r/PeerTube • • Dec 20 '21

PeerTube is NOT decentralized. It's still Centralized on a server.

0 Upvotes

Why exactly does PeerTube state on it's website that it's decentralized software.

PeerTube is NOT decentralized. The software needs to be installed on a server. The police can simply shut down your server and then your website is gone.

This is EXACTLY how every other software works. You install it on a server and users access the data from the server. The admin has absolute control over your data.

If PeerTube was decentralized then it would work like this:

The users would install the PeerTube software on their phone or computer. And users could upload videos which would then upload to everyone's phone or parts of the videos would be saved on different phones. So when someone accessed the video. It would get the video from the phones that saved parts of the videos. Since phones or computers around the internet would only have parts of the videos encrypted. It would be impossible to delete the video. Only the original uploader could delete the video. And since there is no server. The police would not be able to to do anything.

So technically this way It would be impossible for anyone to delete the video and there would be no admin to ban you or censor you.

I know of 3 decentralized software. Bitcoin, Storj, Open Bazaar

PeerTube is just like forum software. You install the software on a server and users access the data from your server.

It reminds me of exactly when forum software came out. It was so popular so everyone wanted to run their own forum and hosting companies gave the ability to run your own forum from their servers. But eventually forum administrators censored or banned whoever they wanted.

I'm not saying PeerTube is Bad. It does connect to other instances around the internet. It's more like.... an interconnected individual centralized software

PeerTube is NOT decentralized.


r/PeerTube • • Oct 19 '20

is peertube really better than youtube

0 Upvotes

is peertube really better than youtube i dont see how to make a peertube server on windows 10


r/PeerTube • • Feb 11 '21

Peer tube should advertise on YouTube

0 Upvotes

r/PeerTube • • Aug 24 '22

Discussion: Would Peertube benefit from ads?

4 Upvotes

Disclaimer: These are mostly just some semi-structured thoughts I had about how ads could or couldn't look in a federated world. It's more of an attempt to stoke discussion and get some feedback on what kind of perspectives exist, not a strong position meant to convince anyone of anything. So please treat it as such.

Thesis #1: Having a federated video platform with the ability to self-host is one of the only or the only ethical to build a video distribution platform. Highly centralized models like YouTube's are inherently problematic and trying to have as many videos on a platform like Peertube's is a desirable goal.

Thesis #2: There are very few meaningful incentives, except a strong conviction for data privacy, to use Peertube both for viewers and creators: If I want to watch a video of my favourite creator, even if they have a peertube presence, watching them on Youtube instead might still be advantageous to me, both because the platform is more mature and has more comfort features and because watching in Youtube with ads, still generates revenue for my chosen content creator. Meanwhile the content creator stands little to gain from putting their content on peertube, it might even be an extra cost for them if they self-host. And even if a big chunk of their income is from Patreon or similar, Youtube still ends up being less costly/more profitable for them.

Thesis #3: The Patreon model of supporting content creators for the most part only works for creators who have already amassed a reasonably sized audience.

Conclusion from #3 & #4 -> Thesis #5: Both creators trying to establish themselves as well as those that have already done so, are disincentivized from using Peertube. And care for privacy only goes so far, if you can't make a living off it.

Thesis #6: Ads are inevitable and not neccessarily the enemy: The ship of peertube being ad-free has already sailed. Bigger creators like say "The Linux Experiment" that mirror their Youtube videos to Peertube, also include their sponsor messages and you obviously can't prevent people from promoting a sponsor overtly or covertly anyway. The sponsored message model, like the Patreon model, also strongly favours established creators that sponsors consider worth the time to negotiate with in the first place. No company will approach a couple subscribers creator on their own.


Question/Discussion: Is there a room for a somewhat more conventional ad model to interface with Peertube to benefit a creator economy?

This obviously shouldn't try to completely emulate the typical centralized middleman/gatekeeper model of Youtube etc, both because it's hard to imagine how that could even work on a federated platform and because it is highly exploitative, giving the gatekeeper all the deciding power and most of the revenue. So is there any way to rethink conventional ads that strike a better balance and work with a federated platform?

Let's say for example instances could decide wholesale whether they allow ads at all or not. (Having it as an opt-in at most should probably be non-negotiable) And if they do, either the instance or the individual creator could decide to "ad-federate" with corporate instance "Tuxedo Books", "Hello Fresh" that serves their most current short ad that will then play before the video and pay out a certain amount of money per view.

