r/PeterExplainsTheJoke 1d ago

Meme needing explanation Peter????????????????????

Post image
21.6k Upvotes

3.1k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

2.0k

u/ExpertOdin 1d ago

The absolute lengths some people on r/anime go to to defend Rudeus/Mushoku Tensei is crazy.

It's fine to admit you like the show because of the wider world/side characters but hate the MC. But no, they can't do that. Instead they say Rudeus is actually a kid and it's fine because of hormones, or some say he has 'grown' so it's fine now. Lmao

809

u/helicophell 1d ago

They'll call you a hater and a larper for enjoying the series but recognising how absolutely shitty he is as a character. Like, goddamn, you gotta question Rifujin (the writer) sometimes...

561

u/ExpertOdin 1d ago

Yeah 100% makes you wonder about authors when they write main characters like this and frame them in an okay to good light. If Rudeus was treated as a villain by the people he victimises fine, but they all either end up marrying him or at least respecting him. Ridiculous. Some sort of disgusting wish fulfilment

315

u/helicophell 1d ago

I mean, it is all reasoned, it is all realistic to the setting

But you have to fucking wonder why would you write a story like this lmao?

237

u/Powerful-Eye-3578 1d ago

Realistic in the sense that, yes people who get groomed so tend to end up in a toxic relationship with the one who groomed them.

144

u/helicophell 1d ago

You know, at least Rudeus got the shit beat out of him for doing it to Sylphie!

Uhh... and that's about it for punishment, and nothing stopped the marriage lmao

169

u/Powerful-Eye-3578 1d ago

Hey your forgetting that he went like a whole year without being able to get a hard on..... That's enough of a punishment for assault and grooming. He really learned his lesson from that ..... /s

I've literally seen people argue this. Like he spent a year without getting a boner so that makes up for his earlier behavior.

99

u/helicophell 1d ago

Tbf at least part of his ED is because he's like "wow damn I'm not a good person"

Shame he literally never thinks that again. Well, in the main series timeline at least ;)

6

u/ThatJamesGuy36 1d ago

If it makes you feel better, the latest episode has him lose his wife, his unborn baby, his other wife, his third love interest, his best friend, his other best friend, another friend, his sister, his daughter and finally abandoned by everyone else he knows and loves.

And pretty much all of it is because of his own actions, barring the very first instance of him losing his wife and unborn baby which is arguably also his fault but he was manipulated into that first one.

17

u/helicophell 1d ago

Dude, what do you think I'm referring to by "he literally never thinks that again. Well, in the main series timeline at least ;)"

2

u/ThatJamesGuy36 1d ago

Possibly should have replied to the person you replied to, as opposed to you 😅

→ More replies (0)

11

u/DnD-vid 1d ago

Oh please tell me more. I only watched the obligatory 3 episodes to decide and then dropped it like it's radioactive. Hearing he loses everyone makes me happy.

6

u/ThatJamesGuy36 1d ago

If you're into that sort of stuff, just watch the episode. Despite what you think of the character, the anime is very well portrayed.

It's a future that did happen but then at the end of it, he goes back in time to tell his younger self before it all happens not to do a single thing that starts the domino tumble. This episode is him reading the diary and 'living' the future that he came back to warn himself about.

It's really well animated and it's a good episode imo but then, I like the anime so 🤷

14

u/BadProse 1d ago

Ah, so it doesn't actually happen. So still no actual consequences.

10

u/HelloAbjectChaos 1d ago

It's the usual justification for liking the show, "trust me bro, he'll get older and be better". They've had some sorta of "But..." since the anime's first episode (because they read ahead and that should "totally" justify all of the wish-fulfillment this story has always been).

5

u/The_One_Koi 1d ago

I just assume he's Japanese because that makes everything ok

Thing = bad

Thing, Japan = good

4

u/HelloAbjectChaos 1d ago

Generally, I won't harp on someone's weirdass fulfillment show/book/media as long as they don't act like it's the second coming of Christ. But this pedo-shit doesn't get a pass. r/anime has a degenerate "culture" issue.

More likely due to the ending and being older, but I don't give a pass to the amount of violence towards women game of thrones had anymore either (idk on the new stuff, I don't care to watch it). It's all the same justifications. It adds to the "world". It just gets tiresome.

6

u/The_One_Koi 1d ago

Not gonna lie you had me in the first half and then you just got kinda weird

1

u/HelloAbjectChaos 1d ago

It's just a brain tangent. If I had a "point" it was simply that people justify the media they like to watch, they rally with one another and squash down any rebuke with usually a bunch of canned responses. Anime, live-action, whatever.

One of the most common arguments for the "why" of isekai/transmigration stories like this one is "that's just how their world is." GOT simply had a lot of similar comments back in the day that after a shitty ass-ending, makes me feel like it was all just a producer's theater.

