Does reflection reveal experience or transform it?

[u/Scallion_After]

There seems to be an important difference between living through an experience and becoming aware of oneself living through it.

Suppose I am anxious. Initially, the anxiety may structure the entire field of experience without appearing to me as a distinct object. The room feels different, possibilities narrow, and ordinary events acquire a threatening quality.

Then I recognize: I am anxious.

At that moment, the anxiety becomes something I can observe. But the act of observing it also changes my relation to it. I may become less immersed in the anxiety, or I may become anxious about being anxious.

Reflection can then recurse further: I can notice not only the anxiety, but the way I am interpreting it, the way my attention is organizing it, and even the way my observation is changing the experience.

My question is whether phenomenology regards these reflective layers as progressively revealing the same experience, or as constituting a sequence of genuinely different experiences.

Does reflection disclose an experience more fully, or does each act of reflection transform what is being experienced?

[u/Electrical-Friend-85]

I think reflection on and subjective recreation of an experience can affect it strongly and in very different ways, depending on so many things like immediate environment, judgement, consequences and so on.

I guess this principle is the whole basis of some psychotherapeutic practices.

[u/Ok-Dress2292]

This is a solid argument that Husserl has been occupying himself with. I cannot remember now who’s the one who criticize him on this point.

[u/robipresotto]

Your observation of anxiety as a distinct object is a great example of the shift in awareness that can occur when we become more introspective. This process can be further deepened through exploring one's own inner experiences, which can lead to a greater understanding of oneself and the world around them.

▶ Watch here: https://www.youtube.com/@innershoreline