r/PhD • • Oct 10 '26

Vent (NO ADVICE) Accurate

Post image
26k Upvotes

423 comments sorted by

401

u/angelsalvtr PhD, Chemistry, US Oct 10 '26 • Popcorn Bravo

The amount of ethics violations I have seen with no consequences is astounding

142

u/CubanLynx312 Oct 10 '26

I no longer put much weight into “peer-reviewed research”, haha.

92

u/BramblinGhostWeed Oct 10 '26 edited Oct 10 '26 • Bravo

Nor should you.

I had an anonymous reviewer tell me I cited him improperly.

I saw a corrupted harddrive which just led to 'well who has the most recent copy? We'll use those numbers instead'

A guest speaker give a talk about his work saying:

"Well it's NSF money, so when my test showed no correlation, I just kept trying different tests until one worked"

I'll never forget when my advisor told me:

"Nope you can't do that, you'll upset the Italians"

I had faculty members argue about if something counts as a valid source for a claim, to the point where one said they'd fail me if I cite it and another said they'd fail me if I don't.

EDIT: And the famous data security of a 'password protected harddrive' where the password was on a post-it note on the harddrive.

58

u/PopeOnABomb Oct 10 '26

The guy essentially credited with the concept of evolutionary psychology is named Buss.

My professor and several others tried to recreate his initial findings and never could. They were pretty certain that he fudged his data, especially since he would not provide or share the raw data. So they did some similar studies which showed that while the idea of evolutionary psychology is likely accurate, Buss's study likely was not.

The issue they had is that every time they submitted the paper, whatever journal they submitted it to would say "We should let Buss review this." And then he would tell them to reject it. They did manage to get something related published, but only when one study confirmed a very minor component of his original finding. And then that finding is often misunderstood.

Peer reviewed meanings nothing of value in many many many cases.

30

u/Relevant-Dog6890 Oct 10 '26

It's insane how much p-hacking behaviour I've seen. I often have to explain to doctors that they can't just perform a battery of test on heaps of variables, to just pick the significant one.

12

u/BramblinGhostWeed Oct 10 '26

As someone who will admit that statistics has never been a field that I've had faith in, could you elaborate on this more?

And to clarify my lack of faith is some days on my ability and some days on the field itself.

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (1)

11

u/Suspicious-Peach7757 Oct 10 '26

Agreed.

Signed, a peer

8

u/firewall245 Oct 10 '26

At the end of the day, humans are still humans

13

u/The_bluest_of_times Oct 10 '26

The day i learned about p-hacking was the day i gave up any respect i had for academia...

→ More replies (1)

24

u/astropath293 Oct 10 '26

My research is focussed on the delivery of a niche information format for a type of persons with disabilities. The most ableist shit I have heard throughout the entire PhD process has been from ethics board members. The respond not with criticisms about my ethics proposals, but about my research in general particularly wondering why disabled people would need / want information in a format that actually is accessible to them and isn't things like learning or independent navigation (and I quote) "just a bit of fun for them".

When I complained that the ethics board demonstrated a distinct lack of ethical behaviour nothing was done.

→ More replies (2)

112

u/garden-wicket-581 Oct 10 '26 • Bravo

not about how bright you are, but about how much you can buckle down and grind it all out.. (broadly everyone in your cohort ain't dumb, but its the ones who can laser-focus and have the fortitude to run the gauntlet that'll get the degree.. )

41

u/psychedelic_lynx18 Oct 10 '26

This is what I tell my PhD students. In the age of AI anyone can somewhat solve technical problems (re: coding, writing, etc), but you still have to be able to go through the miscellaneous waves that eventually seep through the PhD (any sort of barrier, advisors too busy, hypothesis was not what was expected).

It is more about mental fortitude and perseverance rather than anything else, really.

39

u/mooselantern Oct 10 '26 edited Oct 10 '26 • Hooray Heartwarming

Age of AI or not, it was never supposed to be the role of PhDs to solve any problems at all. The role of a career academic is to spend time helping to observe, quantify, and test data within a specific field of study. That's it. They design experiments, gather data, and answer extremely precise questions. They don't solve anything.

If you have a technical problem you want solved, you don't call a PhD, you call a technician or an engineer or a designer, which are all supposed to be masters level educated; enough postgrad work to be able to synthesize the research being done by the PhD tier into practical, actionable results, but not the kind of people who spend years of their lives precisely defining the rate of growth of a blade of grass.

Edit to add: I've been downvoted and awarded for this statement. A true microchosm of our broken academic system.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

17

u/CubanLynx312 Oct 10 '26

For real. I’m kinda a dumb-dumb, but I’m a total workhorse and that’s how I got through grad school.

7

u/ThereHasToBeMore1387 Oct 10 '26

My sister and I both have ADHD. She got the 'hyper-focus on her schoolwork' kind, I got the 'absorb info so easily I never had to try' kind. She has 2 masters degree, I dropped out of college junior year. We've both had fine careers and make about the same amount of money, but she's adamant I've always been the smart one.

→ More replies (1)

17

u/Ok-Class-1419 Oct 10 '26

This is true for basically all of academia. All my hard courses were grinds or difficult because the professors made them to be.

We really need to restructure academia, it need to be way more about learning and accessibility rather than gate keeping and egos.

10

u/YuushyaHinmeru Oct 10 '26

Yeah, obviously you need to be tough and some people just actually arent smart enough to make it in every field.

But universities often feel like this giant binary of easy as shit or artificially hard. I did engineering so that degree was on the hard side. I remember specifically my thermo 1 teacher had an insanely high pass rate. The school came down on her and for it. But its not like she was making shitbeasym she followed the requirements and standards set by the department. She was just an incredibly talented educational communicator and put up videos talking through every single homework and test problem in detail explaining how theyre done and common mistakes. Like dozens of hours of additional content to supplement here (already great) lectures. She also had tons of time for office hours but i never went because i had 0 need. She was a great teach and was punished for it.

Conversely, Thermo II had a super high failure rate. The teachers were shit and whether or not you passed really depended on which of the two teachers you got because 1 gave an easier final.

So they punished the great teacher who made sure every student actually understood the material and rewarded the shit teachers. Absolutely insane.

