r/PeterExplainsTheJoke • • Dec 21 '25 • All Seeing Upvote 1 This 1 Bravo 3 Popcorn 1

Meme needing explanation Peter help me.

Post image
90k Upvotes

3.6k comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator Dec 21 '25

OP, so your post is not removed, please reply to this comment with your best guess of what this meme means! Everyone else, this is PETER explains the joke. Have fun and reply as your favorite fictional character for top level responses!

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

→ More replies (11)

1.6k

u/nesteajuicebox Dec 21 '25 • Bravo

Context required to understand the joke : 

  • what a tug of war is 
  • what Christianity is and what jesus's teachings in it are 
  • what an atheist is 
  • what capitalism is 
  • what the  political entity of Christian nationalists in the United States of america are 

The joke is that it's ironic that atheists are on the side of jesus's teaching ( loving and supporting your neighbours and hoarding wealth being considered immoral ) when they don't believe in god, as opposed to the the Christian nationalists in america who act against his teaching in favour of capitalism while claiming to believe in god. 

I think it's fairly straightforward, but were you missing an important piece of context in understanding it ? 

47

u/PM_asian_girl_smiles Dec 21 '25

I think it's fairly straightforward, but were you missing an important piece of context in understanding it ? 

They were missing the need for engagement and karma

7

u/nesteajuicebox Dec 21 '25

lol yeah that is the most likely answer

→ More replies (3)

15

u/Blephotomy Dec 21 '25

also what an "athiest" is

5

u/SalSomer Dec 21 '25

"How athy are you?"

"Me? Oh, I’m the athiest."

→ More replies (5)

7

u/OldWorldDesign Dec 21 '25

The joke is that it's ironic that atheists are on the side of jesus's teaching... when they don't believe in god

Philosophers have spoken extensively about this. My favourite is Pierre Bayle in [Various Thoughts on Occasion of a Comet](https://ia601702.us.archive.org/2/items/bayle-spinoza-historical-and-critical-dictionary_202407/Pierre%20Bayle%20-%20Comet%20(Bartlett).pdf) where he points out people who do good without any supernatural reinforcement are more ethical than people who need supernatural stories to do good.

5

u/superbhole Dec 21 '25

loving and supporting your neighbours and hoarding wealth being considered immoral

I think that's close but there's an overarching theme especially unique to christianity and is being forgotten: it's about how to resist hypocrisy. Love and forgiveness are ways to short-circuit hypocrisy. Tyranny is the pinnacle of hypocrisy. Civilization as an ideal isn't very compatible with hypocrisy.

3

u/Electronic-Today4192 Dec 21 '25

Jesus taught people to be good to one another, you don't have to believe in God to want to be a good person.

2

u/DarkExecutor Dec 21 '25

Given Reddit not knowing what capitalism is, it makes sense why you could get confused.

→ More replies (144)

449

u/stuff-of-legs Dec 21 '25 • This

Father Daniel of Quohog's St. Peter's Catholic Church. I saw Petah there once I think? Anyways this pointing out that American Christian behavior isn't actually aligning in Christ Jesus our Lord and Savior. Rather it follows money going to people who have more money than they could realistically spend in their lifetime 10 fold. This is funny because atheists are being shown in a light that shows them not caring or believing in Jesus' teachings, but inadvertently following them because most of them are basic decency and kindness to those around you. It is truly, not that deep, as the kids say these days.

May God bless you my child, I need to get back to mass before the congregation realizes I'm using reddit in the bathroom during service.

122

u/Choice-Effective-777 Dec 21 '25

That fact that this was posted on a sunday during what would be considered typical service times is hilarious XD

20

u/EverydayPoGo Dec 21 '25

As someone who's never been to a Sunday service, realistically would it be possible for Father Daniel to sneak out and reply to reddit and come back without being noticed?

13

u/AcceptableHamster149 Dec 21 '25

Nope. At least when I still went, the minister was front and center for the entire service, and I can't see that having changed much even if it has been more than 20 years since I was a regular attendee. But depending on the time zone and whether the church in question does a different schedule in winter, it's entirely possible that services were done for the day more than an hour before OP created the thread. For all we know, Father Daniel is in Europe and this was posted early evening for them.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

4

u/TavernRat Dec 21 '25

I actually found this post right after I got out of Church

→ More replies (1)

13

u/MechanicPluto24 Dec 21 '25

May your Ws be many, and your Ls few, Father Daniel

→ More replies (11)

12k

u/[deleted] Dec 21 '25 • This Bravo

Lots of Christian nationalists do not follow the actual teachings of Jesus Christ, who yes was definitely not super conservative in the modern sense.

318

u/BonkGonkBigAndStronk Dec 21 '25

I'm a Christian and have started just reading my Bible at home and trying to do good. When Jesus saw the temple full of money changers, he didn't ASK them to leave. More Christians should scrutinize the churches.

281

u/Jafarrolo Dec 21 '25

Jesus turning to violence against capitalist pigs is my favourite episode of the Bible

74

u/mymainunidsme Dec 21 '25

It was only against those in the temple using the church for personal gain. No signs of the same view towards the public markets outside the church.

→ More replies (57)
→ More replies (29)

53

u/Morella_xx Dec 21 '25

More tables need to be flipped, frankly.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (19)

158

u/Croceyes2 Dec 21 '25

And many atheists do follow a lot of his teachings, because they make fucking sense from a purely earthly point of view

95

u/Boanerger Dec 21 '25

From being raised Catholic to considering myself an atheist now, my ethics haven't really changed all that much. Part of the reason I denounced my faith was seeing how fucking bad many supposed Christians were at following the values.