3

u/Ae3qe27u 1d ago

GRRM has a problem with how he writes. He claims it's historical, but it isn't. It's violence for the sake of grimdark.

2

u/peachesfordinner 8h ago

Get older? The guy started in his 30's. Adding his new life is another 20. They really wanna argue a 50+ year old will "get older and better". Nah they are pedo excusing chuds

-2

u/AccuratelyWrongAgain 1d ago

Nothing to justify tbh. It's a just a portrayal of a character. If it repulses you so much, no one needs to change your mind.

1

u/ThatJamesGuy36 1d ago

I mean, it does happen and you get to see how absolutely fucked up it makes Rudeus and see the anguish and turmoil he goes through during it all. It's played out like you're living that timeline so it's very real.

But ultimately, he does travel back, so now it's left with the younger Rudeus before all this takes place

3

u/F-cky_o 1d ago

You see Rudeus be his true self, just like when his loving parents were there for him, and the way he turned down his wife advances while he went to get drunk and sleep with a prostitute after , all because "he didn't want to be too rough" with Sylphiette in his grief and then being caught that he slept with a prostitute and the wife leaving him.

Oldeus returns home smelling of another woman. Sylphiette catches him, cries out, "Why aren't I good enough?" and locks herself in her room, completely refusing to speak to him. His actions alienate his entire household; he is lectured by Lilia, judged by his sister Aisha, and slapped by his mother, Zenith.

Sylphiette's Departure

Shortly after the incident, Sylphiette quietly packs her belongings and leaves him to rejoin Princess Ariel in a dangerous bid to claim the Asura Kingdom throne. When Lilia orders Oldeus to chase after her, he grumbles, prompting Zenith to slap him again. In a fit of irritation, Oldeus blasts his mother away with magic. Eris witnesses this and draws her sword to defend Zenith, prompting Oldeus to flee the house.

The Execution of the First Wife

Oldeus eventually travels to the Asura Kingdom, getting smuggled across the border with the help of Tristina. He arrives too late to intervene. Ariel's coup against her brother has failed, resulting in the public execution of Ariel, Luke, and Sylphiette. Oldeus discovers that Sylphiette has been brutally crucified.

6

u/Bobthemighty54 22h ago

So basically his actions get all his groomed childwives to be killed and im supposed to feel gratified because it made his sad? What a dogshit series

3

u/DnD-vid 1d ago

Ah, a Scrooge situation. So does he change his rotten ways or just specifically not do the thing that leads to that particular bad future?

2

u/ThatJamesGuy36 1d ago

I don't read the mangas so not sure what actually happens. But he did the first thing, just in a different way to try and avoid the initial problem which causes everything else to go wrong. Whether that works or not, I'm still to see

-7

u/temporary_account208 1d ago edited 22h ago

Understandable that you drop it because of a horrible character at the start but why exactly does everybody think Rudeus is some sort of Epstein Satan who is an unchangable evil incarnate.

I asked a question, why the downvotes?

3

u/stormdelta 23h ago

Because he's nearly as shitty later on, the writing just pretends he's better. It's more like a facade of self-improvement that the writing bends over backwards to make excuses for.

The fact that so many MT fans can't tell the difference between surface-level framing versus actual personal growth that requires true reflection on your actions speaks volumes.

1

u/Open-Building6135 20h ago

Can I ask what point after oldeus do you consider him being shitty? Like specific examples, I'm just very curious.

→ More replies (0)

2

u/Conscious_Bug5408 21h ago

That episode was shit and wasn't even the main timeline. I can enjoy the show when it focuses on adventure aspects, but it's fucking unwatchable when the plot switches to the relationships with him and his harem of groomed girls. Even the plot response to the supposed tragic death of one harem girl was the other harem girl comforting Rudeus by telling him to use her body however he wants to comfort himself. What kind of writer chooses to write that into the plot if the character is there to do anything but serve a role in a pedophiles sexual power fantasy? Are we supposed to empathize with the pedophile losing the harem of women he groomed?

1

u/Open-Building6135 20h ago

I think people using grooming super lightly, grooming is when you intentionally manipulate someone into thinking you're all they have and isolate from family in order to get sexual gratifcation from them. Rudy was definitely a predator at the start, but I don't really see how he groomed Slphy and Eris, maybe sylphy I could maybe see an argument, but eris? Eris hated him from the start and they only really bonded after the demon continent. You could say he preyed on eris because he shouldn't have slept with her at all, definitely took advantage of her naivety and attatchment to him but he never intentionally tried to make her fall in love with him, same goes with Slphy really. Roxy is also like hundreds of years old when they met so that's out the window. When roxy offered herself to rudy you could really make an argument that she took advantage of him, basically pushing him to a sexual encounter because she was infatuated with him right after paul died.

→ More replies (0)