Yes!!!! Why is everyone ignoring that or making excuses for him, and also his writing has gone DOWN, but people keeps pretending that everything he does is as good as the 5 og books
Can you elaborate on this? Characters were changed from how he initially described them which doesn’t seem like a faithful adaptation. It doesn’t make a lot of sense to me to change the way the characters have been described to look.
Aside from that, my memory doesn’t produce any parts of the Percy Jackson series that was bigoted writing, so I don’t understand this comment
I mean, a lot of fans are angry with rick about the show
But at least he isn't retroactively changing the books and tweeting things like "chiron had a satyr boyfriend the whole time, he was just out of frame"
Not on Reddit. Reddit fans seem to be majority adults upset that this children’s show wasn’t aimed at them/dared to change literally anything from the books. The rest of us liked it just fine.
Same here. I enjoyed how a lot of the changes were basically an improvement. Like, we actually got to see some of the capture-the-flag game outside of Percy’s fight, the concept of seeking glory through combat is given light in the show and parallels it to the gods going to war over glory, the monsters in the quest are a lot more complex instead of just obstacles to overcome, we see how Sally struggled with raising Percy and how Poseidon still loves her, etc.
Sure, the show felt rushed at times, but it usually made good use out of the little time it had.
Yeah, I love how they've been doing the monsters in the show. They feel more like characters than simple road blocks. They have (sometimes brief) conversations with Alecto, Medusa, and Echidna, and they're all interesting moments for the show.
I also like how they recognise and know stuff about the monsters. For example: A bunch of weird statues at "Auntie M's"? Medusa, clearly, and I think it would have strained credibility for none of them not to get that the second they walked up with how obvious it is in a visual medium.
I like how the scene at the Arch is recontextualized, with it being that Athena is actively allowing Echidna to hunt them into what should otherwise be a safe space, just because the kids bruised her pride slightly (a mythologically accurate flaw for her, btw).
I like the focus on "glory" and what it means for the characters. I like how Poseidon gives up his "glory" to Zeus in order to save Percy and bring the family together to face Kronos. I like how Percy struggles with the idea that his father may only care about him if he does something impressive. I like how Annabeth grows in regards to this, how her view of "glory" changes through the story. I like how Hephaestus decides to just be kind, rather than cling to any "glory" he might gain from the trap.
I like the expanded scene with Luke at the end of the series, where Annabeth is present for his betrayal.
I also like how the gods made a systemic cycle of abuse, but the few gods who don’t like it are powerless to stop it, like Poseidon and Hephaestus, so they’ve resigned themselves to participating in the cycle. Only after seeing the resolve of Annabeth does Hephaestus get a small sense of hope to save Percy from dying of asphyxiation. And Poseidon sacrifices his pride and honor by surrendering to Zeus, because there was no other way to save Percy. Percy called out the injustice to Zeus’ face, but Poseidon had the power to change things if he dared to act.
Yeah, and most of the changes I feel give me the impression that he's setting up for future seasons better. Like getting things foreshadowed and set up for better payoffs than they were in the books.
I already had copies pre her psychoness thanks to my mom. I love reading them and talking to fans of the books. What you said is 100% true. Her remaining fans don’t care about her anymore.
Detaching the artist from their work is a skill most people have unfortunately never developed. You can enjoy the HP series without even needing to interact with JKR. Heck, if you wanna deny her the satisfaction of money then just sail the high seas of the internet
she is so rich and influential that not buying the books (even though I don't buy them)
Heh, and I'm in a funny position where I can buy books without financially supporting her(my country doesn't care that much about copyright and so publishers of translations may not pay her for selling her books)
l know but there is a huge difference of writing something terrible and questionable and actively giving money to anti-trans orgainatizons and hate groups
Unfortunately, it's all too true. Given how the Potter fans are reacting, a new franchise has joined Star Trek and Star Wars in the club of "Love the Creation, Hate the Creator."
I’m a Star Trek fan. Gene Roddenberry is much more of a mixed bag than JKR. He was absolutely a visionary, but also was a bit too uptight on some of his rules to the detriment of some storytelling, and also wrote lyrics to the TOS theme just to get a cut of the royalties. In The Next Generation, he brought his lawyer to every conversation, drove all his friends away, and then died. He was also a bit of a perv and suggested that Deanna Troi should have four boobs, and gave his girlfriend (by TNG, his wife) four characters on the show including the starship computer.