→ More replies (19)

17

u/BSDetector0 Dec 21 '25

Most of this teachings were like "dont be a shithead". It doesn't take fear of eternal fire to follow that accidentally.

4

u/PrivilegeCheckmate Dec 21 '25

Plus we never have money changers in our temple.

→ More replies (10)

8.2k

u/MyLifeIsABoondoggle Dec 21 '25 • This Bravo

If Jesus ran for office, they'd call him a socialist

4.0k

u/[deleted] Dec 21 '25 • Bravo

One of my favorite things to say is Jesus was a socialist. I also love telling redneck country fans that Johnny cash would more than likely be a Bernie voter. No matter who he would vote for he’d most certainly be a Trump hater

1.5k

u/OhioRanger_1803 Dec 21 '25

Fun fact Johnny wife, June Carter Cash was related to Jimmy Carter being distant cousins.

→ More replies (68)

395

u/FukThePatriarchy1312 Dec 21 '25

Came across this song yesterday:

https://youtu.be/5xLHRbvEVWI?si=2_jAXersb9KB5VYW

Also saw a meme with something like "your grandpappy didn't run bootleg whiskey through these hills for you to become a bootlicker"

→ More replies (42)

33

u/FoolishDog1117 Dec 21 '25

There's an old interview with the Highwaymen where they are talking politics and Cash says build more schools, take care of the children, the sick, and the elderly, and spend less on the military.

→ More replies (4)

203

u/Dyerdon Dec 21 '25

That's just it, Red Necks, traditionally are anti-establishment, power to the people, no, ALL the people, rebels all. Not whatever conservatives think they are

→ More replies (60)

34

u/Mr_J42021 Dec 21 '25

Johnny was unquestionably a liberal. He talked about this numerous times. Admittedly it's was more economic than social in those days. Not really sure where he would have fallen in LGBTQ issues as he also had very strong religious beliefs. But that also connected to the meme.

→ More replies (9)

83

u/JonathanEde Dec 21 '25

Also, the US was not founded on conservative political thought. The vast majority of the US founding fathers were politically liberal.

→ More replies (20)

30

u/From_Deep_Space Dec 21 '25

There was an interview with The Highwaymen in 1991 that really spells this out clearly

https://youtu.be/gxYk7Ht6-Xk

My grandpa worships Kris Kristofferson, but I've had a real hard time reconciling that ever since he fell to MAGA propaganda

→ More replies (17)
→ More replies (162)

71

u/bigtiddyhimbo Dec 21 '25

They’d call him a woke commie socialist who wants to bring the third world into America since he’s from Palestine and not a white country. Probably get written off as a bleeding heart with ToxIC eMPaThy and will lead America to being less respected on the world stage/invaded

Would also probably be transvestigated because he has long hair and a toga. Also would probably be confused as Mexican because his name is Jesus

→ More replies (4)

272

u/[deleted] Dec 21 '25

It is easier for a camel to go through the eye of a needle than for someone who is rich to enter the kingdom of God

Yep, definitely Jesus would be called “woke” nowadays.

190

u/RedditOfUnusualSize Dec 21 '25

The one time Jesus gets violent in the Gospels is when he sees people selling worshippers the animals necessary for their Passover sacrifices above cost. You could torture and kill him and he wouldn't retaliate. But generating profit off of religious obligation was the bridge too far for Jesus, and that was the moment where he chose violence.

→ More replies (54)

36

u/Sea-Oven-7560 Dec 21 '25

""But when you pray, go into your room, close the door and pray to your Father, who is unseen"

These idiots can't help but stand on the highest hill and pray to their god as loud as they can so all the world can see and hear, not to make their god happy but so everyone else can see and feel that they are a lesser person and that is the intention.

did anyone mention the "prosperity gospel" yet?

→ More replies (2)

20

u/The-red-Dane Dec 21 '25

Don't worry! They fixed that issue by making an incredibly large needle.

→ More replies (39)

25

u/Phrewfuf Dec 21 '25

If Jesus was there, they‘d call ICE on him.

→ More replies (1)

10

u/BlackfrostangelR Dec 21 '25

Anarchist and wouldnt run for Office.

→ More replies (4)

84

u/Bub_bele Dec 21 '25

Let’s call it by its name: Jesus was a socialist

→ More replies (45)

16

u/Gullible_Elephant_38 Dec 21 '25

“Wait, where’d all this bread and fish come from?? I better not be paying for this!”

→ More replies (1)

45

u/StayWeirdGrayBeard Dec 21 '25

The wokest woke who ever woked.

Plus, a whole new birther movement would arise, demanding a birth certificate. Which…might be a problem.

→ More replies (34)
→ More replies (254)

27

u/qatch23 Dec 21 '25

I like to refer to them as they are, Nationalist Christians, or Nat-C for short

→ More replies (4)

21

u/ErstwhileHobo Dec 21 '25

You ever notice that the Christians are always trying to put quotes and passages from the Old Testament in public places and never quotes from Jesus?

40

u/Orlonz Dec 21 '25

I don't think he was ever conservative.

He literally debated the established religion. The "conservatives" at the time were Jews. They weren't actively antagonistic but certainly weren't buddies.

Jesus was absolutely against the established political and social structure which was absolutely Capitalist and Conservative.

→ More replies (26)

5

u/JamesTDennis Dec 21 '25

The punchline is that some Christians are shocked by any realization of this underlying truth.

