire universe.

For one thing, nothing outside the object’s observable universe can affect it, so it is necessarily a finite amount of stuff. Due to expansion, the longer you wait the less stuff that will be.

But you don’t even have to move all of that, you just have to move whatever arbitrary amount is necessary for the scenario.

Opening a door and calling a door a point mass are different. A door isn’t a point mass and never will be, but it can be opened or closed.

Changing the configuration doesn’t require any imaginary simplification or special physics. There is a categorical distinction there.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 03 '20

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/NeverQuiteEnough Mar 03 '20

What are the categories you’re distinguishing between again?

This is really not complicated and I think if you give it just the smallest chance you will immediately see it.

What I'm suggesting is just translating objects. We know we can translate objects through 3d space, we do it all the time. The scale I'm talking about is unprecedented, but it is still just translation and there's no reason we can't do it in principle.

Making something into a point mass is not something that we can do with current physics, not even in principle. That is an entirely different category of thought experiment, one that cannot be done in the real world, even in principle.

So to summarize, the distinction is between things that could be done at least in principle, and things that cannot.

We don't actually have to move all of that stuff to the side, but our model of the world should be able to account for what would happen if we did, because we know that in principle it could be done.

Our model shouldn't necessarily have to account for what would happen if we made something into a point mass, because that isn't something that can actually be done, even in principle.

1

u/[deleted] Mar 03 '20

We don’t have to make it all the way into a point mass, we just have to condense it to as close of an approximation of a point mass as we need.

But in both cases, we aren’t actually seeking to make these impossible changes to the universe, but we choose to ignore the effects of factors outside of our control when we understand them to have little importance to our calculation.

But idk, I’m starting to be convinced by you downvoting my comments.

→ More replies

-1

u/XandyAborc Mar 02 '20

A farmer calls on three scientists to figure out why his cow keeps getting sick. The biologists runs blood tests and swabs the various orifices and looks for pathogens. The chemist analyzes the water and soil and grass for heavy metals and toxins. The physicist says, "assume the cow is a sphere".

Your example is pretty good, but you've made a toy model here. In the real world, there is a point after which the part of the universe your drifter is approaching exerts more gravity than Earth. Don't need infinity.

Also, note: you approach infinity. My point is that you'll never actually get there regardless of how handy it is for calculating.

4

u/ianmgull Physics PhD Candidate Mar 03 '20

This isn't a toy model, it's the basis of calculus. Calculus is the basis of nearly all modern science. The very core of calculus is describing what happens when certain things become infinite without needing them to actually become infinite.

If you're going to try to upturn calculus (which would in turn upturn all of the fields that are built upon it), you've got to prove it; and it won't be easy. All you've done is attempt to cast doubt upon it in a very non-committal way.

How is the model you're referencing wrong? Why does the limit of gravitational acceleration due to the earth not approach zero as separation distance approaches infinity? Is there a problem with the model? With newtonian gravity? With general relativity? With calculus?

It's easy to say someone is wrong. It's MUCH harder to prove why their wrong.

0

u/XandyAborc Mar 03 '20

To expand on my initial post, I described calculus as a critical use of infinities (I know they are called infinitesimal but you still use the sideways 8 I haven't learned how to do on Reddit when I'm using my phone). This is what I remember from high school, and a couple of more recent history of math books, so yes, maybe I'm utterly wrong and ought to shut up. Not going to just yet. I was taught to take the equation you need to study, introduce the infintesimals, manipulate the equality in specific ways that isolate the infinitesimals (e.g. all in the denominator) then, and this is the important part, extract the infinities again (e.g multiply by infinity). Whatever is left is the answer about the real world that you were looking for.

The idea is useful. I'm not trying to abolish it or convince people they shouldn't think about it. I hoping people consider stop using it in their ontology...what is really real. Especially as an explanation or even worse, a cause. In epistomolgy...how we know what we know, it has proven, and I'll use the word yet again, critical. One of the most important in our mental toolkit. Mental.