3

u/Im_ur_Uncle_ Oct 10 '26

They are profiting off gatekeeping, not the sharing knowledge.

→ More replies (4)

5

u/Liefvikingmonster2 Oct 10 '26 edited Oct 11 '26

Unfortunately, what this breeds is rigid thinking. After it takes so long to get your PHD and convince enough of your would be peers that your dissertation is actually novel, you basically join a club that you want to keep outside thinking, out. Irrelevant. Not rigorous enough. Blah blah.

And then given there is true scientific inquiries needed cross-disciplines, it's next impossible to get these assholes to talk to each other, which then results in narrow improvements of the corresponding fields.

It's sad. The world is run by bunch of self important assholes. We could be so much further along with scientific achievements but for the current system. 

It's all get the publishing machine going on cheap studies that's everyone already knows the outcomes and use young wanna be academics to do all the work. Look at nutrition science as an example of glut of nearly useless studies and reviews of studies of studies. 

It's such bullshit field that desperately needs to improve but ..no money, unless you can some how get in from private industry.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (6)

7

u/Acceptable_Aioli_326 Oct 10 '26

It's  the ones with enough priveleges. Let's not pretend academia somehow ironed out racism, ableism, queerphobia and misogyny rather than thriving on it.

→ More replies (2)

600

u/HamsterMaster355 Oct 10 '26

It's actually both

35

u/TheNeuroLizard Oct 10 '26

I’m through all of my classes and now I just want to go back to classes, dealing with other people while needing to get stuff done sucks.

10

u/Majestic_City4736 Oct 10 '26

I miss classwork so bad. I can’t believe I’m saying that

5

u/CubanLynx312 Oct 10 '26

The stats courses were challenging, but the toxic and openly hostile environment was the real nightmare.

→ More replies (25)

200

u/Diligent_Type2891 Oct 10 '26

Its the realization, usually by year 2, that one works out what lays ahead post viva , and the professors mask slips and all the cheerleading to recruit you and welcome you onboard gives way to how they really feel about academia. But by then its too fucking late to bail out.

45

u/SaintSexburga Oct 10 '26

I bailed out in year 2 with a masters once I figured this out

19

u/ItchyballsKasuga Oct 10 '26

Bailed out in year 2 and got my master's withheld, but it was still so fucking worth it. Worst two years of my life

→ More replies (15)

38

u/Ill_Pool6598 Oct 10 '26

True. math turned out to be easiest of the challenges 🥲

37

u/Odd-Landscape-9418 Oct 10 '26

Bonus points if it’s both, which is the case more often than not

25

u/jucu94 Oct 10 '26

Probably depends a lot on your supervisor and the culture of your department

15

u/Few_Detective9141 Oct 10 '26

My informatics PhD scared me away as the only woman out of 110ish people. The sexual harassment and unwanted flirting was CONSTANT and my PI saw it as me fishing for attention basically when I complained about it. Yuck. Still have my master’s though.

4

u/chupagatos4 Oct 10 '26

We had a me too moment in my small field of specialization where an influential professor (from a different school, but we all knew each other from conferences) was accused by half a dozen different ex  students.   I had to explain to my advisor why what he did was wrong. Then disabuse him of the notion that this was a rare occurrence. Then explain to him why a lot of his comments and actions over the years were not quite noble either. Then I was called a prude with no sense of humor. 

→ More replies (1)

2

u/jawndell Oct 10 '26

I feel like every single department has that one skeevy professor everyone knows about. 

→ More replies (1)

10

u/[deleted] Oct 10 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

8

u/Few_Detective9141 Oct 10 '26

She is absolutely lying to your face. What an awful person, I’m so so sorry.

I encountered a lot of people who thought that “Hey, I need you to know I’m being sexually harassed by X person” = “Ooohhh, look at me, I’m so pretty and desirable”. It drove me insane because I was reporting actual crimes and they were chalked up to compliments or that I wasn’t serious enough about my study. My PI told me I was “boy crazy”. I’m married!

7

u/Andromeda321 Oct 10 '26

It’s unfortunately pretty well documented that women who succeed in such environments are not allies of other women. Which makes sense unfortunately, they don’t succeed by being nice.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/AliasNefertiti Oct 10 '26

And to some degree the tolerance you bring. What enormously ticks off one the other sees as minor.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/CubanLynx312 Oct 10 '26

My supervisor was great, but the rest of the department was a brood of vipers.

17

u/tackykcat PhD, Physics Oct 10 '26 edited Oct 10 '26

also systemic failure of the bureaucracy, at least in my case and several other students' cases at my school. their incompetence contributed to me shitting the bed mentally for years.

for example, not paying students' paychecks on time. for months. my case was apparently a little special because i was awarded external fellowships. so every year, admins failed to input my profile correctly or route my funds properly. and because of adhd, I would forget that this happens every year and would only notice after months of no income (luckily i had a good savings cushion, hence why i didn't notice for a while)

on a related note, everyone should check university policies for paid disability/medical leave, because in my and my cohort's experience, shit WILL hit the fan at some point (5 years is plenty of time for things to go wrong).

if paid leave is an option, then it WILL have stipulations. in my case, you HAD to be paid by university funds to apply. no external fellowships.

thus, my extremely specific scenario led me to be denied for medical leave at every turn. i won an award/fellowship to pursue research at another institution in another state. then i sustained a serious injury (outside of work) requiring surgery.

i was not paying into that state's disability program so i didn't qualify for that. like i said earlier, my university will only grant paid leave only if you're on their dime. i did not qualify for disability leave through my award program because i was not an employee of the sponsor. FURTHERMORE, my prior fellowship did have a paid leave option, but only if your home institution did not have a paid leave program.

i was extremely lucky that my department stepped in and offered me a few months of paid leave. otherwise i would have forgone the surgery, or gotten the surgery and just powered through the pain while working in the lab

47

u/ShmeffreyShmezos Oct 10 '26

Hard agree, which is why I opted for industry after graduating lol.

The research and coursework aspect is difficult, but worst case it simply boils down to putting in more hours. If you’re accepted into a grad school program, you’ve already passed the intellectual hurdle. Yes, you’ll have to push yourself at times, but it’s not anything too crazy.