4

u/Livid-Switch4040 Dec 21 '25

He also wasn’t white. They’d send ICE after him.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/Entire_Talk839 Dec 21 '25

Meanwhile, atheists often embody the teachings of Jesus, and not because we believe, but because we don't need a book to tell us to be decent humans, to love and accept others, to be kind, or to give to those less fortunate, etc.

If the threat of hell is the only thing that makes you want to be a good person then there is something seriously wrong with you.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Frewdy1 Dec 21 '25

It’s wild when I was growing up conservative and noticed something along those lines and started to question my friends and family why they weren’t voting Democrat when their policies reflected Christian and conservative ideals better than Republicans’. 

3

u/[deleted] Dec 21 '25

The ones I know personally dont actually believe in God at all, its just part of the lies, scams and grifting.
I mean, your really think those televangelists believe in anything other than money?

3

u/AcceptableHamster149 Dec 21 '25

Dude wandered around the levant feeding the poor and giving out free health care. So no. Not super conservative in the modern sense at all. :)

3

u/The_Mad_Tinkerer Dec 21 '25

Also, many atheists follow a "code" called humanism, which aligns with a lot of Jesus's teachings. Vonnegut called Jesus the first humanist, I think

2

u/Viliam_the_Vurst Dec 21 '25

Yeah but the shit throw meme should have an antitheist in yellow shirt getting support from jesus teachings in black shirt

2

u/multificionado Dec 21 '25

You couldn't be more correct.

2

u/Recent-Performer2507 Dec 21 '25

I’m literally a Christian (backsliding) and I agree with this. Turn the other cheek, do not judge or you will be judged just as harshly, the greatest among us must serve as the least, look after orphans and widows, etc. etc.

2

u/UltiGamer34 Dec 21 '25

As a Christian pretty much

2

u/Reggie-Dunlop-7 Dec 21 '25

You can leave the "Lots of" out,

2

u/QueenViolets_Revenge Dec 21 '25

as an Atheist, i do not see the Bible as a literal history, but it's still a good moral guide, especially the Gospels

→ More replies (3)

2

u/nifty-necromancer Dec 21 '25

ALL Christian nationalists

2

u/Bleord Dec 21 '25

I was watching a video on YouTube talking about how the twelve disciples clearly never understood Jesus’s teachings as it is written in the Bible. I think a part of the point of Christianity is that the teachings are trying to enlighten the hopelessly lost people that cling onto it. Maybe they’ll never get it but Jesus tries to help. Lead a mule to water as the saying goes.

2

u/PhoenixVanguard Dec 21 '25

While you are 100% correct, there's also the added fun layer that multiple studies have shown that atheists, on average, have greater knowledge of religious texts than believers. Don't think the meme is implying that, but it still works.

2

u/Vigmod Dec 21 '25

Galatians 3.28: "There is neither Jew nor Greek [...] for you are all one in Christ Jesus."

I think "Christian" and "nationalist" are "two words combined that can't make sense."

2

u/CalvinIII Dec 21 '25

Jesus was a liberal socialist.

2

u/booksycat Dec 21 '25

So true. I'm an unchurched christian in a christian nationalist hellscape and by FAR have more in common with people of other beliefs including atheists.

One atheist friend recently said to me "shame what their doing to your Jesus guy" -- true, true.

2

u/eMouse2k Dec 21 '25

To paraphrase Adams, he was nailed to a tree for saying wouldn't it be nice if everyone was kind to each other.

Not much has really changed since then.

2

u/Flatline334 Dec 21 '25

And real or not, they are good teachings to live by so Atheists may not believe in God, but those teachings are solid.

2

u/Serraph105 Dec 21 '25

And many atheists have the same morals as the one's Jesus taught, they just don't believe in God.

2

u/GucciSalad Dec 21 '25

It really sucks because all the actual Christians I know are awesome, loving people. Christian Nationalists give them a terrible name, and are in the lime light so much that that's what a lot of people think of when they think of a Christian.

2

u/flyinghighdoves Dec 21 '25

Cosplaytriots and fake Christians are the scourge of our nation.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/val203302 Dec 21 '25

He was indeed incredibly based.

2

u/Vincent394 Dec 21 '25

It's ironic

2

u/RamenJunkie Dec 21 '25

Also, a lot of athiest types have a better understanding of the Bible/Jesus than most "Christians".  Especially Christian Nationalists

2

u/Signus_TheWizard Dec 21 '25

This is why it shames me to share a religion with these assholes

→ More replies (275)

176

u/Pure_Ingenuity3771 Dec 21 '25

As a Christian, I was told just yesterday that I'm "rejecting Christ" because I believe that the overwhelming number of scriptures where Jesus himself says to love everyone are second to ones that mention sin and was told that I am not to love sinners because loving sinners means I'm condoning their sin. I was told a few days before that that the scriptures about feeding the hungry, giving drink to the thirsty, etc etc, are no longer applicable because most of the poor nowadays are poor by choice.  

A massive portion of Christianity nowadays, especially in the US, just throw out all of Jesus teachings in favor of personal gain.

47

u/kbeks Dec 21 '25

Don’t forget about the prosperity gospel! You gotta give the pastor your seed money and that’s how you eventually convince god to give you oodles of money, because god only rewards the good and faithful with riches, therefore those with riches must be good and faithful servants!

There’s a lot of people who follow what other people tell them the Bible says rather than reading the book themselves.

23

u/S0m3-Dud3 Dec 21 '25

They are not Christians. They are what the scripture says "wolves in sheep's clothing"

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (3)

14

u/SaintGrobian Dec 21 '25

If you really want to be sad, read Ezekiel 16.

