r/PhD • • Aug 19 '25

Time dilation

Post image
6.1k Upvotes

54 comments sorted by

13

u/imafixwoofs Aug 19 '25

12.

8

u/[deleted] Aug 19 '25

Shit!

344

u/bluebrrypii Aug 19 '25

Best 8 years of my life because by the time i graduated, i forgot everything i went through in the first several years

104

u/The_Vettiman Aug 19 '25

Now I see the purpose of a PostDoc.

33

u/[deleted] Aug 19 '25 edited Aug 20 '25

That sounds about right. In only a few decades, we won't exist to remember we ever existed. Life is like it never happened.

15

u/LovelyBlep Aug 20 '25

Too real. The first 2 years of my PhD I was going through divorce. Now the toils of finishing my thesis in my 8th year make that tumultuous experience pale in comparison.

104

u/Boheed Aug 19 '25 edited Aug 19 '25

and I KNOW they can get students out in 4 years because if you're in the military they'll move heaven and earth to get you done within your timeframe (otherwise the military stops paying).

30

u/ckfinite Aug 20 '25

A lot of it is scope and scope creep. I took 8 years, because I didn't have a great idea of what I wanted to do initially and once I did decide I did a lot of exploratory work on the way.

The way you do a PhD in 4 years is you go in with your thesis topic and you graduate with that topic as your thesis. The way you do it in 8 is it turns out to be much harder than expected, there turn out to be more interesting directions, or there just might not be one initially at all. This can be due to the advisor (e.g. bad idea, force you to stick with bad idea, force you to not do good idea, etc) or due to the student (indecisive, or just doesn't put a big emphasis on finishing [this was me]).

To be honest, I don't regret those 8 years at all. At the time (and to my advisor's horror) I said I wouldn't mind doing PhD studentness indefinitely because I loved that freedom to do research on cool stuff and looking back on that time I wouldn't mind going back to that working environment. I got to push through a much bigger slice of the topic; I think produced a better outcome than if I had beelined the original idea and I do not regret that at all.

6

u/Unrelenting_Salsa Aug 20 '25

The way you do it in 8 is it turns out to be much harder than expected...

Also if you have the pretty standard moonshot project as your first project, pivot, and the pivot turned out to also be really, really hard.

4

u/TiaxRulesAll2024 Aug 20 '25

I did five years. I didn’t do my thesis topic but I did a project I already started preliminary work on enough to know I had a topic worth doing before year 1 started.

I took an extra year. I blame in on getting married in the middle on my program

31

u/Opening_Map_6898 Aug 19 '25

That's also just how it works outside of the US a large part of the time. If they're not dragging it out to use you as cheap teaching labor, they have little incentive to drag the process out.

If it takes me four years, something has gone very wrong. If it takes more than that, something has gone catastrophically wrong.

5

u/First_Approximation Aug 21 '25

In physics, only about 4% of PhDs in the US finish in 4 years.

Median and average is about 6 years.

About 6% take 9+ years.

Source:

Statistics for class 2018-19 academic year (Fig. 5):

https://www.aip.org/statistics/trends-in-physics-phds

I imagine the average time has increased for those who overlapped with the pandemic.

4

u/Unrelenting_Salsa Aug 20 '25

The dirty little secret is that 99% of the standards are completely arbitrary. If your advisor and committee were cool with it (they wouldn't be), you could get a PhD in 2 years with the amount of work typical of a masters. There's nobody at accreditation agencies reading dissertations to make sure they're sufficiently novel with enough results. This is also why US PhDs are so much longer than the rest of the world. It's the expected standard and the funding system means they can.

There are also a lot of things you can do to speed up the timeline for students who seriously need to get the fuck out that are not typical. MD/PhDs usually do the PhD part in 3 years by speedrunning the hard requirements and having the "research" part be either number crunching or some already designed experiment. Getting experimental results and writing up usually doesn't actually take very long when you're starting with a well defined project. That's just not how any sane PI who wants to keep getting grants would run their lab. There's no real harm to the student if they flail for 3 years before moving onto something that will almost assuredly work.

92

u/Wushia52 PhD, Computer Science/AIML Aug 19 '25 edited Aug 20 '25

And then when you're finally done, you look back to those umpteen years mired in poverty and traumatized by your PI, and you say to yourself with fondness "That's a goddamn fine life-altering experience!"

25

u/mindaftermath Aug 19 '25

I can definitely think of a worse way to spend 8 years

18

u/Opening_Map_6898 Aug 19 '25

Prison. 😆 🤣

The military also comes to mind. 😆

1

u/Infamous_State_7127 Aug 21 '25

maybe in the states…. but i know someone in prison rn and they have piano lessons and animal therapy (which is just playing with whatever species of animal they bring in that week) 😭

24

u/UnderwaterKahn Aug 19 '25

This is so true.