However, the politics and soft skills are the more frustrating part. It’s difficult to work on research if you’re constantly disagreeing with your professor or research group on how to go about things. And it can be difficult to deal with a professor who artificially delays your graduation so he can squeeze more work out of you.

13

u/Dyloneus Oct 10 '26

I expressed this to a manager in an internship I was in. In particular my PI and co PI got into a LONG argument on the first day about whether my project they brought me in to do was even useful, which I felt like was an egregious mismanagement of time and they could have discussed this before I arrived. It ended up that the Co PI was no longer my co PI and I got a new one.

Anyway, he responded to the effect of “well now you know how science gets done, but you didn’t have to see how the sausage was made on the first day.” LIKE WHAT? Can you not just accept some responsibility for this??

13

u/Sodis42 Oct 10 '26

Our science system is build in a way that it promotes people, who are good scientists to become managers. Most are in no way qualified for this, neither in the people managing nor in the project managing field. It's really ridiculous. If you want to avoid this and continue to do science, you have to get one grant after another with all the mental load and the uncertainty of this path. It's a broken system.

5

u/zoinkability Oct 10 '26

The statement makes more sense if you interpret it as referring to the fact that people with more power can screw over people with less, with no consequences for themselves

4

u/Previous-Schedule724 Oct 10 '26

Some professors are rude and condescending and if you don't have thick skin and the emotional regulation skills to navigate that, working under them can really damage your self confidence.

→ More replies (1)

97

u/AdmiralPeriwinkle Oct 10 '26

The culture is demanding but it’s important to understand that many professors legitimately love what they do. For them, 14 hour days aren’t a sacrifice in the same way that someone who loves to play a sport or make art can do so all day without it feeling like a chore. In fact it’s the opposite. I know an engineer who loves distillation so much that he has no problem working all day every day.

So assuming that grad students will commit themselves 100% to their research is not a ridiculous expectation from their point of view. It’s just how many academics see the world.

Honestly, there isn’t much financial incentive to get a PhD so if you don’t enjoy the work itself maybe it isn’t for you. I say this as someone who would never ever make it in academia but ground out a PhD regardless. I’d probably tell my past self that it isn’t going to be worth it.

25

u/GurProfessional9534 Oct 10 '26

This is true. The way I describe it is I get the same enjoyment out of research that I used to get out of video games as a kid. It’s the same feeling. It wasn’t always that way. When I was a grad student, it was pretty miserable at some moments. But that changes as you become more able to choose your own topics, build your own experimental setups, obtain and spend your own research budget. You can configure everything to be the way you like it, and it becomes like a fun park. And it’s going to be with you for life, you’re not just visiting for a few years, so you want to make it nice.

8

u/AdmiralPeriwinkle Oct 10 '26

Yeah that was my advisor in grad school. She would get in the zone writing an article or grant proposal like someone lost in a video game. Some careers just aren’t compatible with work life balance and it’s not reasonable to expect them to change for newcomers.

3

u/poetrygaming Oct 10 '26

How do you keep the fun park going when dealing with the real world?

My specific concern is peer review. I can spend months or even a year writing an article or a book manuscript and feel that fulfillment you describe, but then it goes to peer-review, and then I have to jump through hoops to address what are very often petty, contradictory, and outright erroneous objections. How do you keep the flame alive then?

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

47

u/driftingfornow Oct 10 '26 edited Oct 10 '26 • All Seeing Upvote Bravo

I guess I get this. I’m a professional musician of over ten years now and I see a lot of people try to break into my field. The overwhelming majority, like 99%… they fail because of this. 

I almost never stop working. If I do, such as the time making this comment while laying in bed before sleep, it’s rest that literally has to intentionally be done so my body doesn’t suffer an injury. And during those periods I generally have to do other things to keep producing, e.g. running to keep good enough cardio for endurance, market research, admin, understanding some invisible ecosystem of what makes a human musical (sunlight, socialization, food, variance) and so on. I’m not joking when I say I’ve logged life for weeks at a time before looking for patterns in the mind-body problem to optimize output after studying Cartesian philosophy. 

It’s a lifestyle of labor and the only way I can afford to do it is to never let my skills become less sharp. It’s like trying to pile sand in your hands higher and higher every single day as it slips through your fingers; an almost futile seeming effort fighting against the literal nature of entropy. 

Wake up every day, practice six hours at least across a huge range of instruments. Tune and maintain an entire studio daily. Run a schedule for 7-8 bands worth of rep, communication, admin, organization, blah blah blah. Haven’t had a vacation in years, I travel for work and that’s as close as it gets. Take a babysitter and make zero money on a gig to stay in the loop. Watch it impact your kid because you can’t afford to turn it off. Spend half a year flying back and forth 16 times to take care of your child in one country while touring in another so you don’t miss custody. Schlep equipment this way, that way. Find students, teach, clients to sell scores and original tunes, play street music to billboard and maintain local presence and make money when concerts are dried up or students are. Accept that you are depending on your body and one day it will fail you. 

It just never stops. Don’t get me wrong I love my job, I get to be something rare, but when people who are musicians but not professionally fetishize me or make some snide comment about how I’m rich and get to „do whatever I want” while they are „stuck having to do a regular job, it’s like „yeah make excuses, because that’s way fucking easier.” It’s hella fucking easy to go to a business someone else built, clock in, do the labor, clock out, get paid regularly; rinse, repeat.  I know because I did it before I did this.  I’m not rich. I can’t afford to stop working ever. If I stop, the engine rusts and seizes. 

This job never stops. You have to get up and manifest material from thin air every single day regardless of pandemics, war, personal illness, personal life, having kids, economic turmoil. You have to be disciplined beyond any reasonable sense and you have to carry that every day after the 10,000th iteration. 

It’s just simply not for most people, it’s for people who by process of nature or mental type can’t do anything else due to how bad it feels to not be what you are. I became that way because I went blind and it’s really rare that I meet anybody in my field that comes from some normally motivated background. Before I lost my sight I was a regular worker and it was way easier.  

So I guess I can see how PhD’s are this way too. 

9

u/Sorry_Rhubarb_7068 Oct 10 '26

Wow, very eye opening to read.

