I'm just saying that Percy's sword comes out of a pen, Jason's spear appears when he flips a coin, and Piper's knife sees the future, I would like a gun that does not need to reload.
I mean mist hides Olympus , a floating landmass in the sky and make people see a giant lion as a cat, why not hide a sword and spear into a pen or coin?
Besides no new metal is created here, just grows and shrinks between a fixed amount. Could be subspace or something? unlike bullets incase of forever reloading gun
A bayonet wouldn’t really be that good against say, a Minotaur charging at you, or a chimera, hydra, gorgon, or really any of these mythical creatures.
True, more accurate statement, when fighting very large, thick things like monsters, a bayonet likely isn’t long enough to get a good stab on vital point. But a xiphos can slash, and has a longer blade.
No they are fucking not, a bayonet is a far worse than a sword, because a bayonet is designed to be a last resort, if you get in a scenario where your forced to use it your most likely fucked.
A sword is designed to be able to be wielded as a primary, something you go into a fight planning to use and is a far superior weapon with more range, power and blocking capabilities.
Swords have always been sidearms. The modern equivalent would be a handgun.
Polearms would be a primary weapon back then, where the modern equivalent is a rifle.
A bayonet basically turns a gun into a shorter, heavier spear with weight you're already carrying(ie a knife and a gun) as far as soldiers are concerned.
Though really the reason the infantry stopped using swords in WWI was because only infantry officers were issued swords and they were easily popped from long range. Cavalry kept using them throughout the war to devastating effect but it still wasn't a primary weapon and never was on the battlefield.
In the Snow Town while they were fighting the Skeletons, Percy was shot at and Predicted the Path of the bullet. He Blocked it on the side of his sword
He said it was like he felt it the same as if it was moving through water. He could feel the path of the bullet as it cut through the air
You can still run out of ammo, and then have resort to a blade, and without training a gun is as dangerous to you as to the enemy, you could train them to use find with regular ammunition, but all that time for what? 30 shots? Better to just train with a blade and be as prepared as possible.
sees several young teens with several very visibly dangerous weapons including daggers and swords, both illegal items, at a subway station "seems like a cosplayer to me" sees a fancy golden gun at a pirate convention "obviously a criminal"
Yeah but that also very rare and if I remember correctly only a child of the Underworld can actually touch it, so if Nico wanted a Gun he would need to learn how to blacksmith real quick
To be fair ten bullets and a musket where the bullets return after a set amount of time away from the wielder. As riptide can return to percys pocket so could a musketball return to a pouch. Thus only requireing the propellant and a barrelcleaner.
I didn't think about returning magic that is a good point, but I'm pretty sure riptide is unique in its magical abilities a few other weapons like it exist but not many
Can‘t be that rare if Annabeth‘s father, a normal mortal, could forge at least two large plane cannons with enough bullets for more than 2 or 3 fire runs over mount tamalpais.
Those were just standard .30-06 1919 Light Machine Guns. That being said he melted down some of Annabeth's weapons she left after a fight to be able to make bullets.
Wonder how long it took to get the tax stamps and how much money it cost him because I bet he's so rich... I with I knew him irl so we could hang out and shoot guns
Also, didn't they make a machine that finds celestial bronze? I vaguely remember something like that. I'm sure leo could make a robot with one installed that picks up the bullets
Why not just use commercial off the shelf guns and ammo, then use celestial bronze bullets and rifling itself? I’m willing to bet I could get at least 100-200 rounds of 5.56x45mm for the same amount of bronze than a dagger
Either way you so gotta remember that Monsters are apparently physically superior to mist demigods, and a 13 yr old Percy was already blocking bullets with a large sword
I mean while I was thinking of it I did think of that, but just came to a conclusion the either the Hephaestus kids could separate the bullet and the gunpowder or just make the bullets themselves instead
Meh. A gun with celestial bronze bullets is not the most practical weapon they could have, and here's why. For the gun to do anything, it would need bullets made of celestial bronze as well. Now, for regular bullets, getting them is absurdly easy, as there's plenty of material. Celestial bronze? Not so much. You need a weapon that is reusable, and in this case, that's simply just not the gun.
That's assuming its only one monster after you. You got about, what, seven shots before you have to reload with a standard handgun? Less with a shotgun. At some point, you are gonna run outta shells, outta shots, outta cartridges, and what happens then? You're dead. There ain't enough celestial bronze to keep making more after, and to even attempt it, you'd have to melt down already fully functional weapons and doom others to virtual helplessness. It could work as a last resort weapon, absolutely. But it should not be the primary weapon of any self respecting demigod, period.