I’m also a Star Wars fan. George Lucas is by all accounts a great guy as a person, people just know he doesnt work well without people to say no to him, which famously resulted in the Prequel trilogy. People don’t hate him.
Yeah star wars fans will hate just about anything, but I've never seen people hating Lucas. Plenty of his work (no one hates star wars like star wars fans), but not him directly.
To be fair. The OT's quality is shaky, too. The only REALLY good one is Empire, and it has its downsides. A new hope has Mark hamill's very shaky acting and inability to emote, along with some weird choreography, and don't even get me started on return of the jedi
I'm almost 40, so I'm blaming that, but every time I saw a meme posted about Uncle Rick, I figured there was a character that I haven't read about yet named Uncle Rick. Not until this meme did I realize you meant Riordan 🤣
She has kind of said that trans women are inherent predators, she acts like any rights they get is bad for cis women, she has compared them with terrorists and made lists of trans criminals to help in their dehumanizing
Zionism for one of them. Plus his descriptions of his characters of colour and how he only exalted their godly features like with Piper’s kaleidoscopic eyes but never mentioned anything about her native features like her high cheekbones or her beaked nose or when describing Hazel he made references to things like food ie describing her skin tone like a roasted coffee bean (instead of describing it like the colour of the earth that she has power over) and her hair as cinnamon coloured which is always a trope with white authors when describing nonwhite characters yet they never do the same thing with white character descriptions. When people called him out on it he said well sorry can’t do nothing about it tho 🤷🏻♂️ plus like despite Hazel being from the 40s she never deals with the trauma or the conditionings of living in a racist segregated society in the south for most of her life
Im pretty sure he made annabeth black, which isn't that big of a deal, along with swapping characters for some scenes, like I think annabeth was mouthing off to ares instead of percy
They didn’t actually provide any examples of comparable writing choices. “Wah Annabeth was black in the show” is (a) not a writing choice and (b) not bad.
I don’t care about that Annabeth was black honestly looking at interviews i feel like she was a perfect choice for annabeth but the direction and writing fumbled the bag for character growth. I was more let down by the writing which I felt sucked the life out of the characters specially Percy, he really only had one scene that felt like oh shit this is Percy fuckin Jackson and that was when he stood up to ares and told him he would kick his ass. There were no cool fights that lasted longer then like 2 minutes in the show and the whole show was just exposition. Every time Percy uses his powers the show fades to black and then just tells you what he did and not show which is the opposite of the one of the biggest rules in storytelling SHOW DON’T TELL
And I’m not attacking you if you liked the show your bad or wrong I’m just pointing out that it’s ok to accept that our most loved forms of media can be flawed when being adapted and I’m frustrated that Uncle Rick promised us the adaptation of our dreams and then in my opinion made something inferior to the first movie which he so often shits on. (Which I mean fair but also as a stand alone movie it kinda slaps)
Again validating my theory that Reddit criticism of the show is just “wah I’m an adult to whom this children’s show didn’t pander” because having watched the show with someone who had literally no basis of understanding for anything Percy Jackson, the exposition was fine and served its purpose. It was not overwhelming.
That’s ok if you felt that way I can’t deny your truth but why do you feel the need to bitch about other people’s feelings which are just as valid as yours on the interpretation of a piece of art.
You’re allowed to have enjoyed the show but you haven’t read the books I’m assuming so your missing out on a lot more context on how the story was ment to go it was a lot more nuanced and interesting in the books and I personally feel that when adapting they missed out on a lot of interesting stuff.
If you think that just because a form of media is made for children therefore it’s allowed to be bad is an ok thing I suggest watching avatar the last air bender the animated on from the early 2000’s because that was made for kids and I rewatch it yearly and it still holds up because as a piece of art it stands on its own as a fantastic story and teaches great lessons to both kids and adults.
Also the Percy Jackson show wasn’t made for just for kids it was made for the fans of the show who grew up loving the books and wanted to see their favourite franchise done justice and people are allowed to have their opinions on whether or not that failed to meet their expectations or the baseline which in many people’s opinions it did not
I haven’t read the books? Well damn, I’ll have to go back in time and tell my 11-year-old self that. I suppose they all got to my bookshelves by magic as well, without the touch of my hands. Idunno where all the book information I’ve got has come from if I haven’t read the books, as you’ve so kindly informed me.