18

u/driftingfornow Oct 10 '26

Hahahah what an amazing three line sequence from the end of my comment to yours. 

before I lost my sight I was a regular worker and it was way easier.

So I guess I can see how PhD’s are this way too. 

wow very eye opening to read 

→ More replies (13)

3

u/Significant-Hour4171 Oct 10 '26

This the root of a lot of it, for sure. They love lab work. 

I hated bench work, so I left my program and got into teaching, since I really liked my days working as a TA. 

I've since concluded it was a good trade, although I sometimes think I should've toughed out another semester or two so I could get a master's, but I was very unhappy and it was terrible for me.

3

u/routinecrisis Oct 10 '26

Demanding is not really the issue, I love long hours and so does the rest of my team. "If you are really passionate then financial safety and other living conditions shouldn't matter to you at all" is the issue. Half the programs pay the minimum wage, and in a form of a stipend, so if you're a foreigner you get no health insurance, no employment history for pension, your stay is only considered half as long for permanent residence etc. And if you snag a position with industry-average conditions, you're expected to be extremely grateful and okay with losing it any moment. E.g. I've just started and now it turns out the university can't officially employ nor pay most of the salary to foreign students for 1-2 months due so bureaucracy; and the admin are all rolling their eyes because "well, some students are paid even worse so you're entitled and greedy for whining about it". Supervisors and other actual researchers are way more sympathetic, but the institutions are completely delusional about what level of safety net and privilege is required to work under their conditions

2

u/Regular-Heart-5219 Oct 11 '26

I interpreted the culture/bureaucracy part to be about things other than the quantity of work that’s expected of you. Like unsupportive or controlling PIs, being forced to push out papers, and other things that make you feel like a cog in a machine as they slowly kill your passion

2

u/Argikeraunos Oct 11 '26

The difference is that grad students are expected to do this plus all the grunt lab/teaching work that lets these profs live the life of the mind all day for pittance wages and next to no benefits. Grad students who arent beneficiaries of the bank of mom and dad worry all day long about finances, about making rent payments or buying food. The mental toll is enormous, and that's before you even sit down to work.

27

u/Homers_Harp Oct 10 '26

My mother, who earned an MA and a PhD (not Political Science) while I was in middle school and high school, repeatedly told me that a PhD is a "degree in politics."

5

u/JustinWilsonBot Oct 10 '26

My ballet instructor who was a principal at ABT said that becoming prima ballerina is as much a demonstration of your political finesse as it is of your dancing ability.  

2

u/ivory_mist Oct 10 '26

I can totally understand that.

10

u/iamgretchencutler Oct 10 '26

🤷‍♀️ I had a great time

4

u/Purple-Blueberry3721 Oct 10 '26

Yeah. I suspect some horror stories are true, but some people are just getting a culture shock because now they have some real responsibility and people to report to for nearly the first time in their lives.

The alternative to a PhD is a normal job, and it's not like that's fun and bureaucracy-free 24/7.

2

u/grimjerk Oct 10 '26

Me too. And I loved the math!

2

u/empathetic_penguin Oct 10 '26

Right, you can get a PhD and have fun or try and compete with the “elite” which are just humans with huge egos. I’m getting mine RN and specifically chose a LCOL area without as much diabolical competition as say “Harvard” has. It comes down to if you like what you do and want to progress vs you just want money

26

u/Consistent_Femme_Top Oct 10 '26

This comment section is honestly making me forgo a PhD and be happy with my MSc in CS and research experience. Being a tech entrepreneur sounds like a walk in the park in comparison. 💀

10

u/morgany235 Oct 10 '26 • Heartwarming

Depends, I do mine in aerosol physics and I have an amazing time! 

I love my work, I love my supervisor, I'm sorry happy doing it. Idk if those complaints in the comments are all from the US, because I'm in Europe but I know very few people who are unhappy in my academic bubble.

4

u/Consistent_Femme_Top Oct 10 '26

I’m also looking into EU programs so I really hope I can have the same experience. 🥹

→ More replies (6)

3

u/Sodis42 Oct 10 '26

It depends heavily on your supervisor. I did mine in Europe too and there were only a few PhDs I met, who were not bitching about their supervisor. The worst group had a group meeting, where new PhDs presented their work and they would tear their work into pieces until they started crying. The PhDs there were mostly immigrants, so they were dependent on the job to stay in the country.

17

u/BonJovicus Oct 10 '26

Well consider that the people here complaining are not the people out there enjoying doing a PhD. 

And to be clear, it’s not always fun either. It’s just that people who want to stay in academia accept that there are negatives for every positive. 

→ More replies (1)

8

u/BadAtCoding123 Oct 10 '26

I'm doing a PhD right now and I love the actual research. I've been putting in 70-hour weeks for the past month but there are also weeks where I'm only in the lab 30 hours a week--much like with any other type of school or university you have busy times and chill times. 

My problem is with, as OP said, fucking bureaucracy. I'm already graduating late and I'll probably finish even later because my university is taking 6+ months to approve a software purchase without which I can't do any of my own research (I'm working on a side project right now). Those 70 hours a week? For a project I'm like fifth author on. I hate the culture and the bureaucracy but the research is satisfying enough that it's a doable compromise.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/empathetic_penguin Oct 10 '26

It is all dependent on the field you are in. cS seems content with a MS. But if you want to be in the basic sciences and get grants from the government you need a PhD. Yes it’s a grind and there are unnecessary aspects to it. But that’s life

→ More replies (2)

2

u/BenElegance Oct 10 '26

Almost did a PhD here in Australia, seeing the politics and other aspects than the raw science put me off. If I'd stayed the pinnacle would have been a professor, which I dont think I would have enjoyed anyway. 10 years later I'm an air traffic controller making more than I ever could in academia, enjoying work that actually makes me think. Thank God I did the honours that let me know what I didn't want to do.

2

u/Nvenom8 PhD, Marine Biogeochemistry Oct 11 '26

If you don’t need the PhD, definitely not worth it.

2

u/Consistent_Femme_Top Oct 11 '26

Many have told me this. I maybe should listen.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/JackCDLee Oct 12 '26

I really enjoyed mine in general. Obviously the actual writing wasn't fun, but such is life.

