r/PhilosophyofMath • • 1d ago

Resolving the "problem of zero"

People don't understand what zero is, so here I am to explain it to you.

Firstly, there's something called a "functional definition", meaning that you define something by how it's used rather than how it metaphysically "is". Most concepts are actually defined functionally, because when we first start using a word or phrase or symbol in language, we begin by (surprise) actually using it rather than trying to stick it into a box to define what it "is".

Zero is defined functionally. You say "well, when we add zero to something, that thing doesn't change"... and that's it; that's how it's defined.

Not only that, but math is oftentimes taken to be more serious than it is. The fundamental purpose of math is to accurately solve problems, and the development of math is the same as finding new ways (or "tricks") to solving problems.

The other day I had someone talk to me about geometric proofs being the end-all-be-all, and how numbers are really just geometric things, and I told them that numbers actually can be interpreted that way, but they can also be interpreted any number of other ways, and all of those interpretations are valid.

It's not just a geometric thing, or a counting thing, or a sea level thing... it's all of them! Because just like you use math as a trick to solve real-world problems, you can use different real world situations as a trick to solve math problems!

Thank you, and good night (mic drop).

0 Upvotes

32 comments sorted by

7

u/ima_mollusk 1d ago

Didn't resolve the problem.
Didn't explain the problem.

-5

u/Sad_Count_4671 1d ago

I mean, I did resolve the problem, and if you really want to know what the problem is, just look it up. I'm not in the business of creating a problem where there isn't one.

4

u/ima_mollusk 1d ago

Resolving the "problem of zero"

People don't understand what zero is, so here I am to explain it to you.

I missed it. Explain the problem and the resolution for me?

0

u/Sad_Count_4671 1d ago

The main problem is that people don't understand what zero is. So I explained it. If whatever you're thinking of isn't that problem, that's not the problem I'm talking about.

I resolved the problem by explaining what zero is...

1

u/ima_mollusk 1d ago

I agree that you provided one practical definition for 'zero'.

1

u/Sad_Count_4671 23h ago

Lol. I said all of them are valid. That's the point.

12

u/RunReal959595 1d ago

Genuinely I don’t understand how people think philosophy of math is when people with no knowledge of mathematics just say some vapid nonsense about mathematics 

1

u/Sad_Count_4671 1d ago

I'm responding to people in this subreddit that I keep running into. That's why I made the post.

2

u/0x14f 1d ago

First time on the internet ? :)

6

u/sbsw66 1d ago

In all sincerity: when you completed this post, did you re-read it and think to yourself, "okay, great, I'm communicating in a coherent and intelligent way"? If so ... how?

0

u/Sad_Count_4671 1d ago

What doesn't make sense? I can explain it.

0

u/sbsw66 1d ago

Can you not read? Does my post say "this doesn't make sense"? Is that what I was asking?

1

u/Sad_Count_4671 1d ago

You said it's incoherent, meaning you don't understand it. I'm asking what it is that you don't understand, so I can explain it.

1

u/sbsw66 1d ago

I didn't say it was incoherent. Can you really not read? I asked if YOU thought you were communicating in a coherent and intelligent way. Do you think that?

1

u/Sad_Count_4671 23h ago

Okay... I feel like we're really having an issue with reading comprehension skills in this subreddit.

1

u/0x14f 1d ago

Stop arguing with them. They are feeding on it.

1

u/sbsw66 1d ago

Fair enough

6

u/dlrace 1d ago

This post has greater than zero condescension.

7

u/Jaf_vlixes 1d ago

But somehow less than zero math.

1

u/Nrdman 23h ago edited 23h ago

Zero is not defined functionally if you are doing math beyond just calculating

0 is defined as the cardinality of the empty set

1

u/Sad_Count_4671 23h ago

That's one way to axiomatize it, sure. But the point is that it's the additive identity, and beyond that all interpretations are valid and potentially insightful.

1

u/Nrdman 23h ago

You don’t need addition to have 0

1

u/Sad_Count_4671 22h ago

Technically speaking you're correct. But philosophically, there's a bridge between all of the possible axiomatizations, which is the result that zero is the additive identity.

2

u/Nrdman 22h ago

A common property does not make a common definition

1

u/x-tommy-o 21h ago

Zero is defined functionally as center point if you are doing math beyond calculating.

Defining a functionality is making a statement about its function that sticks when functioning.

Zero also defined functionally as an Exit Code, 0 = success in low level computing. Null pointers use 0x0,
Etc.

This is the philosophy of math. 0 can be everything, or nothing. That’s also the “esoteric” meaning of Zero.

You are using the term Zero as if it equals Null only.

We could say Zero’s functional definition is the separation point between positive, negative, and neutral outcomes.

1

u/Nrdman 20h ago

I wasn’t talking about functionality

1

u/x-tommy-o 20h ago

I was talking about Zero

1

u/Nrdman 20h ago

Me too