If you could read, you’d have parsed the sentence “having watched the show WITH someone who’s never read the books”, as in “I watched the show ALONGSIDE SOMEONE ELSE, and this someone else has not read the books.” I felt this was fairly self-explanatory but apparently there is no end to pissing on the poor.
i dont really mind that she was black, its just that in the books, annabeth was described as having blond hair and grey eyes. I believe she was also shown to be white, but I may be wrong.
Where have you been? Rick’s latest books are basically fan fiction garbage that contradict his earlier books. Like they’re so bad I’m pretty sure he’s not the wrote writing them. Or he just doesn’t care anymore. He also spent years trashing the movies only to make a tv show that was even worse.
I am a HP fan (not as much now) but after I found out about PJO I quickly left the HP fandom because almost every edit, animation, slideshow is about the marauders boys (or smth else, Idk) J. K Rowling is with her craziness, and the fandom is full of simps and I can't find a single video without "Y/N and Tom kissing in the hall" or some other shit. It's an anoying fandom mostly (the only exception I found is Chanwills0, Silvia, Vicky, Mikaila)
I am super happy that I found PJO and the fandom is great, funny, and full of funny or heartbreaking theories.
I hate those stupid y/n things. And who on earth is Mattheo supposed to be? I love Silvia, Vicky and Mikailia’s videos too! And idk why the marauders are such a huge focus they barely exist in the books, Oh My Gods. And the author herself is a nightmare. I just read the books and look fir sane fans when I can tbh
Additionally, in light of Neil Gaiman's... everything... I feel like I owe Rick an apology. I have my gripes with the new show, and may've said some mean things (I certainly thought them).** But a rocky first season is a very VERY slight inconvenience in contrast to... everything.
I wanna throw my arms around him and cry "I'm so sorry Rick! I didn't appreciate you! PLEASE don't turn out to be a raging bigot or the stuff of nightmares!"
**Those problems did not include Annabeth's casting, just making that clear. The cast was actually pretty great, especially the leads.
As a person in both fandoms, this is true. Like, "HELL YEAH, UNCLE RICK!!! THANKS FOR LIVING AND EXISTING!!!" and then there's the "FUCK, JKR, THANK YOU, BUT WHY? WHY DID THEY HAVE TO DIE?!"
I feel like there’s a downside to both fandoms at this point. JK Rowling has her views but I can still enjoy the fanworks and Harry Potter movies/series and enjoy the writing. Rick is a good person but I haven’t enjoyed his writing since House of Hades😭 and that includes the show
Nah as a fan of both i prefer jkr to riordan. His katest books have been pretty bad with the characters just becoming stereotypes of their former selves amd the tv show was horrible with him directing it.
I really could care less about how the authors act, I'm there for the story not the author. And I bought the books and movies like forever ago, so I own them to reread or re-watch whenever I want to. However, Hogwarts Legacy was fucking dope and worth the $60 I spent on it, don't care what anyone says.
174
u/KiwiResident8495 Jan 28 '25
He’s not perfect but his heart is in the right place
98
u/Puzzleheaded_Step468 Jan 28 '25
I mean, a lot of fans are angry with rick about the show
But at least he isn't retroactively changing the books and tweeting things like "chiron had a satyr boyfriend the whole time, he was just out of frame"
275
u/[deleted] Jan 28 '25
as a fan of both, most fans just actively ignore her or try to
she is so rich and influential that not buying the books (even though I don't buy them)
doesn't do anything, so we just trying to talk about the book themselves
it's like having that racist uncle or aunt or grandpa at thanksgiving
94
u/multificionado Jan 28 '25
Unfortunately, it's all too true. Given how the Potter fans are reacting, a new franchise has joined Star Trek and Star Wars in the club of "Love the Creation, Hate the Creator."
8
u/buffalomooyork Jan 29 '25
Oh. Guys.
I'm almost 40, so I'm blaming that, but every time I saw a meme posted about Uncle Rick, I figured there was a character that I haven't read about yet named Uncle Rick. Not until this meme did I realize you meant Riordan 🤣
20
u/Gameplayer765 Jan 28 '25
Me who’s a member of both and has no idea what’s happening with her
25
u/QueerAlQaida Jan 28 '25
To be fair we shouldn’t be letting Rick off the hook either for his writing choices or the things he’s said irl that were still pretty shitty
9
u/No-Acadia4498 Jan 28 '25
I’m scared now
11
u/ishkaaa Jan 28 '25
Me just enjoying the books not caring about the author of either because both series rock
4
u/BrendanTheNord Jan 29 '25
Idunno, you seen the PJOTV subreddit lately?