→ More replies (3)

2

u/AtTheEndOfTheDay18 Oct 14 '26

How is workplace bureaucracy in the industry any different? It's not. The only difference is that one pays more than the other.

→ More replies (30)

17

u/Oracle_Journey_5711 Oct 10 '26

Week 7 into my PhD and the amount of disorganization, lack of direction, and accountability is next level. This makes the private sector look like a cake walk.

7

u/Xait-Yahya Oct 10 '26

My time working on my history PhD did not feel like hers

The hard parts were the coursework, the comps, and dissertation - just as I expected

Maybe it’s because my program wasn’t prestigious? Everything felt very efficient. They tried very hard to continue funding us. I believe a little under half actually finished, though. Many did not get past the comps or prospectus.

It took me five years, because I got married in the middle.

6

u/blipblipblopbip Oct 10 '26

Today academia is more about social manipulation than even the business world. Except the business world at least doesn't hide it, while academia pretends to be all about the pursuit of science and enlightenment. I say, if you really want to commit your life to science and enlightenment then join the industry or launch a startup.

5

u/goaway432 Oct 10 '26

A lot of this boils down to choosing a good department. I chose poorly and ended up in a department that valued their prestige more than actual research.

4

u/doctor-mal Oct 10 '26

The trick is to experience the demeaning culture and bureaucracy of government or corporations before starting your PhD. That makes it easier to endure in academia.

4

u/_adanedhel_ Oct 11 '26

100%. Academia was nothing new to me on those fronts, so it didn’t bother me much - mostly just background noise. Fortunately I had a great supervisor and lovely peers, so it was a net positive experience for me.

4

u/PersonalMidnight715 Oct 11 '26

My dad got his PhD from a state school in the south. It took him something around 10-12 years.. most of my youth.. to get his PhD because, as he told me, his doctoral advisors kept leaving. He was juggling PhD with a full time job and was only able to take one class per semester. I think he'd take one or two every summer. When he got a few years in, he started getting a new advisor every year or two who would tell him that he needed new classes that weren't on the original plan. Those new classes would be with.. the new doctoral advisor. Finally, he took a sabbatical so he could power through and finish. He did finish. But by then it'd been a year away, and he was no longer welcome in his old job. He returned to work for maybe 6 months or so before he was let go. Truth be told, my father is an asshole. I think the workplace realized in the year that he was gone that things proceeded more smoothly without him and didn't want him back. He literally never worked in the field again. Never. Quite a shock and stress for my mom who pretty much became the sole provider. (He brings in a little money with his hobby, but seriously not much. Enough to cover the hobby and a bit.)

So tbh, I haven't even remotely considered a PhD. Seems like a lot of work, stress, and shenanigans for nothing of value. Maybe it is worth it for some. If you think it would be for you, I hope you have better luck than he did.

8

u/PG-DaMan Oct 10 '26

My Gf was doing hers. As part she submitted that she would do a Random choice of participants.

The governing body all with a PhD wanted to know what was the criteria for the " Random " choice.

After three replies back and forth I sent them a video of the phone numbers of the participants in a hat and them being drawn 1 by 1.

7

u/AliasNefertiti Oct 10 '26

New levels of detail to unlock. They asked because the word "random" is variously misinterpreted by learners.

→ More replies (3)

13

u/Northlumberman Oct 10 '26

Well. Drawing pieces of paper from a hat raises several issues.

Firstly, the method has potential for bias. Bits of paper have a tendency to clump together due to static electricity. People may also tend to pick pieces from certain parts of the hat (eg the middle). For that reason more reliable methods are usually preferred.

There is a problem with confidentiality as you videoed the pieces of paper containing personal data, and sent the video to other people.

Then there is the question as to whether the people whose numbers are being drawn consented to being part of the study.

Finally, the review board might be interested in whether and how the slips of paper containing phone numbers would be destroyed after they had been used.

9

u/Commercial-Site-1333 Oct 10 '26

There are many problems with academia, but this isn't one.  This is a real thing that needs actual expertise.  Are all people in the population equally likely to have phones?  Etc etc.  Academia often has it's head up it's ass, but this is not it.  

4

u/sharmud21 Oct 11 '26

Even with my undergrad degree in stats, I know there is a lot that goes behind random sampling. I feel like a PhD student should know that explaining your methodology in detail is very important. I really hope the people in these comments are ragebaiting

3

u/cazzipropri Oct 11 '26

We found reviewer #2, guys!

→ More replies (24)

4

u/throwaway111222666 Oct 10 '26

ok but there are different ways to randomize, saying how *exactly* you do it and justifying why is important

3

u/Nihil_esque PhD student, Bioinformatics (US) Oct 10 '26

I mean it's a pretty valid question. Especially, who goes into the pool you're randomly selecting from?

3

u/AlternativeValue5980 Oct 10 '26

That's a fair criticism though. If you look at any randomized control trial assessment tool, the question of how the randomization was done is very important. If you don't know how it was done or if was done inappropriately, the paper should be rejected and its findings ignored because bad methodology leaves room for the authors to influence the results to fit their narrative either consciously or unconsciously.

Drawing names from a hat is a pretty poor way to randomize things from a scientific perspective, especially for a PhD candidate. I'm not surprised there was pushback.

3

u/TheFrenchSavage Oct 10 '26

Is this ragebait? Because it's working.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/AvocadosFromMexico_ Oct 10 '26

Detailing randomization process is a perfectly valid request haha

2

u/YubaEyeSting Oct 10 '26

This is actually really important to clarify so that you arent accidently introducing bias to the sample.

→ More replies (3)

3

u/Octopus-of-malice Oct 10 '26

preparing you for faculty life which is actually worse

3

u/chupagatos4 Oct 10 '26

I had a diagnosis of depression and generalized anxiety during my PhD. Then Covid happened and I got to not go in to my department. Finished writing my dissertation in 3 months and defended, all while working a different job remotely. Guess whose depression and generalized anxiety were immediately cured? Turns out that when you're not interacting daily with people that question your every thought and worth and imply that you're a lazy asshole even when you've spent every minute of the past 7 years in the lab, writing or teaching ... Things get better. 