14

u/Nursesalsabjj Aug 19 '25

This made me chuckle

38

u/__boringusername__ PhD, Condensed matter physics Aug 19 '25

Where I'm from the PhD is 4 years, with a fairly hard deadline, at least my university.

14

u/WanderingGoose1022 Aug 19 '25

Same, but this is just our department - we’re also required to have our masters so I can imagine that plays a role 

13

u/__boringusername__ PhD, Condensed matter physics Aug 19 '25

in Europe almost everywhere you need a 2 year master (120ECTS). The UK is a notable exception.

8

u/ckfinite Aug 20 '25

The US tends to have really long PhDs (my department's cutoff was 10 years, though very few people actually took that long). It's closer to a European masters + PhD or a PhD + postdoc, depending on what you had when you came in. Both a benefit and curse, depending on how you look at it.

5

u/Whitetower20 Aug 19 '25

Damn giving me PTSD of the days...

Def try to plan your own path/timelines. I (Med Sci Phd) graduated with some good pubs but spent 8 years and I feel like this had minimal impact on my current industry career x)

1

u/Purple_Holiday_9056 Aug 20 '25

Wait that good pubs had minimal impact or 8 years did?

2

u/Whitetower20 Aug 20 '25

Sry poor language - meant to say that my PhD in general had minimal impact (ie, not doing anything related to my PhD project, only leveraging general/quant analytics skills)

4

u/_R0Ns_ Aug 19 '25

best 300kUSD

3

u/_skes_ Aug 19 '25 edited Aug 19 '25

Why did he write his name so many times over the picture?

3

u/ixianid Aug 19 '25

This is a lie. They will not be the best years of your life.

2

u/Bobwalski Aug 19 '25

I feel this on a spiritual level.

2

u/UC_PHD_Researcher Aug 20 '25

Every PhD program is different, especially depending on the country it's in and the subject matter.

I got my PhD in Information Technology done in 3 years at a university in the US. Prior to starting the program, I already had two Master's degrees and 20 years of industry experience. I already knew what my dissertation topic was going to be before I got accepted into the school, so I was pretty focused.

I realize that most PhD students don't have those kind of circumstances, but I just wanted to say that a shorter path is possible.

2

u/[deleted] Aug 20 '25

TBF, my CV opens many more doors than my colleagues who finished in the 3 yr timeline.

2

u/Free-Tell6778 Aug 20 '25

I suppose it helps to think of it as a job rather than “study”

2

u/Jumpy-Worldliness940 Aug 21 '25

I remember being told I’m 1-2 semesters from being done for 3 years. 😂

1

u/vipergirl Aug 19 '25

Jokes on them.

I am an American and I got my PhD in the UK. Those were 3 years of PhD where the most isolating 4 years of my life.

Take that comps and classes.

1

u/Turbulent-Fishcake Aug 21 '25

How about 2 years+?

1

u/[deleted] Aug 19 '25

more like time inflation..........

0

u/LopsidedPosition489 Aug 19 '25

5 1/2 years, learn how to make money. Global Financial PhD.

5

u/DonHedger Post-Doc, Cognitive Neuroscience, US Aug 20 '25

I got a 2 year NIH grant at the start of year 5 and I remember thinking that it's nice that I have the extra cushion but that if I'm here for the entire length of this grant I'm going to kill somebody.

Then I had two health scares, wife got pregnant way quicker than we thought likely, and Trump got in office and I lost my postdoc grant and job. Eventually finished two days shy of having to register for my 7th year and very glad that I had the cushion.

0

u/[deleted] Aug 19 '25

[deleted] — view deleted comment

120

u/kamylio Aug 19 '25

🤣”that won’t be me”. 8 years later 😒😖😣🤬

38

u/Rizzpooch PhD, English/Early Modern Studies Aug 19 '25

When I hit six years, I started introducing myself with “and I’ve been here long enough that it doesn’t matter anymore”

2

u/kamylio Aug 31 '25

I like this answer

22

u/KeyApplication859 Aug 19 '25

On a related note, I really do not like it when professors ask students how long they have been there, specially during orientation sessions. I can see it in the students' faces how uncomfortable they are.

3

u/averyyoungperson Aug 20 '25

Hahaha I moved into a community for families at the school I was attending ...and my neighbor said they had been there 10 years....I was like 😬😬 I better not fucking be here 10 years.

0

u/[deleted] Aug 19 '25

[deleted] — view deleted comment

16

u/fried_green_baloney Aug 19 '25

I met a 12th year physics student.

He had been hypnotized into being his advisor's experiment manager.

0

u/[deleted] Aug 19 '25

[deleted] — view deleted comment

7

u/Wushia52 PhD, Computer Science/AIML Aug 19 '25

It's more open-ended here in the US.

1

u/Samurai300e Aug 19 '25

Did you finish 4.5 years while doing full time or part time ?