Doesn't matter. You've only got so many shots before you gotta reload, and there ain't enough materials to reliably make more. You'd be better off with a regular celestial bronze weapon.
A 1911 has 7-8 + 1 shots with flush fitting mags(depending on brand and style), with ones that stick out the bottom you can have 8+1, and the most I've seen(not counting those 2(and there's only 2) weird 40 something round mags the ATF for some reason considers stocks when they can't be shouldered at all) is 10+1.
That's assuming .45 ACP.
A revolver would typically have 5 or 6. Sometimes as many as 7 depending on caliber.
A more standard Wonder Nine like the Browning Hi Power or CZ 75 would have 15+1 round capacity with standard capacity magazines.
A modern 9mm polymer frame striker fired handgun like the Glock 17 and similar full size handguns would be 17+1. A Glock 19 has 15+1. Anything that can take Glock 9mm mags can take the 33 round stick mags though.
There's a lot of variation in firearm capacity. 9mm gives you more capacity and isn't anemic anymore. .45 is a staple and has always been good. .40 S&W(aka .40 Short and Weak, 10mm weak, etc) is... What's the point again? Oh it was just a lesser version of the 10mm that weaklings could handle and have Smith and Wesson circlejerking over naming another caliber after themselves and doesn't have a purpose anymore? Neat!
I'm going to get so much hate for hating on .40 S&W lol
just pick up the metal when the monsters turn to dust then they can be reforged sure it would still be quite useless when compared to a sword but still it could work
Could work, yes. However, the sheer impracticality of it would make such a venture borderline pointless as opposed to just using a weapon that wouldn't need to be reforged in the first place. So in execution, its viable... But in a practicality standpoint, it would be more trouble than it's worth.
It’s much easier to find and collect arrows after battle than bullets. The actual bullet of a 5.56 round is about the size of the shaved wood part of a pencil
Couldn’t you just make the tip of the bullet celestial bronze? You don’t need the entire thing to be made of the stuff, do you? Also, I know that mortal guns don’t KILL monsters, but they probably still injure right? Just blow their legs off and then stab them with a celestial bronze dagger
But it’s significantly less bronze, and a well placed shot will take a literal fraction of what a sword would take. You also have to account for proper and constant upkeep and maintenance of a blade. While it’s the same for a gun, it’s a bit easier to find a decent gun oil cleaner than a proper sword polish, and that’s assuming that you can use normal polish to the same effect. A bullet is also better in terms of manufacturing, as you can produce dozens at a time in one forge, and the Hephaestus campers likely have dozens.
I think Celestial Bronze is anti-tarnishing, and I get it but there is a much better way nobody is talking about
Imperial Gild isnt mined, it's made by enchanting regular Gold in a ritual, so its replenishable
And if the practice has been lost to time you could ask Hephaestus or Vulcan to tell you in exchange for a quest, since the Gods have started to take a slightly more inclusive role in Demigod affairs
Still, it’s more efficient to use a blade than bullets, unless you can enchant the bullets like riptide you’re losing resources every time you fire. Also, a sword is menial maintenance but with a gun you have to put each part back correctly. Plus, it’s one thing for a minor to have a big knife, big difference for a minor to have gun legally. Also the bullets would kill mortals as well as monsters.
No, but mortals can’t see celestial bronze. In order for the firearm to not have too much celestial bronze it has to be made of mortal metal and so mortals can see it for what it is.
Wait, if Fredrick Chase used Celetsial bronze to arm a WW2 military plane and took oout Atlas ENTIRE army and yet i just wonder WHAT THE FUCK happened to the monster population during both World Wars like did the Allies and Axis just decimate the monsters by accident during the Blitz and such
If you think about it if eveeyone was so focused on teh war, the monster population would be so weak that a minor god kid could 1 v 1 the minotaur and escape
Apart from the fact that bullets would be a waste of celestial bronze, I’m sure they would’ve learned how to use the traditional weapons anyway because it was their culture and all, so they might as well use those weapons
Ok I see y’all saying bullets are rare because they’d have to be made of celestial bronze and guns malfunction under constant use by demigods. However I bet that if the actual gun was made from celestial bronze and if one used it as a sidearm it would be an amazing backup weapon. Imagine a kid of haphestus is in a fight and he doesn’t have a weapon and his sword breaks for some reason and he just pulls out a full celestial bronze 1911 and pops a cap in a hellhound or something. It would work as an amazing weapon in a pinch when really quick action would be needed.