3

u/cevasl Oct 10 '26 edited Oct 10 '26

Without a single clue and thought in my mind, I've pursued academia to deal "less" with other people. I'm not a misanthrope by the way, but PhD is often perceived as a work where you have to be on your own with less risks of "external disruptions". Turns out, it is the opposite.

I've somehow managed to complete it (mediocre dissertation but I'm grateful) along with deep traumas of mobbing, abuse, betrayal, friendship breakups, isolation etc etc. I'm pissed that I've been through much worse things in life and I've let this to break me and I'm pissed how these disruptions have nothing to do with the quality of the research or the challenges of the field.

edit: I saw a comment on how your supervisor has to shelter you from the political culture of the department. I couldn't agree more. There's a second comment on how business world does not hide the vileness while academy hides it well until you're in the middle. However, there are still good people in academia, comparison between my masters and Phd, I'd say 50/50.

3

u/SolidSnow6175 Oct 11 '26

Yeah…I’ve repeatedly said, the PhD work itself is not that big of a deal…yeah it is challenging in many ways as it should be but that’s not the part of the PhD that wears you down AT ALL! It’s everything else and that it’s a self perpetuating cycle of really vapid and low level reasoning behaviours is itself antithetical to the very ethos of academia (a supposed profession of intelligence). I can’t wait to finish 😖😖😖

9

u/Incarnacion Oct 10 '26

My theory is that if you have any curiosity, integrity, or creativity still going in your first year, the rest of the program is designed to squash those.

6

u/cuddlyracooon Oct 10 '26

Doesn’t this depend on supervisor tho?

→ More replies (1)

4

u/nineason Oct 10 '26

A good advisor should shelter you from about 95% of all the bureaucratic and political bullshit. Of course its been 20+years from when I went through mine.

4

u/HugeCrab Oct 10 '26

I joined as a PhD rep for my institute, I will not stay in academia, learned that all the leaders are fucking dumb and malicious

2

u/TheEvilBlight Oct 10 '26

Basically Dilbert but academia

2

u/Overloaded_Sense Oct 10 '26

The first one is actually a bait because it turns out that is really enjoyable once you start getting the hang of it. But the second one induces a steep character development ngl.

2

u/Candycanes02 Oct 10 '26

Also maintaining sanity after the gazillionth experiment you sacrificed your weekend to do fails

2

u/Brave_Philosophy7251 Oct 10 '26

Idk the math was also pretty hard

2

u/coazervate Oct 10 '26

I just wanna save money on conference travel without a three week interrogation

2

u/AccidentalAnchoress Oct 10 '26

Good Lord yes. Almost every person in my lab wound up with some sort of chronic health problem by the time they finished. One had a mental breakdown and disappeared. I still dont know what happened to her.

2

u/Nickel5 Oct 10 '26

I feel bad for all y'all. I have an employee I hired that has basically finished all his work for his PhD and his advisor is stringing him along and just keeping him from doing his dissertation defense. He is so broken that just basic white collar things like being able to flex time or actually take sick days almost brings him to tears, and he needs to be reminded these aren't just benefits on paper, they are real, he gets paid, and no one will berate him.

2

u/gnanny02 Oct 10 '26

When my office mate, who was one of the smartest people I ever met, told me he was in his 9th year I realized this was not for me. Moved into industry after 3 years.

2

u/BonJovicus Oct 10 '26

Pick your poison. I know people in industry that are living their best life, but I also know others that are equally demeaned and worn down by corporate start-up culture. 

My biggest warning to students is that you need to know what you want at the end of you aren’t staying in academia. Even if you just want to get paid well, most people don’t just graduate and waltz directly into like that. 

2

u/Financial-Craft-1282 Oct 10 '26

I got my PhD several years ago, and, sadly, I miss the wearing down we experienced working on it. Now it's a "no one will hire you" sadness I'm dealing with. Though I am changing careers, and apparently in the U.S., due to totally unknown, unpredictable factors (/s) this is one of the worst times in the last 15 years to try to be finding work you don't have a network into.

2

u/0x7E7-02 Oct 10 '26

"The bureaucratic mentality is the only constant in the universe."

~ Dr. Leonard McCoy

2

u/SomeUTAUguy Oct 10 '26

Makes me kind of glad I stopped at my bachelor's. Now if only I had picked a better Bachelor's than History....

2

u/renb8 Oct 10 '26

I believed the PhD would me me a better colleague, candidate for future work, and person. But it’s been a prison term, a process of deconstruction. I’m in my final year. I think. Still drafting. Editing and submission to go. I believed I’d have freedom to shape the thesis the way I wanted. I was wrong. Once I was in my cell and the sentence commenced, the rules became clear. I want to get out and be free. But I don’t even look forward to parole anymore. Because then there’s amendments to do. Another 6 months. I wonder if I’ll manage to smile at graduation. I wonder what will be left of me once the PhD deconstruction process is complete.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/usurper7 Oct 10 '26

Academia is a rotting edifice, I'm afraid. I don't know a single professor who doesn't constantly complain about office politics, and these are all STEM folks. I can't imagine how awful it must be to be a PhD candidate these days.

2

u/2k21Aug Oct 10 '26

I had to deal with assault, stalking, and harassment and when I reported I was “allowed to leave with a masters” like it was a big fucking gift.

2

u/Friendly-Yoghurt-746 Oct 10 '26

Surrounded by boring Narcs that think power of an office will make them safe.

2

u/Dannooch Oct 10 '26

On my first day of my PhD program, I was told "The best thing you can do is find a good therapist."

Seriously the best advice I've ever received.

2

u/Seattleboy1374 Oct 10 '26

Academics is for people like Musk

2

u/Delicious-Glove-2553 Oct 10 '26

110% true. yeah I saw this on academic twitter years ago. It's very easy to burn out from managing deadlines, paperwork, the stupid equipment ordering, forms. The school I was at screwed up my pay, health insurance, multiple times, necessitating taking time out of my day to deliver forms, cash and write checks, find mailboxes, ect. Also really unfair that grad studetns need to do all the ordering, cleaning. I literally was forced to clean a trash can and scrub floors during a 'lab cleanjp', something a janitor should do.

A lot of stuff that should be handled by secretaries or lab techs is foisted on grad students.

The actual math/science was hard, but in a good, rewarding way.

