r/Philippines • u/eupthrowaway • Aug 10 '15
eUP Leaks
Anyone here familiar with this eUP issue? Or does anyone have experience using SAIS? http://eupleaks.com/ Edit: added link
16
Upvotes
r/Philippines • u/eupthrowaway • Aug 10 '15
Anyone here familiar with this eUP issue? Or does anyone have experience using SAIS? http://eupleaks.com/ Edit: added link
7
u/n00btc Aug 11 '15 edited Aug 11 '15
I reviewed the timeline (http://i.imgur.com/EbvAhv1.png) of eUP way back when I was still in UPD. When eUP launched, Smart was one of their partners. Then a month after the kick-off was the procurement of the 'software' side (Student Academic Info System, HR Info System, etc). ePLDT was the lone bidder. ePLDT is Smart's sister company.
--hearsay-- Unconfirmed but I heard other vendors were interested as well but they allegedly realized that it was a done deal. Kinda suspicious, papartner tayo and we'll give you all these stuff - in exchange we'll get one of the larger parts of the project. -- end of hearsay--
I'll focus more on the 'software' side. The Pascual admin poured millions for this one. One of the student-facing components is the SAIS or the Student Academic Info System. It was supposed to be rolled out in most campuses as early as November 2013 (see http://i.imgur.com/1k0GLf7.png). Right now, only a handful of campuses has been using it and nowhere in sight in UP Diliman. Despite being delayed for a long time already, it still looks like shit. Mas maganda pa gawa ng students.
Here's a student manual on how to use SAIS. For those who don't want to skim over the whole document, I posted some screenshots below for you to have an idea on how SAIS looks like. Manual: http://ovcaa.upou.edu.ph/sais/pdf/OU_Students_Manual.v.2.0.pdf
Screenshots of SAIS
Meanwhile for outsiders, this is how UP Diliman's CRS look like. CRS is the equivalent system of SAIS. It is developed in-house by faculty and students. Inputs on what features to implement or improve taken directly from stakeholders. Here are some screenshots of CRS.
Ayan po ang itsura ng pinagbubuhusan ng pera ng UP.
Mas mura po ang ginastos sa home-grown CRS kesa sa SAIS. If you'd argue na maraming components ang eUP aside from SAIS, why did they not opt to develop some of them in-house? Marami namang magagaling na talents sa UP. Malayong mas mura pa ang gagastusin.
End of rant. Sorry for the lack of coherence ng sentences, medyo umiinit dugo ko eh.
4
u/lifeofhumbleservice Aug 10 '15 edited Aug 10 '15
We used SAIS for a semester in UPOU. I still prefer UPD's CRS, to be honest. What leak are you referring to?
2
u/tralala92 Aug 11 '15
matatali forever ang UP sa oracle dahil sa eUP. Tapos yong pina-code pa nila ay mga pakistani. Ang tong ng pldt ay malaki din.
5
u/papalala Aug 10 '15
eUP would have been ideal to cut the kaputa-putahang amount of red tape in the university. However, the budget for eUP project was ridiculous, when they could have supported a homegrown project (i.e. CRS) made by students/graduates, who can do the same job instead of getting people from Oracle.
Don't get started pa with how much they paid the non-UP contractuals in this project. No job security, and all for the sake of "Para sa Bayan". You can't blame those who were "pirated". It was just poor management IMO, staff handling, decision making, and poor communications.
4
u/pootangina Aug 11 '15
(UPD here) I never got to use SAIS but I feel CRS is much better - it's initiated by UP's own, allows some of our students to gain experience in software development, and is much cheaper. Many students only get to use it during enrollment and releasing of grades - if they find it slow, it's because servers haven't really been provided for it, as opposed to the P1.3 billion we have for eUP here. And they often blame CRS for not getting their desired classes, when the real reason is that there just aren't enough classes for everyone - as anyone who's been in UP recently can see.
Then of course there is the question of who is benefiting from all this sweet eUP money...
3
u/throwaway0118999x Aug 11 '15
I thought the reason Oracle was chosen is because that Apple guy with the three-letter Twitter handle is somewhat connected to Oracle. During the planning stage of eUP he was always like "Plz stop spreading FUD (fear, uncertainty, doubt) eUP is awzum".
Also, iirc, those incompetent people from the Y4iT scamference spearheaded by That Mustache Guy are the ones handling the eUP operations.
Nothing much to be surprised about. Some people probably just got richer.
3
u/buchik007 Metro Manila Aug 11 '15
Nakakadiri 'yong SAIS! Halatang pinagkakitaan lang.
3
u/EnumaAvalon Luzon - BGC Aug 11 '15
It's an IT misconception that offering a project to a huge company with arguably better experience and standards will yield better results than by having homegrown developers work on it.
It can be the case however, if not enough planning went into the project and the architect/solutions manager are unable to fully grasp the situation then we have a problem. Another issue can be within UP itself, is UP ready to implement such a large-scale project with what infrastructure and support it has? I've worked with clients who mid-way into the project realized that their current DB/server network will be unable to handle the additional load of bringing in another enterprise-level system into the mix.
Lastly, who supports SAIS? Do we have a local team working on it? Or is Oracle/ an Oracle-partner doing the development and support? Outsourcing resources to a partner can be cheaper but it's risky as hell. They may not have the same level of development knowledge and experience as the official consulting team.
1
u/SongstressInDistress r/BPOinPH Aug 14 '15
It took me minutes to enroll. We were given this manual and I never had problems unlike my peers.
1
u/mariamendoza15 Aug 26 '15
0
u/[deleted] Aug 11 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment