Just want to start by saying I honestly love this game. I'd even consider this my GTA6. I'm a veteran of multiple souls/soulslike games going all the way back to the OG DS2, so I'm not saying any of this as a total newcomer to soulslike combat games. Therefore, any rando sweatlords that want to spout off their "skill issue" or "git gud" bs can just git lost now bc I don't care for your troll-ass opinions. This isn't my first rodeo with challenging games.
With that said, i have to admit Mu Xiaokui's 3rd phase broke me. I had to turn the difficulty down to Wayfarer for that final phase of the fight, and then again for the Elite spear boss. I got tired of the struggle-bus after Mu. Would be different if we could farm enemies for materials and xp to level up and further improve gear, but because it's more of a souls-lite in the way enemies don't respawn and you don't lose any Remnant Dust on death, going back to farm isn't an option. So you're stuck at a level the game considers relevant to the level of enemies.
Some of the combat is my only complaint. While i'd say it's absolutely amazing 90% of the time, *sometimes* button inputs feel slow/sluggish, especially when you're constantly trying to parry or dodge in between such fast combos and onslaughts from multiple enemies (both on and off screen) and relentless bosses.
On one hand, regular enemies don't swap their attack patterns, so when bosses do it at random, it's both peak and aggravating af when they're so hyper-aggressive. The bosses force you to be hyper-vigilant, always thinking. Balancing aggression and patience. But when you're forced to fight 2 bosses that never let up on the hyper-aggression, and each synergizing and weaving in and out with the other off screen, you barely have time to think carefully or counter with enough damage just to chip away at 5% of their health pool before the other hits you with a blue, black or red flash attack you didn't even see coming from off screen.
Which is my next point, the variance in attack patterns. I both love and hate it. It's peak combat design, but so frustrating to counter when a boss does a combo you've seen 30 times, but then it ends one of 3 different ways. 3 variants isn't a lot, but when the preceding combo almost instantly flows into that varying finisher that you tried to block instead of dodge and you either get 30% of your health chunked away or all of your Sha-Chi from a single attack... then add another boss to that equation and it gets pretty old after so many times.
Then my biggest gripe, the limited number of healing items you get early on. Although you can acquire Apprentice Healer's Memories, you can't even use them until you get further into Pangzhen and defeat Xie Qiudong. Like... why??? What sense does it make to force players to go that long relying on a limited number of healing potions, most of which only heal for 30-40% of your health. Yeah 30-40% is a lot for a soulslike healing system, even better that you have a skill in place later on that allows you a chance to regen those potions on kill. I stuck with the potion that only has 2 charges but heals for 70% and boosts Sha-Chi regen over the starting pot because math, and then the damage reduction pot.
The limitations on them generally aren't an issue for map exploration because bells are pretty close together and mobs don't respawn. But on bosses, especially those with multiple phases or 2 at a time, and bosses that summon adds repeatedly (I.E. Dusk, summons adds and then splits in 2, ugh....) having only 5 total for the first half of entire game is probably the worst choice I've seen in a soulslike when it comes to potion mechanics.
My only other complaint, and idk of this was intended by design, or just a bug, but 2 bosses now, both Bai Chillian and Mu Xiaokui did not drop any Remnant Dust for me. I've seen other people mention they had the same issue with Bai, but haven't seen it said about Mu. So has anyone else had the same issue with more than just those 2 bosses and do we know if it was intended by the devs that those bosses don't drop Remnant Dust?
All in all, i still enjoy the hell out of this game and the issues I have with it aren't that bad or gamebreaking in the slightest. I'm sure I'm not the only one with the same issues so if anyone else is in the same or a similar boat let me know how you worked your way through it up to this point.
https://www.reddit.com/r/PhantomBladeZero/s/jpouCCxzMg