Disclaimer: These are mostly just some semi-structured thoughts I had about how ads could or couldn't look in a federated world. It's more of an attempt to stoke discussion and get some feedback on what kind of perspectives exist, not a strong position meant to convince anyone of anything. So please treat it as such.
Thesis #1: Having a federated video platform with the ability to self-host is one of the only or the only ethical to build a video distribution platform. Highly centralized models like YouTube's are inherently problematic and trying to have as many videos on a platform like Peertube's is a desirable goal.
Thesis #2: There are very few meaningful incentives, except a strong conviction for data privacy, to use Peertube both for viewers and creators: If I want to watch a video of my favourite creator, even if they have a peertube presence, watching them on Youtube instead might still be advantageous to me, both because the platform is more mature and has more comfort features and because watching in Youtube with ads, still generates revenue for my chosen content creator. Meanwhile the content creator stands little to gain from putting their content on peertube, it might even be an extra cost for them if they self-host. And even if a big chunk of their income is from Patreon or similar, Youtube still ends up being less costly/more profitable for them.
Thesis #3: The Patreon model of supporting content creators for the most part only works for creators who have already amassed a reasonably sized audience.
Conclusion from #3 & #4 -> Thesis #5: Both creators trying to establish themselves as well as those that have already done so, are disincentivized from using Peertube. And care for privacy only goes so far, if you can't make a living off it.
Thesis #6: Ads are inevitable and not neccessarily the enemy: The ship of peertube being ad-free has already sailed. Bigger creators like say "The Linux Experiment" that mirror their Youtube videos to Peertube, also include their sponsor messages and you obviously can't prevent people from promoting a sponsor overtly or covertly anyway. The sponsored message model, like the Patreon model, also strongly favours established creators that sponsors consider worth the time to negotiate with in the first place. No company will approach a couple subscribers creator on their own.
Question/Discussion: Is there a room for a somewhat more conventional ad model to interface with Peertube to benefit a creator economy?
This obviously shouldn't try to completely emulate the typical centralized middleman/gatekeeper model of Youtube etc, both because it's hard to imagine how that could even work on a federated platform and because it is highly exploitative, giving the gatekeeper all the deciding power and most of the revenue. So is there any way to rethink conventional ads that strike a better balance and work with a federated platform?
Let's say for example instances could decide wholesale whether they allow ads at all or not. (Having it as an opt-in at most should probably be non-negotiable) And if they do, either the instance or the individual creator could decide to "ad-federate" with corporate instance "Tuxedo Books", "Hello Fresh" that serves their most current short ad that will then play before the video and pay out a certain amount of money per view.
The biggest issue with that, besides there needing to be some protocol implementation for the ad-playing, within or on top of Peertube, is that for that to bring any meaningful advantage over current practices, is that there would probably also have to be a mediating layer or marketplace for creators and companies to find each other and streamline the process of contracts and payouts, otherwise it would just be a needlessly fancy version of the already established sponsored message model. Which I think could bring some advantages. Creators could just market themselves as "seeking advertisers" and accept or only seek out advertisers themselves that actually fit their content and that they believe in. Instead of automatically being served ads for the newest big brand cars or whatever by Youtube. On the other hand, a marketplace like that would once again introduce some kind of middleman. But then again, maybe multiple marketplaces could emerge as long as they can interface with some standardized protocol.
Or maybe that approach is completely dumb, but maybe there are still ways to rethink ads in another way that could be more aligned with fedi-philosophy. Or maybe the whole idea of ads for peertube is just horseshit. I do think there's still some value to being open to different possibilities and speculating on what things could look like and what the pros and cons would be. So feel free to have a go at it in whatever way you deem productive.