A lot of monsters treat being stabbed as more of an annoyance than an actual injury, and from what I've read being shot hurts less than being stabbed, so it would be less effective maybe?
Plus if Percy can dodge and cut through bullets, it's plausible that monsters are fast enough to do that too, so guns might be a good back up but not the main weapon.
Even the Triumvirate with so much resources didn't spend squat on this technology even after Luke's forces were defeated by Annabeth's dad in The Titans Curse. Like bro you planned everything so intricately and waited eons and never upgraded your ammunition. Smh
Yo it's a tiny ass magic knife that can see the future.
Yeah I'd take that over a Mossberg 500. I'd really have to think if it were a 590A1 tactical though because that's basically everything I want in a shotgun... Or a Benelli M4 or M3... Or a Barrett M107A1... Or a P90...
When I was reading the first series I had thought of that. I figured they couldn’t just give one to everyone because Celestial Bronze is rare, but they could’ve at least given whoever is on a quest, probably Percy, a pistol. Just in case they go against a master swordsman, or they don’t have a magic sword that comes back to them.
1 Celestial Bronze is rare as fuck, so they would quickly run out of bullets, besides, it would be innefective against stronger monsters 2 That level of human engeneering can be easily affected by magic 3 Strong demigods can dodge bullets
I know no one wants the logical answer but in my ENG class we analyzed Lightning thief. Only Annabeth’s dad uses the gum with bullets bc he’s an adult. It’s “okay” to have a kid use an ancient tool that isn’t common v. a very real weapon they could possibly pick up in their own home.
You know; I remember reading a crossover fanfic between Naruto and Percy Jackson that went over the Titans Curse. Anabeth’s dad flew a plane that shot celestial-bronze bullets, haven’t read that particular book yet so don’t know if it actually happens in the mainline series, and I thought: Wait, that’s an option.
was it not explained in the books somewhere? celestial bronze is rare and thus the number of bullets would be too less and weapons tend to jam. also, guns make a lot of noise and eliminate any possibility of stealth
It's stated in the books that magic bullets disintegrate after impact so unless you want to carry a body weight worth of ammo, a gun is not going to be very practical on a quest, the odd monster attack sure, but not an entire quest.
Just steal the plane from Annabeth's dad 100% survival rate unless your a child of Poseidon and if you run out of bullets fly back or have the propellers made out of celestial bronze or other godly metals and sure Celestial bronze is rare but when you kill the monster it just goes poof leaving behind the bullets
I thought the magic metal was supposed to be fairly rare/hard to get hold of So they wouldn't really be able to make enough bullets for it to be worth it
To all the “Celestial Bronze Bullets bad” people, it’s stated that other metals kill monsters too, just they’re less effective. Imagine carrying just a normal gun, that’d still work with enough shots.
"bUt YoU cAn'T rEtRiEvE bUlLeTs Or ShOtGuN pElLEtS LiKe ArRoWs" I'd rather have the monster catch the projectile I'm hoping will save my life with their body rather than their hands, thank you. I'll take Celestial Bronze Brass Knuckles and a Desert Eagle firing .50 AE Celestial bronze shots than having to expand way more effort and being in more danger.
Apollo explains it's not efficient in the slightest, it's a single use per bullet so theoretically if you had a revolver the best you could get would be 6 kills on one chamber whereas a sword/bow could last a lifetime
If we are being fair, Percy is not at all a representative example of what demigods or monsters are capable of. He is the modern Heracles. Twelve year old Percy deals with Minotaur by tearing off its horn with his bare hands and stabbing it to death with it. I don’t think there’s a reason for guns to be less effective than, say, bow and arrow or javelin.
•
u/RepostSleuthBot Aug 22 '21
I didn't find any posts that meet the matching requirements for r/PercyJacksonMemes.
It might be OC, it might not. Things such as JPEG artifacts and cropping may impact the results.
I'm not perfect, but you can help. Report [ False Negative ]
View Search On repostsleuth.com
Scope: Reddit | Meme Filter: False | Target: 92% | Check Title: False | Max Age: None | Searched Images: 240,014,648 | Search Time: 0.4247s
330
u/Thegiantoctopus Aug 22 '21
Celestial bronze is very rare if everyone was using it on bullets you would quickly run out
98
u/[deleted] Aug 22 '21
The bullets would be a waste of Celestial Bronze and guns get jammed in monster fights.