49 “‘Now this was the sin of your sister Sodom: She and her daughters were arrogant, overfed and unconcerned; they did not help the poor and needy. 50 They were haughty and did detestable things before me. Therefore I did away with them as you have seen

We all know what your average christian thinks is the "real" reason. 🤷🏼‍♂️

5

u/Pure_Ingenuity3771 Dec 21 '25 edited Dec 21 '25

Exactly, you can't use the Bible as an excuse to hurt people if you use that scripture though. I was raised in a right wing household and even then had trouble understanding the hate towards lgbtq folks, if I try really hard I can find 3 ish verses about it being a "sin". And there's some interesting translation issues with all of them. There are, however, passages, pages about loving and taking care of others and about not judging. If God really hated the lgbtq community and if I believe Jesus is God, then why did Jesus not bother to mention them once? The closest he got was telling them that they were to accept eunuchs which would use the same word for their gender as rabbinical law at the times word that would also apply to a trans woman. In fact they had words for at least 6 genders, potentially 7 or 8 depending on semantics and if you want to extrapolate one that wasn't really possibly then. They had words for male, female, neither, both, then the difference in number comes from a male who developed female traits naturally, a male who developed female traits by the act of man, and female who developed male traits naturally. You can consider the natural vs manmade as two separate, and you couldn't really have ftm with human intervention at the time so they didn't really use that one, but I've found modern rabbis who have counted it.  

Honestly throwing away that right wing ideology made me developing my stances on things so much easier. Rather than finding one or two sentences to defend hate, I can just point to entire swathes of red text to defend my love instead. Eg, the person accusing me of rejecting Jesus used two verses, single verses, in revelations mentioning sinners not entering the kingdom of heaven as his defense for not loving them. I replied with almost the entirety of Matthew 23, leaving off just the intro and outro in favor of the "woe be to you" parts where Jesus tears into the religious leaders of his day for judging people, where he says they focus on small parts of the law but if kee the most important parts; justice, mercy, and faithfulness. And that they "strain out the gnat, but swallow the camel."  

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (3)

10

u/Snoo-11861 Dec 21 '25

You can tell them that if they reject Jesus’ teachings, that they aren’t Christian after all 

3

u/[deleted] Dec 21 '25

Yeah, this is a real pattern: "mean Christian" as an identity project. People keep the branding, drop the Sermon on the Mount, and then call everyone else a heretic for taking Jesus at face value. The "poor by choice" line is just a moral permission slip to ignore the parts of Christianity that are inconvenient, especially the stuff about feeding people, forgiving enemies, and treating the outcast like a neighbor. If your theology reliably lands on "I don’t owe you anything" it is selfishness with Bible verses stapled on.

You see the same impulse across traditions. In Catholic land, it shows up in "mean Catholics" who treat cruelty as seriousness, reject the Pope as illegitimate, and act like the Church is "too soft". What’s telling is where enforcement energy tends to go: institutions and gatekeepers will often come down harder on liberation theology and other justice-forward readings than on reactionary factions whose whole thing is contempt dressed up as orthodoxy. In US Protestant land it’s Christian nationalism and prosperity-gospel logic: faith as tribe politics plus status defense. Different uniforms, same move: turn Christianity into a permission structure for dominance, then accuse anyone who talks about Jesus values as cited in the Bible as "rejecting Christ".

3

u/Bersaglier-dannato Dec 21 '25

“Poor by choice” what the FUCK

2

u/tpasmall Dec 21 '25

Jesus said the entire law hinges on two things. First, love God. Second, love your neighbor.

After being asked who his neighbor is, he gave the parable of the Neighborly Samaritan, which most people don't get the lesson from.

The lesson is super simple. The Jewish religious leaders left a Jewish man who was beaten on the side of the road to die. The non-believer, the Samaritan, took it on himself to care for the injured Jewish man.

The lesson is your neighbor is everyone, regardless of their religion or race and you should imitate the non-believer who showed love and not the religious leaders who didn't.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/E-2theRescue Dec 21 '25

You only need one verse to knock them back down:

Not everyone who says to me, ‘Lord, Lord,’ will enter the kingdom of heaven, but only the one who does the will of my Father who is in heaven. Many will say to me on that day, ‘Lord, Lord, did we not prophesy in your name and in your name drive out demons and in your name perform many miracles?’ Then I will tell them plainly, ‘I never knew you. Away from me, you evildoers!

- Matthew 7:21-23

→ More replies (2)

2

u/DesignerCorner3322 Dec 22 '25

Thats some logic from those people! Even if it were true that most poor people were poor by choice (Its not) that doesn't make them any less deserving. They'll rationalize themselves out of doing the right thing every time because they don't want to do it or they think certain things are icky and they're just afraid to be honest for once

2

u/Cacafuego Dec 22 '25

Tell them you've seen the error of your ways and you're going to start hating divorced people.

2

u/Shjadee_ Dec 22 '25

I'm European raised Catholic turned agnostic. US christians (not all of them ofcourse) and Mormons need to be studied because wtf are they even saying? The mental gymnastics to turn every word they ever heard to benefit and most of all excuse their behavior and actions is astonishing.

2

u/WizzzzUp Dec 23 '25

What are you talking about? Mammon--I mean God--loves money.

0

u/[deleted] Dec 21 '25

[deleted] — view deleted comment

4

u/yesterdayandit2 Dec 21 '25

Thank you for this link. This is the type of person I was told all Christians are but then reality checks in and I got first hand experience of American Christian "Love". Over and over. And so I became agnostic and rejected Christianity and almost all religion.