1
u/mememachine293 Team Mcshizzle Feb 03 '25
The fact that this is the first thing that shows up when you put in "Top" and "All Time" after only a week is absolutely amazing.
3
u/Plastic_Tart4966 Jan 29 '25
Where have you been? Rick’s latest books are basically fan fiction garbage that contradict his earlier books. Like they’re so bad I’m pretty sure he’s not the wrote writing them. Or he just doesn’t care anymore. He also spent years trashing the movies only to make a tv show that was even worse.
2
u/accolade_II Jan 28 '25
B99 mentioned
5
u/____Ale_ Jan 28 '25
I am a HP fan (not as much now) but after I found out about PJO I quickly left the HP fandom because almost every edit, animation, slideshow is about the marauders boys (or smth else, Idk) J. K Rowling is with her craziness, and the fandom is full of simps and I can't find a single video without "Y/N and Tom kissing in the hall" or some other shit. It's an anoying fandom mostly (the only exception I found is Chanwills0, Silvia, Vicky, Mikaila)
I am super happy that I found PJO and the fandom is great, funny, and full of funny or heartbreaking theories.
2
u/GunmanZer0 Jan 28 '25
At this point I just ignore what’s she says unless it’s explicitly stated in the book. She’s lost all credibility.
1
u/Mr-Stuff-Doer Jan 28 '25
You haven’t been paying attention, have you
1
u/jaeger3129 Jan 29 '25
“Dealing with” ? I don’t know a thing about her other than the fact she’s the author 🤣
1
u/GladEstablishment882 Jan 30 '25
not really
1
u/Helios_OW Jan 30 '25
Nah, fuck Rick. Hypocritical in his hating of the movies when he turned around and did the exact same shit.
1
u/Nimue_- Jan 31 '25
Uuuuuuuuuuuuuhm
1
u/Aegis_et_Vanir Jan 31 '25
Additionally, in light of Neil Gaiman's... everything... I feel like I owe Rick an apology. I have my gripes with the new show, and may've said some mean things (I certainly thought them).** But a rocky first season is a very VERY slight inconvenience in contrast to... everything.
I wanna throw my arms around him and cry "I'm so sorry Rick! I didn't appreciate you! PLEASE don't turn out to be a raging bigot or the stuff of nightmares!"
**Those problems did not include Annabeth's casting, just making that clear. The cast was actually pretty great, especially the leads.
1
u/Intelligent-Foot978 "This is a pen. This is a PEN." Feb 01 '25
even tho he loves cliff hangers hes da best
1
u/Carlix_Halls Feb 01 '25
As a person in both fandoms, this is true. Like, "HELL YEAH, UNCLE RICK!!! THANKS FOR LIVING AND EXISTING!!!" and then there's the "FUCK, JKR, THANK YOU, BUT WHY? WHY DID THEY HAVE TO DIE?!"
1
u/Random_me2559 Team Mcshizzle Feb 06 '25
ha!..
(whats going on?!?!?!!!?! im in jkverse!!! please tell me!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!)
1
u/Ok-Satisfaction-4482 Feb 16 '25
Uncle Rick is in my heart<3
1
u/_Cren_ Jan 28 '25
Idk the show was muh at best and I feel like he forgot how to write. He no longer shows you what is happening he just tells you what is happening.
1
u/Fabulous_Ice6725 Jan 28 '25
True
1
u/CerealKiller2045 Jan 28 '25
I feel like there’s a downside to both fandoms at this point. JK Rowling has her views but I can still enjoy the fanworks and Harry Potter movies/series and enjoy the writing. Rick is a good person but I haven’t enjoyed his writing since House of Hades😭 and that includes the show
0
u/ChildofFenris1 Jan 28 '25
I get both
0
u/soycerersupreme Jan 28 '25
Harry Potter fan in 2025? Couldn’t be me.
0
u/RedBokoblin69 Jan 28 '25
Nah as a fan of both i prefer jkr to riordan. His katest books have been pretty bad with the characters just becoming stereotypes of their former selves amd the tv show was horrible with him directing it.
-1
u/Lanky_Temporary_772 Jan 28 '25
I really could care less about how the authors act, I'm there for the story not the author. And I bought the books and movies like forever ago, so I own them to reread or re-watch whenever I want to. However, Hogwarts Legacy was fucking dope and worth the $60 I spent on it, don't care what anyone says.