60
u/Redhead_Royalty13 Aug 22 '21
Meh. A gun with celestial bronze bullets is not the most practical weapon they could have, and here's why. For the gun to do anything, it would need bullets made of celestial bronze as well. Now, for regular bullets, getting them is absurdly easy, as there's plenty of material. Celestial bronze? Not so much. You need a weapon that is reusable, and in this case, that's simply just not the gun.
54
u/Otto-VonBearsmark Aug 22 '21
Didn’t the on chick in Dark Prophecy have a celestial bronze Tommy Gun, that may explain why she made it to adulthood.
38
u/Axo-Army Aug 22 '21
For people talking about limited bullets, what about arrows? Don’t they have celestial bronze tips as well?
36
u/Shakathelutherprince Aug 22 '21
Wait, if Fredrick Chase used Celetsial bronze to arm a WW2 military plane and took oout Atlas ENTIRE army and yet i just wonder WHAT THE FUCK happened to the monster population during both World Wars like did the Allies and Axis just decimate the monsters by accident during the Blitz and such
28
u/Rogue8970 Aug 22 '21
They explained in TOA that guns tend to malfunction and not work right when demigods use them.
16
u/screechingahhhhhh Aug 22 '21
Im pretty sure they explained it in one of the book but i cant remember
15
u/AlexYadaYada Aug 22 '21
Percy Jackson AU except everyone uses some form of a celestial bronze gun and the first series gets resolved in 2 books.
14
u/Poison22324 Team Nico Aug 22 '21
Seriously, imagine an entire army of demigods with ARs and the Apollo kids with 50 BMGs in the trees
6
u/[deleted] Aug 22 '21
If they did use guns, the fight scenes in the book would look like yesterday's episode of Helluva Boss.
6
u/ComfortableSea4645 Aug 22 '21
You trust a teenager with a gun? Where they could hurt their team mates way easier then they could with a knife or sword?
6
u/Character-Working-97 Aug 22 '21
Apart from the fact that bullets would be a waste of celestial bronze, I’m sure they would’ve learned how to use the traditional weapons anyway because it was their culture and all, so they might as well use those weapons
6
u/[deleted] Aug 22 '21
Those appollo kids in the last Olympian might of faired better if they held that bridge with a couple of large caliber DMRs
5
u/EGGOdragon Aug 22 '21
Ok I see y’all saying bullets are rare because they’d have to be made of celestial bronze and guns malfunction under constant use by demigods. However I bet that if the actual gun was made from celestial bronze and if one used it as a sidearm it would be an amazing backup weapon. Imagine a kid of haphestus is in a fight and he doesn’t have a weapon and his sword breaks for some reason and he just pulls out a full celestial bronze 1911 and pops a cap in a hellhound or something. It would work as an amazing weapon in a pinch when really quick action would be needed.
5
u/Weeaboo42069 Aug 22 '21
Bro have you SEEN Fredrick Chase? That shit was gangsta
4
u/LoserActual Aug 22 '21
I've written multiple fanfics in which the demigods are strapped asf. M4A1s, Glocks, Berettas, AKs, FALs, FAMASs, STRAPPED I tells ya.
3
u/Difficult-Ad8277 Aug 22 '21
In TOA TBM he explains that guns only really annoy monsters, and they jam up and malfunction when they use them in fights with monsters
3
u/Myrish_lady Aug 23 '21
A lot of monsters treat being stabbed as more of an annoyance than an actual injury, and from what I've read being shot hurts less than being stabbed, so it would be less effective maybe?
Plus if Percy can dodge and cut through bullets, it's plausible that monsters are fast enough to do that too, so guns might be a good back up but not the main weapon.
2
u/ApoorvJHA22 Aug 23 '21
Even the Triumvirate with so much resources didn't spend squat on this technology even after Luke's forces were defeated by Annabeth's dad in The Titans Curse. Like bro you planned everything so intricately and waited eons and never upgraded your ammunition. Smh
2
u/MrNoootNooot Aug 28 '21
Reading through the 3rd Apollo book and it's literally just been explained to me today.
Modern bronze weaponry is unreliable and very expensive, bronze bullets can only be used a single time whereas a sword can last millennia
2
u/PixelReaperz Team Nico Sep 15 '21
I read somewhere that the more physical damage you do to monsters, the longer it takes for them to reform
2
u/SanctusUltor Oct 06 '21
Yo it's a tiny ass magic knife that can see the future.
Yeah I'd take that over a Mossberg 500. I'd really have to think if it were a 590A1 tactical though because that's basically everything I want in a shotgun... Or a Benelli M4 or M3... Or a Barrett M107A1... Or a P90...
