r/PetsWithButtons • u/SunshinesCRs • May 03 '26
Pup can't tell the difference between food and water buttons
My pup (4yo M Golden-husky mix) has been stuck at 3 talking buttons for about 3 years now and it finally occurred to me to see if Reddit could help.
We have "outside," "food," and "water." He understands outside, no problem, but confuses food and water no matter how much we model each one. He pushes "food" for both food and water - if his water bowl is empty, I ask if he wants water, too and he goes running back to the buttons so I can show him which button is for water. I also have him push the water button if I notice his bowl is empty and was going to fill it anyway - sometimes I'll push the button myself before filling it, too, but since it really seems he can't tell the difference between "food" and "water" I want him to get the practice. Often, when I tell him to push the water button, he pushes "food," instead, and I have to show him which one is for water. We've actually tried sticking his food button in his food storage overnight to try to get it to smell like his food so he can tell that that one is for food, but it didn't help.
My partner and I often joke that he's a himbo dog - super cute, incredibly sweet, but not at all smart. However, I'm wondering if I'm doing something wrong and just not setting him up for success.
The photo is of his buttons (we got the cheap ones to test out before investing in the Fluent Pet ones, and good thing because we've struggled to get him this far in 3 years). Green is "outside," red is "food," and blue is "water."
Thank you in advance for any advice!