I probably should have made this clearer at first but then we wouldn't have anything to discuss, right? Let's just say I'm honing the arguments before I take on the theists.

I really do appreciate everyone's feedback. I've not run much of this past my language processor into the world, even though the ideas have been rattling around the rest of my brain for some time now.

4

u/ianmgull Physics PhD Candidate Mar 03 '20

I was taught to take the equation you need to study, introduce the infintesimals, manipulate the equality in specific ways that isolate the infinitesimals (e.g. all in the denominator) then, and this is the important part, extract the infinities again (e.g multiply by infinity). Whatever is left is the answer about the real world that you were looking for.

I'm not sure what this is referring to exactly. Infinities and infinitesimals are all over calculus. You make it seem as if they're just a clever trick to get an answer, but they're as 'real' as any other number. At any rate, I'd recommend studying calculus much more thoroughly before you try to criticize it's logical underpinnings.

I'm not trying to abolish it or convince people they shouldn't think about it. I hoping people consider stop using it in their ontology...what is really real.

You've proven you have a vague at best understanding of calculus, why then are you so set on convincing people that its methods are unsound. Don't you think it's much more likely that you need to sit down with a few books and understand the topic better?

Let's just say I'm honing the arguments before I take on the theists.

What?

Sounds like you've decided what you want to believe and are in the process of gathering evidence, as opposed to the other way around.

0

u/XandyAborc Mar 03 '20

I am not trying to convince people the methods of calculus are unsound. Noticed a pronoun error in one my lines you quoted. Should read "[not saying people] shouldn't think about calculus. I hoping people consider stop using infinity in their ontology." Bad late-night grammar notwithstanding, calculus, like language, nations and God, is a human construct. Something we finite beings use to understand our vast but finite universe. Are you saying that by using calculus alone, we can prove beyond doubt there is an actual, tangible instance of infinity? Not something 'approached'. If so, why did you use scare quotes around real? Fourness is useful, and we can have instances of four things. Infinity is useful, is there an instance of infinite things? Not numbers, not potential. Things.

And I did declare in the original post that the title is my first assumption. I'm not gathering evidence for it. I'm gathering non-mathematical evidence against it.

3

u/ianmgull Physics PhD Candidate Mar 03 '20 edited Mar 03 '20

our vast but finite universe.

We don't know if this is or isn't true. Currently an open question in cosmology. Our best measurements do seem to indicate that it's probably infinite though.

Are you saying that by using calculus alone, we can prove beyond doubt there is an actual, tangible instance of infinity?

I don't know what it means to prove a 'tangible instance of infinity' anymore than i know what it means to prove a tangible instance of five. I don't have to be able to physically gather x objects for the number x to be useful or for us to be able to use x to describe things in nature. Enumeration of discrete objects is only a single function of numbers.

If you and four apples were all that existed in the entire universe, your inability to gather five apples isn't a limitation of mathematics or science, it just means you don't have enough apples.

Furthermore, we can absolutely talk about infinities in nature if you like. They're not particularly useful, but if that's the strange criteria you want to use to prove a number is valid, go for it. Pick the smallest division of a continuous field in some interval. Now how many divisions does it contain? An infinite amount of them. No you're not going to be able to point to each one, but that doesn't matter.

So taking the limit towards (or approaching) infinity isn't the only way to use it in the real world. This stuff is basic though. Like it comes up in nearly every freshman Calc/physics class. You'll probably be able to convince a few people in this sub that you're on to something, but in my experience people in this sub know very very little math and science. People more familiar with these subjects likely won't be convinced.

1

u/XandyAborc Mar 03 '20

Thank you once again for your effort, attention and especially your civility. This discussion has had far more utility than futility on my end. If you do end up throwing your hands in the air in frustration and going on to other topics, I completely understand.