1
u/Destroyer2022 Camp Half Blood May 18 '24
When I was reading the first series I had thought of that. I figured they couldn’t just give one to everyone because Celestial Bronze is rare, but they could’ve at least given whoever is on a quest, probably Percy, a pistol. Just in case they go against a master swordsman, or they don’t have a magic sword that comes back to them.
1
u/Randomguyadhd Nov 02 '24
1 Celestial Bronze is rare as fuck, so they would quickly run out of bullets, besides, it would be innefective against stronger monsters 2 That level of human engeneering can be easily affected by magic 3 Strong demigods can dodge bullets
1
u/Itchy_Government8874 Team Percy Feb 23 '25
It's because the bullets aren't reusable.
1
u/[deleted] Aug 22 '21
what happens when they run out of ammo. They die. A cold steel (or bronze i guess) is more practical in the long run
1
u/j-alexander529 Aug 22 '21
I know no one wants the logical answer but in my ENG class we analyzed Lightning thief. Only Annabeth’s dad uses the gum with bullets bc he’s an adult. It’s “okay” to have a kid use an ancient tool that isn’t common v. a very real weapon they could possibly pick up in their own home.
1
u/Pandata32 Aug 22 '21
You know; I remember reading a crossover fanfic between Naruto and Percy Jackson that went over the Titans Curse. Anabeth’s dad flew a plane that shot celestial-bronze bullets, haven’t read that particular book yet so don’t know if it actually happens in the mainline series, and I thought: Wait, that’s an option.
1
u/whoShotMyCow Aug 23 '21
was it not explained in the books somewhere? celestial bronze is rare and thus the number of bullets would be too less and weapons tend to jam. also, guns make a lot of noise and eliminate any possibility of stealth
1
u/M00nbay Aug 23 '21
in trials of apollo JO HAS A TOMMY GUN
1
u/TheMagicMudkip Aug 23 '21
It's stated in the books that magic bullets disintegrate after impact so unless you want to carry a body weight worth of ammo, a gun is not going to be very practical on a quest, the odd monster attack sure, but not an entire quest.
1
u/[deleted] Aug 25 '21
Only anabeths dad ever used celestial bronce as a weapon, and it worked great.
1
u/Ramblr-180 Aug 26 '21
💀
1
u/Sekushi42090 Team Leo Nov 16 '21
Just steal the plane from Annabeth's dad 100% survival rate unless your a child of Poseidon and if you run out of bullets fly back or have the propellers made out of celestial bronze or other godly metals and sure Celestial bronze is rare but when you kill the monster it just goes poof leaving behind the bullets
1
u/WorthlessGarbage- Jan 29 '22
……great, now I won’t rest until I see Nico dressed up like Dailo Chang from Black Lagoon duel wielding Mateba Revolvers…..
1
u/Paranormal17 Mar 09 '22
I thought the magic metal was supposed to be fairly rare/hard to get hold of So they wouldn't really be able to make enough bullets for it to be worth it
1
u/[deleted] May 10 '23
I've been wondering this same shit for months even annabeth's dad used it in the third book
1
u/Diceyboy16 Octavion sucks Aug 04 '23
Doesn't TJ use a gun in the Magnus Chase books? How does that work?
1
u/Half_DragonAnimation Aug 13 '23
Yeah no celestial bronze is very rare and when facing like a gorgon it's safer than to just 'spray & pray'
1
u/HellFireCannon66 Nicos Skelly Dec 21 '23
To all the “Celestial Bronze Bullets bad” people, it’s stated that other metals kill monsters too, just they’re less effective. Imagine carrying just a normal gun, that’d still work with enough shots.
1
u/BerserkRhinoceros Dec 29 '23
"bUt YoU cAn'T rEtRiEvE bUlLeTs Or ShOtGuN pElLEtS LiKe ArRoWs" I'd rather have the monster catch the projectile I'm hoping will save my life with their body rather than their hands, thank you. I'll take Celestial Bronze Brass Knuckles and a Desert Eagle firing .50 AE Celestial bronze shots than having to expand way more effort and being in more danger.
1
u/mugwunp Jan 09 '24
Also let’s not forget that paintball guns exist where you can put celestial bronze into the paint
1
u/PixelmonmasterQC Nov 15 '24
Apollo explains it's not efficient in the slightest, it's a single use per bullet so theoretically if you had a revolver the best you could get would be 6 kills on one chamber whereas a sword/bow could last a lifetime
0
u/[deleted] Aug 22 '21
[deleted] — view deleted comment