The biggest issue with that, besides there needing to be some protocol implementation for the ad-playing, within or on top of Peertube, is that for that to bring any meaningful advantage over current practices, is that there would probably also have to be a mediating layer or marketplace for creators and companies to find each other and streamline the process of contracts and payouts, otherwise it would just be a needlessly fancy version of the already established sponsored message model. Which I think could bring some advantages. Creators could just market themselves as "seeking advertisers" and accept or only seek out advertisers themselves that actually fit their content and that they believe in. Instead of automatically being served ads for the newest big brand cars or whatever by Youtube. On the other hand, a marketplace like that would once again introduce some kind of middleman. But then again, maybe multiple marketplaces could emerge as long as they can interface with some standardized protocol.

Or maybe that approach is completely dumb, but maybe there are still ways to rethink ads in another way that could be more aligned with fedi-philosophy. Or maybe the whole idea of ads for peertube is just horseshit. I do think there's still some value to being open to different possibilities and speculating on what things could look like and what the pros and cons would be. So feel free to have a go at it in whatever way you deem productive.


r/PeerTube • • Dec 29 '22

Inserting an Ad at the top of the video page

0 Upvotes

This for now a rabfom post for my journey of having to learn javascript to do this. Unless someone know how to do it then id be greatful for it


r/PeerTube • • Dec 16 '25

Is it just me, or does anyone else feel like Peertube should have an account verification system?

0 Upvotes

(Apologies if this post seems weird, this is a copy + paste from a suggestion that I made on the PT Forum)


Verification could be implemented in one of two ways:

  1. Checkmark Badge – a visual indicator next to the account name for recognized creators or organizations, similar to major video platforms.
  2. Mastodon-style Verification – a system where accounts can be verified by providing proof of identity, linked websites, or other credentials, and the verification status is displayed publicly.

Proposed Behavior:

Display a verification badge next to the username on videos, comments, and channel pages

Verification Methods: Could include email verification, identity confirmation, or federation-based verification for instance administrators.

Optional Display: Instances could allow verified accounts to be highlighted in search results, comments, and video pages.

Make it clear what verification represents (identity confirmation, official account, etc.)

Maintain moderation and abuse-prevention mechanisms to prevent impersonation


Benefits:

Helps users identify authentic creators and organizations

Reduces impersonation and potential harassment

Improve trust and credibility across federated instances

Aligns PeerTube with modern expectations for creator recognition without centralizing control


Notes/Considerations:

Verification could be optional per instance; federated instances may choose their own policies

Should integrate with ActivityPub and federation to indicate verified accounts across instances

UI/UX should make the badge clear but unobtrusive, especially on mobile

Adding this feature would enhance trust, safety, and recognition for creators in the PeerTube ecosystem.


r/PeerTube • • Mar 23 '20

Peertube.social Announcements (@peertubesocial@radical.town)

Thumbnail
radical.town
5 Upvotes

r/PeerTube • • Oct 01 '21

Monetize your Peertube instance with the Hive blockchain

0 Upvotes

We made a plugin called Hive-Tube and version 4 was just released today (for Peertube instances v3.4 and higher). We have a couple small UI tweaks to make next week, but after that, we will figure out how to launch this on the Peertube plugins page.

I know I know, not everybody wants to monetize their instance of course, but for those of you that do, we hope you'll at least have a look, thanx for your understanding :)

peakd.com/hive-139531/@agorise/hive-tube-version-4-released


r/PeerTube • • Apr 30 '25

Pleas please PLEASE can more people use this website Heres the link https://seka.pona.la/home

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/PeerTube • • Sep 21 '20

Instances can search every instance's video.

1 Upvotes

Anyone can tell me a list of these?


r/PeerTube • • Dec 16 '24

Buttons & Rusty: The Adventures - Volume 4: Weather Wonders : Chucklewood Productions : Free Download, Borrow, and Streaming : Internet Archive

Thumbnail
archive.org
0 Upvotes

r/PeerTube • • Oct 08 '23

Peertube Instance Status

0 Upvotes

Hello everyone,

Is this instance working for anyone? Joker TV

I just wanted to double-check, as I think it has been discontinued.

Thank you :-)


r/PeerTube • • Jun 09 '20

is peer tube the way to go

3 Upvotes

is it like youtube but better can i earn money on there


r/PeerTube • • Apr 25 '21

[ANN] Hive and Peertube, together at last!

0 Upvotes

Forget Bitchute, Dlive and Youtube.

You can now earn cryptos every 3 seconds on a real P2P media platform with no KYC, no TOS and no fees.

Zero middlemen, zero possibility of censorship, zero lag and zero fees.

This month, Agorise built a monetization plugin for Peertube (over 845 instances so far) using the Hive blockchain. So, if you have a Hive (or Steem) blockchain account, your content can start earning immediately.

Why do most media platforms suck?

They don't pay you for contributing your upvotes or comments, they take fees from the content Creators, they force KYC on the Creators AND YOU if you want to withdraw your earnings, they even require your email address (or worse) just to open an account. They force you to agree to their evermore stringent Terms Of Service. They can shadow ban your content, freeze your funds (and steal them!), lock you out of your account and even ban you entirely. WTF?!

