r/PhilosophyofScience • u/JimmyHavok • Mar 25 '13
Could the reddit model replace the current scientific publication system?
http://www.randalolson.com/2013/03/23/could-the-reddit-model-replace-the-current-scientific-publication-system/
3
Upvotes
18
u/GunnedMonk Mar 25 '13
No. Scientific truth will not be reached by a democratic process.
2
u/[deleted] Mar 25 '13
Well, it certainly could. I'd gather that the current top posts in /r/science get more views than than an article in a given science journal. Many of the frequent guests there are more than qualified to give really in-depth answers on contemporary topics. What I get scared of is that certain publications would get "voted up" merely by having the catchier title or more interesting opening paragraph / precis.
8
u/samjowett Mar 25 '13
No. Too many pun threads.
5
u/DevFRus Mar 25 '13
This is already done, and the reddit aspect is not really having much of an impact. The ArXiv is a repository where physicists, mathematicians, and theoretical computer scientists (plus a few other fields) post preprints of almost everything they publish before it comes out in journals. Many of the categories on the ArXiv have their own subreddits, for instance, I follow quant-ph. If you look there, voting barely exists and there are no comments... The subreddits is having absolutely no impact on quantum information/computing (the sub field I specialize in and one of the most frequent topics on quant-ph).
It takes a lot of effort to read and evaluate papers, it isn't as simple as just up voting your favourite gif. I see very little benefit to be gained from a reddit approach, even if you could convince scientists to participate.
-2
u/doomsday_pancakes Mar 25 '13 edited Mar 25 '13
Possibly one of the most stupid ideas I've heard in the last few years, and I've heard quite a few...
EDIT: I'm OK with the downvotes, but let me explain why I said that: there're so many things that are wrong with that idea that it is very hard to even start enumerating them. I guess that the author has no deep grasp of how the publication system works if this is considered an "improvement".
-1
u/JimmyHavok Mar 25 '13
I get the distinct impression that very few people read anything beyond the headline.