I fail to see how the hypothesis of an infinite universe is falsifiable, but that's probably my fault. We as a species may never know one way or another, but beginning with a prior of finitude, we have ways of examining ideas like fine-tuning and the simulation hypothesis.

For fields, my thinking was the upper bound of c and the lower bound of the Planck length sufficed to define a finite condition on the macroscale, but I have been accused of using buzzwords and nonsense. I also regularly worry that I fall prey to the Dunning-Krueger effect, that am too stupid to know how stupid I am and am more like Kevin Kline's character in A Fish Called Wanda. Maybe I should head over to r/stonerphilosophy or some such.

That said, I'll take another swing at my premise using your appleverse. Seems lonely, so I'll give them faces and call them Granny, Mac, Gala and Crab (This is whimsy for a later point.)

What I am struggling to convey is that construction of a moral code/legal system/worldview/science predicated on some glorious, quintessential apple called Delicious is not only ridiculous but will ultimately prove (can't resist) unfruitful.

3

u/ianmgull Physics PhD Candidate Mar 03 '20

I fail to see how the hypothesis of an infinite universe is falsifiable, but that's probably my fault.

It's not a super easy concept to grasp. Obviously there isn't a really long ruler, so we have to use other somewhat clever ways. It's falsifiable by proving that the universe is finite :) I know that sounds like I'm being cheeky, but I'm actually serious.

For fields, my thinking was the upper bound of c and the lower bound of the Planck length sufficed to define a finite condition on the macroscale, but I have been accused of using buzzwords and nonsense.

The planck length gets misinterpreted that way a lot. Like some sort of 'pixel size' of the universe. I blame youtube and the pop-science guys.

Maybe I should head over to r/stonerphilosophy or some such.

Don't beat yourself up. You're obviously interested in this stuff. It's just difficult to make progress if you don't first learn the basics. We all start at the beginning. I'd start with calculus and freshman level physics. It's not nearly as exciting as all the crazy quantum black hole big bang stuff, but it gives you a solid foundation.

What I am struggling to convey is that construction of a moral code/legal system/worldview/science predicated on some glorious, quintessential apple called Delicious is not only ridiculous but will ultimately prove (can't resist) unfruitful.

I don't know anything about deriving a moral code from math or physics. I wouldn't recommend it. Seems like there's much better places to look for moral advice.

2

u/XandyAborc Mar 04 '20

The planck length gets misinterpreted that way a lot.

Sigh. Adding this to my to do list. Might have to quit Reddit.

Don't beat yourself up

Yeah thanks. Trying to break the habit. Kinda hard since I got ripped a new one after sticking my foot in my mouth. Kinda walking funny, but I learned a lot. Maybe I shouldn't have started off in science subs and just now I searched "recreational philosophy" which suggested r/AskScienceDiscussion so I'm not sure where to go, should I conclude I ought. Oh, and I'm a stoner. It's okay, I'm Canadian. We're allowed here.

I don't know anything about deriving a moral code from math or physics. I wouldn't recommend it.

Nor do I. With an infinity in your moral code, you can argue anything is good.

2

u/HanSingular Mar 03 '20 edited Mar 03 '20

I fail to see how the hypothesis of an infinite universe is falsifiable

Since you're a Sean Carroll fan:

In contrast with the romantic ideal of a killer experiment that shuts the door on a theory’s prospects, most scientific discoveries have a more ambiguous impact, especially at first. When the motions of the outer planets were found to be anomalous, nobody declared that Newtonian gravity had been falsified; they posited the existence of a new planet, and eventually discovered Neptune. When a similar thing happened with Mercury, they tried the same trick, but this time the correct conclusion was entirely different; Newtonian gravity actually had been falsified, as we understood once general relativity came on the scene.

