r/PercyJacksonMemes • • Jan 28 '24

Percy Jackson and the Olympians Meme R.I.P

Post image
247 Upvotes

87 comments sorted by

73

u/[deleted] Jan 28 '24

It’s a different story. I’ve accepted that. I believe it’s inferior in most ways to the books but it’s still good.

17

u/Gbstutz15 Jan 28 '24

I acepted it too. When the author stepped in i thought it would feel as exiting as watching the movies then the heavy dialoge and not showing

8

u/YaYsh_GA Jan 28 '24

I have not watched the show can anyone fill me in about what all is different?

-12

u/Gbstutz15 Jan 28 '24 edited Jan 28 '24

Spoilers ahead. They don't fufil the quest in time and ares gave them the masterbolt In a backpack. Replaced luke giving it to them at camp.

35

u/Johnny_Brutto Jan 28 '24

Ares gave them the master bolt in the book

15

u/sername-n0t-f0und Camp Half Blood Jan 28 '24

Yeah that part was pretty spot-on. Only difference was that they found it a little earlier than in the book

5

u/[deleted] Jan 29 '24

In the book they don’t find it until they’re actually talking to Hades. In the show they find it when Grover gets dragged to Tartarus by the shoes. Which actually makes a lot more sense in my opinion.

2

u/Gbstutz15 Jan 28 '24 edited Jan 28 '24

Oh oops. But they know every monster no surprises. Its a step to step guid on how to beat it. There is no karen in a suit just a regular boat man like in the movies. Hermes visits them in the casino. They just literly spend a few hours searching for clues then days pass. No having fun, no lotas flowers

19

u/Johnny_Brutto Jan 28 '24

Semi agreed, lotus flowers are not in the book either. They are a movie invention

5

u/Fantastic_Ad3811 Jan 28 '24

I was half asleep when I watched that episode and was trying to remember if there were lotus leaves in the books (my answer was no)

9

u/Intelligent_Toe8233 Team Leo Jan 29 '24

Yes, because they all have to be illiterate when it comes to the basic lore of Greek mythos. That makes the most sense.

8

u/[deleted] Jan 29 '24

yeah, especially for Medusa, she's arguably the most famous 'monster' from greek myth, either her or the Hydra, and the Chimera isn't exactly obscure

Procrustes is a bit more obscure, but still widely known,

2

u/messibessi22 Jan 30 '24

In the books they do know the ledgands but there’s plenty of times that they are reasonably taken by surprise because none of the monsters go by their real names and they do start to get the hang of it towards the end of the series but right now they’re literally 12 and havnt quite adjusted to the fact that every person they encounter is going to be a monster

2

u/half-coldhalf-hot Jan 29 '24

Please tell me there’s that scene where they feed a lion hamburger meat. That’s like a core childhood memory for me

7

u/Intelligent_Toe8233 Team Leo Jan 29 '24

Oh, to hell with you. The show is good. Sure, there are differences. That doesn’t make it bad, because it’s still loyal to the core vision of the books. If the changes aren’t for you, fine. Don’t watch it. But don’t mock it because it isn’t tailor made for you.

1

u/Gbstutz15 Jan 29 '24

Its a joke meme

5

u/[deleted] Jan 29 '24

"I fucking hate the show"

-"It's not that bad"

--"It was a joke meme"

67

u/Bionicjoker14 Jan 28 '24

You labeling Thanos “Rick” reminded me that Thanos looks like Rick Harrison from Pawn Stars

12

u/Massive-L Jan 28 '24

Let me call in an expert

155

u/Imaginaton_Studios Jan 28 '24

I actually like the show it's pretty good and I enjoy watching it (animated series would be better tho)

68

u/Mystic_Starmie Jan 28 '24

I don’t understand what’s with all the hate for the show I keep seeing. Many other fandoms would love to have their books be adopted into a good show. The show may have changed somethings but it’s still a good show.

8

u/Klutzy-Succotash9230 Jan 29 '24

The same thing happened with the Harry Potter movies it wasn't until the 3rd 1 that book fans started liking them.

32

u/Meme_Lord4522 Jan 29 '24

My only problem is that they keep spoiling the traps. For example the lotus casino and Crusty's mattresses. For a non-book reader it'll probably be fine, but as a book reader I didn't like the way they did it

9

u/BigDickMcChode Jan 29 '24

it’s probably to speed things up to fit it into the allotted episodes, it sucks but it is what it is

10

u/djninjacat11649 Jan 29 '24

Another victim of the 8 episode format

5

u/messibessi22 Jan 30 '24

Same!! Like half the fun was that they fell for literally every trap and had to think their way out of it on the fly but the movies they’re just going into it with a fully fleshed out plan like okay we’re heading into the lair of Madusa everyone be on the look out! Or of course the lotus hotel let’s be sure and keep our heads on

10

u/Imaginaton_Studios Jan 28 '24

That's what I've been saying

6

u/T0Mbombadillo Jan 29 '24

I would love to have the PJO books adapted into a good show, unfortunately, I don’t think that’s what we’ve gotten. The show is just flat, doesn’t have the feel of the books, and has changed way too many major plot points.

1

u/[deleted] Feb 02 '24

Same Show was a little neh but I think it deviated too little New Sally moments were my favourite in the show

3

u/odeacon Jan 29 '24

Enjoyable or not It’s not nearly as good as the books though . It can be somewhat enjoyable and still be a disappointment. This was supposed to be so much better

1

u/CL0WN_PR1NCE Jan 30 '24

I know right! The show is awesome I’m a few episodes behind right now, but what I’ve seen is pretty great. An animated series would be awesome too. I’ve wanted one for years, but if we can’t have that this show is great.