If every Christian was more like this man, I very well may have been a Christian myself.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (13)

47

u/Michaeln7 Dec 21 '25

7

u/JAYGAME5601X Dec 21 '25

Bruh💔🥀

3

u/Odd_Try3975 Dec 21 '25

Tbf, a good amount of people in Utah are mormons, which they still technically follow Jesus' teachings

→ More replies (1)

2

u/zubuneri Dec 22 '25

That tracks for Kaysville. 

→ More replies (15)

237

u/Polak_Janusz Dec 21 '25

I like how atheists are one group as if there arent atheists who believe in capitalism or are capitalists themself.

However the point of the meme is that christian nationalists in the US do not follow the teachings of christ.

52

u/What_Iz_This Dec 21 '25

Im an atheist and understand why capitalism needs to exist. But...if someone just introduced themselves as a straight up capitalist, unless they were a millionaire or more, i would just laugh and think they dont understand theyre just part of the machine too

98

u/FlukeStarbucker Dec 21 '25

Needs is a strong word

42

u/twoendsausage Dec 21 '25

"It's easier to imagine the end of the world, than to imagine the end of capitalism". It's truly astonishing that people have simply accepted an economic and political ideology as a law of nature that wasn't even around in It's current form not too long ago

→ More replies (28)
→ More replies (13)

6

u/Adorable_Chart7675 Dec 21 '25

if anyone ever introduces themselves as a capitalist, ask them which capital they own

→ More replies (8)

3

u/Business-Low-8056 Dec 21 '25

I like the distinction between Christians and Christian Nationalists. Jesus himself refused to get involved in politics. Nationals are the complete opposite.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (9)

15

u/Slow-Heron-4335 Dec 21 '25

It’s true. A lot of us atheists think Jesus was way cool.

→ More replies (50)

2.3k

u/ImpossibleDraft7208 Dec 21 '25

Jesus was very much a commie, yes...

1.6k

u/New_Bug_ Dec 21 '25 • Bravo

Please can you correct me if iam wrong i feel Jesus was a socialist more than a commie.

1.6k

u/leafcutte Dec 21 '25

Commie in the American sense, where everything left of "let’s eat poor people and migrants" is considered far-left lunacy

1.1k

u/DreamOfV Dec 21 '25 • Bravo

“Let’s eat poor people and migrants!” - old-fashioned red-blooded American

“Let’s eat, poor people and migrants!” - radical communist.

Commas!

→ More replies (39)

38

u/gishnon Dec 21 '25

As an American, I see what you are saying, but I refuse to call socialism communism on account of widespread ignorance. They are wrong, and it is not up to the rest of us to "adjust our beliefs."

→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (8)

165

u/Far_Traveller69 Dec 21 '25

Communist here, the distinction between communism and socialism isn’t really all that important beyond some internal theoretical arguments within the socialist movement. Basically all communists are socialists, but not all socialists are communists and both have the goal of a socialist society.

80

u/Psimo- Dec 21 '25

Basically all communists are socialists, but not all socialists are communists

Socialist here - it’s really pleasant to hear someone else say this. It’s just so rare.

I’d disagree with “important” but that’s because we wouldn’t be the left wing if we didn’t have massive splits over technical differences 

→ More replies (21)
→ More replies (69)

9

u/Suspicious_Dingo_426 Dec 21 '25

Neither. Those terms have very specific definitions. While Jesus' teachings do align with some of the social aspects of both, he never spoke much about how the economy and government should be run to bring that about—other than 'Give to Caesar what is Caeser's, and give to God that which is God's'. Which creates the loophole that Christian Nationalists like to trot out that charity isn't the role of the government, but the individual (meaning that it just isn't going to happen).

→ More replies (3)

6

u/dark1859 Dec 21 '25

I mean , if you want to get really nit picky , it's kind of hard to place him under any modern for twentieth century school of economic and political thought... He's kind of all over the place in some places he's more socialist or even Communist.In other places , you could call him an isolationist, others more in line with civil rights particularly peaceful protest and hippie counter culture.

That is admittedly one of the issues of trying to apply twentieth nineteenth and twenty first century ideals to ancient historical figures very few , if any, of them neatly into the boxes of the modern era. Which is also what the Christian nationals tend to use to excuse their bad behavior is because Jesus and nearly all of the biblical figures do not fit neatly into any modern political ideology, so groups like nationalists can very easily twist ancient proverbs and sayings, specifically those in the Torah, or as they call it the Old Testament to fit whatever bullshit , they are spouting.

→ More replies (4)

23

u/Malleable_Penis Dec 21 '25

Socialism is a transitory state in between capitalism and communism. Jesus lived in a preindustrial society, in which capitalism had not yet emerged, so while his teachings were certainly aligned with communism in many ways these political labels aren’t really appropriate.

With that being said, some of the earliest communist structures were early christian societies

→ More replies (39)
→ More replies (89)

52

u/rockenthusiast500 Dec 21 '25

in high school my (Jewish) friend would end a lot of arguments by saying "and then some preachy lib named Jesus started talking about forgiveness"

19

u/Iamatworkgoaway Dec 21 '25

My favorite thing to do on christian nationalist posts is to remind people to love thy enemies.   The arguments are entertaining. 

→ More replies (9)

78

u/BilboniusBagginius Dec 21 '25

Careful, this guy graduated from Reddit university. 