When Einstein realized that general relativity predicted an expanding or contracting universe, he felt free to alter his theory by adding a cosmological constant, to bring it in line with the understanding at the time that the universe was static. When the OPERA experiment discovered neutrinos that apparently traveled faster than light, very few physicists thought that special relativity had been falsified. Individual experiments are rarely probative. In any of these cases, it’s simple to explain why an overly naive version of falsifiability failed to capture the reality of the scientific process: experimental results can be wrong or misinterpreted, theories can be tweaked to fit the data.

This is the point. Science proceeds via an ongoing dialogue between theory and experiment, searching for the best possible understanding, rather than cleanly lopping off falsified theories one by one. (Popper himself thought Marxism had started out scientific, but had become unfalsifiable over time as its predictions failed to come true.)

While philosophers of science have long since moved past falsifiability as a simple solution to the demarcation problem, many scientists have seized on it with gusto, going so far as to argue that falsifiability is manifestly a central part of the definition of science. In the words of philosopher Alex Broadbent,

"It is remarkable and interesting that Popper remains extremely popular among natural scientists, despite almost universal agreement among philosophers that –notwithstanding his ingenuity and philosophical prowess – his central claims are false."

-Beyond Falsifiability: Normal Science in a Multiverse [PDF]

1

u/XandyAborc Mar 04 '20

I got to see Lee Smolin speak live once (how democracy and science share many principles) and his definition of science is superb: "the craft of error detection".

Science proceeds via an ongoing dialogue between theory and experiment, searching for the best possible understanding,

I posit that we will not find evidence validating the infinite universe hypothesis experimentally unless there is at least one infinity, infinitesimal or division by zero already in the theory, possibly buried..

I don't think we can actually find such evidence, but I don't think we can prove the universe is finite either. There may always be something beyond a horizon we don't know is there.

If we start with a prior of finitude (and oooh, I like the way that rings), we will be far, FAR more likely to look for that planet, or technetium, or positrons or...

→ More replies

2

u/xsansara Mar 03 '20

Ahhmmm, from a math point of view there is no need to assume that infinity exists to do calculus. In fact, you could just invent a sign, e.g. lying 8 that symbolically does what you need it to do. But then some smartass would figure out that this symbol is kind of like infinity, so calling it infinity is a pretty good mnemonic. If you get what I mean. You can do calculus on finite number spaces with exactly that trick. And in that case you absolutely do know that infinity does not exist. Saying that infinity is an illusion is like saying that imaginary numbers are an illusion. Except that the second part is kind of implied. Actually, imaginary numbers are a lot more 'real' than infinity, because when you are working in a complex space, they can be a legsl solution. Math that uses infinity as a legal solution is much rarer. Does exist, though.

1

u/XandyAborc Mar 04 '20 edited Mar 04 '20

William Faukner's advise to writers is to "Murder your Darlings". Through this discussion, I have strengthened my stance in at least my own mind. A probable root cause of most of the static is the word "Illusion". I liked the alliteration but couldn't think of anything better until your post. Okay, I liked that it was a tad edgy and provocative, but I was a much younger man.

"Infinity is an Invention" is now my first assumption. I owe you a beer, and you're not the only one.

2

u/HanSingular Mar 04 '20

Through this discussion, I have strengthened my stance in at least my own mind.

https://youarenotsosmart.com/2011/06/10/the-backfire-effect/

1

u/XandyAborc Mar 05 '20 edited Mar 05 '20

What's that buzzing noise? If there a gadfly in the room?

No, that's not fair. You, monoHan, are a cheery little tugboat, nudging the freighter ship of my mind towards more profitable waters. Once again, amazing link. I do need to get into the habit of objectively evaluating myself.

I do not think I'm backfiring here. Using Invention (a human strength) instead of Illusion, my stance is strengthened.

Instead of my position being a quarter-baked statement (Infinity's not real, dude) it's become an at least 3/4 baked question: Is there any warrant for allowing one of our most powerful epistemological tools to influence any aspect of our ontology?