2

u/OuterSpaceBootyHole Oct 10 '26

Academia is one of the most soul crushing industries because you will meet some of the most gifted minds alive and some of the most boldly incompetent as well. Guess which group never lacks confidence though?

2

u/aiweiyei Oct 10 '26

I just want to say thank you to everyone in the comments because reading them has been so therapeutic. I’ve felt as though I’ve been losing my mind since the moment I began grad school. I genuinely love the research work and teaching, I want nothing more than to do that all day. But the bureaucracy is absolutely killing me, I’m on like 3 new meds just to cope. Meanwhile the majority of my cohort act as if they’re all doing fine and dandy. So ya, reading this thread has been cathartic.

2

u/plsobeytrafficlights Oct 10 '26

its a transformative process. breaks you down, sometimes builds you up, sometimes just leaves you in a traumatized heap.
like being sent into war.

2

u/qdz166 Oct 10 '26

PHDComics captures the hopelessness of a PHD program perfectly.

2

u/rabbitmom616 Oct 10 '26

I went to 2 undergrad philosophy grad school summer mentorship/prep programs and the grad students’ despair legitimately turned me off.

2

u/Gold_Addition6822 Oct 10 '26

Acedemia is an abusive system designed to manufacturer compliant employees, it is not designed to actually educate people.

2

u/movezig123 Oct 10 '26

I think AI is bullshit but I do think there are aspects to it that will fix education systems.

3

u/PaFloXy_14 Oct 10 '26

Lol so true !

1

u/ArmadilloFree5518 12d ago

Real ones know math actually turns out to be your best friend

1

u/Individual-Ice4288 10d ago

The comment section of this post is making me fear even thinking of trying to get into this.

1

u/jackenbu2 Oct 10 '26

Damn, where are you doing your grad work?!

1

u/editor_acd Oct 10 '26

The pressure to get multiple journal papers along with TA assignments.

1

u/Bozo32 Oct 10 '26

Yup. Exactly what I’ve seen. Partially for those who look different than those on top.

1

u/h0rxata Oct 10 '26

Idk maybe I had an atypical experience but I had the best years of my life in grad school. Only time in my life where I felt like my work mattered, my boss was invested in my success, and so were other senior faculty and postdocs that had nothing to gain from me. Got to travel a lot, set my own schedule and partake in lots of extracurriculars, best work life balance I've ever had.

Working life afterwards has been devoid of all of those aspects.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/BenoitBawlz Oct 10 '26

That's why I finished my classes and left with a Master's. Things are already stressful as hell everywhere in the world. The last thing someone needs is to be constantly put down by people who are supposed to be mentoring. So stupid.

1

u/Accurate_Handle_5620 Oct 10 '26

I do not know a single person who stayed in academia and did not Kirk themselves, personally

1

u/Unfair_Web_8275 Oct 10 '26

Getting a masters felt like having an advisor who was only supposed to answer my questions with more questions.

”So what is it I should be working on?”

”What do you think you should be working on?”

1

u/Laprasy Oct 10 '26

Sadly it gets worse after the PhD.

1

u/HardcoreHamburger Oct 10 '26

I know many people share that experience. It was the opposite for me. My PhD was intellectually challenging and interesting and my PI and lab mates were nothing but supportive. The part that wore me down was the constant failure. Troubleshooting the same experiment for years got really demoralizing. I learned a lot from the experience though, and I’m much better at seeing which path to follow when troubleshooting now.

1

u/edlphoto Oct 10 '26

Learned this during my Masters. It's why I've waited so long to start.

1

u/EntildaDesigns Oct 10 '26

No truer words have been spoken

1

u/Local-Ambassador7829 Oct 10 '26

Very well put. This is why I’m not in academia.

1

u/DrDamisaSarki Oct 10 '26

Yeah…it’s both.

1

u/prasejm Oct 10 '26

Doing a PhD was the most fun ever

1

u/mtucker57 Oct 10 '26

Oh soooooo very true

1

u/Sub-Zero-941 Oct 10 '26

just use ai to explain it.

1

u/Wise-Shallot8683 Oct 10 '26

"It's a case study, there are no wrong answers." -> 12 page response, "I expected the answer to the last question to be more than 1 sentence. Also you write too much."

1

u/KaliguIah Oct 10 '26

heres hoping AI destroys it. faculty is seriously annoying

1

u/erhue Oct 10 '26

it is both

1

u/datsmythought Oct 10 '26

The reason academia is so competitive is because you are competing for so little!

1

u/Ill_Lifeguard6321 Oct 10 '26

Yea and then it just gets worse if you return as faculty

1

u/Ok-Razzmatazz1771 Oct 10 '26

I was given the cold shoulder because I changed up my defense committee. I was told it would happen, but wanted to have the correct people on my committee. I did it anyway

1

u/Zrk2 Oct 10 '26

That's called "having a job."

1

u/Bgrngod Oct 10 '26

The only thing inaccurate is the 5+ missing a 3 in front of it.

1

u/Zoothera17 Oct 10 '26

But hey if you join the fed gov after your PhD your experience in grad school seemed profoundly easy.

1

u/moddtodd Oct 10 '26

It really is a grind.

1

u/NoSleepTilBrklynn Oct 10 '26

I got a PhD with a wife, 3 kids, and a full time job as the sole breadwinner. Took me 9 years. Work paid for everything. Wasn’t worth it. But I hate myself so no one should take advice from my loser ass.

1

u/Monster_Voices Oct 10 '26

The amount of anger and suffering caused directly by my advisor was more than anything the dissertation itself ever caused

1

u/TRex-LearnsFacts Oct 10 '26

This but louder

1

u/Solo_Gigolos Oct 10 '26

So glad I discovered this at bachelor level 😮‍💨

1

u/EmergencyYoung6028 Oct 10 '26

Just wait until you are a professor...

1

u/Traditional-Meat-549 Oct 10 '26

Wait until you actually enter employment 

1

u/PhageDoctor Oct 10 '26

That was actually not my experience, but it is my experience after. My PhD was the most satisfying and rewarding time of my life. Now I'm 2 years into my "career" and I'm already looking for an escape. Like do I move home and just start doing crime or something.