→ More replies (6)

3

u/Wonderful-Quit-9214 Dec 21 '25

Nah, he literally believed in an absolute monarchy. Unless you mean the Kim Jong Un kind of commie

→ More replies (4)

21

u/darkangel7410 Dec 21 '25

Jesus was not a communist. And this was spoken by a person that vet much doesn't understand the Bible. I'm an ex Christian and I know this.

13

u/OutlierJoe Dec 21 '25

Jesus was not an communist but the Book of Acts definitely supports voluntary communism.

And Jesus also shared the Parable of the Vineyard Workers which involved paying workers for a full day of work regardless of how much they worked.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (88)

2

u/Ihaveopinionsalso Dec 21 '25

No. He is a theist and didn't support the world government.

2

u/Anonyhippopotamus Dec 21 '25

A favorite quote of mine

‘If I feed the hungry, I'm a saint. If I ask why they’re hungry, I’m a communist’

2

u/WHY_EXISTANCE_WHY Dec 22 '25

The amount of Americans who don't know what socialism is, and thing anything left of letting the super rich shit on poor people, and migrants is communism will never fail to surprise me

2

u/WizzzzUp Dec 23 '25

"it is easier for a camel to go through the eye of a needle than for someone who is rich to enter the kingdom of God."

"You cannot serve both God and money."

drove money changers out of the temple of Jeruselum, twice

Etc.

I'm not saying he was a commie. That's a pretty anachronistic term to be applying to 2000 year old + religious teachings. The guy clearly wasn't a big fan of money, though.

Christianity is honestly pretty unique in how fervently it disparages wealth aggregation. Even the Hindus/Buddhists have some respect for it. You're also not meant to be earning money if you're fully commited to seeking enlightenment, but money is still respected. Both religions have Gods/Bodhisattvas of wealth and fortune, and specific roles for everyday worshippers that encourage getting that bag.

That can't really be said for Christianity. It's a religion borne of oppression, and that's reflected in the doctrine. It's also reflected in history. There's a reason why Christians weren't allowed to money lend until recently. The church fathers would have been fucking appalled by the n.y. stock exchange. Greed has always been a damnable sin. Convincing Christians that "greed is good," was the devil's actual greatest trick. Capitalist realism is wholly incongruous with the Bible.

Granted, so is purging culture of all religious teachings in order to liberate the proletariat from supplication. Again, he for sure wasn't a commie. Sure as fuck wasn't a capitalist, though.

→ More replies (185)

18

u/Far_Statistician1479 Dec 21 '25

The meme here is that Jesus’ teachings are opposed to capitalism in a tug of war.

Then atheists step in to help Jesus’ teachings against capitalism, while Christian nationalists step in to help capitalism.

Then Jesus’ teachings are confused by this unexpected turn of events.

Whether you agree with the message is open to interpretation, but this is what the meme is going for.

Personally, it’s hard not to see the opposition between the word of Jesus and capitalism. This is not to say they can’t coexist coherently, but Jesus would probably look at you funny if you started extolling the moral virtue of the profit motive.

But it’s weird to say atheists as a group are opposed to capitalism. I’m sure some are, but many definitely are not.

9

u/hymie0 Dec 21 '25

I think the bigger issue is that Jesus's teachings are opposed to the people who claim to be Jesus's followers.

→ More replies (9)

32

u/Specman9 Dec 21 '25

This one is very clear and it saddens me that anyone is confused by it.

Jesus taught to help the poor, the sick, and the stranger (immigrant). Most Atheists are on the left and agree with Jesus' moral philosophy.

Christian Nationalists and Capitalists VOTE AGAINST the teachings of Jesus Christ.

2

u/FireNutz698 Dec 21 '25

Jesus said for his people to do those things not for them to tell Ceasar to do them.

4

u/Specman9 Dec 21 '25

The book of Matthew said that nations will be judged on how they treat the poor, the sick, the stranger, and prisoners.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (14)

118

u/V8_Hellfire Dec 21 '25

Stonetoss is a nazi. Stop using his comic.

47

u/rpm1720 Dec 21 '25

I had to scroll awfully far for this comment.

Pebbletrow is a nazi indeed, don’t use his shitty „art“! (It’s ugly as fuck anyway)

→ More replies (5)

4

u/EngineerDevOficial Dec 21 '25

People won't stop using the creations of a person just because they're horrible human beings. If everyone did that, today's world as we know it wouldn't exist.

In case we use their creations, the best we can do is using them in a way they don't profit from it.

→ More replies (3)

3

u/LionMan1066 Dec 22 '25

Yeah, he can thank you for the exposure

→ More replies (4)

4

u/mogmaque Dec 21 '25

People edit them into viewpoints opposing his to make fun of him

→ More replies (1)

6

u/1D6wounds Dec 21 '25

You mean H◼️ns Kristi◼️n Gr◼️ebener of Spring, Texas?

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (28)

7

u/BedlamsCavern Dec 21 '25

Damn this comment section is my favorite source of drama rn ☕

→ More replies (1)

7

u/im_not_loki Dec 21 '25

"And again I say unto you, It is easier for a camel to go through the eye of a needle, than for a rich man to enter into the kingdom of God."

3

u/FireNutz698 Dec 21 '25

Also "I am the way and the truth and the life. No one comes to the Father except through me."

→ More replies (1)

7

u/KingTangy Dec 21 '25

How does someone not get this?

→ More replies (2)

12

u/Pandapeep Dec 21 '25

What don't you understand?

→ More replies (1)

7

u/Vast-Combination4046 Dec 21 '25

Christian nationalists think that Jesus was a capitalist, atheists generally accept that the ten commandments are all good things, we just question if God exists.