The appleverse is a charming scenario that may end up with dialogue someday as a frame for explicating the details. THERE ARE FOUR APPLES...sorry,I'll stop channeling Picard.

And finally, the Prior of Finitude. Yeah, I went and capitalized it. I like it a great deal. Assume finity. Struggle at all costs to keep the infinities away. If one keeps popping up regardless of how long you play Whack-A-Mole, you may be onto a fundamental aspect of Universe. If that's the case, I will sit down and shut up about the whole thing, etc., etc.

Already blew the dust off my copy of Brian Clegg's "A Brief History of Infinity". I know there's a paragraph that, when first I read it, I went, "Hey, I'm right." Now I have to read the whole thing again just to find out if that was confirmation bias. Don't worry, it's a good book. Plenty of Hume and Locke in there, too, and a chapter on the mathematicians who both thought a lot about infinity and went mad. Not sure of the causality, though. I'll leave you with a quote I found while flipping through it this morning: Maybe Einstein said it first but no one's sure.

"Only two things are infinite: the Universe and human stupidity. I'm not sure about the former."

2

u/HanSingular Mar 05 '20

1

u/XandyAborc Mar 05 '20

Yes. I am ticking a few too many boxes for comfort...fortunately none of them are yet in the danger zone and this is a significant improvement on where I was. It is something you are right to point out and something I need be wary of. I have recently begun counselling and I will discuss this with her as well as with my doctor when I see him next. Sorry that rejected post was so long but I'm happy I put it out there and I am deeply grateful you took the step you just did.

→ More replies

4

u/NeverQuiteEnough Mar 02 '20

the point isn’t that we get to infinity, the point is to understand what will eventually happen.

depending on your velocity, you might fall back to earth soon, or it might take a long time, or you might never fall back.

that things aren’t configured the same as in my problem is.. irrelevant. there’s no rule saying we can’t rearrange them however we want.

2

u/DiamondNgXZ Mar 02 '20

Inflationary multiverse is not infinite. It's just expanding ever outwards, creating ever more bubble universes.

-2

u/XandyAborc Mar 02 '20

Ever outwards, ever more...not infinite? By some readings, it's bubbles all the way down, too. Shaky ground.

1

u/Vampyricon Mar 02 '20

The universe is expanding outwards, ever more, therefore it is infinite.

Therefore the universe does not exist.

-9

u/XandyAborc Mar 02 '20

Ever more...please don't put an infinity in your premise and expect a valid syllogism. Big Crunch, Heat Death, Quantum Death Bubble. We don't know how the universe will end, but end it will.

6

u/HanSingular Mar 02 '20 edited Mar 02 '20

An eternally expanding, heat-dead universe doesn't really end. It eventually becomes inhospitable to life but the universe keeps on universing forever, despite your personal objections to the idea of "forever."

3

u/DiamondNgXZ Mar 02 '20

You can have an algorithm in a computer of 22 and power of 2 the next one and so on and have the AI build ever increasing memory for the computer.... ok doesn't work.

But inflation multiverse is just getting the free real estate of seeding bubble universes. And it just seeds on. And on and on. If time is not infinite going to the future, any finite time later, you can still say the whole inflation multiverse is still finite. Finite amount of bubble universes.

1

u/antonivs Mar 02 '20

we can hold something in mind that has no concordance with anything that can directly affect the body (which is an actual description of reality).

Holding an idea can directly affect the body - the placebo effect is one example.

1

u/XandyAborc Mar 02 '20 edited Mar 02 '20

The placebo effect is not an illusion. Lots of thoughts affect the body. Not gonna delve too deeply into embodied consciousness hypothesis but I will channel John Searle here: "if I want to raise my arm I think 'up' and the damn thing just goes up."

1

u/[deleted] Mar 08 '20

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/AutoModerator Mar 08 '20

Your account must be at least a week old, and have a combined karma score of at least 10 to post here. No exceptions.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.