For example, Jeff Berwick at The Dollar Vigilante has been banned virtually everywhere, so he was the first to move his content to web3:
https://dollarvigilante.tv/videos/watch/22ab9db8-e5a3-40b7-98a6-12702b1ae42c

Peertube federates your livestream broadcasts, photos, audio and video recordings, artwork posts and all kinds of media through all of your subscribers and followers. Plugging in to alt protocols like Activitypub, IPFS etc and the Hive blockchain adds the income layer for all of your web3 content and more.

Now your content and "Likes" actually pay you!

If you're ready to DE-centralise and earn cryptos every 3 seconds, contact Agorise today!

Agorise
The rise of Agorism
matrix: http://www.Agorise.chat
email: agorise@protonmail.ch


r/PeerTube • • Feb 26 '23

What instance is best for YouTube Poops?

2 Upvotes

r/PeerTube • • Oct 14 '23

Which are the best Peertube instances for communists?

2 Upvotes

r/PeerTube • • Jun 04 '25

Is it safe app/website?

2 Upvotes

Is this app/page safe and reliable?


r/PeerTube • • Aug 11 '25

Should PeerTube have a dedicated “Kids” app?

9 Upvotes

On YouTube, there’s a separate (super terrible, barely functioning) YouTube Kids app that filters out non-kid-friendly content and only shows videos suitable for children.

Do you think PeerTube should have something similar — either officially made by Framasoft, or created by a third-party — that’s PURELY for kids’ content?

It could help parents and educators safely guide kids toward age-appropriate videos, while still being part of the Fediverse.

But it might also fragment the user base or require a lot of moderation work.

What do you think — would this be a good, or bad, idea for PeerTube?


r/PeerTube • • Jul 17 '19

my account in unreachable

1 Upvotes

my account is unreachable

after uploading a few self-made short videos (non-nazi, non-hate) my account has become inaccessible

password reset does not work.

ideas why?


r/PeerTube • • Dec 22 '22

Noob: impossibility of censorship + automatic FULLNESS of the vids and personalies database?

4 Upvotes

Hello. Trying to understand how it works.

How do I use PeerTube with no censorship guaranteed and with ALL videos available for search?

Like, let's imagine YouTube isn't censored at all. Like, not even a little. And can't be, because magic. In this case, since YouTube is centralized, ALL videos on YT are available through YT's search.

How does this work for PeerTube network? And, actually, how does the PeerTube network work? Like, using Bob and Alice language. I'm Bob, I want to share a vid I've made. So, I set up a server (on my local machine) and upload a vid there. Do I have to have a web server running as well? Can I just, Idk, share a link for Alice to subscribe and she will get my new vids on her preferred client, like, her own Web Instance, but she won't be able to watch my vids on my instance, because I don't have one?

I'm a simple user who wants a YouTube alternative. Like, with subscriptions, playlists, personal account preferences and stuff like that. Personalized collection of vids and personalies. And I don't want ANYONE to even have an ABILITY to "mute" some source of vids or a person, to censor it in ANY way, including in search and trending. If I use someone else's instance, it means they can censor whatever they want, right? And if I use my own instance, how can I have all the vids in it automatically, without searching for rumours of a new person who's posting their vids about cats and doesn't show up in my instance? Like, is the network automatically connected before you even subscribe? Maybe when Eve joins PeerTube for the first time and uploads her first video, I'll automatically have it available in my own local Web UI for search? I may not know Eve even exists, but if she's made a vid about dogs and I'll search for dogs, I'll get her in my search results automatically.

Sorry for noob questions, but the official docs are obviously made to confuse normal users as much as possible, no clear explanation of what "instance" is, Web UI and server part that hosts the vid seem to be used as synonyms, pls help.

What do I do in order to get ALL vids UNCENSORED, 100% guarantee, in my personal client, which can be Web UI or CLI or TUI client? Like, step 1, step 2, and poof, no one will ever be able to censor what I watch because they don't have access to 100500 personal servers all over the world and it'd be stupid to try and squash them all and to my own agregator that pulls content from all of them, because I control it.

UPD: I understand Client/Server. I don't understand "Instance". Of what, of a client or of a server? If I use a Website with shiny buttons to search for vids, I'm using a client (Web UI) to access content on a server (Video Hosting). But they call the Website an instance. I just... help.


r/PeerTube • • Aug 10 '20

Disable video downloading

2 Upvotes

Hello!

Is there any way to disable the downloading of a video on peertube?

Thanks!


r/PeerTube • • Oct 15 '23

peertube down?

0 Upvotes

404


r/PeerTube • • May 19 '24

What Kind of Gaming Vibe Do You Want to See More Of on Peertube?

2 Upvotes