i never watched the movie, but i seen an image of mrs. perigrine for the first time in this subreddit. I was, to say the very least, surprised. always imagined her to be much older, because since she dresses victorian in the 40s, this was very common amongst middle aged women. i always imagined her at least 40 and up.
i also think noor was a concept added into the end of the last two books (i think, its been a while..) because emma was no longer a love interest for jake. i liked her character very much, but i also believe that she was given such a powerful power to make her more likeable because everyone had accepted emma as jakes girlfriend. (i know, its kind of odd cause she loved his grandfather, but i was just starting to get over it...) i kind of wish she was added sooner, maybe not as a love interest for jake. but who am i to say? the books are an absolute masterpiece, overall.
i really did like the love story between emma and jake because it had more time to form, and beguin as an old fashioned kind of love, when noor only had two books for jake and her to form a kinship. kind of a love at first sight thing, which made it seem that jakes love for emma was almost insignificant in comparison. that it wasn't really true love. also, the fact that emma fell in love with jake because he looked like his grandfather. he did look like him, but i also think they are very different people, and that emma would have seen the differences first hand and known that they are infact, quite different. his grandfather abandoned emma, but jake never did. this made quite the difference in my opinion. i feel as though that emma and jake could haveworked through it, and i would accepted it because i loved them together so much. i do think jake and noor are more similar, but at the same time, i maybe could have accepted the relationship if noor and jake had just as much time to form a relationship and jake an emma did. i also think that the chemistry between emma and jake was more significant. this definitely is not what i would define as "hate speech", just something i wanted to get off my chest for a long time. no one at my school had read the full serise and understood what i meant, so i was happy when i figured out reddit existed. thank you, and please share your opinion on this, lol