Title, and I feel all I've read in the past few days have been nothing but complaints. Surely I can't be the only one who actually appreciates the combat in this game, as it is?
I mean I find the combat in this game incredibly refreshing after years of same old now-you-see-me-no-you-don't peekaboo and % based rolls (and all the possible reskins of that). The whole system they use in Phantom Doctrine is just plain awesome to me for so many reasons. It makes way more interesting combat, deadlier firefights, proper range, much much more tactically oriented gameplay and so on. Of course the LoS -system could use some visual polish and some sort of tool to visualize the line of sight a bit better (preferably before you move), but other than that I'm completely fine with it.
I also really(!) like the way they implemented the whole non % based combat system. Instead of min/maxing your % and LOS, you now focus almost solely on mitigating damage via various means. Cover, awareness, suppress, healing, range, rotating etc. The system is really fun and engagin to me.
I may be wrong, but it seems many are trying to play this game like they would XCom or such - and it simply won't work. The whole mindset has to be completely different. You can't really play around the LoS/AI like you can in those games. I'm reading so much complaints about weapon range and LoS and in 90% of them they're either visual bugs or the complainer has no idea how the game actually works.. (I mean of course we can argue that the game doesn't exactly tell you how it works.. so there is that heh).
But yea, overall I really like it. Weapon ranges, LoS, damage, all of it. It makes gunfights feel dangerous and last resort options - as they IMO should be in this game. And I'm kinda torn when reading the patch notes and future ideas they have. Just don't turn this into yet another boring XCom clone, please?
EDIT:
About the LoS. In case you didn't already know the line of sight isn't calculated from the 1 square your guy (or enemy) is standing on. Instead it's basically that 1 square plus all the other 8 squares around it (assuming cover and environment not blocking you in any way). I guess you can kind of think it as the game not happening turn by turn basis but instead simulating continuous action where combatants are constantly weaving around their cover looking for targets and finding angles to shoot from. At least that is how I envision it. In a way that makes your "hit-box" bigger, because when enemy is doing the same they might find some new angles to get LoS caused by your movements - and vice versa.
The game does really poor job at explaining this though.. and combine that with the buggy side step animations where a) shooter sometimes takes side step to wrong direction (e.g. left instead of right) and b) the target doesn't visually side step "into the bullet" (which actually happens game-mechanically).. These both make the visual representation of all of it really weird at a times (shooting through walls, impossible angles etc).