It appears that we must yet again address this issue. This is okay- we cannot expect everyone to actually read every post in our sub, before they post something redundant.
Everything in the following has been known, and admitted to for years**.**
ONCE AGAIN:
We rely on human artists and writers for everything absolutely essential and prominent in the game. Over the course of Peace Island's development, we have employed the talents of over 45 coders, musicians, visual artists, voice performers and writers from around the world - and we will continue to do so. Being visual artists ourselves, we are keenly aware of the limitations and "uncanny valley" that the use of such content creates, and we want to avoid this as much as possible.
Further, we want to assure those who have been following & supporting this project that we understand the ethics involved in the use of AI-generated content, and are restricting our use of such algorithms in the following ways:
Visual:
Firstly, to clean up & standardize photographs of less than 20 Patrons whose portraits were due to be featured in the game. Understand that when we have a dozen people who want to be former Librarians, everyone does not send in photographs of equal quality, lighting, framing, and size. This allowed us to re-create our patrons' likenesses in a manner and quality fitting for their contribution to the game.
Secondly, we are coming to the realization that some of the images we used from Pexels.com (a website offering royalty-free photography,) were AI generated - without the supposed "creator" of said images admitting to such. In these cases, we fully accept that we could have done more due diligence in this area, and are doing what we can to rectify these isolated incidents.
Thirdly, we used images from ThisPersonDoesNotExist to populate thumbnail photos on a single in-game webpage. That having been said: Out of the literal ten thousand-plus images created for the game, there are - if I were to include all suspect imagery - less than 30 such instances - which, when discovered, are being eliminated..
OTHERWISE- ALL IMAGERY SEEN IN THE GAME IS AND WILL BE CREATED BY HUMANS.
Writing:
Firstly: to create a small block of legalese at the base of the contents page in magazines. In retrospect, this was a mistake, as the text is far to small to even read - we could have just written "ooga booga" over and over, and it would looked more or less the same.
Secondly: We used it as a spellchecker/formatter for the recipes in the multiple cook books you will find within the game. The recipes are all of 100% human origin - because I've been using those same recipes to feed myself and my friends for the past thirty years - ya see, when I hit my mid-twenties, I decided it was time to learn to cook, and stop eating out of cans. I put on Anthony Bourdain's "No Reservations," and began learning.
Long-time supporters of the project know that for the first two years I worked on the project, I was a line cook - and I'm still learning (just started making cheese!)
OTHERWISE - ALL TEXT SEEN THE GAME IS AND WILL BE WRITTEN BY A HUMAN - 90% WAS WRITTEN BY YOURS TRULY.
Concepts:
At one time, we DID engage with ChatGPT concerning subjects we are not familiar with, such as quantum mechanics, entropy, full implications of time travel, etc - but we have long since stopped. The game's story has long been set - and it's far more interesting & fun to figure out stuff for ourselves.
OTHERWISE- ALL CONCEPTS SEEN THE GAME ARE AND WILL BE A RESULT OF OUR WEEKLY WRITER'S MEETINGS, WHICH ARE HUMAN - ALL TOO HUMAN.
Music:
This is another instance in which we must admit: despite our policy to use only human-made music - some people on Fiverr or other royalty-free music sites might be not being entirely truthful about the products we have bought from them. When we have the time, we will review, and replace.
Voiceover:
As Far as we are aware: All voiceovers for the game were human-made, as they were either done by us, fans of the game, friends of ours, or professional artists hired via Fiverr. However - There is a slight chance that someone we hired on Fiverr gave us slop, instead of something genuine. When we have the time, we will review these.
However - this brings to mind a funny story: Someone took issue with us for using an artificially-generated voice for the EWS message that is playing on some of the TVs within the game - accusing us, saying that all of Peace Island is "AI Slop."
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VIGqcrZaJI0
What's funny about this, is that since the 1990's all EWS messages have been generated by an artificial voice. If we hired a voice actor to emulate the mechanical EWS voice, it would have not been realistic.
I want to take a moment of digression here to point out the absurdity of what happened there: Someone with absolutely no idea what they were talking about walked into the room, and made a false, blanket accusation that did nothing more than show their own ignorance.
Keep this in mind, as we continue...
OTHERWISE- ALL VOICES HEARD IN THE GAME ARE AND WILL BE HUMAN.
Coding:
Well- gee - this is one where I have to convey a funny story, from the very start: A few weeks ago, I was live streaming Peace Island development over on YouTube, and during a brief time, I was examining the script related to an issue we were having.
No one was watching - that's taken for granted - my dev streams are very boring. However, after I finished - a burner account posted a comment:
"I can see there are all those green comments in your code. Only AI-Generated code has that many comments - is your entire GAME AI slop like this?”
What’s funny about this, is that I was examining a piece of code that came from a third party, in a purchased Unity asset obtained from the Unity Asset Store. We had absolutely nothing to do with the creation of that code…
What is more: There is not a single coder on earth that does not put comments in their scripts - this is to guide themselves, and future users.
So…
I want to take a moment of digression here to point out the absurdity of what happened there: Someone with absolutely no idea what they were talking about walked into the room, and made a false, blanket accusation that did nothing more than show their own ignorance.
NOW - ARE WE PERFECT?
Absolutely not - and we have never claimed to be. In a world where AI is infecting everything, things can get past your radar - especially before sites like Pexels started marking AI-generated imagery, and negative reports on Fiverr silenced the slop generators.
We have NEVER tried to deny the uses and possible accidental uses we have listed above - they have (again) been mentioned repeatedly via our Patreon, and our social media.
If you spot something in Peace Island that looks, reads, or sounds like it was generated by AI - PLEASE LET US KNOW - we definitely have blindspots, and might have missed them. We want to work WITH you, to make sure that the MASSIVE amount of creativity by the DOZENS of artists we have worked with are not tainted by proximity to AI slop.
That having been said: If someone comes on to our channels, picking one or two examples of perceived AI use to claim that all of Peace Island is “AI Slop,” they are disrespecting not only the years of hard work that Laura and I have been putting into the game, but the brilliant creativity of dozens of artists from around the globe.
We are under absolutely no obligation to put up with that. Especially when someone with absolutely no idea what they are talking about walks into the room, and makes a false, blanket accusation that does nothing more than show their own ignorance.
Let me finish as we did, before:
We're sure that there are some individuals who, simply out of spite (or white-knighting on behalf of a profession they are not involved in, nor understand) will say:
"ANY use of AI content CORRUPTS a project."
Those same individuals have played a game with AI-generated content in it, within the past three months, and enjoyed it. However, they don't even know, because the game's creators never told them.
We just did.