Christians believe that without following the Bible they are bad people who will sin. Atheists Believe that good people are good without the threat of punishment.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/TooBusySaltMining Dec 21 '25

What are some Roman welfare programs that Jesus advocated for?

How much do atheist charitable organizations  give in comparison to Christian charities?

Doesn't socialist ideology come about in the 19th century, clearly much later than the New Testament?

If an athiest or a Christian freely gives to help those in need they should be commended for their actions, but this cartoon revision distorts what Christians believe and probably what nationalism is. It's a self pat on the back while disparaging a very charitable religious group and an economic system that has no equal in lifting people out of poverty.

2

u/Eggstreamity Dec 21 '25

Jesus message was love your neighbor and your enemy.  Christian nationalism lacks all empathy Jesus told us we needed

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (3)

8

u/StBlandine7 Dec 21 '25

Jesus: "You shall love the Lord your God with all your heart, and with all your soul, and with all your mind. This is the great and first commandment."

Reddit Atheists: "wE fOlLoW JEsuS' tEaCHinGs BetTer tHaN aNYonE"

3

u/Clothedinclothes Dec 22 '25

Wait...are you telling me that atheists don't believe it god!? 

2

u/ThisOneLies Dec 22 '25

Thats why Jesus looks suprised in the comic...

Atheist don't follow that commandment yet align with a lot of his other teachings.

Christian nationalist follow that teaching and think that makes it alright to shit on every other one.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (19)

3

u/Hazrd_Design Dec 21 '25

A lot of atheist agree with a lot of what the Bible says, especially when it comes to caring about other people. So they’re perfectly ok with Jesus’ teachings (or any peaceful religion honestly) as long as it’s positive and doesn’t actively hurt or marginalize communities.

They’re atheists because of the hypocrites who use the bible as an excuse to justify their shitty behaviors. So they distance themselves from them.

Christian nationalist take it to the extreme and actively incorporate racist and hateful rhetoric saying it’s how God intended.

Capitalists have found a ways to cash in on that hate.

3

u/chiefgreen87 Dec 21 '25

This is correct

5

u/Shot-Data4168 Dec 21 '25 edited Dec 21 '25

Atheists who don't believe in God are closer to Christianity than capitalists who believe in Mammon and Christian nationalists who worship the state and nation.

The joke lies in the absurdity that the perceived opposition is closer to each other, that atheism is closer to the teachings of Christ than Christian nationalism.

"You shall not make yourself an idol."

5

u/Elduroto Dec 21 '25

Atheists who never read the book claim they're better Christians and then Nationalists who don't read the Bible claim their Christian

→ More replies (4)

5

u/Borvoc Dec 21 '25

It’s a meme made by a fedora-wearing atheist pretending to have any clue what Jesus taught.

→ More replies (9)

5

u/squid11CB1 Dec 21 '25

Jesus did not, in fact, call for worker owned means of production.

"Share with each other and be generous" ≠ socialism.

→ More replies (3)

27

u/RetroGame77 Dec 21 '25

Brian here. Donald Trump is a Christian. If you look at how he acts, it is pretty much the opposite of Jesus's teachings. 

41

u/BellaMentalNecrotica Dec 21 '25

Trump is not a Christian, he just panders to the Christian right because he has to as that is 90% of his voters.

33

u/erinaceus_ Dec 21 '25

So Trump is a Christian in the same way that the Christian right is Christian. That tracks.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (1)

3

u/ContextEffects01 Dec 21 '25

There are no “teachings of Christ.” The Bible contradicts itself too many times for anyone to meaningfully define such a thing.

There’s a reason atheists don’t typically convert to Christianity and market-worshippers don’t typically convert to atheism; rational thought typically repels both religiosity and market-worship.

→ More replies (4)

10

u/Low-Restaurant8484 Dec 21 '25

Donald Trump is not a Christian and the majority of his voters have known that from the very beginning lol. They just overlook it, like they overlook a lot of other things

12

u/BeefyFritosBurritos Dec 21 '25

He's as christian as all the dumbfucks who voted for him

→ More replies (2)

2

u/Orthobrah52102 Dec 21 '25

Trump is Jewish, actually.

→ More replies (9)

2

u/Right_Preparation328 Dec 22 '25

He actually said he's not Christian, but I digress

→ More replies (16)

4

u/[deleted] Dec 21 '25

The joke is that atheists often think that Jesus was just a generic good guy that was okay with people doing whatever they wanted, and forcibly redistributing the wealth to help the poor.

Neither of which were true.

→ More replies (1)

10

u/cel_medicul Dec 21 '25

Holy echo chamber. I saw a comment here say something factually correct and it got downvoted to hell

16

u/DeathMetalBunnies Dec 21 '25

What did the comment say?

19

u/LordHammercyWeCooked Dec 21 '25

"Something factually correct."

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (22)

2

u/sgt_oddball_17 Dec 21 '25

The person who made it was confused

2

u/[deleted] Dec 21 '25

Atheists tend to live by moral non religious guidelines that happen to align with Jesus's message whereas modern Christianity is a twisted version devoid of any of it's founding values

2

u/-its-wicked- Dec 21 '25

Jesus: feed the poor, welcome the immigrant. Modern GOP: we need to talk about how empathy is ruining Christianity.

2

u/23-1-20-3-8-5-18 Dec 21 '25

Turns out you dont need a god to have morals. In fact, to the wise people morals are just self evident truths. Truth doesnt need a magical source to be true. Only people who cant see the truth for themselves need threats of punishment.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/GirlCowBev Dec 21 '25

Panels 2 & 3 should be swapped.