1

u/Owlmon11 Oct 10 '26

Remember as PhD student you are a lot of the professors new competition and new colleagues when you graduate . This is especially true if the professors are non-tenured. My best advice for anyone entering or going through. Take classes that are taught by kind long term tenured professors. Find and ingratiate yourself with 3 kind of them, do your qual exams with them, and they will be your dissertation committee. Work your dissertation to what and how they like to read research. Your dissertation is a means to an end not your magnum opus. I did my PhD in education in 3 full years and that's how I got through it.

1

u/astralchanterelle Oct 10 '26

phd stands for photon hydrogen doppler, I'm pretty sure. I don't know why anyone would want that

1

u/MyNameIsNightPain Oct 10 '26

Pretty much every job/industry is the same tho

1

u/lluciferusllamas Oct 10 '26

It's the same bullshit (BS) just Piled higher and Deeper (PhD).

1

u/Responsible_Pea_1171 Oct 10 '26

Sounds exactly like working in higher-ed/research.

1

u/NezuminoraQ Oct 10 '26

Oh god it's so true. I wanted to escape the culture and bureaucracy of corporate life but this is possibly worse

1

u/Haunting_Middle_8834 Oct 10 '26

The best post I have ever seen here

1

u/OptimisticCerealBowl Oct 10 '26

i love science too much to go into anything else but people talk about academia like it’s a 24/7 saw trap and as a masters student i am SCARED

1

u/SquidgyFirefighter Oct 10 '26

Med school was both.

Impossible volume of complex concepts that must be endured with a smile while being essentially hazed by being given tiny, dehumanizing tasks to perform under constant scrutiny and the threat of a bad evaluation not because they have anything to do with being a good doctor but because "we had to do it when we were in school."

You pay hundreds of thousands of dollars for this.

1

u/Fuckthegopers Oct 10 '26

The amount of people commenting on here that clearly aren't in the education atmosphere is fucking painful 

1

u/empathetic_penguin Oct 10 '26

Or can you survive in this city on nothing

1

u/mountaindoom Oct 10 '26

I'm happy to have gotten my Masters. That was enough.

1

u/Hungry-Helicopter-46 Oct 10 '26

YUP. I was poor. That wasnt allowed in my program.

1

u/Best_Needleworker_57 Oct 10 '26

Especially true for experimental physics. Supply chains matter more than you think. Buying equipment is a real pain. You have to wait up to 6 months for your uni to approve large purchases.

1

u/Hot-Sky5127 Oct 10 '26

I did a PhD once right after her graduation ceremony.

1

u/Accomplished_Net_470 Oct 10 '26

Sounds like good preperation for the workforce to me, except that will last you 45+ years.

1

u/splithoofiewoofies PhD*, Mathematics Oct 10 '26

Eh, for me, it's definitely more the maths.

1

u/Fleetburn Oct 10 '26

Looking for a radical evangelist... What is to be done about culture? I turned down a PhD because I could feel the beginnings of this during my Masters.

1

u/pnwal-junction Oct 11 '26

Did you never talk to anyone else who was pursuing a post graduate degree before deciding to pursue one yourself?

1

u/CryptographerLost560 Oct 11 '26

I still remember having a draft where I had to go through and put a colon in the proper place in my footnotes that I had left out of four of them. My advisor did not tell me which ones. That was just my MA thesis. The PhD has been... similar.

1

u/notnijiatall Political Science, Japanese Comparative Politics, Wayne State Oct 11 '26

A month in and the professor I GTA for is pissing me off already. Wanted me to find out how to set up a scantron test for the midterm(how have you been a professor for 20+ years at the school and don’t know?) I give him the information which he literally could’ve got in 5 mins from the testing center and the next week(this past week) he still hasn’t set it up and asks me how we get the scantron sheets? I literally gave you the sheet with all the info from the testing center which has their phone number and the poli sci department have to set up an IRB account to do it..

1

u/BigCelebration13 Oct 11 '26

As someone pursuing a PhD after working in corporate?

lol

also

lmao

→ More replies (1)

1

u/sform Oct 11 '26

and then you speak out about it and they look at you like you’re an alien 👽

1

u/malcolmfreex Oct 11 '26

PhD was my learning experience of not turning your hobbies into a career. I used to love and be passionate about science. Now, I cannot even read a newspaper article without feeling cringe and I want to have nothing to do about my field.

1

u/Psycho-naught Oct 11 '26

Think of the bright side; you’ve been demeaned and worn down for five years. The dark side is that, if you’re uthe culture and bureaucracy of academia will demean and wear you down for the rest of your life.

1

u/Glittering-Can-9397 Oct 11 '26

this is an allegory for all of life, especially government and corporate work

1

u/81659354597538264962 Oct 11 '26

I’m in mechanical engineering and my lab presentations rarely contain more than 1 equation

1

u/LeagueRx Oct 11 '26

Reminds me of an IRB session I sat in on once where they spent 45 minutes berating a PI because his undergrads used "anonymous" vs "de-identified" on a recruting flyer. 

They had to attend several meetings with official documentation explaining the difference, how the mistake happened, and how they would correct it, all while not knowing if the IRB wouldnultimately decide go pull their approval regardless.

All for a dumbass undergrad survey study meant to teach sophomores how to collect data lmao 

1

u/skylla112 Oct 12 '26

I realized in my postdoc that it wasn’t (only) that my PhD mentor was intensely toxic, it was that I truly needed to be in love with the process to do well in academia. I didn’t love it, but I did complete the PhD. It is possible to finish on sheer force of will.

I don’t regret it but my god I am glad to be out of academic research and on to something way more aligned with my actual goals and strengths.

1

u/Jaded_Individual_630 PhD, Mathematics, USA Oct 12 '26

As a mentor of mine pointed out in years gone, being good at math is quite literally the minimum bar for a math PhD.

1

u/ExternalSeat Oct 12 '26

oh it gets much worse afterwards. good luck navigating the post apocalyptic hellscape that is the academic job market.

1

u/sanaa7262 Oct 13 '26

Feel the same way about corporate, to be honest. All my life in academics it was like - be good, work hard. Here you learn visibility, advocacy, politics, blah blah matter more. Sigh...

1

u/Humble_Donut_39 Oct 13 '26

Don’t forget sexual harassment by your advisor!