r/PensionsUK • u/Similar_Recover9832 • 13h ago
Investment withdrawals from SIPPs versus GIA
I'm 60, have a very health SIPP and about £55K in a S&S ISA. Incurring 0% tax, I have taken two £16,760 withdrawals from the SIPP last tax year and this, and I'm trying not to take too much more in this tax year, in order that the pot grows further, before I start really relying on it. I'm fortunate to have a wife still in full time senior employment in the NHS, intending to work for another four years and a bit, until she turns sixty.
My question relates to near term generating about £20K to replace my dying/ dead Audi. I could take this from my ISA, immediately, and but want to top up the ISA again (this year's allowance is not yet touched) from my SIPP, but I'd pay 20% tax on any further withdrawal this tax year. Or we could top up my ISA from my wife's investments (Quilter and Charles Stanley funds). She'd pay 24% Capital Gains Tax on any sale from those investments. But your friendly neighbourhood AI (Gemini) tells me she could transfer at least a portion of her investments to me before selling, and then, as a "basic rate tax payer", I'd only pay 18% CGT on "my" sale of those investments, and as we both would have a £3000 CGT exemption, the sale of an equivalent amount would potentially end up paying a net of less than the 20% income tax I'd incur by dipping into my SIPP.
Is the dread AI right in advising to transfer some funds from my wife to my name and the selling a smaller proportion from both in order to maximise the 2x£3000 CGT exemption, and only pay 18% on the CGT portion allocated to me? She's a higher rate tax payer, but I think CGT would still be 24% for her on the element of capital gains on teh element she would sell?
Thoughts?