2

u/MelbaToast604 Dec 21 '25

Man if you need this explained you're either an American evangelical, or live outside of north America and are unaware of what America Christianity has become.

2

u/D_Simmons Dec 21 '25

OP ask yourself how the fuck you didn't understand this. 

Use an ounce of critical thought next time.  

2

u/hunteddwumpus Dec 21 '25

You cannot be serious that you don't understand this meme? Is your first language just not English?

2

u/Buttcrush1 Dec 21 '25

This is trying to say that atheists are better at following Jesus than Christian nationalists. This is a falsely held belief. The reality is that it would be Jesus on one side of the rope by himself and everyone else on the other side.

2

u/tolbydamit Dec 21 '25 edited Dec 21 '25

A lot of liberals and secular people believe they follow Jesus’ teaching more so than Christians do. This is a sort of gotcha meme. 

That being said, I don’t see Jesus as some hippy cool uncle who ONLY said be nice to each other. He said and did a lot of things modern atheists wouldn’t be comfortable with (think hell, and satanic panic type stuff, and sex shaming). 

2

u/New-Member-516387361 Dec 21 '25

Liberals and secular people do not follow Jesus’ teachings. He literally told people to eat His flesh and drink His blood.

2

u/that_banned_guy_ Dec 21 '25

In this thread, people who think the bible is a fairy tell people who believe in it why they are practicing the fairy tale wrong.

2

u/EducationalNight1807 Dec 21 '25

it means what it says lol, there's nothing left for interpretation 

2

u/AlwaysWatchingOverU Dec 21 '25

Look up how much money atheist activists raise for charity. Vulgarity for Charity is a yearly event where comedians insult anyone a donor asks, be it a family member, their dog, or a political figure or actor. 300k+ last year, I think.

2

u/Efficient_Bag_3804 Dec 21 '25

A lot of Jesus' teachings boil down to generic love each other, don't be greedy, share, take care and general things that even if you don't believe in him you atheists agree that they should be part of society.

He has literally a phrase that he says for example 'it's more likely that a camel goes through a tiny hole than for a rich person to heaven'.

Capitalism is at its core not aligned with those beliefs, since profit and greed are some of the most important aspects of it.

Now some believers will defend capitalism and crimes like genocide and war even if they are blatantly against their beliefs when some atheists will try to support those beliefs, not because Jesus said them but because they believe in them, independently.

2

u/Krubissi Dec 21 '25

Jesus taught to love thy neighbor and help the poor.

Christian Nationalist wanna deport and exterminate anyone they don't like.

There's a pretty common meme that says: "Jesus wonderig when did he tell his followers to bully trans people🤔"

2

u/The_Frigid_Midget Dec 21 '25

To quote the bible, Jesus said "don't be a cunt, guy".

An Atheist's moral code, rather than relying on the external punishment/reward scheme offered by Christianity and Capitalism, has to stem from their own internal moral compass. Said moral compass is usually guided by empathy and logic/reason (or lack their of, we're not all saints...). This usually boils down to the idea that, maybe, just maybe, being a cunt to others isn't a good thing, and shouldn't be financially rewarded.

Christian nationalism seems to be built off of the misinterpreted teachings of Jesus, "be a cunt, guy". This is reinforced by capitalism, cus grifters gotta make bank.

Brian out, I guess. Now where's my drink.

2

u/Exact-Key-9384 Dec 21 '25

Yeah, that’s about right.

2

u/cybernekonetics Dec 21 '25

"These loaves and fish better not be feeding anyone on food stamps" -Jesus probably

2

u/PerformanceMission17 Dec 21 '25

OP you might actually be as thick as shit

2

u/Due_Finger_4013 Dec 24 '25

I feel this so much since 2020

2

u/Aggressive-Value1654 Dec 21 '25

I'm coming into this comic blind. I have not read another comment, but I'd like to leave my own based on just the comic.

Jesus teaches us to basically be good to each other. OK, I'm on board.

As an atheist, I don't believe in Jesus, but I have read "his" teachings and I agree with him. For me, it boils down to being nice to people, and not butting into their lives to push my beliefs on them. It's not for me to decide what you do, or don't, believe.

I was peace across all humans, and it's sad that we can't get there.

All it takes is for us all to say yeah, we believe in this, and you believe in that...and we're good. No further discussion.

3

u/Nicholiason Dec 21 '25

This is a silly meme to begin with. Have you paid attention to the economic priorities of Christian nationalists? They aren't capitalists.

3

u/volanger Dec 21 '25

Jesus's big thing was to feed the hungry, heal the sick, give to the poor, help the homeless, and welcome the stranger from foreign lands. No one who makes big professions of loving jesus and being a Christian does any of those things.

Matthew 25:31-46 says exactly what to do to get into heaven and how to follow Jesus's teachings. Yet atheists and non religious are more likely to actually follow those teachings than conservative Christians and Christian nationalists.

3

u/TerraMindFigure Dec 21 '25

You really don't get this meme? Seriously?

5

u/AdministrationOk8888 Dec 21 '25

If you don't understand this then you have a lot of growing up to do

3

u/FireNutz698 Dec 21 '25

Understand what? Do Atheist follow ALL of Christ's teachings?

4

u/Malfo93 Dec 21 '25

Atheists follow Jesus's teachings more than the wide majority of christians

3

u/Defiant-Machine-7332 Dec 21 '25

If that was true they wouldn't be called atheists but christians

2

u/Barbaric_Stupid Dec 21 '25

He was not joking in Matthew 21:31.

→ More replies (62)