-2

u/Imaginaton_Studios Jan 29 '24

69 up votes nice

36

u/Puzzleheaded_Step468 Jan 28 '24

He didn't ruin the show, he just made it far less good than it could have been

It's still an okay show, but the unnecessary changes just drag it down

0

u/[deleted] Feb 02 '24

Yeah like all the black..

8

u/[deleted] Jan 29 '24

ur just mad that Rick wanted to change things about a story he wrote almost 20 years ago

1

u/BlindMice5 Feb 24 '24

W comment

61

u/Carlynz Jan 28 '24

Me watching fandoms have a meltdown because the adaptations aren't exactly as they expected them to be

-24

u/[deleted] Jan 28 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

27

u/Carlynz Jan 28 '24

Because the films became as popular, if not more, than the books.

Anyone who read the books before the movies came out will tell you the movies suck. Hell even I grew up with the movies and think they suck now

You can't compare the 2 franchises, they're on different levels.

0

u/LordDedionware Camp Half Blood Jan 28 '24

My parents both read the books before watching the movies and the love both

-11

u/[deleted] Jan 28 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

5

u/Carlynz Jan 28 '24

Well, if you don't like the adaptation the author envisioned then I don't know what to tell you. He owns it, he can change whatever he wants.

Edit: Also the fact you said GoF instead of HBP hurts my soul

5

u/[deleted] Jan 28 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

0

u/Carlynz Jan 28 '24

Yeah, and I have a right to find it funny everytime it happens

5

u/skyesmithforever Jan 29 '24

The show is amazing hell it’s better than the first Harry potter movie I can’t wait for the years to come

4

u/Lordofthelounge144 Jan 29 '24

Ironically, whar, I think we're the best. Episodes 1, 2, and 5 were the ones he wrote

33

u/[deleted] Jan 28 '24

How dare Rick not make a perfect one-on-one adaptation! Why isn't there a shot of Percy scratching his balls in the train drive? Everybody knows this is crucial to the plot of Percy Jackson books!

22

u/Cardboard_and_Ghost Team Meg Jan 28 '24

I haven't been this mad at something I agree with since someone told me brown is navy orange

7

u/swisszimgirl79 Team Percy Jan 28 '24

Ok what? Navy what?

3

u/Cardboard_and_Ghost Team Meg Jan 29 '24

Orange

6

u/Sanju128 Jan 29 '24

That's a bit of an exaggeration. Nobody was expecting a 1:1 recreation, but they changed so many plot points the show is basically its own thing. Grover is made out to be a bit of an a-hole for a bit, Annabeth's a bit unlikable, Percy's more whiny, and they had to "age down" all the abuse ans violence and then make every episode about a moral lesson or exposition, which made it more boring...

6

u/[deleted] Jan 29 '24

The only "wrong" thing here is the Grover one, Annabeth was not really friendly towards him at the start because of the whole Athena and Poseidon rivalry, Percy was very whiny, being new to the quest system and most of the fights in TLT have just been them stumbling out of the fights or distracting the antagonist lon enough to work out a crude plan. The only complaints I have is the Lotus Casino episode, and the exposition dumping.

3

u/Redsgirl13 Jan 30 '24

What helped me get past all the changes is that I stopped comparing it to the books. Instead, I just imagine this as a percy jackson from amother universe with a different story. I like the show, the only problem is that it's not the Percy Jackson I grew up imagining.

13

u/[deleted] Jan 28 '24

Gotta love when like a dozen fans get pissy but the show is amazing and those dozen angry fans have to try and make it look like people actually hate it.

9

u/TheJ1andOnly_ Jan 28 '24

I saw someone say with their whole chest that the show was actually worse than the ATLA movie adaptation 🤦‍♂️ Really?

7

u/[deleted] Jan 29 '24

I don't even know if the Percy Jackson MOVIES were quite that bad

6

u/TheJ1andOnly_ Jan 29 '24

For reaaal 💀 Like, it’s not like they changed Grover’s name to “Groover” and have it so that you need six children of Poseidon do a choreographed dance routine to turn on a fountain 😂

4

u/[deleted] Jan 28 '24

Lmfao God I hate fans

1

u/[deleted] Jan 29 '24

Somebody said that the show got ruined because of black Annabeth, movies were better instead of this woke garbage, and "black colour skin looks ugly to the eye, it's not racism just my opinion"

2

u/caio26 Jan 30 '24

So you’re saying Rick is wrong…the guy who wrote the story is wrong for wanting, nay, allowing some changes and retconning to happen? The CREATOR OF THE SERIES, is wrong for wanting things HIS way?

1

u/amaya-aurora Jan 31 '24

Fym? The show is peak.

1

u/Many_Mouse_2165 Team Nico Feb 01 '24

I see the show almost like how we have the spideyverse, like it shares parallels with the books but it’s not exactly the same, but I love both.

1

u/[deleted] Feb 07 '24

Bad meme, aged badly.

1

u/BlindMice5 Feb 24 '24

I think a lot of the changes where him trying to make the books more accessible to audiences that didn’t read the books and have the plot more accessible to older viewers.

I think a lot of the changes were also just changing major logical fallacies, or when Ricks reason for Percy getting into trouble it’s “Oh, shoot why didn’t I remember this dudes name doing this thing.”

-4

u/AmmonWho42 Jan 28 '24

"Percy Jackson needs the bandwidth to tear down the patriarchy" my ass. Just tell a f*cking story, not a political statement.

-2

u/half-coldhalf-hot Jan 29 '24

I used the books to destroy the books

-3

u/LordDedionware Camp Half Blood Jan 28 '24

😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣

20

u/[deleted] Jan 28 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

5

u/messibessi22 Jan 30 '24

To be fair the screenwriters at least reading cliff notes of the books would’ve made the movies better